6 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Bad Blood (Results & Review)
Punk and McIntyre settle their (literal) blood feud, Dom hangs around, and an electrifying return.
The era of WWE PLE super-cards is well in the rear-view mirror, leaving shows like Saturday’s Bad Blood as the new normal: a five-match show that featured a Match of the Year contender, an angle-heavy main event, and three middling matches that could easily have taken place on free television.
That’s not to say that Bad Blood was a bad or uneventful show; far from it. Plenty happened here, even in those less-than-stellar matches, to advance stories. But the bar has been consistently raised across wrestling in recent years, and delivering average matches – or worse, sloppy ones – on Premium Live Events is simply something that can’t be overlooked or brushed aside.
Still, WWE delivered probably its best Hell in a Cell match in years with Drew McIntyre and CM Punk leaving it all – including their blood – in the ring, restoring (for one night, at least) the true magnitude of what a cell match should encompass. This battle, along with the main event, made Bad Blood worth a view and worth an overall thumbs up.
However, WWE’s continued bizarre obsession with trying to artificially make its Saudi shows more important via sportswashing took center stage once again, dragging the PLE to a screeching halt right in the middle of the event.
Thankfully the closing 10 minutes delivered a couple of huge surprises to wash any bad taste out of fans’ mouths.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
5. Don’t Promise Something You Can’t Deliver…
Or something you really shouldn’t try to deliver...
During Triple H’s presentation of the Crown Jewel Championship, Gunther came down to the ring (more on his promo later) to praise the new title, and then to run down one of the legends at ringside: Atlanta’s own Goldberg.
A couple of weeks ago, Gunther told Bret Hart in Canada that he was one of his favorite wrestlers, behind Goldberg – the man who ended Bret's career. It was a great piece of meta-heel work, using an inside reference that worked on the surface as well.
Saturday, Gunther dredged that back up by telling Goldberg that he lied when he said that last month, remarking that the greatest wrestler alive couldn’t possibly be impressed by “a one-trick pony.” This and an insult dragging his son Gage into the mix prompted Goldberg to hop the barricade and approach the ring, with security holding him back as Gunther taunted that he had three minutes for the WCW legend.
All of this might have popped the crowd, but it also put the thought of Goldberg back in the ring in your head, and his last matches in WWE were… less than good. The notion of Gunther and Goldberg colliding does not invoke good vibes, unless it involves the Ring General putting the aging superstar down in 30 seconds.
Most likely, this isn’t something that is on the horizon. Goldberg, 57, hasn’t had a match in more than two years and looked run down back then. He was exposed almost every time he stepped into a ring in the last couple of years. So, if this was just an occasion to pop the hometown crowd, it worked, but it also implied a match that either WWE won’t deliver, or if it happens, the match itself very likely won’t deliver.
4. Underwhelming Women’s Title Match
Following the Hell in a Cell match was always going to be a tough act, but the Women’s Championship match did itself no favors.
Nia Jax and Bayley clashed Saturday night in a somewhat plodding, sloppy match that barely survived on a couple of cute moments (the referee bump and Tiffany Stratton’s contemplated Money in the Bank cash-in). The match started with Jax dominating with her power before Bayley managed to land some blows to get back into it.
However, the match was littered with messy or contrived spots: Bayley’s neckbreaker in the ropes, Nia’s purported hurricanrana, Jax’s Samoan Drop, and Stratton whiffing on her first briefcase shot.
Jax and Bayley have had much better title matches than Saturday’s effort. This was a disappointment.
3. Should Have Lowered Expectations
In his latter outings as World Heavyweight Champion, Damian Priest was starting to show an aptitude for being a big-match wrestler. And Finn Balor has always had that ability to deliver huge in the clutch.
Given those facts, the collision between the former Judgment Day teammates should have been a can’t-miss success. Instead, Priest and Balor turned in an average-at-best match. Damian had some good fire-up moments and overcame the odds to emerge victorious, but this was a Raw television match, not one of five matches on a PLE card allegedly blowing off a months-long feud.
Maybe it’s a function of expecting too much from both men. The match itself wasn’t bad, but given the quality of wrestling fans see on a weekly basis, this should have delivered more in this spot, and it didn’t.
2. Making Rhea Look Foolish
WWE has booked itself into an awkward spot with Liv Morgan and Rhea Ripley.
Ripley clearly is the dominant, superior wrestler who should be able to take her Women’s World Championship back in a fair fight, but Liv is highly entertaining as the smarmy heel champion with a boyfriend who will gleefully interfere on her behalf.
Then WWE books a match with Dominik Mysterio in a shark cage to seemingly take him out of the equation when everyone well knows he’s going to factor into the match somehow. But rather than Dom escaping, he fell out of the cage and inexplicably was hung upside-down by a chain conveniently fastened to his ankle.
Even if you put the contrived nature of that aside (because it was visually hilarious), what came next was just plain stupid. Rhea asked the referee (on camera) for leniency so she could abandon the match to wallop Mysterio with a kendo stick. Mind you, Ripley has gotten her hands on Dom a few times already, and she had Liv dead to rights in the ring, while Mysterio was literally not going anywhere.
Thus, Rhea looked like a babyface idiot bailing on winning the title she so desperately craved just to land a few kendo shots. That backfired when Raquel Rodriguez returned to attack Ripley – an attack that also was a botch because it happened in plain view of the ref, who had no choice but to call for a DQ. (It was pretty clearly a botch because the ref tried to turn away from Raquel, and she put Morgan on top of Ripley for a supposed pin.)
The idea was solid, but the execution was horrible. Fans in the arena seemed to love it though, so it’s hard to completely bash this match.
1. Another Worthless Saudi Belt
WWE’s partnership with Saudi Arabia is questionable enough for those who oppose it on the basis of human rights, geopolitical issues, or even just corporate greed. But all wrestling fans should be able to agree that Triple H’s “history-making” announcement at Bad Blood was a cheap ploy.
Billed as a “new era for WWE,” Triple H revealed that a new annual tradition would be taking place at Crown Jewel, with both the men’s and women’s WWE and World Heavyweight Champions facing each other at that Saudi show.
Neither title will be on the line, but the “definitive winner” will be awarded the Crown Jewel Championship, which was unveiled to be a gaudy, jewel-bespeckled belt. The announcement was met with a decent amount of boos, and rightfully so.
This is little more than a sportswashing ploy to juice the Saudi crowd by presenting the winner with a meaningless title that most likely will never be seen or mentioned on WWE programming again. (Go ask Braun Strowman where his Greatest Royal Rumble title belt is.) Further, the idea of pitting each brand’s world champ against each other harkens back to the Survivor Series PLEs of the 2010s, which played out to mixed results.
It also means none of the top four singles titles will ever be on the line at Crown Jewel – if this annual tradition holds. That could have an impact on card makeup going forward. The fact that all of this is happening at a Saudi show and was announced in the same segment where a Goldberg/Gunther match was teased just made this a huge dud.
Ups…
6. Belair Gives Heel Vibes
"I wish her the best of luck. ??"
BIANCA DOES NOT LIKE BAYLEY AT ALL STILL LMFFFFAOOO ?#WWEBadBlood pic.twitter.com/tXWkS8ZldF
Advertisement— Matt (@BWAChief) October 5, 2024
Being saddled with hosting duties for a PLE can feel like a pointless demotion for a gifted wrestler, but when it involves some character development, the assignment becomes a net positive.
The Women’s Tag Team Champions and Naomi hosted Bad Blood Saturday, opening the show in the ring and appearing in a couple of other segments. Before the WWE Women’s Championship match between Bayley and Nia Jax, Naomi voiced her strong support for her friend Bayley. For the second night in a row, Bianca Belair visibly cringed before saying she wished Bayley “the best of luck” and gave a disingenuous double thumbs-up.
The subtle (by WWE standards) heel work gave some meaning to a segment that often exists just to fill time. If Bianca is turning heel or getting more of an edge, this will be built upon going forward.
5. Delivering Moments
WWE has mastered the dark arts of covering up middling action and limited, five-match PLE cards with a variety of shortcuts and ga-ga.
The middle three matches at Bad Blood were underwhelming-to-decent-at-best, but each one had something memorable that occurred between the bell that fans can remember – moments that very possibly will overshadow match quality.
The WWE Women’s Championship match featured Tiffany Stratton interfering to save Nia Jax (after a rare female referee bump), leading to confusion between the champ and Tiffy about whether Ms. Money in the Bank was going to cash in her briefcase. That obviously will feed into growing distrust between Jax and Stratton.
Dominik Mysterio being hoisted into the air in a shark cage during the Women’s World Championship match on its own was an incredible visual, but Dirty Dom hanging upside-down from the cage by his ankle was even better, regardless of how contrived it was. Raquel Rodriguez returning to save Liv Morgan by attacking Rhea Ripley will be a major talking point heading into Raw as well.
Even Damian Priest and Finn Balor’s grudge match included the moment of Priest finally overcoming the Judgment Day numbers game that had befallen him multiple times during the past month.
While these moments don’t wholly overcome lacking matches with other flaws, they do deserve recognition as positive developments during Bad Blood.
4. Gunther Continues To Be Gold On The Mic
One of the most surprising stories of the last year-plus has to be Gunther’s success… as a promo guy.
Widely regarded as one of the best wrestlers in the industry, Gunther was on no one’s radar as a top guy on the mic a couple of years ago. But the Ring General has become so comfortable with the stick that it’s almost scary, like he was hiding this skill the whole time.
At Bad Blood, Gunther continued this trend as he tried to put over the gaudy Crown Jewel Championship by noting that Triple H had handed him the King of the Ring crown the last time they were in Saudi Arabia, and he would award him that title in four weeks when they return to the kingdom.
Gunther then took a swipe at Sami Zayn before attacking hometown hero Goldberg, prompting the events previously described. Aside from that though, he riled up the fans, who exploded when Sami Zayn attacked the World Heavyweight Champion and chased him to the back.
Although their world title match wasn’t taking place at the PLE, they managed to make it a hot ticket and generate interest in their clash on Raw Monday night.
3. House Show Tag With Some Pizazz
Let’s face it: the main event tag between the Bloodline and Roman Reigns & Cody Rhodes was mostly a pedestrian melodrama with very basic offense, up until the closing moments.
But match quality wasn’t the driving force here. It was the story of Cody and Roman being forced to team up to take down their mutual enemies, the new Bloodline. Even with the two megastars teamed up, they still found themselves in a deficit. Cody took out Jacob Fatu with a splash through the announce table, leaving Roman with Solo Sikoa… and the Tongans.
Reigns seemed about to fall victim to the same numbers game that benefited him for years, until Jimmy Uso resurfaced to take out Tama Tonga and Tanga Loa, allowing Roman to put Solo down with a spear.
The match itself was fine overall, but it thrived on the strength of the drama and the show of Roman returning to action and then reuniting with his cousin Jimmy. Reigns and Uso coming to Cody’s aid afterward was also a nice show of respect, indicating that the Original Tribal Chief might not be a pure “good guy,” but he’s true to his word.
2. "Yeah, But Whose Side Is He On?"
Of course, the biggest talking point coming out of Bad Blood has to be The Rock returning for the first time since the Raw after WrestleMania 40.
Rock carried his People’s Championship as he walked out in the closing moments, staring down Roman Reigns and Cody Rhodes. He didn’t say anything and simply gestured, “1, 2, 3” before his music played again and the PLE ended, leaving it completely open-ended as to his intentions.
When Rock last appeared, he was the Final Boss, his best version of a villain in eons, and he pledged that he would come back for Cody’s Undisputed WWE World Championship. Roman was at Rock’s side in the build to and including at WrestleMania, but his change of heart in siding with Rhodes against the new Bloodline could put him at odds with the Final Boss.
Even in a video posted to his social media accounts after Bad Blood, Rock left his intentions incredibly vague, forcing everyone to speculate for the foreseeable future.
1. A Methodical, Violent Build
For all the rhetoric about how much they hated each other with every fiber of their beings, Drew McIntyre and CM Punk certainly didn’t tear into each other at the beginning of their Hell in a Cell match.
They slowly walked toward each other and started with some punches and chops before spilling to the outside to brawl and retrieve plunder. But the muted opening would slowly build as Drew and Punk began using weapons, becoming increasingly violent. Punk busted McIntyre open hardway with a toolbox, leaving Drew’s hair blood-soaked and pasted to his head. They took turns grinding wrenches into their wounds. McIntyre suplexed Punk off the apron and through a table. Drew hit a White Noise on the steps.
But it was Punk who capitalized at the crucial moment, dodging a Claymore that carried Drew into a gruesome bump on the edge of the ring steps. A chain-wrapped knee provided the knockout power with a GTS, leaving Punk the winner in a violent Hell in a Cell match that fans haven’t seen in years. They avoided a lot of the showy ga-ga, and the match was all the better for it.
One of the best HIAC matches in years and maybe one of the best WWE bouts of the year. Great end to a feud that had peaked multiple times and needed to reach its climax. The fun will be seeing where each man goes from here.