6 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (31 Jan)

Dog food or dog sh*t?

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

Vince McMahon loves any excuse to play sophomoric pranks.

Advertisement

Why else would the real big boss man book his wrestlers to fart on screen, crap their pants due to explosive diarrhoea or eat disgusting amounts of dog food over the years? It's childish, it's over-the-top, it's WWE sports entertainment, and this week...it was a great laugh.

That's right, there's no po-faced criticism in this article about 'King' Corbin's misfortune. In fact, it was one of the biggest 'Ups' from a night of Royal Rumble follow up that also had its fair share of 'Downs'. WWE are very much back to killing time between now and WrestleMania, it seems.

Advertisement

Still, they did at least make time to set up some stuff for both Elimination Chamber and the ill-needed (or wanted, depending on your tolerance) Super ShowDown special in Saudi Arabia at the end of February. The company could've done without at least one of those shows, that's clear, and this week's SmackDown proved that.

Oh, and the Super Bowl is this weekend on the off chance you haven't been paying attention to real-world sports. Even if you haven't, all you need is a black sharpie pen...

Advertisement

Downs...

4. The Half-Assed Super Bowl Tie-In

WWE.com

This wasn't a regular edition of SmackDown. It was a "Super" one.

Advertisement

WWE's Super Bowl tie-in was so blatantly last-minute this writer almost died from giggling. It's like someone at FOX said, 'Uh, guys, the Chiefs play the 49ers in 48 hours. Maybe you should say something about that on SmackDown?'; panic must've been everywhere backstage before someone reached for the black marker pens.

The word "Super" was super-imposed over the top of the usual SmackDown logo like someone had rediscovered Microsoft Paint. Either that or Hogan and the boys had been called upon to bring their old nWo spray cans to the show so WWE's graphics department could go to town on that logo '4 life'.

Advertisement

As usual, the word "Super" was a lazy attempt at souping up a show that didn't need it. Despite pre-advertising four HUGE matches beforehand, WWE mostly phoned it in on Friday when it came to in-ring action. Their NFL hype may have been bigger were it not for Vinnie Mac's own football league too.

3. Skewed Logic

WWE.com

The four-way tag match to determine new number one contenders for New Day's SmackDown Tag belts wasn't elimination style, so why in the name of Christmas hams did everyone willingly tag other guys in? It didn't make much sense.

Advertisement

At one point, Corey Graves noted that Lucha House Party man Lince Dorado was "in a bad way", so he "had to tag in anybody". No! Why would he risk losing the match even if he was hurt? Surely, it'd be preferable for a title-hungry wrestler to fail on his own terms rather than hoping someone wouldn't get pinned or submitted before he recovered.

There was no logic here.

Advertisement

It made matters worse than this match was important. The Lucha lads should be breaking their necks to earn a crack at the SmackDown Tag-Team Titles, not gleefully tagging out of the match just because they need to sell a big bump. Other teams did it too. Maddening.

2. The Death Of A Faction?

WWE.com

If this is to be the end of Sami Zayn's heel faction alongside Shinsuke Nakamura and Cesaro, then WWE creative deserve a slap. Sami is one of the best talkers on the roster, gets great heel heat and knows how to work the manager gig better than most today. He's been rewarded by losing his threat.

Advertisement

Every single bit of it.

On SmackDown, Sami accidentally cost Nakamura the Intercontinental Title, whinged about it backstage, was interrupted by Elias and then sent Cesaro out to get turned over by the music man. It was a complete disaster for heel credibility, and it made the previously-important threesome look like a bunch of chumps even the Mean Street Posse would pity.

Advertisement

WWE need to think long and hard before they book any kind of split between Nakamura and Zayn especially. Sami is there to do Shin's promos for a reason, and nobody needs 2017-era Naka to make a sweeping comeback any time soon.

1. The Lack Of Bray Wyatt

WWE.com

It was totally understandable that Daniel Bryan took a week off. He was a beaten, disconsolate man after Royal Rumble's Strap Match, and he was filmed for YouTube questioning whether or not he loves pro wrestling "too much".

Advertisement

That's all well and good, but where the hell was Bray Wyatt? There was no 'Firefly Fun House' segment, and barely any mention of his 'Fiend' character at all beyond some Rumble recap. It's not that Wyatt needs to wrestle every week as Universal Champion, but he probably should be featured somehow.

Isn't that why he has two personas?

Advertisement

WWE chose to kill time this week instead of motor forwards towards WrestleMania and the Wyatt vs. Roman Reigns match everyone and their dog (hopefully one that eats better-quality food than 'King' Corbin) knows is coming.

Ups...

6. Cupid Goes Stupid

WWE

What's love got to do with it? If you're endearing funny man Otis, everything.

Advertisement

Heavy Machinery's finest landed himself a big Valentine's Day date with Mandy Rose on this week's show, and it was genuinely hard not to smile. Otis is that one kid at school everyone knew. You know the one – that guy nobody wanted to buddy up with for projects, and the last little dude to get picked on teams when it came to playing sports.

He's a likeable babyface, and that's a trait which often comes at a premium in this promotion. WWE aren't forcing things either, which is only making the tale better. Otis was nervous, Mandy teased she'd decline his offer to go out, Sonya and Tucker played their roles perfectly and then the story had a happy ending.

Advertisement

If nothing else, these segments in two weeks are gonna' be fun. Someone on that writing team must convince Vince McMahon that Otis showing up in his ring gear with a bow tie is for the best. He should be loud, OTT and chronically awkward.

5. Sheamus Moves On

WWE.com

The biggest surprise on SmackDown was that Michael Cole and Corey Graves weren't instructed to say things like, 'Sheamus made short work of Shorty G' and, 'Now Sheamus can move on to bigger things'. Hahahahahahaha. Aren't height jokes just the best?

Advertisement

You're right, they're not.

In all seriousness, Sheamus running through Chad Gable for the second time in a week was the right call. The Irishman has another big (that wasn't another height gag, honest) run in him, and his feud with Shorty was always going to be a brief one. Now it's done, Sheamus can target the Intercontinental Title or maybe take part in an Elimination Chamber match.

Advertisement

One thing's for sure: WWE have to get more out of Sheamus that they did in this fleeting rivalry. It didn't quite lead to the great matches this fan expected it too, and it didn't exactly heap sympathy on Gable the way WWE might've liked.

4. Naomi's In The Frame

WWE.com

Lacey Evans was presumably in the same lockbox backstage that Daniel Bryan and Bray Wyatt were hiding out in. She neither addressed her failure to become SmackDown Women's Champion at the Royal Rumble nor got in Bayley's face for bragging like a bully.

Advertisement

Naomi was the one wheeled out to replace her, and she's next in line to challenge the heel champion for her belt before WrestleMania 36. In fairness, it makes sense (Naomi got a nice pop at the Rumble, looked great on her return and has shown before that she can pull the best out of anaemic heel champs).

She has a real challenge on her hands with Bayley.

Advertisement

The reining champ's promo skills were lacking once again here. Her material was fine, but the way Bayley laughs at the audience and delivers her lines lacks real venom. Fingers crossed some fast-paced matches with Naomi can get her over this hump.

3. Dirt Sheet Wins Clean

WWE.com

As confusing as the format for that four-way tag match was, it's true that the right team won.

Advertisement

The Miz and John Morrison were always going to win, sure, though the obvious result shouldn't detract from the fact it was the right one. Perhaps the only downside here is that the announcers hyped Miz and Morrison vs. New Day for Super ShowDown, not WrestleMania.

The 'Dirt Sheet' boys are Saudi Arabia bound then. Looking on the bright side, this might be the first chapter in a feud that could stretch to 'Mania; if the SmackDown Tag Title bout is early on the card in Saudi, there's a chance it'll end via disqualification and allow for some sort of rematch come Houston's big night.

Advertisement

That's acceptable booking, especially when one considers how poor the SmackDown doubles division has been as of late when it comes to pure story. Ideally, WWE will book Miz and Morrison to have Big E and Kofi Kingston's number until Xavier Woods can return from injury and make the difference.

2. New IC Champ

WWE.com

In 201 days as WWE Intercontinental Champion, Shinsuke Nakamura defended his belt on television exactly four times (and one of them was this loss to Braun Strowman). Naka beat Ali at Smackville on the Network in July 2019, bested The Miz at Clash Of Champions in September and lost by DQ to Roman Reigns on the 18 October episode of SmackDown.

Advertisement

Hardly the most memorable of stints then.

Braun Strowman should offer an improvement for the IC's fortunes. He's someone WWE love, and he does get a lot of TV time even when the company aren't using him to the best of his abilities. Strowman's fans won't care about Nakamura's misery either. They'll look at the near future and see that Braun has a guaranteed spot on 'Mania's main card to look forward to.

Advertisement

His first singles title in WWE will be a big deal personally as well, but it'll end up meaning little if WWE don't learn from the Shinsuke experience and book more championship defences on SmackDown and pay-per-views to come.

1. 'King' Corbin's Humiliation

WWE.com

There will be some fans out there hating on 'King' Corbin's dog food humiliation from this week's show. Detractors will point to the silliness of it all, and to the 50/50 nature of the booking (Corbin did this to Roman Reigns, so the babyface must do this to the heel). Some may even think it ruined the need for a 'Falls Count Anywhere' match at the Rumble.

Advertisement

This writer doesn't agree with some of that.

Yes, it was silly, and yes, it did dilute the Rumble stip, but anyone who willingly turns on WWE programming must know they're going to see things like this every so often. It's Vince McMahon's way, and it has been since the mid-80s. This is what WWE do. Besides, it's not like Corbin can't shrug off the embarrassment.

Advertisement

He's a heel, and he's supposed to look foolish from time-to-time. Fans in attendance for SmackDown had a great time laughing at his comeuppance, and Corbin himself sold the canned pet food like it was skin-burning acid. The skit put a bow on his pesky pursuit of Reigns.

Plus, it was better than that lifeless 'Big Dog' nonsense from several months ago.

Advertisement

What other takeaways do you have from this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out 10 Times Wrestlers Ignored Direct Orders and 10 WWE Stars Who Will Miss WrestleMania 36!