7 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (June 8)
Will Ospreay opens the Forbidden Door, Jon Moxley chooses violence, and ANOTHER new belt?
Chaos.
That was perhaps the most succinct way to describe how things felt in AEW less than seven days removed from a pay-per-view that set out to conclude several long-running stories, one of which included the crowning of a brand new AEW World Heavyweight Champion.
Double Or Nothing's build had played to mixed responses, but the show got enough right on the night that CM Punk's crowning felt just as big a story as the outside-the-ring scandal that had engulfed his newest legacy rival Maxwell Jacob Friedman that same weekend. MJF's contract dispute didn't get in the way of him putting over former charge Wardlow, but it overshadowed just about everything else, and the electrifying worked shoot promo he cut on the following Dynamite dominated much of the conversation there too.
All until Friday evening when Punk and the company (in somewhat shambolic fashion) revealed that he was taking time off to injury and there'd be need for a new interim Champion. The news was clumsily handled, the follow-through even more so, but Dynamite sought to clean up the mess and set some sort of clearer course for June 26th's Forbidden Door pay-per-view.
Did it achieve those stated aims?
Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
4. Forbidden Bore
There was worthy work to be enjoyed between Hangman Page and David Finlay, but in yet another somewhat damning indictment of the Forbidden Door concept being made real, a theoretically enormous AEW x NJPW interaction being used to further other things (see also: Adam Cole Vs Tomohiro Ishii and Minoru Suzuki Vs Samoa Joe) implied that there's still too much going on for anything to register fully.
Hangman Page's post-victory promo was more intriguing than great. His understated burial of the Battle Royal and his apparent exclusion from it spoke more to MJF's similar internal complaints last week than anything else, but an interruption from Adam Cole to ensure yet another battle between the former rivals felt like over-egging a pudding that has already been baked.
It's logical enough that Cole would want Jay White to beat Kazuchika Okada, and be angry enough at Page for suggesting this wouldn't occur. But the match feels like a condescending delay - Page/Okada should be and presumably is the direction; was a foregone conclusion TV squabble between Page and Cole really necessary to build for the way there?
3. If You Can't Win A Title In AEW...
You f*ckin' suck, pal.
A dispirited Mick Foley once said as much without the curse word at the tail end of 2001 in a pre-Survivor Series attempt to clean up the mess of titles during the Invasion, but a company that once took 17 months to introduce a secondary male strap last night unveiled the eleventh belt that will theoretically be fought for over the three hours a week the company has on television. Twelfth including the interim AEW World Heavyweight Championship. Thirteenth including Ricky Starks FTW Championship, which has been featured on "Battle Of The Belts" and should thus count too. More still if the Owen belts are ever put up for grabs, or the AAA titles appear, which they likely will.
The Ring Of Honor belts continue to feature as long as ROH doesn't have a place of its own, and in Samoa Joe and FTR arguably have stronger holders than their AEW equivalents at present.
But back to the All-Atlantic Championship a second. Speculatively, it feels as though the belt exists as part of some political nicety between AEW and NJPW, or indeed any other promotion it may be defended in. But that doesn't give any thought to yet more creative complications, so as fans, what reasons should there be to care about it? And more worryingly, was that even considered before it was devised?
2. The Battle Of The Sexes
More on Thunder Rosa Vs Marina Shafir elsewhere in this article, but a quick note here on the bigger picture of AEW, its continued mistreatment of women's wrestling and why more people should have taken the (later doubly confirmed) news of Rosa's displeasure seriously before racing to the company's defence.
Jon Moxley fought the world to get to Chris Jericho. Kenny Omega hatched a cruel super-villain's scheme. Hangman Page rose back up the ranks overcame years of self-doubt and anxiety. CM Punk went on an emotional and physical odyssey to prove himself equal before he could prove himself the best again. The entire roster had a stake in an interim variant of his currently-parked prize.
Marina Shafir...walked up to Rosa, asked for a shot and got one three segments later. Which conveniently fell in the dreaded death slot too. These are the damaging differences that have dogged this promotion for three years and will continue to do so until tangible and consistent change is achieved.
1. Tables, Ladders & Cage
AEW is still the best wrestling promotion on the planet, even if sometimes that notion disguises itself amongst overwrought and overthought concepts and ideas.
Christian Cage and Jungle Boy's exchanges in this were a riot, with Cage's negging of Jack Perry starting to reach a critical point ahead of whatever splinter occurs in the group. Cage yet again booking his charges in an incredibly difficult encounter was a nice detail too - he's had a habit of this and at some point it's likely he'll blame them if and when it all goes wrong.
Jurassic Express defending their Tag Team Championships against The Hardy Boyz and The Young Bucks in a ladder match next week gets a massive, massive down for being the fourth one this year, not counting other brawls that have included the weapon. After Cody Rhodes' Hell In A Cell main event it's probably not the week to stir up more debate about what wrestlers should and shouldn't do if they declare themselves fit, but here's hoping the elder statesmen take it a little easier in this one.
Ups...
7. Ghost At The Feast
AEW had one job to do this week when it came to preserving the value of the MJF story, and that was to not feature him at all. That they succeeded is a credit to the company in these particularly chaotic times.
Valid comparisons to the CM Punk's 2011 face-melter should not extend to how quickly he was back on the scene after winning the WWE Championship at Money In The Bank. Punk was given just eight days to pretend he had the title hostage, so MJF getting at least longer than that after calling his boss a "f*cking mark" was crucial.
The longer the better, being honest. Wrestling fans have long memories, and will be right there for MJF's shocking reappearance whenever he finally makes it.
6. Interim Solutions
The Casino Battle Royal to determine an opponent for Jon Moxley later in the night was one of several imperfect solutions to the problem of CM Punk's injury, but the match itself spoke to the company's ability to gradually fix a broken format and still think about tomorrow.
Folding in several short and long-term stories featuring rivalries old and new and details between performers that couldn't have been forecast without prior notice of the field, AEW at long last made the best of this bad situation in a layered - if occasionally clunky - opener.
Kyle O'Reilly's victory generated an unexpected gem of a main event, but there was more to the match than that. The future health of the Swerve Strickland/Keith Lee unit was explored, Eddie Kingston and Jake Hager continued the JAS/BCC war, Wheeler Yuta returned to television and was presented as an immediate threat to to the top of the card, and O'Reilly's battle royal ability and/or future babyface prominence was as pronounced as its ever been. These elements and more spoke to the ambition at the core of the company. In the face of a number of unexpected obstacles, a battle royal existed to build rather than simply get them out of a jam.
5. All Action For The All-Atlantic
Buddy Matthews and PAC's match was so destined to be a ripper that it was announced before the title it ended up being fought for.
A toasted Wednesday afternoon graphic drop, the singles match between representatives of House Of Black and Death Triangle respectively delivered on lofty expectations despite the sudden news that it was actually serving as the first qualifier in the All-Atlantic Championship tournament.
PAC may be the most underrated wrestler in the world. It's not that people don't stop to praise his work because they justifiably do. But his consistent hit rate is out of this world, and there were exchanges in this that - as with their Double Or Nothing flash points - literally beggared belief. Matthews as an almost-mirror image makes for one of his best natural rivals, to the extent where their futuristic offence here was normalised but only in the best possible sense.
The feud between the two stables might be stagnant, but nothing stands still when these forces of nature collide.
4. United Empire Make A Statement
A passive Up for this, if only because AEW at very least delivered a major NJPW name with just three weeks to go before the Forbidden Door pay-per-view.
Truthfully, Will Ospreay's arrival should have been greeted with headline news acclaim, but a combination of Tony Khan's over-reliance on surprise appearances of late and Ospreay's knack for alienating folk over the years diluted the shock and awe.
It was otherwise a serviceable and functional piece of television. A beatdown including Aussie Open and Aaron Henare on Trent Baretta and FTR set up a six-man tag for Rampage and potentially another multi-man at the pay-per-view. It's midcard stuff, but divisive d*ckhead Ospreay will likely elevate it with his presence alone just as he did here.
3. Wardlow's World...
...wasn't exactly the coolest catchphrase, and the big man being forced to explain away why he didn't want to enter the battle royal at the start to the show spoke to the problems with that, but there were two moments of magic to be gleamed from a potentially problematic situation.
1) Next week on Dynamite, Wardlow will fight twenty - two zero - people in a single match. A brilliant way to simultaneously tie up his loose end with Smart Mark Sterling and get one more go on the Wardlow Vs The World ride that defined his feud with MJF, this can't be anything but a total blast.
2) Answering the prayers of just about every AEW fan, he as good as promised to clean up the TNT Title mess by eventually facing and defeating Scorpio Sky when the Champion is healed enough to take the sh*tkicking. Babyfaces don't let you down in All Elite Wrestling, and Wardlow won't when the time comes.
2. Fighting From Underneath
Given no story beyond a backstage challenge and a pre-show graphic, AEW Women's Champion Thunder Rosa and apparent Number One Contender Marina Shafir took to beating the absolute f*cking sh*t out of each other to generate some noise from a crowd understandably fairly uninvested in the match.
Gutting their way through the traditional death spot the division is typically afforded, this was better than Shafir's high profile loss to Jade Cargill by orders of magnitude, and if Thunder Rosa's only real role is going to be a fighting babyface Champion, she might has well have micro-bangers like this once a week.
That may very well be the case following the post-match too - Toni Storm made an appearance after the match to save Rosa from a beatdown, and gave the belt an NXT-style long stare to indicate her intention. That should rule too. Baby steps?
1. Jon Moxley Is The AEW World Heavyweight Champion
Or at very least the Interim one-in-waiting, and as he should be after yet another inspired and life-affirming performance in a TV main event. This, again, absolutely ruled.
Finding gripping drama against the battle-worn Kyle O'Reilly when AEW's booking had made such a thing tricky and counterintuitive, Moxley manipulated what it means to be a babyface in 2022 by simply being the hardest and most dangerous motherf*cker alive in a squared circle. Absorbing the punishment with a force of will shared only by his colleagues in the Blackpool Combat Club (and Eddie Kingston, of course), Mox simply refused to let O'Reilly get his sh*t in. And on the few occasions he did, the way in which he powered out and fought back harder spoke more to the internal characteristics of both men rather than following a trope-laden playbook of how to do a good match. Bloodsport and bloodbath combined, two men went to war and one came out on top. Professional f*cking wrestling as it should be.
He does this all the time, too, so it's okay to expect loads more. Moxley/Tanahashi was where this had to go before all the confusion and contrivance, and we're all now one step closer. In potentially running Moxley/Punk down the line, AEW have a thrilling bout to determine the future of the belt as well.