7 Most Surprising WWE PPV Main Eventers Ever
Triple H. Shawn Michaels. The Spirit Squad. One of those things is not like the others...
Although pay-per-view is pretty much a dead medium these days (at least as it pertains to WWE), it used to be a serious cash cow for the company. Today we're living in a post-WWE Network world, where the creative team can put out just about any card because, hey, people are paying 9.99 a month (I think that's the right amount) to subscribe so they'll watch it regardless.
That extends to the main event, aka the most important match on any given show. To some extent, it doesn't really matter what WWE put on last these days since they already have fans' money and subscriber numbers aren't going to wildly fluctuate off the back of one supershow main event alone.
Hence Roman Reigns versus Sheamus at TLC 2015.
Back when PPV was king, WWE relied on having an enticing top-liner to draw punters in and convince them to part with their hard-earner cash, which was significantly more than today's 9.99 asking price. The shows with the biggest or most interesting main events have, traditionally, been the biggest earners (outside of WrestleMania, which essentially sells itself, of course).
Despite this, WWE have presented some truly odd main events in their time, with some very unexpected performers. While you'd expect to see Steve Austin, The Rock, Triple H, John Cena and co. in the money spots, you don't usually anticipate seeing comedy acts and ageing, aimless veterans battling at the end of the night.
But it has happened.
7. JBL - Judgement Day 2004
John Bradshaw Layfield was a career midcarder before the absences of Kurt Angle (injury) and Brock Lesnar (quit to try out for the NFL) forced WWE to turn him heel and hastily shunt him up the Smackdown card. He ditched longtime tag partner Ron Simmons (who was also fired for real) and became 'JBL', a JR Ewing style millionaire.
His first main event programme was opposite WWE Champion Eddie Guerrero and, despite a poor, cheap heat-filled buildup, the two men headlined May's Judgement Day pay-per-view. The outing was pedestrian, meandering stuff in the early going (it was quite clear that the challenger had no stamina), but it seriously picked up at the midway point.
Clattered with a vicious chair shot to the head, Latino Heat bled a gusher. 'A gusher' is putting it mildly: Guerrero, the ring and the ringside area were soaked in the red stuff. It made for a far more dramatic match, as viewers genuinely felt like Eddie might not make it out of the match alive, let alone with his WWE Title.
A DQ finish necessitated a rematch at the next Smackdown PPV, the dire Great American Bash, but that match didn't headline (the Undertaker versus Dudley Boys 'Concrete Crypt' disaster did - more on that later). Of course, JBL would go on to headline many more pay-per-views over the following years (quite ably, too), but it was certainly a surprise to see him in the show-closer in May of 2004, after being so aimless for the months beforehand.
6. Hardcore Holly - December To Dismember 2006
Speaking of lifetime midcarders thrust into the main event scene, it's Hardcore Holly! Now I must confess that I rather enjoyed the work of the former Sparky Plug, in all of its hard-nosed smashmouth glory. But a main eventer he was not, as was demonstrated in his brief revenge-fuelled feud with Brock Lesnar in late 2003/early 2004.
Bombastic Bob was, amazingly, given a WWE Title shot at Brock at the 2004 Royal Rumble, but the match was placed firmly in the midcard and given all of six minutes. Holly then went right back down to the midcard, but his career would bounce back somewhat when he was transferred to WWE's relaunched ECW brand.
On the so-called 'C' show, Holly was given more of a chance to shine, contesting long and competitive matches with the likes of Rob Van Dam and CM Punk. Still, he wasn't considered a 'main eventer', much less a PPV main eventer, more of a grizzled veteran who could be depended on for a believable, hard-fought match.
Holly was thrown into the main event of WWE's only ECW pay-per-view, December to Dismember, though, when originally scheduled participant Sabu was removed due to bad backstage behaviour. Sabu's loss was Holly's gain, as he did battle with Rob Van Dam, CM Punk, Test, Bobby Lashley and Big Show.
Because of the fact he was originally meant to wrestle The Sandman on the show, this really was a surprise, but the fact that Holly made it to a PPV main event is surprising in itself.
5. Spirit Squad - Vengeance 2006
Vengeance 2006 was a superior Raw brand pay-per-view with a pretty stacked card. Randy Orton versus Kurt Angle, Ric Flair versus Mick Foley in a 2/3 Falls match, Rob Van Dam versus Edge for the WWE Title. Hell, it even had the inherently weird yet compelling Sabu versus John Cena Lumberjack match!
Yet somehow the Spirit Squad ended up closing the show. So what gives? Well, the male cheerleaders had been heavily involved in Vince and Shane McMahon's feud with Shawn Michaels, interfering on behalf of the boss and doing their best to beat down The Showstopper.
They'd also been in the mix with Triple H, taking him on in handicap and gauntlet matches. Figuring they'd lessen the numbers disadvantage, Shawn and Hunter joined forces, reforming DX. Thirteen days after reuniting, the duo took on the Spirit Squad in a 5-on-2 handicap match at Vengeance.
Since this was the first DX match since 1998, it had to go on last. As a match, it was nothing special, since nobody bought Nicky, Kenny, Johnny, Mikey and Mitch as credible threats. I mean, they were jokes, just fodder for the degenerates to run over, which they did, rather easily.
Adding insult to injury, HBK forcibly inducted Mitch into the 'Triple H Kiss My A** Club' afterwards. How appropriate.
4. R-Truth - Capitol Punishment 2011
John Cena has beaten everyone. Literally everyone. Everyone that has ever wrestled.
Well, maybe not quite, but he's certainly thwarted pretty much all who have tried to stop him from rising above hate over the years. Invariably, Big Match John would get the better of his foe in a pay-per-view main event to, y'know, put smiles on faces and all of that good stuff.
Whether it was Umaga, Kurt Angle, Triple H or Batista, Cena would usually be the one standing tall with his hand raised in the air at the end of a supershow. He's had one or two weird PPV opponents over the years (including Bobby Lashley and the aforementioned Sabu), but few are as strange as R-Truth, whom Cena faced at Capitol Punishment in 2011.
Credit to WWE for putting someone new into the mix and taking a chance of the bizarre R-Truth, but it was an experiment that didn't exactly work. The build up was good, with Truth delivering some very entertaining promos, but it just didn't deliver on the night.
The ring work was pedestrian and the finish was a joke (a child at ringside threw a drink in Truth's face, then Cena threw him back in the ring and AA'd him for the win). And that was that for Truth's main event run, as he went on to have a lucrative career as painfully unfunny comedy relief which has lasted over five years now.
3. The Nexus - SummerSlam 2010
As with R-Truth a year later, WWE deserve credit for trying something different at SummerSlam 2010. Yes, there were established WWE headliners in there in the form of Edge, John Cena, Chris Jericho and, erm, Bret Hart, but the opposing team was full of rookies freshly called up from developmental.
The Nexus angle was hot sh*t at the time, with Wade Barrett and co. running riot on Raw and really getting over as a force to be reckoned with. Still, as good as the angle was to that point, it was nonetheless surprising to see them headlining one of the biggest pay-per-views of the year.
The match itself was good and well worked, even if some of the combatants looked none-too-ready for the big time, with the returning Daniel Bryan (wrestling for team WWE), Justin Gabriel and Barrett standing out as ones to watch. Logic would dictate that Team Nexus would triumph over Team WWE, but it was not to be.
Instead, good ol' Super Cena never gave up and fought back against the odds, vanquishing Barrett and Gabriel despite taking a DDT on the floor. That was pretty much it for the Nexus as a force to be reckoned with, and only Barrett headlined pay-per-views from that point on.
2. Farooq - King Of The Ring 1997
If JBL's ascendancy to the main event in 2004 was surprising, so to was his longtime partner Ron 'Farooq' Simmons' climb up the WWE card in 1997.
Unlike JBL, however, Simmons had been a main event player in the past. He wasn't just some career midcarder getting a call because he was 'due' a run. On the contrary, Simmons was the first ever black WCW World Heavyweight Champion, having downed Vader at a WCW house show in August 1992.
The former member of Doom held the belt for five months but was then quickly relegated to the midcard and eventually joined the WWF a couple of years after his WCW contract expired. After a truly rotten spell wearing a misshaped helmet and working under a gladiator gimmick, he was repackaged as the leader of the pro-black group the Nation of Domination, which was much more in keeping with the Attitude Era.
The new super-serious Farooq was granted a WWE Title shot against backstage buddy The Undertaker at the 1997 King of the Ring. There was not a particularly strong build for this one, which leads me to believe that WWE felt the KOTR tournament would sell itself and that the main event was fine. Besides, there was nobody else for that spot, since all the good workers were already vying for the prestigious crown.
The match itself was, for lack of a better term, laboured, and didn't exactly electrify a crowd that had already witnessed a Steve Austin versus Shawn Michaels barnburner. 'Taker won the match (obviously), which was supposed to set up a match between the Deadman and Ahmed Johnson at the next supercard, Canadian Stampede, before the master of the Pearl River Plunge fell injured.
Farooq then started sliding back down the card on his way to being usurped by a young blue-chipper named Rocky Maivia...
1. The Dudley Boys - Great American Bash 2004
I'm not saying the Dudley Boys aren't a legendary tag team and didn't deserve to be in a WWE main event, but their inclusion in the top-liner of the 2004 Great American Bash - one of the worst WWE pay-per-views ever - was shocking, for a couple of reasons.
Firstly, how often do handicap matches headline PPVs? Not very. If they do, it's usually two very top stars against another very top star, such as Triple H & Steve Austin versus The Undertaker at Insurrection 2001.
Then there was the fact that the Dudleys had been spinning their wheels on Raw for the best part of a year and were beyond stale. They'd done just about everything they could do and their act was getting old. So WWE drafted them to Smackdown, turned them heel and inserted them into the ridiculous feud between The Undertaker and Paul Heyman.
The Dudleys had been involved in one WWE pay-per-view main event in the past, but that was with eight other guys in the 'Inaugural Brawl' at Invasion in 2001. Spring 2004 Dudley Boys were a far cry from the act they were back then and interest in their match with 'Taker was low.
It didn't help that it was a nonsensical 'Concrete Crypt' match where the major players were The Phenom, Paul Bearer and Heyman. The whole thing was a farce, a lame excuse for a pay-per-view main event. Viewers told WWE as much, as the 2004 Bash only drew 238,000 buys.
The Eddie Guerrero versus JBL WWE TItle Bullrope Match should have really closed out the show.