6 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (Sept. 12)

Judgment Day has banner night, Owens rules on the mic, Deville stumbles in the ring.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

Well, of all the episodes of WWE Monday Night Raw that have been reviewed in this column, Monday’s show certainly was one of them.

Advertisement

It’s difficult to put into words how to feel about this episode. It wasn’t bad, but unlike recent weeks, it wasn’t that great either. It featured a couple of really good little matches, and it also had a couple of clunkers that should have been trimmed in length. It had a passionate promo that was all fire, and it had announcer banter that made you reach for an icepick for your brain.

Kevin Owens could have talked for another five minutes. He was magnificent as he dressed down Austin Theory. Johnny Gargano showed fans why he’s earned his nickname. And Matt Riddle and Finn Balor did serviceable work.

But the Women’s Tag Team Championship match was messy, while the Raw Women’s Championship bout felt like neither woman was on the same page. Throw in Dexter Lumis stalking, an Omos squash and announcers arguing and you have a very uneven show.

Some of the criticisms here are items that have previously been overlooked, but as Raw’s overall quality has improved, we’ve been forced to look more critically at the show and begin to expect more from the program. It’s not fair to keep grading on a curve when WWE actually studies for the exam and begins passing.

Let’s get to it…

Downs…

5. Not Everyone’s Cup Of Tea

Advertisement

In case you haven’t noticed, the Dexter Lumis/Miz saga has vacillated between positive and negative in this column throughout its run on Raw.

Quite simply, it’s hard to peg down a feeling about this ongoing story of Lumis silently stalking Miz at every turn like a serial killer. Some weeks, it’s mildly amusing. Other weeks, it’s painfully bad.

Monday night’s stalking involved Dexter trespassing at Miz’s house, and then going inside after Miz and Maryse had left to leave a drawing for him… all caught on WWE cameras while Corey Graves freaked out about Lumis possibly kidnapping Miz’s family.

When this stuff is in the arena, it’s one thing, but when it’s in “the real world,” wrestling rules don’t necessarily apply, so this then feels awkward and icky. And yeah, some fans probably loved it, and that’s fine, but this just didn’t cut it.

Also, what’s the payoff going to be? Lumis doesn’t talk, and he’s not exactly a prolific wrestler, so it’s not like we’re going to get some really passionate speech or a good match at the end of it. It’s just a lot of unblinking staring and general creepiness.

4. SHUT UP

WWE

At what point can we get a serious petition going to separate Corey Graves and Byron Saxton permanently? Send one to Antarctica and the other to the Arctic Circle and leave them there.

Their constant bickering on Raw isn’t adding anything to the product. It’s not producing any good analysis or insight. It’s just annoying and distracting from the actual product. During Raw Monday night, the two yammered mindlessly over top of Johnny Gargano’s entrance, thus muting (to the TV audience) the impact of the crowd's reaction to his first match.

But it’s not just that. After years of listening to Graves and Saxton argue, you just go numb and lose track of all the bad moments. Oh look, Saxton the man-child said something dumb. Now Graves will talk about how he can’t get a date and lives with his parents, and then Saxton will make an insipid “comeback” to prove Corey’s point.

And Raw rolls on…

3. Impromptu Opener

WWE

What was the opening match for Raw going to be if we didn’t have the impromptu conflict between Matt Riddle and Finn Balor? If not for that confrontation, would there just have been a 15-minute gap in programming?

Those are serious questions. We’ve given a pass to WWE for years now for stuff like this, but it’s time to start expecting a bit better from them. Seth Rollins opened Raw, and was interrupted by Riddle, who then was confronted by Judgment Day. This led to the Balor/Riddle match, which clearly wasn’t planned.

So what was supposed to be the opening match? WWE loves this booking crutch, and while you can get away with it once in a while, they do it so often that we have to knock them for it here. You can’t keep pretending to book on the fly and expect to have it work every time.

2. Deville Drags Title Match Down

WWE.com

Bianca Belair is a special talent. She’s incredibly gifted in the ring.

So when the Raw Women’s Championship open challenge was clunky and messy throughout, you have to look at the challenger: Sonya Deville.

The match seemed to be wrestled by two women on different pages of different books, with even Belair looking frustrated a few times. At one point, they seemingly got confused on an exchange and Bianca basically forced Deville into a suplex on the fly. At another moment, she sat up from a pinfall attempt looking perturbed.

Advertisement

Even Corey Graves was openly bashing Deville on commentary about how she was wasting time and wasn’t going to win a title the way she was wrestling. That’s never a good sign, because it has to be approved by whoever is in Gorilla. Maybe that was meant as a message to her, but it certainly wasn’t positive news.

1. Right Call, Bad Execution

WWE.com

The moment the rematch from the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship tournament finals was announced last week, it felt like the outcome was a fait accompli. But that doesn’t mean it’s an automatic “up.”

Damage CTRL was set up to get a rematch for the tag titles against Aliyah & Raquel Rodriguez after the champs won by pinning the wrong competitor in the finals. It was kind of an unnecessary detour to get where everyone knew it was going to end up.

The match itself was nothing special, and it was seriously hurt when Aliyah apparently got injured midway through, seemingly hurting her shoulder. The match ground to a halt as the ref repeatedly checked on her, and then rather than targeting her arm, Dakota Kai went to… a chinlock.

The bout plodded along so Raquel Rodriguez could get her offense in, running through both heels before tagging out to Aliyah, who botched taking Kai’s finisher before being pinned.

Advertisement

If the injury was real and Aliyah gutted it out, good for her, but maybe they should have called an audible and gone to a finish, because the match was dull and anticlimactic. If she wasn’t really hurt, then they should have shortened the match down to Raquel running wild for two minutes, Aliyah tagged in and got pinned in 30 seconds. Everything else was bad fluff.

Ups…

6. WRESTLING

WWE.com

If you like watching wrestling when you turn on a World WRESTLING Entertainment program, you were likely happy with what you saw Monday night.

Raw featured six matches, five of which ran 12-15 minutes. Out of 180 minutes of programming, matches consumed more than one-third of that time, 68 minutes. And the in-ring action was mostly good. You had two championship matches – including one title change – a return bout for a superstar who had been away for nine months, and a blood feud that was set up a week in advance.

There’s less reliance on backstage antics, which is great, and best of all, fans are reacting to the longer matches. This doesn’t mean that every match needs to go 12-15 minutes. In fact, at least one could have had five minutes lopped off. But overall, this is a positive trend.

5. Weaving Stories Together

WWE.com

WWE did a nice job weaving the Seth Rollins opening promo with Matt Riddle attacking him, which then gave way to Judgment Day offering him a spot.

What made this work was some decent storytelling (imagine that!) from the announcers noting that Judgment Day only seems to show up when superstars are emotionally conflicted and drained, thus vulnerable to their entreaties. It made them look opportunistic, and it gave them a reason to be there.

Advertisement

This set up the Riddle/Finn Balor match, which itself was pretty good, and then Rollins returned after being attacked by the Original Bro to repay him and cost him the match.

All of it is tied together. Maybe it wasn’t the prettiest package, but it made sense, and it actually gave Judgment Day a possible calling card of showing up whenever a wrestler is down on their luck.

4. Judgment Day Gets Off Mysterio Train

WWE.com

Monday’s opening match was noteworthy for one important reason: It finally brought someone else into Judgment Day’s orbit.

Ever since Finn Balor joined the group in June, he and Damian Priest have only faced five men in matches: Rey and Dominik Mysterio, Rey’s best friend Edge, and a short offshoot against AJ Styles and Dolph Ziggler.

For Balor, six of his last eight televised matches involved the Mysterios. For Priest, seven of his last eight TV bouts involved the Mysterios or Edge. That’s a lot of repeat matches.

But Monday, Finn tangled with Matt Riddle in a solid opening match that lasted a good 14 minutes. Although there was some outside interference, there was a decisive finish, with Balor hitting the Coup de Grace on Riddle for the pin after several near-falls.

Advertisement

Now, if we could see Judgment Day branch out a bit more and fight others on the Raw roster, that would be nice. We’ve done the Mysterios and Edge to death. At least have some side matches with others to keep things fresh.

3. Johnny Wrestling Gets Back To Work

WWE.com

When it comes to picking an opponent for a featured superstar’s return match, you want to make sure you have the right person to help accomplish your goal.

In the case of Johnny Gargano’s singles match debut on Raw, you knew WWE wanted to showcase his in-ring skills to their fullest. Enter: Chad Gable.

Gable and Gargano had a great TV match where the outcome never really was in doubt – they weren’t beating Johnny Wrestling in his big spotlight bout – but both men worked at alternating rhythmic and frantic paces, exchanging mat wrestling holds, dominating the other, going into overdrive for the finish. It sucked the fans in completely and made Gargano look like a huge deal, while Gable once again looked like a wizard in the ring.

Advertisement

Great stuff from Gable and Gargano, with the video package beforehand giving fans a bit more background on Johnny to make it a bit more meaningful.

2. Rhea Brings Out Dominik’s Evolution

WWE.com

Call Rhea Ripley Dominik Mysterio’s whisperer. At least, that’s how they’re portraying her these days.

Ripley was seen literally whispering in Dom’s ear during his backstage promo, prompting Mysterio to add that he’s now a man. She later shooed Rey away while Dominik was preparing for his match against Edge. And she was ringside with Dominik, offering encouragement and advice during the match.

Meanwhile, Dominik still is learning on the fly, but he’s already 20 times more interesting as a member of Judgment Day than just Rey’s son. And his promo nailed that very point, about how a small man like Rey casts a big shadow, and Dom wanted to get out of it.

Advertisement

The match itself was decent enough, and it got the greater point across, that Judgment Day actually is dangerous, as they took out Edge to close the show. Perhaps now the group can move on and pick a new target before we get the inevitable Rey/Dominik match.

1. Theory Still A Focal Point, Just Shifted

WWE.com

It’s funny how Austin Theory has gone from Vince McMahon’s handpicked golden boy to whipping boy in less than two months, yet he still is a major focus of Raw each week.

Theory has been beaten at nearly every turn in the past several weeks, with Johnny Gargano and Kevin Owens beating on him and putting him in his place. But then Monday night, Austin laid out Johnny Wrestling after the NXT stalwart’s successful singles debut, only to face off with KO yet again.

Owens lambasted Theory in a tremendous promo, sounding like an avatar for Triple H as he said that Austin might have been the handpicked future, but that’s not how it works in WWE anymore. He noted that he might not look like Theory, but dozens of guys like him have come through WWE in the past couple of decades and fizzled out, while the KOs and Garganos of the world are the heart and soul of the business. He then dared Theory to prove him wrong, finally slapping him.

Advertisement

It all ended in a big pull-apart brawl that saw Theory bloodied. This is a clever way of leaning into Theory’s character and motivation under Mr. McMahon and turning it on its head. It allows Triple H to say – through Owens – what he wants to say to fans about WWE being more of a meritocracy. And it allows Theory – who isn’t just some pretty boy – to possibly evolve from this character, even if he has to be broken down to do it.

There seems to be a lot at work here through this storyline, and it feels a lot more ambitious than just battering Theory.