6 Ups And 8 Downs From WWE Crown Jewel 2019
The Fiend redeems, women make history, marquee matches disappoint.
To call Crown Jewel 2019 the best of the four Saudi Arabia supershows would be an understatement.
Thursday’s PPV was the first of the bunch to truly be newsworthy, noteworthy and historic all at the same time. We witnessed history with the first women’s wrestling match in the country. We saw a major title change hands. We saw some decent wrestling on the card.
Most importantly, we walked away from Crown Jewel with something to talk about on SmackDown that in theory should get people to tune in. That doesn’t happen often, especially after the Saudi shows.
However, the PPV was not without its usual drawbacks. The battle royal was largely a waste. The two most hyped matches on the card underperformed even low expectations. And the tag team turmoil match must have been booked on a napkin in catering a half-hour before bell time, because it was the dumbest outcome short of the B-Team winning it all.
This version of Crown Jewel will be remembered going forward, but it’s not the kind of show you’ll settle in and rewatch. But if you caught it, you probably don’t feel like it was a waste of your time.
With that said, let’s buckle down and find out what made this show click and what made it clang.
Let’s get to it…
Downs...
8. Battle Royal Stupidity
In WWE, comedy, not competition, reigns supreme. Sorry, “comedy.”
That means that rather than watching a battle royal that focusing on intense competition to earn a United States Championship title match, you’ll see dumb things like No Way Jose trying to get Luke Harper and Erick Rowan to dance. (He got beaten up and tossed.) Or you’ll see Akira Tozawa try to stand up to Rowan and then (figuratively) defecate himself when Harper comes up behind him. You’ll see Drake Maverick try to slam Rowan, because it’s funny, see?
And look, this writer isn’t a total curmudgeon. Comedy spots when done well are entertaining as hell. But none of that was funny. And with a title shot on the line, why is Jose trying to get two of the biggest heels to dance?
In a match where very little stood out positively, dumb things are magnified.
7. Flippy-Flippy For Nothing
Wrestlers flying around the ring showing off their acrobatic skills is part of the nature of today’s in-ring action. It’s often entertaining to see performers doing things the average person can only dream of.
But when someone does it stupidly and it directly leads to them losing, then we’ve got to flag that.
During the opening contest in the tag team turmoil match, Gran Metalik came in to take on Robert Roode and Dolph Ziggler. He was faring pretty well overall, hitting dropkicks and dives everywhere. But then at the end, he watched Roode walk off to the side with the referee and decided to hit a handspring backflip – and landed right in a Ziggler superkick. That led to a Glorious DDT and their elimination.
Now, maybe Roode was way out of position. But watching it live, Metalik looked like a moron going for a “move” like that when no one was in the same zip code. He basically opened himself up to get beaten. In the grand scheme of things, this is nothing, but it was a moment where this writer jumped forward at the stupidity of that spot.
6. Does Anyone Think Around Here?
We’re not going to get super-preachy here, but someone in WWE has to have enough common sense to think things through, right?
The company rightly caught a ton of flack when they ran the Saudi Arabia show last year in the immediate wake of Saudi crown prince Mohammed bin Salman’s role in the murder of American journalist Jamal Khashoggi. (Several wrestlers have refused to perform there in light of that heinous crime.)
Khashoggi was dismembered after he was murdered. Maybe this is a stretch, but shouldn’t someone have grabbed Bray Wyatt before he went out and took his lantern away from him? You know, the one that looks like a dismembered head of the cult leader version of Bray?
It’s not a horrific sin, but a billion-dollar, image-conscious company should be smarter than that.
5. Cliched Ending
You would think a wrestling, er, sports entertainment company with a pedigree such as WWE that employs 87 writers would have numerous ideas and different ways to book matches, but the company constantly falls back on the same old tropes.
Case in point, the 20-man battle royal for a United States Championship title shot came down to Luke Harper, Erick Rowan and Humberto Carrillo. Whenever you see this scenario in WWE, you can almost book it: the two big men will team up on the little guy, and either one will backstab the other and have it backfire, or the little guy will get a surprise elimination before succumbing.
Sure enough, Rowan turned on Harper and eliminated his buddy while Harper was tossing Humberto, but the cruiserweight snuck back in and immediately tossed Rowan for the surprise victory.
God forbid you let a small guy look strong in victory. If it’s against bigger guys in WWE, the little guy must always look lucky.
4. Big Matches Fail To Deliver
Throughout the lead-up to Crown Jewel, two matches were pitched as the main draws, both circus bouts in their nature: Tyson Fury versus Braun Strowman, and Cain Velasquez versus Brock Lesnar.
Neither match was expected to be “good” in the traditional sense, but neither was entertaining in any way. The Velasquez/Lesnar match went on first and was over before people had sat down, with minimal action. The beatdown afterward (Brock attacking Cain and Rey Mysterio chairing Lesnar) lasted longer than the match.
The Fury/Strowman match could have been fun, but they clearly were limited in what they could do, and again, it just didn’t translate well. Sadly, this wasn’t Muhammad Ali confronting Gorilla Monsoon or a spectacle like that. It just fell flat, with Fury landing one punch as his offensive move and the match ending in a countout.
If you enjoyed these matches, bully for you, but this writer wasn’t expecting much and still wasn’t impressed.
3. A Big Mess
Tyson Fury was not going to turn into Ronda Rousey and become a combat athlete/wrestling prodigy overnight, but his match against Braun Strowman didn’t do anyone any favors.
Braun would lose by countout after Fury landed one of his few offensive moves: a right hand. Granted, as the lineal heavyweight boxing champion, Fury’s right hand should be a finisher. But when the match has slogged along clumsily and the wrestler has dominated much of the bout, losing to one offensive move just makes Braun look ineffective.
And then just to make this even more of a mess, Strowman hit a powerslam on Tyson afterward, and Fury immediately popped back up, no-selling Braun’s finisher. Because why not?
Yeah, that made Big Show/Akebono look refined by comparison.
2. A UFC-Length Title Match
No one was expecting a 60-minute broadway between Brock Lesnar and Cain Velasquez at Crown Jewel.
But what we got was a 2-minute “match” that featured a lot of tie-ups, close knee strikes and a flurry at the end with Cain getting a head kick before his ground-and-pound went south when Brock grabbed a Kimura for the tap-out.
On one hand, Lesnar losing to a man in his WWE debut would have been stupid. But to hype Velasquez as this badass who ended Brock’s UFC title reign and then fall in about 1/10 of the time that Daniel Bryan lasted with Lesnar is madness. (And Bryan had Brock more on the ropes than Velasquez did.)
What do you do with Cain now? He didn’t look impressive enough to sell him as a UFC killer in WWE. What fans are going to buy that off 120 seconds of “action” at Crown Jewel? This just throttled Velasquez down the card – if he’s sticking around WWE.
1. Who Booked This Crap?
This is in no way was a knock on WWE for booking The OC to win the Tag Team World Cup. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson are a solid duo who could use some accolades to their names.
But the way in which this was booked makes you want to smack a writer or three in the head.
The OC handed the Viking Raiders their first pinfall loss in NXT/WWE in about 5 minutes. Five freaking minutes of mediocre action. And the Raiders were the fresh team in the match!
To quote Randy Orton: “Stupid! Stupid! Stupid!”
Months of building up the Viking Raiders on the main roster as almost unbeatable monsters – they’ve defeated The OC three times already – was flushed just like that.
They could have booked this so much smarter, like have the Raiders enter much earlier and eke out wins against 2-3 teams, with Erik’s knee being targeted in each bout. Then, Anderson & Gallows focus on the injured body part and pull out the win over the exhausted Vikings. See? Easy.
But instead we got the dumbest outcome, overshadowing The OC’s victory.
Ups...
6. At Least Shane Didn’t Win
It’s sad when you have to list as a positive, “Thank God the owner’s son didn’t win a tournament he wasn’t originally entered in,” but such is WWE in 2019.
As mentioned earlier, The OC winning the Tag Team World Cup itself was not a negative, but how it was booked. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson are one of the most renowned tag teams on the roster right now, with credentials around the world, so winning this tournament actually make sense in a sort – though a tournament featuring the B-Team and Zack Ryder & Curt Hawkins isn’t exactly a tourney to crown the Best in the World.
So there you go. Kudos to The OC for not being Shane McMahon or losing to Shane in a surprise ending.
5. Rowan, Harper Dominate Battle Royal
Battle royals often are just time and space-fillers. The match quality isn’t great, and unless something is on the line, there isn’t much to crow about afterward.
The Crown Jewel battle royal was marked by one notable thing: the utter dominance by Erick Rowan and Luke Harper. The duo combined to eliminate 11 of the 19 wrestlers tossed, with Rowan tossing two men from the apron early on during an elimination scare himself.
Eliminations in battle royals don’t often count for much, but making someone look strong rather than doing a one-for-one elimination where no one stands out is preferable. If WWE wants to play this up on SmackDown Friday or Raw on Monday, they absolutely can.
They probably won’t, but we’ll give the credit and see if they shock us.
4. Home Country Advantage
When it was announced that Cesaro and Mansoor were having a match in Mansoor’s home country and hometown, you kinda knew what was going to happen.
The good thing is that Mansoor was up to the task of having a perfectly solid match with Cesaro, as the two traded bombs and near-falls throughout the match. Mansoor clearly is still young inside the ring, but he hung with the Swiss Superman well, unloading a standing moonsault, tornado DDT and diving crossbody as part of his arsenal.
In the end, Mansoor hit a superkick, sunset powerbomb and a moonsault for the upset win. The best part about this though was Michael Cole & Corey Graves actually selling this perfectly on commentary – how overmatched he was, the significance of fighting in his home country, how big of a deal it was to win.
Good storytelling can be a huge difference-maker, and considering how poor WWE announcers are at it typically, when they do it well, it should get a shout-out.
3. Women Make History
Let’s set aside the character break for Lacey Evans and the match quality and all of that nonsense for a minute: WWE made history with the first women’s wrestling match in Saudi Arabia. Period.
These shows have rightly been lambasted for many things, but one of the goals Triple H stated at the outset was this very one: that women would eventually wrestle here. And while they wore XL T-shirts instead of their normal gear and wrestled a pretty basic match, this was a first, and that’s truly noteworthy.
Natalya and Lacey clearly seemed moved by the entire experience, and it was great to see the fans really into it, which made you feel that this was the right move all along.
2. 5-on-5 Fun
There were no real stakes involved in the Team Hogan versus Team Flair tag match, but that wasn’t the point here.
What was the point was to have Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair parade around in front of the audience for a payday while “coaching” their respective teams. And what we got was a fun, entertaining 10-man tag match. It wasn’t overly complicated, but it also didn’t get weighed down with silliness either. It was something you might see on a big house show, complete with a clean pin after Roman Reigns hit a spear on Randy Orton.
There wasn’t much doubt that Hogan was going to beat Flair once again (naturally), but the action inside the ring was good enough to keep you watching even when you knew the outcome.
1. The Fiend Takes The Gold
WWE.com
It was a month overdue, but Bray Wyatt is your new WWE Universal Champion.
The match itself was too long and too over-the-top with Seth Rollins stomping The Fiend’s head into the stage a half-dozen times, but the outcome was at least the right one this time, as WWE seemingly learned its lesson from Hell in a Cell, where the match was rightly booed out of the arena.
Rollins threw everything he had at Wyatt, complete with steel chair shots, steel steps, eight stomps on the floor, countless superkicks and a few sledgehammer shots to boot. But The Fiend kept coming, finally locking in the Mandible Claw and hitting Sister Abigail for the title.
We could have done without Rollins kicking Wyatt into a pile of pyro for a cartoonish explosion, but when Fiend rose up out of the pile, it provided a really cool visual.
It will be interesting to see how they handle all of this, with Wyatt on SmackDown Friday night and the title originally belonging to Raw, but hey, maybe that’ll put more eyes on the blue brand this week, which would be a nice change of pace.