7 Reasons John Cena Doesn’t Belong On Team SmackDown Live
Shane's Survivor Series announcement makes no sense, even by WWE standards.
Announcing a special guest referee, ring announcer, timekeeper, enforcer, or a secret final team member for a big match should be exciting and surprising. The Undertaker, for example, made his debut as Ted Dibiase's mystery partner at the 1990 Survivor Series. It was shocking, it was amazing, and it was different. It was also glorious, but that may be gimmick infringement.
Announcing John Cena as a special guest... anything, just doesn't have the wow power that it once did. It's not that Cena isn't a big star, because he is. It's more that he is used so often, in so many cases, that it just doesn't have a lot of meaning anymore, nor does it generate the kind of excitement that WWE hopes for in many of its fans.
When Shane McMahon tweeted on 8 November that Cena would be joining Team SmackDown, a lot of people were disappointed for a lot of different reasons. The fact is that John Cena just doesn't belong on Team SmackDown Live.
7. A Double Whammy Of Boos
There are two people in WWE that are being pushed to the moon and beyond by the WWE, while fans reject the notion with a chorus of boos.
When Shane McMahon confirmed Cena’s return via the only legitimate political platform, Twitter, the general thought was that the second in the duo of boo magnets, Roman Reigns, would still be on the shelf and would remain out of the event. As it stands now, should things work out as expected, Reigns will also make his return to action at Survivor Series in a 6-man-tag between The Shield and The New Day.
Is the WWE ready for the boo-fest that they have potentially unleashed? What does it mean if one gets booed and the other cheered? These are all questions to ask after this Sunday’s event. The question to ask now is why WWE would put themselves in that position.
6. Won't Somebody Think Of The Poor Movie Studios?
At the beginning of August, it was announced that John Cena had been cast in the upcoming Transformers: Bumblebee spin-off movie. Probably the best casting ever, given that John Cena looks like he might transform into a Mac truck and “roll out”.
It seems odd that the movie makers are willing to let Cena climb into the ring, jeopardising their star’s health. It is even more surprising that the studio’s insurance company would allow it to happen. Even if the movie had completed principle shooting, the necessity of reshoots could arise. It was one thing when there was talk that Cena would join the card as the guest referee of the match between Brock Lesnar and Jinder Mahal. It is another thing entirely to have Cena actively taking bumps.
Is it possible that this could be a sign of further shenanigans to come? Probably not, but it’s still a pretty good reason he shouldn’t be competing for team SmackDown.
5. Cena’s Return Gets Lost In The Chaos
There’s no denying that things have been bonkers-go-nuts over the last few weeks at WWE. There’s also no denying that John Cena has “made his return to the WWE” so many times that it’s nearly lost all meaning. The result is that a dubiously anticipated return gets completely overshadowed by rarer and crazier things.
In just the last few weeks, wrestling fans have been treated to an unusual number of major news stories. Neville’s departure, Owens and Zayn being sent home from the European tour, Roman Reigns’ likely return at Survivor Series, Chris Jericho effectively defecting from WWE to New Japan, and news of Paige's seemingly never happening return. That is to say nothing of the continuing events surrounding outside talent like The Young Bucks and the firing of popular writer, Jimmy Jacobs.
These last few weeks have been a genuinely exciting time to be a wrestling fan. Whereas all of these events have raised interest, the return of John Cena to the world of wrestling after he hasn’t been gone long enough to miss him is likely to fall as flat as Damian after a visit from The Canadian Earthquake.
4. Randy Orton Is On The Team
The WWE has told us that the rivalry between John Cena and Randy Orton is one of the most legendary in WWE history. In some form, John Cena and Randy Orton have faced off 86 times on WWE television and on pay-per-view. These two guys are supposed to hate each other. Their bitter feud has been boiling since they both debuted out of Ohio Valley Wrestling in 2002, and while both are currently faces, there’s just too much history to believe that the two could coexist.
Orton and Cena have beaten the ever-loving crap out of each other in just about every major match type: Hell in a Cell, Elimination Chamber, Tables matches, I Quit matches, and an Iron Man match. They have done absolutely terrible things to one another inside the ring. Even in kayfabe it’s hard to see how someone goes from having some dude punt your father in the skull, to a point where you want to climb in the ring on the guy’s side.
3. He Just Left And Made A Show Of It
Near the end of September, John Cena left Raw to film a starring role in the upcoming Transformers spinoff movie. This is nothing new for the company’s lead man. Cena has been in movies before, and it was always assumed that he would return fairly quickly.
This time was different. After the match, Cena lingered in the ring looking for all the world like a like a lost puppy. This even prompted “Thank You Cena” chants from the part of the crowd with deep voices that are usually booing him. It was all very emotional.
Cena stood for one more moment in the ring, and looked like he was about to cry. Then, he walked up the ramp and lovingly fondled the video screen as though he would never see it again. It was sad. They must have been close. Now, of course, the whole thing seems just a little bit silly. September to November is not enough of an absence to justify tender feelings toward LED lights.
Someone send Cena a copy of The Boy Who Cried Wolf.
2. It’s A Wasted Opportunity For A Showcase
SmackDown Live has really built their foundation on being the land of opportunity, especially for up and coming superstars. This Survivor Series team could have been an opportunity to shine a spotlight on newer talent.
Nakamura and Roode would be considered the two “rookies” on the card (if you can call them that with a combined 40+ years experience between them). Orton and, for some reason, Shane MacMahon already represent the established superstars.
The 'Perfect 10' Tye Dillinger is on SmackDown Live’s roster and isn’t doing anything Sunday night. He has a certain overness with the crowd that could have benefited from a rub like this. If not Dillinger, then why not add Chad Gable to the team? With his former tag team partner, Jason Jordan, on Raw it would have created an instantly recognizable conflict.
Regrettably, no. Instead we get the non-surprise of John Cena once again returning to save the day. Sure it probably sells merch, but it sure does get tiresome.
1. John Cena Is A Ringer
What Shane McMahon has done, is gone out and hired someone who is not on the roster to boost his team’s chances of winning. That’s the definition of poor sportsmanship though not-technically cheating. It’s basically the counting cards of competition. It’s not illegal, but there are people who will break your legs over it just the same.
So how does Mr. Hustle, Loyalty, Respect, the pinnacle of the White Knight stereotype, justify taking part in a scheme so sophisticated that Monty Burns pulled it off using Darryl Strawberry and Jose Canseco back in 1992?
The only way that this loophole can really be closed would be if Shane had locked Cena into some kind of long term SmackDown contract. As of now, there seems to have been no such agreement.
In scheduling John Cena to appear at the last minute on the Survivor Series card, WWE seems to be ignoring a great deal about his character and seriously jeopardizing any credibility John Cena had legitimately built with fans. Is it worth it where there were other options? Find out this Sunday at Survivor Series.