7 Major Problems With RAW Vs. SmackDown At WWE Survivor Series

It makes no sense and it doesn't mean anything...

By John Bills /

WWE.com

WWE really does not understand the idea of 'once in a lifetime'. One year after the WWE Universe was told they were viewing a one time thing, Survivor Series is once again going to be a RAW vs. SmackDown Live pay-per-view. The stars of the flagship show and its bratty younger brother will do battle in Houston on 19 November, with brand supremacy on the line.

Advertisement

Except none of it matters really, does it? Shane McMahon and various members of the SmackDown Live roster 'invaded' RAW this past week, laying waste to anyone and everyone in what was a genuinely entertaining final segment of the show. The New Day led the invasion as various members of the blue teams's lower card beat up Goldust, Curt Hawkins, Apollo Crews, and the rest. It was fun, but it was ultimately pointless.

Despite clearly having no idea how a 'siege' works, WWE is missing many steps with this program. The RAW vs. SmackDown idea is creative laziness in action, a sure sign that the writing team is out of ideas as 2017 splutters to a close. There are major issues with this Thanksgiving throwdown.

Advertisement

7. Rivals Working Together

WWE.com

When the initial novelty wears off, the sheer lack of logic involved in cross-brand invasion stories becomes depressingly apparent. The SmackDown Live roster invaded RAW this past week, laying waste to anyone and everyone they could find in the backstage area, before posing for a couple of group photos for WWE’s various social media profiles.

Advertisement

The faces and the heels of SmackDown stood together, Bobby Roode and Dolph Ziggler fighting as partners as opposed to bitter rivals. It makes absolutely no sense at all, and completely trivialises the feuds on the individual brands. Citing ‘brand loyalty’ simply isn’t enough.

The WWE Universe is expected to believe that the only way for rivals like Roode and Ziggler to settle their differences is inside the ring. It seems as though the same outcome can be achieved by putting both men in SmackDown Live t-shirts (available on WWE.com, by the way).

Advertisement

6. The Lone Wolf Isn't So Lonely Anymore

WWE.com

For the past year and a bit, Baron Corbin has been an absolute pain to anyone and everyone on the SmackDown roster. The Lone Wolf has repeatedly put the boots to whomever he feels may be in his way, showing little regard for face and heel alignments when it comes to beating down fools. Corbin is The Lone Wolf after all, and he frequently acts in that manner.

Advertisement

The SmackDown invasion and subsequent storyline has shown that Corbin is anything but a lone wolf. The Big Breakfast was front and centre of the invasion, holding Kurt Angle hostage alongside fellow blue brand heel Rusev. Corbin is going to fight WWE Intercontinental Champion The Miz, to prove that the secondary title on SmackDown is the better of the two.

WWE spends so much time and effort on creating ‘characters’, yet the promotion is always eager to contradict the personalities for the sake of short term storytelling. Corbin is a performer on thin ice at the best of times, so forcing him into a story that goes against the previous 18 months of his career is only going to hurt him.

Advertisement

Why does Baron Corbin care about Shane McMahon and SmackDown Live? He doesn’t, but for the next month we will have to pretend that he does.

5. A Feud For The Sake Of It

WWE.com

There have been many magical RAW vs. SmackDown matches throughout the history of WWE. Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle went one-on-one at WrestleMania 21 in one of the greatest bouts in promotion history, a cross-brand battle for supremacy that ticked every box available. The Undertaker and Randy Orton also fought at that same event, SmackDown going two and zero over the evening.

Advertisement

This year’s line-up screams ‘laziness’ however. The RAW vs. SmackDown story that we currently have is a half-baked attempt at drumming up some interest in the shows, and it really does feel like a story booked for the sake of doing it. From top to bottom, it makes very little sense.

A few months ago The New Day were beloved babyfaces on RAW - why oh why would they want to viciously attack unsuspecting red brand stars backstage? Chad Gable going straight for Jason Jordan is almost understandable, but what beef does Mojo Rawley have with Titus O’Neill? Tye Dillinger, and Goldust? Carmella and Bayley?

Advertisement

WWE is known for the short-term mentality of its booking, but these sorts of stories well and truly take the biscuit.

4. Weeks Of Neutered Television

WWE.com

For the next few weeks, the episodes of RAW and SmackDown are unlikely to matter in any way. The SmackDown invasion of RAW surely needed an immediate response from the red brand, but nothing was forthcoming. WWE is headed to Europe shortly too, so the chances of any more cross-brand violence is next to non-existent.

Advertisement

After seeing Roode and Ziggler work together on Monday, not to mention a host of babyfaces acting like vicious goons, how is the WWE Universe supposed to get involved in the usual run of stories on SmackDown Live? Chad Gable has been a great babyface so far, but after seeing his behaviour on Monday I have less of a desire to see him succeed. Gable is simply one example.

WWE is likely to sleepwalk through its television programming for the next couple of weeks, until the door is open again for invasions. The promotion has a hard time keeping its TV audience as it is, so a couple of weeks of harshly neutered television is only going to be detrimental to both RAW and SmackDown’s numbers.

Advertisement

3. The Championships And Survivor Series Are Devalued

WWE.com

Survivor Series is theoretically one of the four biggest events of WWE’s year. The last of the ‘Big Four’ in the calendar year, the Thanksgiving extravaganza has been on borrowed time for a number of years however, and it undoubtedly holds less prestige than Royal Rumble, WrestleMania, and SummerSlam.

Advertisement

A surefire way to make it even less prestigious is to have no title bouts on the show. As of right now, Survivor Series 2017 is going to feature a host of ‘champion vs. champion’ matches, all of which will be non-title. Not a single championship will be on the line at the fourth biggest show of the year.

Those 'champion vs. champion' matches also throw up a number of issues. There have been times when these bouts added credibility to championships, but this isn’t going to be the case this year. Unless the show involves a mass of unfulfilling finishes, titles are going to be devalued on 19 November.

Advertisement

Jinder Mahal has already done a number on the WWE Championship. Unless he does the unthinkable in Houston and defeats Brock Lesnar, the most historic title in the game is going to be knocked down another couple of notches.

2. Uninspiring Matches

WWE

If the WWE Universe was tasked with coming up with a card of RAW vs. SmackDown matches, the chances are the card would be very exciting. Brock Lesnar vs. AJ Styles? Asuka vs. Charlotte Flair? Finn Bálor vs. Sami Zayn? These are just three potential bouts that such a set up could bring.

Advertisement

Instead, we get matches that nobody wants to see. There is a morbid curiosity in seeing Lesnar take on Jinder Mahal, but that curiosity subsides when reality kicks back in. It is a colossal waste of The Beast Incarnate on one of the promotion’s biggest shows of the year.

The less said about The Miz vs. Baron Corbin the better. The Miz is one of the best talkers in the company but his in-ring work still leaves a lot to be desired. The sooner he stops using Daniel Bryan’s kicks, the better. And Corbin? The jury is still out on The Lone Wolf, almost 18 months after his arrival on the main roster.

Advertisement

With the exception of The Usos vs. Seth Rollins & Dean Ambrose, all of the RAW vs. SmackDown matches on the card for Survivor Series 2017 are thoroughly uninspiring, to say the least.

1. There Are No Consequences

WWE.com

The main problem with RAW vs. SmackDown matches is an issue that is true of practically all of WWE programming. On November 19, the stars of red and blue will do battle for brand supremacy, thrilling the WWE Universe in a series of matches that will end with one brand just beating out the other. If there are seven matches, a brand will win 4-3.

Advertisement

But then what? RAW will take place on 20 November and everything will simply carry on as before. The champions will move into their new feuds. The winners and losers from the night previous will fall back into their old grooves, as the next story cycle begins ahead of the 2018 Royal Rumble.

How hard would it be to introduce some consequences into these matches? The respective general managers should be motivating their performers with promises of championship matches and more. The losers should be punished, the winners rewarded. Instead, Survivor Series will take place and everything will stay the same. When the next draft is held, will this night have anything to do with it?

Advertisement

RAW and SmackDown will be bloodthirsty rivals for a night, before reverting back to being two sides of the same coin. It is a huge waste of everyone’s time, a self-imposed holding pattern that comes about only when a writing team is out of ideas.

This is wrestling’s version of ‘and it was all a dream’.

Advertisement