John Cena has been the face of WWE for close to 10 years now. His main event run has far exceeded the length of Steve Austins, The Rocks, and even Hulk Hogans. But his time on top is coming to a close. It may not be within the next year or two, but Vince McMahon is going to need to find a successor. Ryback was too one-dimensional, CM Punk was too much of a headache and Daniel Bryan doesnt fit the archetype that McMahon has laid forth for what he wants in a superstar. A man who does fit that vision is Roman Reigns. Much like the producers of the 007 films having to find a new James Bond every few years, the boss appears to have chosen Reigns as his next guy to carry the company. Since breaking away from The Shield, he's been pushed heavily until an injury took him out of action. Now that hes back, it may only be a matter of time before he gets the rocket strapped to his back. Unfortunately, the reviews so far are pretty mixed, and thats not a good sign for the next big thing. Reigns has improved in every category since his debut, but hes being held to a standard that no other superstar is. He needs to be great. While he may be a star for the company for years to come, here are seven reasons why he will struggle to carry WWE.
7. Hes Too One-Dimensional
Roman Reigns made his WWE main roster debut in November of 2012. That was over two years ago, and we still dont know that much about him. Looking at his former stablemates, Seth Rollins is a greedy, manipulative and cowardly man who is solely out for himself. Dean Ambrose just wants to watch the world burns, with some hints of a troubled upbringing. Roman Reigns is...um a guy that likes to hit people in the face and yell Believe that? The Shield itself was never quite defined either. They fought for a vague concept of justice, but it was never consistently enforced of what that meant. Now that Reigns is on his own, we are still left to fill in the gaps ourselves to what he wants in his solo run. This is far from a fatal flaw at this point, but to become a full-time main-event act this lack of character development is only going to hurt him. There are rare exceptions like Goldberg where less is more, but Reigns doesnt seem to quite fit that character type, nor does he have his charisma. He's like the aforementioned Ryback that just didn't quite connect with a mass audience. In order for people to get behind Roman, we need to find something about him that we can like, besides a nice head of hair.
6. Because The Heels Have All Been Easily Defeated
When Hulk Hogan passed the torch to The Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania 6, it briefly felt like the company had a new top guy. After all, Hogan hadnt lost cleanly on television in over six years, which made it a huge moment in the companys history. But after that, Hogan went away for awhile, and Warrior needed some top heels lined up to challenge him. But in 1990, Hogan had already done away with credible heels like Ted DiBiase and Randy Savage. Andre was on his last legs, and Roddy Piper and Jake The Snake were babyfaces. WWE decided to go with Rice Rude. While in hindsight that seemed like a great choice, Warrior had already won a feud against him months earlier at SummerSlam. Now we were supposed to buy the rematches as pay-per-view main events, and believe the heel now magically had a chance at winning? Yeah, it didn't really work. Currently, what heel in WWE could get Reigns to the next level? Kane? Who on the roster couldnt beat him at this point? Bray Wyatt? Cena did away with him and his family pretty easily not long ago. The Big Show? Nah, Cena's disposed of him time and time again too. Cesaro and Miz havent been protected enough to mean anything. Seth Rollins is busy trying to build himself up. The only guy that could really give anyone a boost on the heel side is Brock Lesnar. Thats it. WWE already damaged the rub from beating him a little bit by showing John Cena would have most likely won their match at Night of Champions. If Reigns does become the top guy, its doubtful (especially with the current creative regime) that a series of main-events against Rollins and Kane are what's going to get him there.
5. He Has Some Maturing To Do
WWE is a PG company. After years of fighting that fact, it seems most fans begrudingly accept it. While most male fans despise Cena, they would hopefully be able to at least admit that he fits in well with the current product. The man is a true workhorse. He does an incredible amount of charity work, and conducts himself well in interviews and on social media. Reigns, however, still has some growing pains to go through. A few months ago on Twitter, Roman Reigns apparently had a dinner that he wasnt very fond of. Instead of keeping that to himself and some friends, he took to twitter to blast the restaurant. Fair enough. Weve all said a thing or two on social media that we would probably wanted to have not posted. But not many of us are seen by millions of people every single week. When someone like Reigns called a manager a smug b***h you have to wonder what hes thinking. He also did this when he was 29, not 19. Trying to make light of the situation, WWE producer Billy Kidman made a joke on Twitter saying Reigns was just trying to score a free meal. Reigns didnt get it. He basically blasted Kidman and called him an old man. Reigns may be going through some growing pains in the public eye, but you can imagine some faux pas like that probably make McMahon a little more cautious about choosing him as his next guy of his family entertainment company.
4. His Matches Are Mediocre
When Roman Reigns was in The Shield, he was protected perfectly. Rollins and Ambrose did most of the work, then Reigns would tag in a couple of times, hit some power moves and call it a night. Once he left the group, all eyes were on him when he was in the ring. He also had to take on lengthier matches, and the results have been prettymeh. Now Reigns is certainly better in the ring than McMahons last pet project in Ryback. Hes also better than Ultimate Warrior ever was, but for top level babyfaces thats about it. Hes nowhere near the same league of Steve Austin, Shawn Michaels or Bret Hart. Yes, hes only been in the wrestling business since 2010, but in those four years he hasnt displayed an uncanny knack for the sport like say a Kurt Angle or Brock Lesnar. Right now, hes probably most comparable to Batista. His matches are fine, but he needs a really good opponent to take him to the next level. Even Randy Orton, who has had his share of great matches over the years has only pulled some fairly-bland to fairly-good matches out of him. At the age of 29, Reigns is bound to keep improving, but for someone slated to be John Cenas heir, it would be nice to have already shown some signs of potential in-ring greatness.
3. His Promo Abilities Are Suspect
Believe that! Well, not every catchphrase can be as good as Austin 3:16. While former Shield members Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose have improved on the mic, Roman remains awkward. Really awkward. At TLC, he cut a brief promo after his return, and just kind of embarrassed himself as he stumbled to say he would be the first one to announce their entry into the Royal Rumble. The next night on Raw, the company didnt even let him speak. Coincidence? Probably not. Roman has only been called upon a small number of times to deliver a promo that lasted more than a couple minutes, and none of them have been home runs. None of them have even been doubles. While a top star doesnt always have to have incredible promo abilities (like Sting, Goldberg, or Andre the Giant), it sure cant hurt them in the largely character driven WWE.
2. Fans Dont Want Another Superhero
Part of the reason why fans latched onto Daniel Bryan so much is because of how sick they were of John Cena as a living super hero. Bryan is presented as more of a regular guy, one who had to work his way up to the top after being held down for so long. It's the same reason that CM Punk exploded in popularity: he represented a "real" wrestler, someone that didn't fit in with pre-conceived plans of what a wrestler should look like. More so than anything, it was talent that brought them to the big time. A lot of people can relate to Punk and Bryan, and how they had to fight for everything they earned. As much as Cena wont admit it, he basically has the exact look that Vince goes for in a top star, which is why he got the opportunity that few others have. When Cena does call it a career, fans don't want someone just like him to take over. Ten years of the same thing is way too much as it is. Adding on a few more could be lethal. The audience doesn't want another good looking, dominant jock with a limited amount of wrestling moves as the face of the company. Sadly that kind of sums up Roman Reigns.
1. Fan Passion Isnt There
This is the big one, because no matter how much WWE may want you to love a particular wrestler, it just can't be forced. As soon as The Undertaker lost his winning streak at WrestleMania, one of the big questions was who would dethrone Lesnar and benefit from that monumental night. It was Roman Reigns who was rumored for that role, and it seemed like WWE was going to put him on the fast track to superstardom. The problem is the fans werent going along for the ride. Reigns does get a pretty good crowd reaction compared to the rest of the roster, but its nothing like Steve Austin, The Rock or John Cena were receiving before they were the chosen ones. While McMahon says he listens to the fans, that a dubious claim. He seems to handpick who he wants on top and forces them on the fans until they start to accept them. He tried this with Ryback a couple of years ago, and his push was met with a healthy amount of backlash. He tried again with Batista last year while the fans were demanding Daniel Bryan. If the audience starts to believe that Reigns is the chosen one without actually having to earn their love first they will rebel. The future is overall bright for him, but WWE cant make us to accept him as a top guy, which is why he may not be welcomed as Cena's successor like McMahon is hoping for.