7 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (24 April - Results & Review)

Fatal Influence debuts and WWE books title change on strong post-WrestleMania 42 SmackDown.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

WWE couldn't have booked a weaker lead-in to WrestleMania 42 than last week's edition of SmackDown. The 'go home' segment creative chose was a sickening love-in between Cody Rhodes and CM Punk, but pretty much nothing on the show worked to inspire confidence that the company was going to knock it out of the park across 2 nights in Las Vegas on PLE.

Advertisement

Thankfully, Sunday's portion earned huge plaudits, but Raw on Monday (despite some interesting debuts) was another mediocre slice of WWE TV. As you can probably tell from the 'Ups' and 'Downs' counts alone, Friday's SmackDown was a lot stronger. When Triple H and staff do the simple things well, the product is a lot more palatable.

A staggering 23 workers just got their release papers ahead of the show, and there's no way it's a coincidence that WWE is calling so many wrestlers up from NXT at the same time. Here, 3 fresh stars hit the women's division hard (and there's another coming soon), and the likes of Ricky Saints was also teased as coming to the blue brand.

Advertisement

Further, only Friday's main event fell a wee bit short of greatness. The status quo appears to have stabilised due to healthy reactions towards reigning WWE Champ Cody Rhodes as well, so it'll be interesting to see whether or not that persists. If it does, then just build a statue of this guy - his babyface sustenance is unbelievable!

Here's all the yay and nay from what turned out to be a really solid Smackers to sit down and watch.

Advertisement

Downs...

2. “I Should Be Talking To Roman Reigns!”

WWE.com

Jacob Fatu nailed it when he interrupted all of the talk from The Usos, Solo Sikoa, the MFTs etc to say just that. He's right when he says he should be addressing the 'OTC' himself, not his cousins or any other family members. Also, Jimmy and Jey sort of played heel in this segment, which was interesting but a bit all over the place because of Roman’s presentation.

Advertisement

The match between Roman and Jacob at Backlash is ostensibly babyface vs. babyface until further notice, but with The Usos adding a bit of a rogue element that doesn't seem necessary. It really feels like been there, done that on the issues between Fatu and Solo too - they feuded over the United States Title before, and the results were mixed back then.

Fatu was fine on the mic (again) and did line up a main event, but this was a fairly weak opening segment that was missing the key ingredient. In other words, Jacob having a war of words with Jimmy, Jey and Solo isn't going to come anywhere close to touching a staredown between Fatu and Reigns. That's the real meat in the sandwich here. Everything else will just fall by the wayside.

Advertisement

Predictably, that's what happened.

WWE must sort out what they want The Usos to be, man. They can't have Jimmy tell Jacob not to listen to clowns in the audience, then have both he and Jey pander to those same people with their "YEET" business. That's messy. This whole revolving door promo was, to be perfectly honest.

Advertisement

1. Main Event Fails To Cap The Night Off

WWE.com

Then, in the headline slot to close the show, Jacob Fatu vs. Solo Sikoa meandered from the opening bell and didn’t really pick up the pace nearly enough until the final stretch. This definitely wasn’t a slow-burner like CM Punk vs. Roman on Sunday night at 'Mania. It was a dull TV match that was more of a vehicle for what happened afterwards than anything else.

Advertisement

It looks like that's a wrap for Jacob on SmackDown for now, and this wasn’t the best match for him to go out on. Personally, and not to press repeat, but this fan isn't into the bizarre heelish edge The Usos are showing around Fatu either. Generally, this week’s headliner didn’t hit the heights Triple H surely planned it to, and that must owe something to the fact that fans don't really buy Sikoa as being on Jacob's level nowadays.

Admittedly, the post-match stuff was better and fits Fatu’s recklessness, but that wasn’t enough to pull the nose up on the match itself. The writing team made the 'Samoan Werewolf' look powerful enough to take on Solo and the MFTs by himself (he neither wanted nor needed help from Jimmy and Jey), but it would've been nice had that story been packaged into a better bout between these dudes.

Advertisement

Strangely, Fatu and Sikoa don't seem to have much chemistry as opponents. On paper, every match between them should be bruising and entertaining, but this one certainly wasn't. It's a bit of a shame that it's the scrap that sends Jacob on over to Raw. Not the best goodbye to team blue!

Ups...

7. Routine But Fun Tag Title Defence

WWE.com

Now that The Wyatt Sicks are history, it's over to Damian Priest and R-Truth to carry SmackDown's tag-team division. They won't be getting any backup from the Motor City Machine Guns either, and it does feel like a missed opportunity that Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin burned bright then fizzled out in WWE. The creative team defo seems more comfortable with a wacky alliance like Priest and Truth than anything else.

Advertisement

Here, the unlikely allies beat MFT’s Tama Tonga and JC Mateo in around 10 minutes. The match was a vast improvement over Priest and Truth's lifeless defence vs. Kofi Kingston and Grayson Waller last week, that’s for sure. There was more energy in the building generally than there was in Las Vegas for last week’s SmackDown, but that bout really was the pits.

Putting the belts on Priest and Truth was an inspired decision, at least. They can always ride it out in matches like this to help the show, and guys like 'Ron Cena' are always going to get some sort of reaction out of a live crowd. Yep, it's a tidy spot for the pair as they fend off various squads before hopefully settling into a proper feud as champions.

Advertisement

As the subheading says, it was "routine", but that isn't meant as criticism. Sometimes, all a show needs is a couple of matches that hit the 6/7 out of 10 mark without trying to be too flashy or complicated. Weekly challenges like this one will fill the void left by the United States Title open season too.

Good stuff.

Advertisement

6. Danhausen & The Miz Just Work

WWE.com

It's always nice to report on WWE comedy done right. The promotion has sought laughs in crummy pre-tapes or by using toilet humour aplenty over the years, but Danhausen is genuinely funny and endearing. What's more, The Miz is fabulous foil for him, because his delusional arrogance and self-aggrandising behaviour is a neat fit for Hausen's OTT spookiness and silliness when giving bad guys comeuppance.

Advertisement

Skits involving both at Miz's house, including a welcome cameo from Maryse, added nice levity to SmackDown. Then, their match out in the arena (whilst short) was another barrel of laughs. This guy has to admit he got it badly wrong when he said that Danhausen would be demoted to NXT by now after a poor Elimination Chamber debut. He deserves a lot of praise for how over he’s been getting, and WWE/TKO will be loving the merch sales.

There was another giggle-worthy moment when Joe Tessitore called it “a quickhausen” after the finish too. Everything the duo tried here was overtly silly, but that’s the point, and there's absolutely nothing wrong with the company reaching for some silly string when it feels natural and isn't forced against fan wishes. People seem to adore Danhausen, so why not use him in this fashion?

Advertisement

It's way, way, way better than the old 24/7 Title guff, put it that way.

Getting Kit Wilson in on the act and maintaining his promising double trouble thing with The Miz was also sweet to see. This is working out well for everybody, and that doesn't happen often enough in wrestling. Got to love it when everyone wins and gets some character development.

Advertisement

5. Sami Zayn Is The Gingerbread Man

WWE.com

In theory, Sami Zayn revealing that he sneakily dressed up as the Gingerbread Man to ambush Lil Yachty and Trick Williams would've been played for giggles too, but one gets the impression that things are about to get real serious between Sami and Trick. They pulled off a double turn before and during WrestleMania 42, then put the United States Title on Williams to boot.

Advertisement

Speaking of boots, Zayn planted one in Trick's face with his Helluva Kick after revealing that he was wearing the mascot outfit all along. Mercifully, none of his gumdrop buttons fell off when he was performing the move. He didn't show off that he was wearing a thong either. Mind your business, Pinocchio. Anyone else want to rewatch Shrek after all of this?!

What a well-worked segment overall.

Advertisement

The promo Williams cut with Yachty made him look like a star, then his Gingerbread Man mascot attacked with the candy cane and it was revealed to be Zayn. No, that's not a sentence anyone thought they’d be typing, but here we are. WWE were always going to extend this feud to lean deeper into Sami's heel turn, and it worked a treat.

Fingers crossed that's now the end of the gingerbread stuff and they can get a lot more feisty, because Sami’s attack warrants anger from Trick rather than more mascot nonsense. They've done that, so draw a line under it and move onto a gimmick-based grudge match in time for Backlash. Also, give 'em more time than they got at 'Mania and everything will be just dandy.

Advertisement

4. Hopefully This Reignites Tiffany Stratton

WWE.com

It's 'Tiffy Time' again. Well, sort of.

Advertisement

Stratton beat Giulia to become the new Women’s United States Champ on Friday night. Being fair, Giulia is blatantly about to split from Kiana James (some of the dirty looks both gave one another during a backstage promo beforehand gave the game away on that) and will probably be used to get Kiana to the next level. The former champ is a bit dead in the water on SmackDown, being honest.

Meanwhile, Tiffany has needed something/anything to get her going again, ‘cause she’d fallen off big time since last year. The actual match itself was a fab watch. That’s the thing about both women: They can go in-ring, but they just haven’t been very interesting as characters or have been forgotten about by Hunter and staff for the longest time. Maybe less so for Giulia recently.

Advertisement

What a lovely moment for Tiffy regardless. Presumably, both were miffed about being left off the WrestleMania card, so they brought it and Stratton’s win got a noticeable pop. Giulia reversing the moonsault tease into a submission was awesome too; that tricked the crowd into thinking they were about to be robbed of a possible title switch in their hometown.

Then, WWE came through on it and everyone cheered. All's well that ends well. Maybe rumours about Stratton starting to fall out of love with pro wrestling and WWE as a whole have been greatly exaggerated. Only she and management will know what's really going on there, but this was her best performance in ages.

Advertisement

3. You’ve Got To Give Cody Rhodes Credit

WWE.com

Has...has Cody Rhodes survived the recent lull he had heading into WrestleMania 42?! The reigning WWE Champion was super over as a babyface on SmackDown, but there was a bit of spice to his words too. Personally, this writer still reckons Rhodes would benefit from going heel, but he was on fire this past Friday night. There's no denying it.

Advertisement

Whilst doing these 'Ups' and 'Downs' articles, it's wise to strike a balance between looking at the bigger WWE picture and analysing matches/segments/promos on an individual basis. “I’m easy to find and I’m hard to beat” was one hell of a line from Cody, and it'd be daft to ridicule him or the company for buying some time with this sort of promo.

A rematch vs. Randy Orton will surely happen at Backlash if Rhodes is medically cleared in time. The fact remains that he isn’t for now, so this was the best use of him possible. Leaving the main man off SmackDown entirely would've sucked, and all Trips had to say was: 'Bring the fire, champ'. Cody 100% did, and he successfully managed to skirt the fine line between using TKO as an excuse for lame content and bashing them for poking their nose into a system they know precious little about.

Advertisement

2026 will be the last year of Cody's remarkable 4-year face stretch, surely. If so, then he obviously plans to go out on a high. Somehow, he's avoided catching strays due to over-exposure and unhappiness about Pat McAfee's involvement in the 'Mania biz with Orton. Onto the next.

2. Fatal Influence Debuts

WWE.com

Nick Aldis must've got on the blower to Adam Pearce and asked to borrow Dominik Mysterio's old heat-seeking machine from Raw, because the live crowd were on for Fatal Influence's debut and Jacy Jayne's duelling promo opposite Rhea Ripley. Firstly, Jayne and her pals Fallon Henley and Lainey Reid took their main roster bow by wrecking a match pitting Paige and Brie Bella vs. Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss.

Advertisement

That was a vehicle to introduce Jayne and the rest of Fatal Influence to SmackDown. Can’t say fairer than that. Jacy has deserved this debut for a while, but seeing Reid and Henley come with her is another positive, especially when the group appears to be gunning for the Women’s Tag-Team Titles as well as singles gold.

Again, Influence got great heat from the live crowd, who chanted “YOU SUCK” and jeered hard. It's all about how WWE follows up on this, of course, but it was a strong debut and one of the strongest for an NXT act in a while. Influence should be really proud of that, and chuffed that all of them got to do some talking during the bit with Ripley later on.

Advertisement

Henley and Reid coming after Paige and Brie sounds good, as does seeing the newcomers match up vs. Flair and Bliss. That babyface pairing will almost definitely campaign for another title shot after all of this, which is cool. This is the best use of workers like Charlotte, Alexa, Paige and Brie imaginable.

WWE is dead set on clearing out and building towards the future.

Advertisement

1. WWE Keep Jacy Jayne Strong

WWE.com

What a night this was for Jayne specifically.

Advertisement

She got to hang with Rhea Ripley in a hastily-assembled Women’s Title match, and the incoming NXT star didn’t even have to do the clean job. Instead, her Fatal Influence pals interfered for the DQ. Everyone won big here. Rhea got that first title defence under her belt, Jayne and faction look like a threat from the off, and the women’s division on Fridays just got a nice shakeup. To that point, Blake Monroe is incoming too.

This was a really good experience for Jacy, Fallon Henley and Lainey Reid, and it’s clear that Ripley will work as the division’s focal point. IYO SKY’s absence could be considered slightly surprising, but she’ll be along to help Rhea at some stage. Those crocodile tears between friends on Raw will look even more odd in retrospect, especially once IYO sprints out to help 'Mami'.

Advertisement

Or, perhaps her absence will be used to slow burn build towards a Women's Title war between tag-team partners. Who knows? In the short-term, it's Fatal Influence who will take the fight to Rhea whilst simultaneously going for the Women's Tag belts held by Paige and Bella on top of that. These ladies are about to be real busy.

This match will be used as a reference point for more to come between Jayne and Ripley in the future, and that's a positive. Honestly, the Influence trio's debut couldn't have gone any better. This is what they would've dreamed about doing on the main roster, and now they're all here living it.

Advertisement

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling content like this, check out 15 New Directions For WWE After WrestleMania 42 and 10 Way Too Early Card Predictions For WWE WrestleMania 43!