7 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE Backlash 2023 (Review)

Does Cody's story continue? Did hometown heroes Bad Bunny, Zelina Vega triumph?

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

Someone is going to need to do an experiment to determine if Backlash really was that good of a show, or if the deafening roar of the Puerto Rico fans elevated merely good material. Just re-watch the show with the sound muted and report back.

Advertisement

In all seriousness, WWE delivered a really, really good show Saturday night, incorporating some of its own history into the proceedings and giving the San Juan crowd a reason to get excited several times. The matches varied between good and great, with the opener between Bianca Belair and Iyo Sky stealing the show.

Bad Bunny was the folk hero of the night, eliciting huge cheers from fans and stepping up to really be a big part of the show rather than coasting or relying purely on plunder and outside interference to get the job done. It he wasn’t already the biggest musical artist on the planet, he could probably give wrestling a go.

Cody Rhodes’ story will continue, though it did not have an emphatic statement entered into the record Saturday night. Still, at least they didn’t treat him like John Cena at SummerSlam 2014.

Overall, WWE continues to offer up solid PLEs that succeed in spite of some spotty booking. We’ll have to see if that carries over to Night of Champions.

Lets get to it…

Downs…

3. Cody Escapes With The Win

WWE.com

This is one of those “your mileage may vary” deals.

Cody Rhodes picked up an important win at Backlash, defeating Brock Lesnar in a grudge match that should have been his first WWE Championship title defense, but that’s beside the point.

The story here was Brock jumping and battering Rhodes on the Raw after WrestleMania 39, and Cody sought revenge. He would bloody up Lesnar badly and lay into him, but he got the win by pushing up while Brock had him in a Kimura, pinning the Beast while he had a submission hold locked in.

And then Cody rolled out of the ring to celebrate, essentially fleeing because Lesnar was furious at losing while having a submission locked in. That’s how the show went off the air.

It’s a terrible look for Rhodes, who inexplicably lost his world title match to Roman Reigns at Mania last month. Instead of slaying the Beast, Cody used leverage to survive.

There’s always the possibility this is going to lead to a second match between the two at Night of Champions (Brock typically works the Saudi shows), and that would take Rhodes out of the World Heavyweight Championship picture. So, we’ll give this a mild down – the result was the right one, and there’s a plausible reason. But if it turns out this was just to keep Brock strong, then it was a bad move.

2. This Guy Knocked Off Cena

WWE.com

Beating John Cena at WrestleMania should signify that you’re a top star, capable of great feats. At the very least, you should be able to win a title match definitively. Otherwise, you’re just a banana peel champion.

But that’s Austin Theory in 2023. He beat Cena at Mania last month, and he defended his United States Championship against Bobby Lashley and Bronson Reed. On paper, if you were to predict how Theory would retain, the smart money would have been on Lashley incapacitating Reed, only for Austin to toss Bobby and “steal” the pin.

And that’s exactly what happened. Theory was a third wheel in a power match between Reed and Lashley, but he was in the right place to toss Bobby after a spear and pin Bronson to retain the title. Even Michael Cole called him a “survivor,” which again isn’t how you should be describing the guy who got a career-defining win just five weeks ago.

Advertisement

Yes, Theory is a heel champion, but if you’re going to continue booking him like a chickensh**, maybe he shouldn’t have beaten a 16-time world champion at Mania.

1. Better Served As A TV Main Event

WWE.com

The old expression, “a meeting that could have been an email,” applied to the penultimate match on the Backlash card Saturday night.

The Bloodline defeated Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn and Matt Riddle in a six-man tag that was full of “drama” at the hands of Jey Uso and Solo Sikoa as the two brothers openly sparred and jockeyed for superiority during the match. They almost came to blows a couple times, and Solo even started to give Jey the Samoan Spike before restraining himself.

But this internal strife still didn’t prevent the Bloodline from prevailing, as Sikoa spiked Riddle to win the bout. The drama was fine for what it was, but the match itself ground to a halt when they went full melodrama with the Bloodline. This would have been better off as a TV main event on SmackDown, where everything is more sports entertainment than a straight wrestling show.

Advertisement

It also was the quietest match on the night, which is saying a lot when you consider the fans were electric the entire night. They either were worn out from the Bad Bunny/Damian Priest match, or they were just not into this stuff. Either way, the match and the gaga would have worked fine on free TV to advance the storyline.

Ups…

7. An Incredible Crowd

WWE.com

If every WWE crowd was like the ones in San Juan this weekend, we would be talking about how red hot the company is, regardless of the backstage issues with morale, last-minute script changes, questionable booking and spotty writing.

A hot crowd can change perceptions just by virtue of their noise and energy. But some of the silent crowds we’ve gotten in the continental United States have dragged decent shows down into the doldrums.

Backlash was a good show on paper and in the ring, but the fans super-charged everything, turning the opener into a white-hot title match. The noise for hometown heroes Zelina Vega and Bad Bunny was off the charts, and the reaction to surprise appearances by Savio Vega and Carlito also were insane, making those returns feel really special.

You’ve got to hope fans watching at home see this and realize that sitting on their hands at TV tapings is not the way to go. You paid for your ticket, so why not get loud?

6. Vega Homecoming Moment

WWE.com

Let’s face it: No one outside of Zelina Vega’s family thought she was going to leave Backlash with the SmackDown Women’s Championship in hand.

But getting a PLE match in front of friends and family in Puerto Rico was a pretty big victory in and of itself for Vega, and she milked it for everything it was worth, wearing the island’s flag and soaking in the cheers from tens of thousands of fans.

Zelina did manage to get a couple hope spots, but the outcome was never really in doubt. Rhea Ripley was in her first title defense after a tremendous match at WrestleMania 39 against Charlotte Flair. Winning this bout was a necessity for Ripley.

Advertisement

The match was fine for what it was, but this was all about the moment for Vega, and it was a nice little moment for her.

5. A Little Color Brightens Things Up

WWE.com

When in doubt, Brock Lesnar is the best person to turn a match into an epic affair with one simple move.

During his match against Cody Rhodes, Lesnar got sent into an exposed turnbuckle, which he rammed into face first and busted himself open hardway. The blood quickly started flowing, and the match instantly went from “pretty good” to “can’t take your eyes off the screen.” Brock wore the crimson mask, spurting blood as Cody pounded away on the cut and repeatedly chopped the Beast down with Cody Cutters and a Disaster Kick before hitting the Cross Rhodes twice for a near-fall.

WWE is never going to be like AEW and have blood on nearly every PLE card, but matches like these are elevated by the visual of the Beast streaming claret and Rhodes smearing it on his chest. It made Cody look that much more like he was out for blood… literally. And it gave the visual of Lesnar as a wounded animal.

Advertisement

See? Even the plays on words and phrases are better with blood.

4. LWO Reinforcements

WWE.com

For the longest time, WWE leaning into the locations where their events took place amounted to heels bashing the local sports team and hometown superstars losing in front of friends and family.

But lately, WWE has used geography to their advantage, leaning into major matches for hometown wrestlers and playing into the flavor of where the event is taking place. Puerto Rico has a rich wrestling heritage, so it would have been a smart move to incorporate some of WWE’s own crossover history into Backlash.

And for once, they did. During the Bad Bunny/Damian Priest street fight, the Judgment Day ran down to attack the Grammy-winning artist. Rey Mysterio came down for the save, but he was overwhelmed. This brought San Juan native Carlito out to even the odds to a thunderous pop, sporting an LWO T-shirt.

Advertisement

Rey and Carlito dispatched with Finn Balor and Dominik Mysterio, who were met at the entrance by Savio Vega… and the rest of the LWO. Judgment Day was wiped out by sheer numbers, a 6-on-2 mugging.

What a perfect concept: The LWO could have tons of honorary members who show up whenever WWE happens to be in their backyard. No one is expecting Savio to be on SmackDown next week, but if WWE swings back to Puerto Rico in a year and LWO is still thriving, he could easily pop up again.

Plus it was just cool to see Carlito in a WWE ring again.

3. Slaying The Nigerian Giant

WWE.com

Hats off to Seth Rollins for not only picking up a big win on Saturday, but also for pulling off a really fun Davis versus Goliath match against Omos.

Without much of an angle aside from MVP requesting the match to test the Nigerian Giant, this really was a spectacle match pitting the Grand Slam champion against the biggest man on the roster. As you might expect, Omos dominated early on, jumping Rollins while fans were serenading him and running over the Visionary.

But Rollins kept coming, dropkicking Omos’ knee and superkicking the giant. An early stomp attempt was blocked, and then Omos kicked out of back-to-back stomps, only for Rollins to hit a leaping stomp off the top to finally fell the big man.

Advertisement

If Rollins is indeed a top contender for the new World Heavyweight Championship, losing here wouldn’t have been the best, though it could have worked. Still, there’s nothing wrong with a multi-time world champion figuring out how to defeat a man literally twice his size.

2. A Barnburner Opener

WWE.com

A super-hot crowd obviously is going to elevate a match, but when it’s a class battle between Bianca Belair and Iyo Sky, you’ve really hit on something.

Belair defended her Raw Women’s Championship in what was decidedly hostile turf, with the Puerto Rico fans entirely in Sky’s corner, cheering everything she did and booing if Bianca would so much as escape a hold.

The two wrestlers had a brilliant match, with Iyo targeting Belair’s left arm, trying to neutralize the EST’s power game. It worked exceptionally well due to Sky’s unique and countless ways of attacking her arm, and Bianca’s writhing on the mat. Several times, it legit felt like Sky had the champ’s number, which is something you can’t fake.

Advertisement

Although Iyo came up short, this worked to really establish her as a threat, and you could make the argument that Bayley cost Sky the match when her interference backfired. Hopefully, that will be followed up on SmackDown.

1. Bunnies Can Fly

WWE.com

Bad Bunny deserves a mountain of credit for his work in Saturday’s street fight against Damian Priest at Backlash.

Bunny very easily could have leaned on plunder and outside interference to limit his involvement or lessen the number of bumps he took, but in addition to all of that, he actually wrestled a really physical and convincing match. Seconds into the match, he hit a shock Michinoku Driver and we were off to the races.

Priest all but had it won with a South of Heaven, but he pulled Bunny up. Bunny made him pay shortly after with a tornado DDT and Falcon Arrow. The two fought into the crowd, where Damian hit a Broken Arrow off a stack of cases through several tables. Bunny would get the upper hand and key in on an injured leg, which gave us the rare situation of a celebrity working a body part in a garbage brawl, but again, it worked well.

Advertisement

And of course, we get the full array of Bad Bunny highspots, including a Sliced Bread #2 and a Canadian (Puerto Rican?) Destroyer for the win. Tremendous fun and just a great example of a celebrity coming in and just going all-in on being part of the action and not just a spectator to it all.