7 Reasons Why James Ellsworth Is Obviously Not A Main-Eventer
"Any man with two hands has a fighting chance" will not be the catch cry of a generation.
It rolled on from a little spark that set the internet alight.
The New Era has gifted wrestling fans with all sorts of gems, with the story of the common man rising up against the odds as the central conceit. No one has represented that mentality more ironically than James Ellsworth.
SmackDown Live has, at this point in time, proven itself to have huge potential for success in the struggle to claim TV ratings. It’s fresh and exciting, daring to take risks in all its divisions, in an effort to grow away from the mundane garbage we had become accustomed to on the old SmackDown. It feels like the "People’s Show" again. James Ellsworth has epitomised that mentality.
But all good things must come to an end, and Ellsworth’s good thing is dangerously close to outliving its natural lifespan. SmackDown closing with immense “Yes” chants for Ellsworth’s hot tag says multiple things, but more than anything, suggests an underlying problem with the current product.
Here’s 7 reasons James Ellsworth’s main event spotlight needs to die.
7. The Joke Is Dead
WWE have a well-documented history of drawing out a joke longer than it’s entitled to live.
I’ll give them credit this time round, especially the SmackDown team for crafting clever and simplistic stories around these characters, and giving superstars the opportunity to shine. Who could have foreseen that Heath Slater’s kids would be the most over gimmick on a WWE show?
Why is this? Simplicity creates intoxicating stories. They become relatable, and they resonate with fans. I can guarantee there’s a few faces in the crowd who connect with the idea of Ellsworth, but for the most part, he’s just a living breathing meme. Who doesn’t love a good meme these days?
It had me in stitches, but once the t-shirts came out, the joke had grown a few grey hairs. It’s really not so far removed from the demise into comedic centricity of Dean Ambrose, and it won’t be long before we take SmackDown for granted with Ellsworth at the forefront.
6. It Makes SmackDown A Joke
SmackDown Live is light and fun. Stories are cohesive, and a weekly episode is far removed from the long slog that is a three-hour Raw. But when Ellsworth is the central figure over guys like Ambrose, Styles, and even Cena, there’s an issue.
SmackDown runs the risk of becoming the irrelevant show once more for a whole other reason. Big returns like Edge and Undertaker might counter-act this temporarily, but having Ellsworth close the show every week sends a message of comedic value to your audience, and that it shouldn’t be taken for anything other than this.
Bearing in mind the target audience for WWE programming, this is definitely an adult form of comedy that will detach young fans before anyone. No, we’re not in the ‘PG Era’ anymore, but that doesn’t mean that there aren’t massive numbers of kids tuning in to watch their favourite superstars fight. I’d like to draw comparison to how I felt as a kid every time ‘Big Dick’ Johnson interfered in a match/promo – Okay, it’s not that bad, but you get my point.
5. He's Getting Too Much TV Time
The fact that Ellsworth gets two/three backstage segments and a main event match (even if he is standing idly by), against the near-five minutes Tyler Breeze gets in a terrible tag match against the Vaudevillians is flat out criminal.
At the commencement of the ‘New Era’, SmackDown was foreshadowed as the show for the people, and it’s since lived up to that reputation. Yet perhaps our self-indulgence is obstructive to the careers of superstars deserving of TV time, who can’t get on when James Ellsworth is in their slot.
It just goes to show the power of social media and fan response. Despite what we’ve been feeling for years, someone is listening. Someone has caught onto the charm of Ellsworth, and is using it to the full advantage of fan appeal towards SmackDown.
Whether this will be healthy long-term, at the expense of potential careers like those of Tyler Breeze, is questionable.
4. Fans Are Getting Themselves Over
This could be a whole new argument in itself, but I’ll try to keep it sweet. Wrestling is amazing. It’s an immersive experience that includes its fans unlike any other sporting or recreational activity.
But there comes a time where we need to accept what we are being presented with, and go along for the ride for it to manifest itself to its full potential. The role of the wrestlers and the production team at the core is to take us to an alternate reality. When fans ark up and attempt to hijack a show, you know something’s up in audience mentality.
We’ve seen some incredible fan-induced moments and stories over the years; CM Punk, Mizdow, Daniel Bryan, the ‘list of Jericho’, to name a few. But these people all gave us something to work with, in the hope we would reciprocate emotional response and gratification for their work. Not that we would completely steal the show.
The passive nature of Ellsworth’s character has allowed him to float to the rafters on the echoing voices of fans. When it’s at the point we are ignoring AJ Styles over Ellsworth, the line needs to be drawn.
3. He's A Blatant Contradiction
The sight of AJ Styles sitting on commentary watching James Ellsworth appearing in the main event for the fourth consecutive week made my heart ache.
When did comedic relief become more important than seeing the WWE World Champion AJ Styles (a sight that at the start of the year we thought we would never see), wield the audience’s attention in palm of his hand? When did we decide that gimmicks are more important than talent?
Admittedly, fans are rightfully confused. By virtue, AJ is a heel. We want AJ, but he don’t want none. On the other side, no one seems to care for Ambrose, which in itself is a problem given the potential he has, or had. Ellsworth has served as a vehicle for a lacklustre feud, which is concerning given these two are at the top of the food chain.
We search for stability and certainty, something that reflects our desires. Ellsworth provides that security. He delivers the unthinkable, and has been astutely used as a device to guide the struggling main event scene, something we knew would be an issue post-brand split.
2. This Is A Short-Term Fix
Entertainment comes in many forms. This is no more apparent in any other entertainment complex than in wrestling. What makes wrestling successful at this level of exposure, is when it combines different entertainment facets. It needs to tick all the boxes thoroughly to appeal to the wide range of audiences the ‘New Era’ hopes to captivate.
Gillberg had his run, and likewise this won’t last forever. SmackDown needs a fine balance of competitive nature and buffoonery, and right now it’s saturated from head to toe with cringe-worthy finishes and laugh-out-loud “this is f***ing ridiculous moments.”
Raw and SmackDown need to meet in the middle if the company is to collectively revitalise their product.
1. He Has Potential Elsewhere
With The Brian Kendrick defending his Cruiserweight Championship against Kalisto at Survivor Series, the potential for a double switch of the Cruiserweight division and Intercontinental title is imminent.
Ellsworth has proven that he has all the potential to get the crowd behind him and shift his momentum towards success. Where better a place to do that than in the Cruiserweight division?
While we don’t want to return to a time where Hornswoggle was the last Cruiserweight Champion, Ellsworth feels a little more pure. SmackDown will be a prolific environment that nurtures the division, particularly under the wing of Daniel Bryan. With the complimentary gimmick of Ellsworth, the division will take on a life of its own, in the favourable manner it was intended. Two birds, one stone.
Ellsworth is a cult icon, and will be remembered as such for as long as our generation continues to document his legacy in the form of memes and Facebook tribute pages. But it’s time for him to head on down the ladder, and build on something great from another perspective. It’s not good-bye, it’s just “see you soon”.