7 Completely Unnecessary Times WWE Keeps Kayfabe
Appreciate the dedication, but this is a bit much...
Keeping kayfabe has been a tradition in professional wrestling since its inception. The more realistic it looks, the better it looks. To keep it looking realistic, wrestlers would keep kayfabe, to the point where the fact that wrestling was scripted was a dirty little secret.
In the mid-1990s when the internet boom started, and the companies decided to stop insulting their fanbases intelligence and peel back the curtain a little, the dirty little secret wasn't so secret anymore.
After this revelation, kayfabe didn't die, it just changed. Promoters and wrestlers found new and unique ways to keep kayfabe in a world where everybody is in on it. Referees are supposed to throw up an X with their arms in matches when wrestlers are legitimately injured. Because most of the fans know about this practice, a referee may now throw up an X, and it's now a part of the storyline.
However, should kayfabe be kept when the show is over? At what point do the wrestlers stop being wrestlers and start being real people? Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels both admitted in their Rivalry DVD that they got so caught up in their work of trying to create realistic heat that they accidentally worked themselves into a shoot and couldn't stand each other. The lines between kayfabe and reality have been so blurred over the past 15-20 years, it's not crystal clear what's a work and what's a shoot anymore.
Specifically, there are seven places where the WWE and its wrestlers try to keep kayfabe thats completely unnecessary...
7. In WWE Studios Movies
Nowadays WWE Studios have become a company that mostly puts out direct-to-DVD movies to little fanfare but even films that make theatres like Dead Man Down are a joke. The main reason the movies aren't mainstream successes is because they aren't very good but an under-the-radar reason, particularly in movies featuring their superstars, is because the wrestlers who star in the movies are billed by their characters name, not by their real name.
On The Marine 4 poster, Summer Rae was billed as Summer Rae, rather than her real name, Danielle Moinet. For the 12 Rounds movie, the star of the movie is Dean Ambrose, not Jonathan Good. Other wrestlers like The Big Show, Brodus Clay, and Kane have been billed by their gimmick names in WWE Studios movies.
Now, there may be royalty payment reasons why the wrestlers are billed that way. Most likely, WWE Studios uses the gimmick names because that's the brand that the audience identifies with. Still though, it's implied that Jonathan Good is playing Dean Ambrose who is playing the lead of the new 12 Rounds movie, which makes no sense if you take a step back and look at it logically.
The wrestler is not doing the acting, the person is doing the acting! Interestingly enough, Triple H is billed as Paul Levesque Triple H on the cover of The Chaperone and Inside Out.
6. At The Hall Of Fame
Kevin Nash recently commented that there are only two things in the wrestling business that are truly real: when you win your first World Championship, and when you get inducted into the Hall of Fame. So if that's the case, why did his buddy Scott Hall get inducted as Razor Ramon and give his induction speech in his Tony Montana-esque dialect?
To continue the comparison to actors, this is akin to Tom Hanks winning the Best Actor award at the Oscars for Forrest Gump and then giving his acceptance speech as Forrest Gump.
To be fair, for the most part, the Hall of Fame inductees typically give shoot interviews in their speech; there are only a few exceptions where they didn't break character, Razor being the most recent example.
The Hall of Fame offers the one chance for wrestlers to publicly reflect on their careers. Why use that moment to continue keeping kayfabe?
5. On The Bus To The Show
Back in the 1980s and 1990s, when the secret about wrestling hadn't fully been revealed, it was common for the babyfaces to travel from town to town with other babyfaces, and the heels to travel with other heels. This is so that if a fan catches them at a rest stop or hotel, they won't be confused as to why the good guy and the bad guy are hanging out together.
Real-life relatives Bret and Owen Hart and Eddie and Chavo Guerrero traveled separately while they were feuding. Would you be surprised to know that the practice of babyfaces and heels traveling separately still exists in the modern era of kayfabe?
In an interview with GQ Magazine in 2011, CM Punk confirmed that there were still babyface buses and heel buses.
C.M. Punk: We were just in Australia, and somebody on the babyface bus comes up to me and says, "Cena was at an appearance this morning, so do you know who was on the babyface bus with the most seniority? Kelly Kelly." GQ: So there's really a babyface bus and a heel bus?C.M. Punk: Absolutely. GQ: Which one has the better atmosphere?C.M. Punk: I don't know, depends on who you ask. The business has changed a lot. It used to be about bragging rights between the buses, about who partied harder. Now, I'm the only heel who's awake on the bus; everybody is passed out asleep. I can only comment on the heel bus. I wouldn't set foot on that other bus.
It's very strange to see that the tradition of babyfaces and heels traveling separately survived from the pre-reality era.
4. On Total Divas
The many issues with Total Divas have been chronicled here, but the one big problem with the show that's inexcusable is that they call it a reality show but they still manage to keep kayfabe on it. The first season did a pretty good job about introducing the real names behind the Divas, where Cameron was introduced as Ariane, Naomi was introduced as Trinity, and Daniel Bryan was introduced as Bryan Danielson.
In the second season, when Summer Rae joined the show, she was called Summer Rae, not Danielle. Subsequent additions of Rosa Mendes, Alicia Fox and Paige have them going by their gimmick names (although Paige sometimes calls Rosa Roucka, which is her legit last name).
Now, it's possible that the gimmick names have become nicknames both in and out of the arena, and maybe Paige's coworkers know her mostly as Paige and not as Saraya, so it would be off-putting for them to call her Saraya, even though that's her real name.
A couple weeks ago, on the Season Finale, the main storyline explored a legitimate past relationship between Dolph Ziggler and Nikki Bella, and they mostly referred to Dolph as Nick, his real name. Every now and then, however, Brie would also call him Dolph.
It's interesting to see how even the wrestlers themselves have a hard time distinguishing between their birth names and their ring names. The storyline of Nick making attempts to get Nikki back was scripted for the show, but it was drawn out of a real-life relationship, not unlike WWE borrowing from reality to enhance their stories.
3. Backstage At Shows
This one may be a bit more forgivable. When Hugh Laurie, a British actor, was playing Dr. House, an American character, he would speak in an American accent even during takes, because it was so hard for him to go in and out of his stage voice.
Reportedly, backstage at WWE shows, stagehands and other support personnel are directed to refer to the wrestlers by their gimmicked names. So rather than calling The Undertaker Mark or Mr. Callaway, you have to refer to him as Undertaker or even Mr. Taker.
If you want to make the argument that this is a type of method acting or getting into character backstage, that discussion can be had. It's just incredibly goofy that any coworker would have to address Mike Mizanin as Miz in a professional business setting backstage if they didn't know him personally.
2. On Social Media
This is the biggest offender of ridiculous kayfabe, and it's hard to know where the line is drawn. Some wrestlers have their gimmick name as their Twitter (Lana, Seth Rollins, Xavier Woods, etc.), others have their real name (R-Truth, Natalya, Tyson Kidd), and Cody Rhodes even had one twitter handle for Stardust and one for himself, where he had an advisory in his bio that the tweets are his own and do not reflect World Wrestling Entertainment.
Some wrestlers post about real-life things, and others keep their Twitter completely related to their character. Some wrestlers also use Twitter to further their current storylines, and there are reports that wrestlers were mandated to comment on other storylines on their Twitter handles, such as when Big Show was fired by Stephanie McMahon in October 2013.
When Lana and Rusev had their breakup angle, they used social media to further the storyline, with Lana even taking pictures with Dolph Ziggler (her on-screen boyfriend) at Disney World. Keeping kayfabe on Twitter opens heel wrestlers up to negative comments from fans who choose to go along with the show and treat them like heels on Twitter, and it gets confusing when that same heel will post a tweet or a picture as their true self.
To continue with the actor comparison, Bryan Cranston of Breaking Bad has a Twitter account, and it would seem insane for somebody to tweet at him and berate him for cooking meth. Yet, in the wacky world of professional wrestling, this is the norm.
1. In Real Life
This is probably the most accepted and understood way of keeping kayfabe outside the arena, but also seems like the most asinine. Wrestlers for the most part are expected to keep kayfabe in public 24 hours a day. They are WWE ambassadors outside the ring, and whether it's on the street, in an airport, or at a restaurant, they are still considered to be superstars.
In no other entertainment medium (movies, television, sports) is a performer still considered to be a performer when theyre no longer performing. If you run into a wrestler on the street or at a restaurant and want to talk to them, what name do you call them by? If you see Seth Rollins, do you call him Colby? And how will he react to you calling him Colby? Would he react at all if you called him Tyler (Rollins worked for years as Tyler Black on the independent scene)?
Some wrestlers see it as an insult to be called by their real name by people who don't know them personally; that it may be an attempt for the fans to show the wrestlers that they're in the know or on the inside. CM Punk seemed bemused on Colt Cabana's podcast as he pondered his transition into life as Phil Brooks after more than 10 years being CM Punk, and both men openly questioned whether he should be addressed as Phil or Punk out in public.
When the lights and cameras are on, they perform as characters that are either amplified versions of themselves or somebody different entirely. Who they are in the ring may not necessarily be who they are outside the ring. In public interaction, there should be an understanding between the wrestler and the fans that what happens on TV stays on TV, and the person is different from the character.