6 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Elimination Chamber 2024
Nia/Rhea steals the show, women's chamber delivers, Cody calls out Rock.
How do you know the WWE is a hot product, even if the actual content is at times mediocre? When they can fill up a stadium with nearly 50,000 fans for a PLE where Cody Rhodes isn’t wrestling, Roman Reigns is absent, and Nia Jax is headlining.
That’s not a knock on Elimination Chamber, which actually was a pretty good show, albeit a four-match main card that felt more like a table-setting show for WrestleMania than a major stadium show.
Both chamber matches delivered expected outcomes but also set up potential Mania rivalries along the way. The women’s chamber match in particular was great at filling the space with action. The final few minutes featured counters galore and a bang-bang set of eliminations to finish.
It might be unpopular to say this, but the Grayson Waller Effect interview segment underwhelmed a bit, with the expected formation of the modern-era Mega Powers between Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins just kind of happening rather than being a “capital-M” Moment. This could have and probably should have felt bigger, especially on a card this small.
Of course, there will be time inside for praise for Nia Jax and Rhea Ripley, but suffice it to say, this was the right call to close out the show.
Overall, even the negatives here were minimal -- nothing was a fatal mistake, and all of them could be overlooked in in different ways. Even from a critical standpoint, this show didn't have any huge bumps in the road.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
4. Not The Best Return PLE
Naomi spent more than 18 months away from WWE after walking out of the company in May 2022, returning at the Royal Rumble to a huge reaction. The former singles and tag champion had to be looking for a big showcase upon her return, but Saturday’s Elimination Chamber match was little more than an exhibition.
Naomi started the chamber match with Becky Lynch, and they spent the opening segment trading offense, rollups and counters. She got a bit of offense, but then she was unceremoniously pinned immediately after landing an avalanche sunset bomb off the pod, but Tiffany Stratton simply rolling her up. She was gone before the last two participants entered, scoring no eliminations and just one semi-notable “moment.”
That’s three matches since returning, with a nondescript appearance in the Rumble, a qualifying match win over Alba Fyre, and this showing. Throw in doing away with her signature entrance for a new glow-less theme that spells out her name and you’ve got to wonder what’s going on here with this booking.
You don’t spend the better part of two years away, becoming a world champion in another promotion, to return and become part of the furniture in one month. But hey, if she’s happy, that’s really all that matters. From a fan’s perspective, it’s confusing at best, disappointing at worst.
3. An Underwhelming Showing
If you were keeping score in the men’s Elimination Chamber match, you’d notice that two men registered all the pinfalls: Randy Orton (two) and Drew McIntyre (three). That meant the other four men had to make noise in different ways.
Kevin Owens and Logan Paul occupied themselves quite well battering each other throughout the match, with Paul factoring in directly to Orton’s elimination at the end. But for Bobby Lashley and LA Knight, the chamber felt like an underwhelming night for both.
Lashley did hit a sweet spear on Logan through a pod, but that spot also has become standard in a chamber match, and he was unceremoniously eliminated first with a Claymore while he was trying to cinch in a Hurt Lock.
Knight was the first one in the match, and he did little to stand out in the field once the bell rang, spending large portions lying on the floor while KO and Paul fought. He got a visual pinfall on McIntyre before AJ Styles interfered and battered him with a chair, but there wasn’t much else to his appearance.
It was a far cry from the megastar that some fans were saying should have been strapped up against Roman Reigns at Crown Jewel less than four months ago.
2. Missing The Mark
If you’re going to build up a talk show segment for a stadium show PLE, it better be a massive happening with some major news being made.
And sure, Cody Rhodes calling out The Rock for a match is a big deal. And Seth Rollins saying he will be medically cleared imminently is notable. But everyone had to know Rhodes was going to issue fighting words to Rock after the Great One slapped him at the Las Vegas press conference. A general call-out just left things where they were before the Grayson Waller Effect: Cody is pissed at heel Rock and wants revenge.
The general feeling was that this interview segment was where the Rhodes-Rollins modern-day Mega Powers formation would take place and a tag challenge would be issued for WrestleMania against the Bloodline. (The promo video with the four stars has all but made it official.) Saturday’s developments did advance that story – Seth said he’d be alongside Cody – but it was just way too small of a development to merit a PLE interview.
Even the Seth-Cody alliance was downplayed. On Raw last week, Rhodes was screwed out of his match against Drew McIntyre by the Bloodline, and Rollins just cut him a look. Saturday would have been a great opportunity to have them acknowledge that as the basis for their teaming up, with Cody admitting he needed the backup. Instead, it was a simple comment from Rollins reiterating his pledge to Rhodes.
While it’s hard to call this a negative, it definitely was a disappointment from what many expected and what could have been. This easily could have been a random Raw segment.
1. Homeland Pop, No Fire
As a moment, seeing Indi Hartwell wrestle in front of her fellow Australians was heartwarming. You’d have to be a callous bastard to not appreciate that.
But as a match, Indi and Candice LeRae’s challenge against the Kabuki Warriors was hardly a threat to the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions. They wisely kept the match basic, with LeRae eating the bulk of Asuka and Kairi Sane’s offense and struggling to make it to her corner before finally getting the hot tag to Hartwell.
And that’s where the problem revealed itself. Normally when someone gets a hot tag, they’re the proverbial “house afire,” frantically attacking both heels with furious offense, whipping fans into a frenzy.
After building to the moment where Indi got the big tag in her first WWE PLE (non-Royal Rumble) match – in her home country, no less – Hartwell delivered some extremely basic clotheslines, a double-noggin knocker and an ugly looking low crossbody. The crowd was behind Indi, but if you muted your TV, there was no real fire, no “snap” to her hot tag. Hartwell didn’t even really play to the crowd during a segment that lasted less than 45 seconds.
The entire match was built on Indi’s hot tag, and it fell far short of being a moment in itself. It might be a bit pedantic (to borrow Michael Sidgwick’s word) but it needs to be noted and called out as a negative.
UPS…
6. Tag Match Magic
Heading into the Undisputed WWE Tag Team Championship match, no one expected the New Catch Republic to do little more than put up a good fight against the Judgment Day.
But fans got more than they bargained for with this match, as Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne kept the tag champs on their heels throughout the match with a blitz of offense, including several unique double-teams. There were a couple spots where you couldn’t be blamed if you lost yourself and just assumed that they were switching the titles.
However, Dominik Mysterio played his role perfectly, saving Finn Balor and prolonging the match long enough for Judgment Day to overcome and retain the tag titles. For Bate and Dunne, they got to show a lot more of their skills in a setting that made them look like serious players rather than a novelty tag act.
Surprisingly good, competitive match in what should have been a simple forgone conclusion.
5. Cody Cuts Into Rock’s Veneer
While the actual “news” coming out of the Grayson Waller Effect interview was disappointing, Cody Rhodes deserves some credit for doing something very few get to do in today’s wrestling landscape: cut a legend like The Rock down by attacking the very foundation of what makes him popular.
When John Cena feuded with Rock, he traded verbal jabs and bad-mouthed him. But Cody went a different tact Saturday night, calling himself a fan of Rocky… before shredding the Great One’s entire persona and shtick. Cody noted that if Rock were in Perth, he would call Rhodes a “candy something,” says something about “rudy poo” and then talk about “pie.” He also took a swipe at Rock's self-appointed title as the People's Champion.
In one fell swoop, Cody disintegrated Rock’s decades-old routine that he’s been relying on for… well, decades. That routine has long since been outdated, but no one has really called it out as such in the way Cody did.
Of course, this opens the door for Rock to (hopefully) shed that material and use his superior verbal skills to unleash new patter. After all, Brian Gewirtz is there to help guide Rock’s ship to WrestleMania – might as well earn his pay and update the material for 2024.
4. Great Big-Stage Debut
Multi-person matches like the Elimination Chamber can present great opportunities for wrestlers to stand out without winning, gaining recognition and that all-important momentum.
For Tiffany Stratton, Saturday’s chamber match was her big-stage debut, her first real opportunity to show the larger WWE audience what she has to offer – and she delivered. For example, the handspring back elbow has been a staple in women’s matches for years, despite many failing to execute it well. Stratton made it look explosive in delivering two to Becky Lynch and Naomi.
Stratton might have been the newcomer to the main roster, but she fit right in battling Lynch, Naomi, Raquel Rodriguez, Bianca Belair and Liv Morgan. Tiffany flew around the ring, including a Swanton Bomb off the top of the pod onto everyone. She picked up a pinfall on Naomi as well while becoming an instant fan favorite.
All told, this was a great showcase for Tiffy Time, who has a bright future ahead of her.
3. A Frenzied Finish
The outcome of the women’s Elimination Chamber match was never really in doubt, crystalized the minute Becky Lynch and Rhea Ripley faced off on the stage at the Las Vegas press conference a few weeks ago.
But how we got there Saturday night was entertaining as hell, so that’s a big victory. The women’s chamber match crammed in a ton of action despite running for well over a half-hour. The final flurry from Lynch, Liv Morgan and Bianca Belair (and Raquel Rodriguez before her elimination) was really well done, with each woman landing huge signature spots, countering one another and constantly trying to pin another superstar. It felt like a real struggle to get the upper hand and bounce someone from the match.
The finish saw everyone counter each other, leading to Liv rolling up Bianca, then turning straight into a Manhandle Slam, giving Lynch the victory. Because they had been going at 100 kph up to that point, it was easy to believe that everyone was running on empty, so the rollup registered and Becky’s immediate capitalization felt both cunning and desperate.
No one looked foolish or weak here, and we still got the finish that everyone anticipated. Job well done.
2. New Age Opportunist
For years, Edge lived by the nickname “The Ultimate Opportunist” after his Money in the Bank cash-ins. Saturday night, Drew McIntyre might have borrowed that title due to his performance inside the Elimination Chamber.
McIntyre picked up the expected win, going wire-to-wire and eliminating three of his opponents. But all three of those pins came after capitalizing on situations, including two outside interferences. AJ Styles entered the chamber and obliterated LA Knight with a steel chair, allowing Drew to cover him. And later, an eliminated Logan Paul used brass knuckles on Randy Orton, and McIntyre pinned him to punch his ticket to WrestleMania 40.
The slow slide of McIntyre into becoming a pure heel has been a thing of beauty to watch, as he’s decried the underhanded tactics of the Bloodline, and now he’s openly taking advantage of those same situations with no hesitation or remorse.
All of this makes Drew – a dangerous opponent for Seth Rollins on its face – even more of a threat because he won’t let any advantage slip by.
1. An Over-Delivery In Every Sense
If someone had said at any point between 2015 and September 2023 that Nia Jax would main-event a stadium show PLE and it would be good, they would have been checked into a facility for monitoring.
But here we are in February 2024 and Nia and Rhea Ripley headlined Elimination Chamber with their Women’s World Championship match – and it was shockingly really, really good. They didn’t try to get too cute with the action: Jax dominated with headbutts, leg drops, splashes, and a few Samoan Drops. She also employed submission holds like a Stretch Muffler and a Torture Rack. She put Rhea through a table too for good measure, thwarting the champ’s plans.
Ripley – normally the powerhouse in any match – had to rely on speed and more high-flying moves to try to knock Nia off her feet. She kept trying to overpower Jax, but it wasn’t until the finish that she succeeded in lifting her off the ground, which whipped fans into a frenzy as she retained with an improbable Riptide.
By keeping things relatively simple and just delivering on those basic moves and the space in-between, Jax and Ripley had a good, engaging title match that utilized the fans’ built-in investment as fuel. They didn’t have to deploy a bunch of gimmicks to suck fans into the match, and they knew that and used that to their advantage.
Great job all around. Happy to have been dead wrong about Nia – her return to WWE has been nothing short of incredible.