6 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (14 August - Review)

Judgment Day is all over the show, Becky/Trish disappoints, world title feud set.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

The SummerSlam afterglow has faded, and WWE very clearly is resetting its feuds, some promising, others less so, but Raw set the table Monday night.

Advertisement

The question at hand is whether these programs will capture fans’ imaginations and attention, or if they’re just something to occupy space and time as WWE heads into the season where its TV ratings take a hit from Monday Night Football. This phenomenon has played out before, with the company turning out lackluster placeholder angles heading into the fall, knowing that the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania season are just a few short months away.

That’s not to say that what Raw offered Monday night was underwhelming. But a Seth Rollins/Shinsuke Nakamura feud probably isn’t going to main-event the next PLE. However, Chad Gable and Gunther will likely be must-see television next week. So this isn’t exactly a hard-fast rule.

Raw was mostly solid, if unspectacular. It’s hard to get fired up when the fans in attendance are sleeping through large parts of the show, coming to life to sing Rollins’ theme and to react to finishing sequences. To be fair though, they had to suffer through a disappointing Becky Lynch/Trish Stratus match that had an awful finish and an even worse aftermath.

Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

4. A Minor Quibble

WWE.com

It’s fair to say that Alpha Academy is still mostly a comic relief act, though they’re starting to be taken more seriously in-between the ropes.

If the entire gimmick is Chad Gable teaching his prized pupils Otis and Maxxine Dupri to be successful, wouldn’t it be considered a colossal failure if one of them lost focus on the task at hand mid-match? Otis finally got Gunther off his feet in their match, and rather than quickly following up, he stopped and set up to do the Caterpillar, which allowed the Intercontinental Champion to recover, flatten the #1 Guy, and then powerbomb him for the win.

The lesson here should have been to stay on top of a wrestler who hasn’t been pinned or submitted during his entire main roster run, not goof around with a move that takes 15 seconds to set up.

Advertisement

Yes, this is obviously a very minor gripe, and you have to really think about this sort of thing, but if WWE starts taking Gable and the Alphas seriously, this is exactly the kind of thing they have to consider. It undercuts your ability – even on a subconscious level – to take an act as a serious threat if you can poke holes without much thought.

3. Another Show-Opening Judgment Day Promo

WWE.com

There’s a lot to love about the Judgment Day, and the group’s current strife is a central theme on Raw most Monday nights.

But the Bloodline they are not. And while the ongoing Finn Balor/Damian Priest tension might be good television, it doesn’t mean dominating WWE airwaves is the best avenue.

The now-clichéd Judgment Day show-opening promo threatened to delve into soap opera territory before interruptions from JD McDonagh (on Finn’s behalf) and Sami Zayn (to attack JD) took it back to WWE trope territory. And this gave us another trope, the impromptu match.

Advertisement

There are better ways to convey the dissonance between Priest and Balor than forced dialogue and an intermediary. The idea of McDonagh being sent out on Balor’s behalf was an interesting twist after Damian failed to keep the veil up that everything was OK. Maybe if everything else wasn’t so hackneyed, it wouldn’t have felt like a blob of WWE formula.

2. The Return Of The Dead Crowd

WWE.com

It was a nice run while it lasted.

WWE has been plagued in the past by arenas full of fans who sit on their hands for three hours, coming to life only for entrance singalongs, catchphrases and the closing moments of matches. Recently, it seemed like they had turned a corner, with crowds making noise organically, breathing some much-needed life into the product.

But if people thought this was a problem of the past, they were jolted back to reality Monday night with a dead crowd in Winnipeg, where fans watched Chad Gable and Giovanni Vinci wrestle in near-silence, not make a peep during Rhea Ripley’s match and mute themselves for much of Sami Zayn’s bout with JD McDonagh.

The fans almost always roused themselves for the finishes, but there was little reaction to the actual back-and-forth action, which is just baffling – people pay money for a ticket to a “sporting” event and then sit there like they’re at church. And it’s not just a few fans; it’s the entire arena.

Hopefully, this was a one-time regression. If this is the return of those dead crowds every week, Raw is going to suffer greatly.

1. All That, For THAT Finish?

WWE.com

Trish Stratus versus Becky Lynch is the zombie feud that just won’t die.

The ill-fated rivalry between a Hall-of-Famer and one of the best of this generation has underwhelmed at nearly every turn, right down to an expected SummerSlam match being bumped up to Raw, then punted two weeks to Monday night’s episode.

And then Monday’s match droned on for what seemed like forever, only to end in a double count-out and brawl in the concession area, setting up a third blowoff match between the two at an undisclosed time – inside a steel cage.

Advertisement

Why? Why continue this underperforming, atrocious feud? It was bad enough they did a 2-second match a couple of weeks ago, bypassed SummerSlam and then didn’t even give this a main-event slot (not that it actually deserved it), but to drag it out to another match is just madness. The dead crowd – in Trish’s home country – the blown spots and the dismal reception for the entire feud should have been enough to mercy kill it right here.

They’re not trying to make lemonade from lemons; they’re trying to get blood from a stone. And this stone was bled dry before WWE started to squeeze.

UPS…

6. Trying To Pick Up McIntyre’s Spirits

WWE.com

Matt Riddle regressing back to his “But Raaaaandy…” tag team idiot persona is hardly a positive, but there was a silver lining to it Monday night.

The Original Bro approached Drew McIntyre backstage and tried to bring the Scottish Warrior out of his post-SummerSlam funk, asking him to team up against the Viking Raiders. While Riddle did the same goofball shtick that he employed alongside Randy Orton – and garnered groans because of the regression to a comedy character who is ripe for falling victim to a heel turn – it actually worked to a small extent.

Riddle and McIntyre had previously teamed and had each other’s backs. Drew was clearly down after his loss to Gunther at SummerSlam – Wade Barrett even made mention that the Scot hadn’t returned his calls – and Riddle’s attempts were aimed at raising his spirits. And for one night, it worked, with Drew celebrating their victory. (Next week against New Day might be a different story.)

Advertisement

Of course, this can all fall apart at any minute, much in the way fans expected Orton to turn on Riddle. But if WWE can resist making Riddle a total idiot, he might actually be a sympathetic face for when McIntyre tires of this routine.

Fair warning: If they go the pure moron route, fans might actually cheer McIntyre turning on him, so WWE would be wise to understand there’s a fine line… and when have they ever missed an opportunity at subtlety?

5. New Champ Alert!

WWE

News about Sonya Deville’s unfortunate injury just weeks after finally winning a title in WWE was heartbreaking – there’s never a good time to go down with a torn ACL, but this was rotten.

Deville’s injury also cast doubt on the future of the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship, which has been vacated multiple times in the past year-plus, with champs bit by the injury bug as well.

Adam Pearce was on the verge of forcing Chelsea Green to relinquish the titles when she suggested holding auditions for a new tag partner to take up Sonya’s spot, a move that isn’t completely unprecedented in WWE lore. Katana Chance & Kayden Carter came into Pearce’s office looking for a tag title shot, only for Chance to get blindsided by a returning Piper Niven, who declared herself Chelsea’s new partner.

Advertisement

Green’s shock and ensuing attempt to wiggle out of this arrangement was great, and it was made even better by Niven basically saying that she wasn’t suggesting it – she was stating it as fact.

Better yet, Piper providing the muscle while Chelsea continues her rants against WWE management and the women’s division could be pretty entertaining. It would switch up the dynamic from two complainers to one epic Karen with a bodyguard.

4. Simple, Straightforward Motivation

WWE.com

Why Shinsuke, why?

Oh, Nakamura just wants the World Heavyweight Championship. And he wants to get an edge on Seth Rollins. That’s why he blindsided the champ with a Kinshasa last week. Sometimes, you don’t need some great motivation or long, detailed explanation of your internal struggle. Just, “I want the title” will suffice every now and again.

Rollins of course as the fighting champion accepted this challenge Monday night, only to be stunned by something Shinsuke whispered to him, only to eat another Kinshasa via sneak attack. This was mindgames without the announcers using that term repeatedly to drive the point home.

Advertisement

Make no mistake: This feud isn’t going to captivate fans’ imaginations or set the world on fire. But as a challenger stepping up because he simply wants a world title he’s never captured, Nakamura is a fine opponent for Rollins.

3. Rhea Runs Over Hartwell

WWE.com

No messing about here, and no reason to give Indi Hartwell anything more than the briefest of hope spots in her match against Rhea Ripley.

The Women’s World Champion steamrolled the Raw rookie without breaking a sweat, more indignant than anything that Indi managed to land a spinebuster and a few shots on her. Ripley might not wrestle often on Monday nights, but when she does, it’s with a viciousness that makes her stand out from everyone else on the roster. Hartwell – and many others – aren’t in the same league, so why bother to give her offense to pad out a match runtime?

Advertisement

This was nothing more than a good squash to remind fans that Rhea is more than an integral part of Judgment Day – she’s dominant in her own universe.

2. Alphas, Imperium Step Up The Friction

WWE.com

Watch out, WWE is actually building up an Imperium/Alpha Academy feud in which you might become invested.

Chad Gable’s five-minute survival against Gunther was fumbled a bit, but the two factions have managed to make this rivalry something to watch, with Ludwig Kaiser in particular stepping up as a slimy heel putting the moves on Maxxine Dupri. His promo Monday night was glorious as he called Alpha Academy a sinking ship and offered a hand to Maxxine to save her from the 360-pound anchor dragging her down toward embarrassment.

And then there was Gable toppling Giovanni Vinci in a fun little match, followed by Gunther defeating Otis in no-nonsense fashion, followed immediately by Gable getting the drop on the Intercontinental Champion.

Advertisement

Odds are that Chad Gable is not going to end Gunther’s near-record IC title reign, but he’s building a fair amount of momentum and investment that you know he’s going to land a home run at some point in their match and fans are going to bite.

But even afterward, a tag match between these two factions – or a six-man if the Alphas can find a suitable teammate – could garner a spot on a PLE or be a spotlight match on Raw as the rivalry potentially continues. The personalities mesh well, the in-ring action is class, and the Dupri wrinkle is a fun one. More of this please.

1. A Hot Closing Segment

WWE.com

Cody Rhodes and the Judgment Day in the same segment is probably the best case scenario for WWE these days. Despite all the goofiness, the heel stable is still one of the hottest acts on the show, and they’re still menacing enough to give Rhodes and any allies fits.

The American Nightmare defeated Finn Balor in exactly the kind of match fans would expect from two skilled professionals, but it was the aftermath that stuck out. The Judgment Day pounced, and Sami Zayn ran down to make the save, only for JD McDonagh to tip the scales, leading to a 5-on-2 beatdown that saw the heels stand tall.

Beating up the red brand’s top babyface and one-half of the tag champs is a pretty good sign that despite any group turmoil, Judgment Day is still a force. It would be better if WWE nixed some of the melodrama of the opening segment, and the miscue with the briefcase during the Rhodes/Balor match made Damian Priest and Finn look like amateurs.

Advertisement

Overall though, this was a strong closing segment. If WWE can resist the urge to create “drama” and “tension” every week, they’d have something here.