7 Mistakes WWE Have Already Made With The Shield’s Reunion
'Believe In The Shield'? Not bloody likely if this booking keeps up...
The mini-Shield reunion between Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose blatantly came about because WWE's creative team had no other ideas for either over the summer. A lack of creative inspiration is hardly good enough reason to start pulling the trigger on a comeback for one of the best-loved groups in recent memory, but it's happening.
There are positives to this Rollins/Ambrose love-in despite the glaring flaws. It is true that neither had a solid storyline to sink their teeth into individually, and they have helped Raw's Tag Title division motor along with brilliant matches against Sheamus and Cesaro. Couldn't that have happened without any Shield overtures though?
WWE have now booked themselves into a corner and created a situation wherein one of the least-liked stars on the roster is the missing piece of the puzzle. That cool factor which dripped off The Shield back between 2012-14 has been diminished already, and the full reunion hasn't even happened yet...
7. Booking A Mini-Comeback
Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose could easily have worked as a tag-team without this semi-Shield reunion. The group would have been mentioned in passing, obviously, but Michael Cole and pals often refer to this team as The Shield on commentary when it's not. This is no more Shield than Ambrose teaming with Roman Reigns in 2015 was.
You can't have a full Shield comeback without all of the original members involved, otherwise it's not an actual reunion. WWE would have been better off avoiding any mention of The Shield until they were ready to do things properly. Right now, Ambrose and Rollins don't look, act or wrestle like they did when wearing the SWAT gear anyway.
Making fans think of The Shield without the music, ring attire, or kickass beatdowns they're famous for is an odd strategy from WWE. This is akin to Bray Wyatt and Braun Strowman putting the Wyatt Family back together on Raw, only for the latter to continue doing a totally different gimmick.
6. Involving The Miztourage
Before diving into this point, it's important to recognise just how good The Miz is in 2017. One of WWE's best all-rounders, Miz is one hell of a talker and can enhance any segment regardless of material. He's just an excellent mic man, but he's not enhanced by having cannon fodder like Curtis Axel or Bo Dallas by his side.
The Miztourage are never going to be The Shield. Not even Miz can make that one sound realistic, and yet the writers penned him a speech on Raw during which the heel claimed his group was superior to Roman Reigns and his old running buddies. Fans might not respect Reigns, but even his biggest critics recall how well he worked alongside Ambrose and Rollins.
If WWE are going to book a full-blown Shield reunion at some point in 2018, then they should keep The Miztourage out of it. This association won't help the group rekindle their killer edge and it will only hurt The Miz further.
5. Roman Reigns Dismissing The Idea On Television
Perhaps the problem lies less with The Miz comparing his cronies to The Shield and more with the fact that Roman Reigns is the only thing stopping the band from getting back together. WWE are banking on the idea of fans clamouring to see Reigns realign with Ambrose and Rollins. That could work, if people actually liked Roman.
The Roman Reigns of 2017 is a far cry from the quiet, smouldering menace who stalked opponents before unleashing a powerful roar and Powerbombing hapless victims through tables. Several years ago, Reigns was cool, but he's now anything but. The creative team's awkward attempts to turn him into a smart-talking good guy has seen to that.
Roman's mantra when pressed on what Ambrose and Rollins are doing has been dismissive. Almost laughing when asked about a Shield reunion, Reigns has repeatedly palmed off suggestions that it'd be a good idea. He's big-timing his old friends whilst claiming to have more important business, and that hardly puts across the group's importance.
4. The Unlikeable Way Seth Rollins Has Been Written
Seth Rollins as a babyface has lost the cool he had as a heel. By being so remorseful and passionately apologising to both the audience and Dean Ambrose, Rollins has come across more wimpy than genuine. Where is that fire he showed when feuding with Triple H earlier this year, and why hasn't the arrogance of his heel run become his war cry even as a babyface?
Instead, Seth pleaded with Dean to reunite with him. Then, in a completely stupid moment, he resisted the temptation to fist bump Ambrose like he had wanted to all along. This was explained as Rollins playing hard to get, but there were gaping holes in WWE's logic; why would Rollins turn down Ambrose's forgiveness, something he had pursued for weeks beforehand?
Now, that story has been abandoned because Seth and Dean are all buddy-buddy again. Meanwhile, Rollins has introduced his new 'Burn It Down' catchphrase, again going against the idea that he's a team player. It's all mixed messages from WWE when the story needs to be simple.
3. Introducing It When Dean Ambrose Was At His Lowest Ebb
It doesn't help that Dean Ambrose was going nowhere before this latest tag-team with Rollins. Since moving to Raw just after WrestleMania 33, the ex-Intercontinental Champion has done little of note aside from this current storyline. In fact, he was at real risk of being tagged with the 'career mid carder' brush just a few months ago.
A damning verdict of WWE's topsy turvy booking style, SmackDown's top draft pick just last summer didn't seem like a former WWE Champion when he bounded onto Raw post-Superstar Shakeup in April. Worse, it didn't seem like Raw's writers had anything for him; left without a satisfactory feud to get stuck into, Ambrose was once again programmed against The Miz despite fans already seeing that on SmackDown.
Ambrose wasn't ready for The Shield when WWE started talking about his history with the group again. Dressing up as a teddy bear and outsmarting The Miz during comical segments in June did little to inspire feelings that the unhinged Shield mouthpiece of before was on the comeback trail.
2. Using The Trademark Hand Gesture So Soon
The live crowd responded in a big way when Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins performed the trademark Shield hand gesture on the 14 August episode of Raw. As good as the reaction was, it poses a problem. That was the pop WWE should have manufactured for a full reunion, not for Ambrose and Rollins finally putting their issues behind them.
Dean went from not trusting Seth one week to acting like nothing had happened the next. It was too sudden, almost like WWE realised they needed something that would placate fans in the short term. Such booking rarely helps out the long term, and that's been the case here. The signature pose should have been teased until Roman Reigns was part of the equation.
Again, without all of the members present this isn't The Shield. If that was the reaction to Ambrose and Rollins reuniting, then just imagine how loud people would've been had all three ex-members been involved. WWE gave away one of the biggest moments of the reunion just for the sake of building towards a Tag Title match.
1. Not Capitalising On The Surprise Element
People now know it's only a matter of time before Roman Reigns rejoins Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins as The Shield. The surprise element has been washed away by WWE's booking; unlike when the group crash-landed on the roster at Survivor Series 2012 and laid waste to everyone, there's no mystery there.
On top of that, Reigns has been smirking when asked about a Shield reunion and was not part of the initial get-together in August. Now, instead of all three members coming across as equals, WWE are not-so-subtly telling fans that Roman is the biggest star of the trio and will reform The Shield when he's good and ready. The aura has vanished.
Fans will still pop when The Shield come together again, even if it's only a short-term thing, but wouldn't it have been better to see it happen organically? Ambrose and Rollins should exist as a tag-team aligned only to stop Sheamus and Cesaro from bragging about being 'The Bar'.
Then, when they are joined by Reigns without warning, some shock factor would still be possible.
-
Do you feel WWE are already threatening to drop the ball on a full Shield reunion? Let us know down in the comments section below!