6 Ups And 9 Downs From WWE No Mercy 2016

Leading off with your closer? Not the best idea...

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

When you can easily say that a U.S. presidential debate was more entertaining than a WWE PPV, you know the company is in trouble.

Advertisement

Granted, the debate did involve a WWE Hall of Famer, but it still doesn’t excuse how off No Mercy was Sunday night. Opening the event with the main event – WWE World Championship triple threat – was a strange move. Presumably, this was done because the debate (which started an hour after the PPV started) was going to suck the oxygen out of WWE, but leading with the match sucked all the oxygen out of the live crowd. Plus, with a streaming WWE Network, fans could have watched the PPV at any time after the debate (as this writer did).

Regardless of match order, No Mercy was a disappointment. Becky Lynch did not compete, negating a Women’s Championship match. Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton competed in a dull, sloppy match that wasn’t worthy of the main event spot it occupied. And the rest of the PPV could have easily been broadcast on an episode of SmackDown… with one exception. We’ll leave that one as a pleasant surprise.

Advertisement

So what won over the crowd and what should have vanished into the ether? Let’s get to it…

Downs...

9. Glow Needs To Go

WWE.com

That header is not a knock against Naomi’s entrance itself. Her blacklight-infused entrance is unique and awesome.

Advertisement

However, her persona that goes along with it absolutely should be shelved. Yelling, “It’s glow time!” or asking the crowd to “Feel the glow!” during a match is just ridiculous, and it means nothing, no matter how many backstage segments they might do trying to explain it. Nikki Bella’s “Fearless” tagline is odd but mostly inoffensive. John Cena’s “Hustle, loyalty, respect” is odd as well, but it has been part of his persona for years.

Naomi’s entire character seems to be tied up in “glow time,” which just doesn’t make sense. Now if she started talking about lighting up her opponents as she fires off a series of kicks… that might work.

Advertisement

8. No (Wrong) Turns Doesn’t Make A Right

WWE.com

Heading into No Mercy, fans would not have been surprised if either John Cena or Dean Ambrose resorted to underhanded tactics to win the WWE World Championship. After all, both men went after the other and champ AJ Styles in aggressive fashion, both with words and physicality.

Advertisement

But neither man stooped to that level, with Styles being the one to retrieve and use a chair to retain his title. While that was to be expected, it doesn’t mean that he should have been the only man to use a weapon. Maybe it’s just wishful thinking, but it would have added some spice and freshened things up if Cena or Ambrose had used the chair or another weapon to his advantage. We’re not talking about turning heel here, but even a little “shades of gray” would have added something.

Cena has toyed with this sort of thing before, and Ambrose’s character as a lunatic always seems just a step or two removed from reverting to a villainous persona. None of this means that the match was a disappointment, but it would have added a little more to it to give fans something of a twist, even if it was resolved on SmackDown two days later.

Advertisement

7. Another Meaningless Tag Match

WWE.com

From a purely entertainment standpoint, the eight-man tag match between American Alpha and the Hype Bros versus the Vaudevillains and the Ascension was good fun, with decent action and a couple good spots, including the end.

Advertisement

But beyond that, what purpose did the tag match serve, other than to give eight men some pre-PPV time? Sure, we know Jason Jordan and Chad Gable are cooling their heels until they can feud with the Usos and that they needed to stay in the spotlight a little, but still. We’ve seen several of these multi-tag team matches during the past two months, which might be entertaining, but not much else.

Advertisement

It’s not that these matches have no place in WWE, but it’s a little disappointing that we couldn’t have gotten a straight tag match set up on SmackDown last week to put Alpha in the spotlight with at least some stakes rather than just a multi-team bout.

6. Strange Booking In Tag Title Match

WWE.com

Someone is going to have to explain this one, because it doesn’t seem to make a lot of sense.

Advertisement

When Heath Slater and Rhyno won the new SmackDown Tag Team Championships at Backlash, it felt like a feel-good story that gave Slater his job and paid off a nice angle with the One Man Band being disrespected and finally breaking through. But it never felt like something that was going to be long-term in any way.

So when the recently turned Usos, who are also feuding with up-and-comers American Alpha, challenged Sunday for the tag titles, the result seemed perfectly clear and logical: Usos capture the tag titles (possibly through nefarious means) and then go on to fight Alpha over the titles. Simple, easy and correct.

Advertisement

But instead, Rhyno Gored his team to victory, leaving the Usos with a second straight loss to the makeshift tag champs, which doesn’t help their standing either. Perhaps we’ll see a rematch on SmackDown, but this was a missed opportunity to pull the trigger.

5. Bliss Gets The Shaft

WWE.com

So with Becky Lynch out with an undisclosed injury, Alexa Bliss was forced to compete in an impromptu match against Naomi rather than competing for the SmackDown Women’s Championship.

Advertisement

To add injury to insult, Bliss would get rolled up and pinned after a short contest. And just like that, the #1 contender for the Women’s Championship was beaten on PPV in an unannounced bout. Now this is something WWE apparently does on a regular basis – when an announced match doesn’t go off due to injury, the replacement match is typically won by the face. We saw this last month with Kane replacing Randy Orton against Bray Wyatt and then winning the match.

Advertisement

That doesn’t make it right though. In fact, it’s counterproductive to beat the wrestler who is involved in an active feud like this. Naomi didn’t need the win, unless she’s suddenly going to challenge Bliss for the #1 contender’s spot on SmackDown. If anything though, Bliss could have used the win to further her case for the title shot.

4. Swagger On PPV

WWE.com

Look, this isn’t supposed to be an unfair jab, but Jack Swagger has no place being on PPV in 2016 as anything more than a job guy. And WWE has no one to blame but itself.

Advertisement

Before he defeated Baron Corbin last week under dubious circumstances, Swagger hadn’t won a match on Raw or SmackDown in 2016. He was barely featured on either show, but when he did compete, he lost. Jinder Mahal defeated Swagger to send him packing to SmackDown last month. So it wasn’t exactly a huge coup for the blue brand when the Real American jumped. And Corbin shouldn’t have been quaking in his boots when Swagger zeroed in on him.

Advertisement

This is emblematic of WWE’s problem these days. You have a talented guy like Swagger, but he’s been a goober who loses so much that no one takes him seriously as a threat. And if he had beaten Corbin out of the blue Sunday, it would have been counter-intuitive to beat a supposed rising star like that.

3. Selling The Drama

WWE.com

Considering that Nikki Bella missed several months of action due to a neck injury, it only makes sense that Carmella would focus on assaulting the former Diva Champion’s neck.

Advertisement

But aside from a couple nasty bumps in the early going, the newcomer simply relied on a series of chinlocks to attack Nikki’s neck. And Bella’s “selling” of the injury consisted of putting her hand to her throat a couple times and grimacing mildly. That’s not exactly convincing the crowd that her career might be in jeopardy.

Advertisement

Not everything can be a technical classic, but if you’re going to use an injured body part as the theme of a match, then you’ve got to be more convincing than that, both on the offense and on the selling sides. This should have felt like a match where Carmella beat Nikki within an inch of her career, and it didn’t.

2. Wrong Match Headlines PPV

WWE.com

The moment that we opened No Mercy with the WWE World Championship title match, many would have assumed which match would be the main event, but many would have been wrong. Simply put, just listen to the crowd. Hands down, Dolph Ziggler versus The Miz should have closed out the PPV.

Advertisement

Ziggler and Miz had fans buying into every false finish, especially with Dolph’s career on the line. His ultimate victory got a huge reaction from fans and would have made for a memorable close to the event. Instead, we got a plodding main event with Randy Orton taking on Bray Wyatt in a match continuing a feud described as “mind games.” Orton and Wyatt had a decent bout, but there really was no comparison to what fans were into more.

Sometimes, the matches with the most “star power” isn’t the biggest match on the card. WWE should know that by now, and this certainly was the case Sunday night.

Advertisement

1. Orton/Wyatt SnoozeFest

WWE.com

Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt are both very talented wrestlers who are capable of putting on captivating matches. But what they put on Sunday night in the No Mercy main event was anything but.

Advertisement

Orton and Wyatt had a dull, plodding, sloppy match that only got interesting when the lights went out. (And a guy not in the match got the biggest reaction.) They traded multiple attempts at finishing moves and other signature moves but didn’t hit a lot of high-impact moves until halfway through the match. Even then, it was sloppy at times and certainly wasn’t captivating.

Advertisement

This followed backstage segments that did nothing to build the match, only to remind us that both men had played mind games on the other and that they were going to settle it in the ring… and then Wyatt resorted to his usual lights-out trick to win, so nothing was really resolved. The feud – and presumably the “mind games” – will continue.

Click "next" below for the Ups...

Advertisement

Ups...

6. Bait And Switch As a Good Thing

WWE Network

Ordinarily, advertising a wrestler’s debut at a PPV and then deliberately not delivering on it would be considered a negative, but in this case, WWE might have done the best thing possible concerning reintroducing Curt Hawkins to the fans.

Advertisement

Hawkins, as many fans might remember, was one of the Edgeheads along with Zack Ryder, then faded into a jobber role, teaming with Tyler Reks and eventually being relegated to NXT before being released in 2014. His new character, which includes a spin on the popular Chuck Norris facts that have lived on e-mail chains and social media, has been entertaining.

Advertisement

But let’s face it: Once he starts wrestling, it will be Curt Hawkins again. That’s not meant as an insult. Wrestling on the No Mercy pre-show would not have helped him, but by simply strolling into the ring and cutting a short promo and celebrating his appearance was about the best thing they could do to prolong his re-debut.

5. He’s Got Kids!

WWE.com

Even though this column questioned the booking earlier, it’s hard not to feel for Heath Slater with his plight during this summer, and not root for him (and Rhyno) as SmackDown Tag Team champs.

Advertisement

Slater and Rhyno’s Cinderella story is a fun one – although Vince McMahon’s redneck overtones weigh it down a bit – so seeing them win a couple PPV matches is a nice change of pace. And it throws a curveball to the conventional wisdom that said that the Usos should have run over them Sunday night. So while it was strange booking, it also was interesting at the same time.

Advertisement

And give Beauty and the Man-Beast credit: They’ve connected with the crowd and had them behind them. Slater has earned it, so if that means a bit longer with his victory lap, we won’t condemn it.

4. Welcome Back Harper

WWE.com

As uninspiring as the main event was, it did include one glimmer of hope that we’ll give a positive for right now: Luke Harper returned to television.

Advertisement

Harper, a vastly underrated big man who can fly around the ring like a guy 50 pounds lighter and still brawl with the best of them, had been sidelined for several months. His return to action is welcome and much-needed in this brand split era. Now, where the questions can come in is whether rejoining the Wyatt Family is good for his career.

Advertisement

Bray Wyatt’s underlings have often served as cannon fodder troops in his feuds, as Erick Rowan was served up to Randy Orton before he went down with an injury. If Harper is going to be jobbed out to guys Wyatt is feuding with, then this is a waste. But for now, let’s be happy to see him return.

3. Making The Title Matter

WWE.com

You would think an Intercontinental Championship match between two guys who had a combined nine IC title reigns (at the beginning of the bout) would feel unimportant, but it was the exact opposite Sunday night.

Advertisement

Give credit to having Dolph Ziggler’s career on the line. Give credit to Miz playing such a perfect heel that people love to boo him. And give credit to Daniel Bryan for being a great foil to Miz backstage, helping to elevate the champ even more. All of that helped play a role in making the Intercontinental Championship feel like a desirable title again.

Advertisement

So with Ziggler winning the strap at No Mercy, here’s hoping that WWE is cognizant of this and tries to make the title continue to matter. Do not turn this into a hot potato or have Ziggler lose every non-title match he’s in. Book a champ like a champ and have a challenger fight for a shot.

2. AJ On A Roll

WWE.com

Who would have thought a year ago that AJ Styles would debut in WWE at the 2016 Royal Rumble, go on to beat John Cena at SummerSlam, win the WWE World Championship the following month and then beat Cena for the third consecutive time to retain the title Sunday?

Advertisement

But that’s exactly what has happened in 2016. Sure, Styles used a chair at No Mercy, waffling Cena to gain the pinfall, but all’s fair in a triple threat, where there’s no DQs. Along the way on this journey, Styles has been consistently having tremendous matches, and he, Cena and Dean Ambrose delivered a great opening bout, unloading on each other and giving fans fits with several false finishes.

Advertisement

In the end, AJ resorted to the chair when it became apparent that he couldn’t topple his opponents without an equalizer. Styles has now beaten both men multiple times, solidifying his position as the top guy on SmackDown.

1. Rejuvenated Stars

WWE.com

To counter the argument about no one caring about Jack Swagger, consider the cases of The Miz and Dolph Ziggler, both of whom have gone through long phases where they lose a lot and fans seem to not care about them anymore.

Advertisement

Miz has rebuilt himself during the past six months after winning the Intercontinental Championship and having his smoking hot wife Maryse by his side. He’s gone from a goof to a credible IC champ and annoying Hollywood type. Ziggler was seeing his career flag further after losing a feud to Baron Corbin and was in desperate need of a reboot. After losing to Miz a couple times, the two engaged in a war of words that built and built until Dolph put his career on the line.

Advertisement

The result was an Intercontinental Championship versus career match at No Mercy that sucked in the fans and had the crowd reacting to every pinfall attempt. Even with an overbooked ending, it still worked quite well. Now, what WWE does next could reduce the impact of this feud, but this was a high point on Sunday. Kudos all around.