7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (27 Nov - Results & Review)

The Punker returns, Orton tangles with Judgment Day, Cody refocuses, Creeds ascend.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE

If your entire enjoyment of WWE Raw hinged on CM Punk delivering a vintage promo that picked up right where he left off in January 2014 – or even August 2023 – then you probably waited three hours to be pretty disappointed.

Advertisement

But fans who tuned in willing to go along for the ride and to see what else WWE had to offer Monday night likely came away happy. They saw Punk go an unexpected direction with his first WWE promo in nearly a decade. They also saw Cody Rhodes try to get his story arc back on track after months of feuding with the Judgment Day, only to get sidetracked again.

Drew McIntyre continues to be one of the most intriguing characters in WWE these days, which elevates several of the superstars who interact with him. Randy Orton’s return was handled well overall as the company eases him back into the rotation after 18 months away due to injury. And the Creed Brothers had another standout moment as they continue to impress since their call-up.

On the flip side, a returning tag team fizzled out in under 120 seconds, while it’s looking like WWE is intent on giving Miz another shot at the Intercontinental Championship after Saturday’s match under-delivered.

Overall, this was a good effort, bolstered by its returning stars, its blue-chip rookies, and charting a path to WrestleMania for one of its biggest babyfaces.

Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

4. Just A Match

WWE.com

Chelsea Green and Piper Niven have been Women’s Tag Team Champions for more than three months. Monday night, they defended the titles for just the second time in a nondescript match that might as well have aired in its entirety during a commercial break.

That’s not to say anything bad about the champs or challengers Tegan Nox and Natalya, but without any real reason to care about the challengers or think they had a chance – Monday was only the second time they had tagged together – the match fell flat and played to a subdued crowd.

Advertisement

It’s good that the champs defended their titles, that they got TV time, and that they won cleanly. But simply throwing barely average matches on television isn’t necessarily enough to garner positive marks. If everyone is going to talk about WWE being on an upswing, fans and critics should expect better and hold the company to a higher standard.

3. Indus Sher Fizzle

WWE.com

Any time there’s a tag team turmoil match, there’s bound to be a duo that is a massive disappointment. Inevitably, a team will be eliminated easily and look like fools in the process.

Monday night, it was Indus Sher, who had just returned to action and were promptly bounced from the gauntlet match in less than two minutes when Veer missed a blind charge and Johnny Gargano rolled him up.

Veer and Sanga did not look that impressive in that short burst, spending almost as much time posing and yelling as they did attacking #DIY. They looked more like token jobbers brought in to fill a spot than threats to any tag team on the roster. Maybe if they had been reestablished as a duo, this could have been brushed off as a bad night, but when it’s their first Raw match in more than five months, this was embarrassing.

Advertisement

It also didn’t help that fans didn’t react to any of Indus Sher’s offense, making them look even more ineffective and inconsequential.

2. Where’s The Piss And Vinegar?

WWE.com

For someone who bills himself as the most controversial superstar in professional wrestling, CM Punk sounded more like a guy ready to kiss babies and toe the company line on Raw.

Punk’s return promo steered clear of any pipebomb-esque comments, save for some veiled swipes at unnamed wrestlers who claim to be the best, because obviously, he’s the best in the world.

If fans were looking for some vitriol, or airing of grievances, or even passing references to the cloud under which he left WWE (or AEW for that matter), they had to be seriously disappointed. Punk sounded more like a happy-go-lucky babyface brimming with confidence than a grizzled vet with a chip on his shoulder. He delivered more of a rah-rah, pro-WWE promo than the guy who used to preach about shaking up the system.

Bear in mind that that very likely was the purpose of the promo – to deceive fans into believing his intentions are pure before snapping the trap on them – but if you sat through three hours of Raw waiting for a vintage Punk promo and got that promo instead, you were likely disappointed.

1. No, No, NO

WWE

What part of “no” does WWE not understand?

One Intercontinental Championship challenge from The Miz was enough. He lost cleanly, even after he blatantly cheated – twice! – at Survivor Series, so why does this alleged babyface deserve a rematch? Why do fans have to watch Gunther try to once again sell for Miz’s barely-make-contact kicks like they’re shotgun blasts?

But yet, there was Miz, stepping to Gunther backstage and challenging him to another title match, only for the IC champ to scoff and walk away. Unfortunately, WWE rarely lets stuff like that dissipate. Instead, it will resurface next week and Miz will finagle his way into another title match.

Saturday’s match wasn’t that good, period. There’s no reason to expect a second one, especially after WWE blew through it’s best shock near-falls for Miz, will be any better.

UPS…

7. A Simple Return To Action

WWE.com

Easing Randy Orton back into the flow of things on Raw is probably the best course of action, especially after back fusion surgery and an 18-month layoff.

During WarGames, Orton didn’t take a real bump. And in his first singles match back Monday night, the Viper got to beat Dominik Mysterio from pillar to post while not taking a single flat-back bump, even while he was briefly in peril. And of course, Orton got to drop Dom-Dom with an RKO, giving fans what they really wanted.

Hopefully, Orton is able to shake the ring rust off and get into bigger, higher stakes matches in the coming weeks, but this was a good thing to see Monday night.

6. Battle Of The Beef Planets

WWE.com

The collision between Bronson Reed and Ivar has been brewing for some time now, and it had the potential to be a fun, hard-hitting spectacle that drew a lot of “oohs” and “aahs” from fans.

Thankfully, that’s exactly what fans got Monday night, as they chanted “meat!” as the two behemoths battled, trading high-impact slams, kicks and strikes, but also showing off their nimbleness. Unfortunately, there was only one finish for this match: a double count-out.

But that was because the two were going to continue brawling into the crowd, with Reed throwing a security guard at Ivar, and the Viking diving off an electrical case to hit a cannonball on Bronson and security.

Advertisement

Why would a double count-out get positive marks? Because the brawl outside pretty clearly sets up the best match WWE has to offer with these two super-heavyweights: a Viking Rules match. Previous iterations have been tremendously fun, chaotic matches, and it could be an interesting experiment to see Ivar and Bronson do battle via Viking Rules.

If they’re headed in this direction, then this was a perfect setup. If not, both men better up their game for any other potential rematch.

5. Cody Refocuses… Sort Of

WWE.com

Ever since Cody Rhodes lost at WrestleMania 39, he’s said he wants to focus on finishing the story, but it’s been one distraction after another: Brock Lesnar, the Judgment Day, the Judgment Day, and more of the Judgment Day.

But Monday night, with Rhodes’ team emerging victorious in WarGames against the Judgment Day, Cody turned his attention back to finishing the story. The American Nightmare declared his entrance into the 2024 Royal Rumble, looking to get back to Roman Reigns and the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship.

That refocusing was welcome, but it was short-lived, as Shinsuke Nakamura made it clear that Rhodes was the person he was nebulously referencing in all of his video promos. Nakamura appeared in the ring and misted Cody, leaving him writing on the mat before leaving, setting up a decent interim feud for Rhodes before he enters the Rumble in two months.

Advertisement

This column has been adamant that Rhodes should have won at WrestleMania 39, and WWE certainly is stretching things out to get Cody all the way to WM 40 to (hopefully) finish the story against Roman. This feud is filler, but it should do just fine, and at least for the first time, there’s a clear path on the horizon for Rhodes.

4. Daddy’s Back

WWE.com

If CM Punk wasn’t going to open Raw Monday night, the only other person who could have successfully led off the show without being drowned out by “CM Punk” chants was Randy Orton.

The Viper returned to WWE at Survivor Series after a year-and-a-half on the shelf and he drank in the cheers, seeming to really appreciate being back after such a long layoff. It’s not in Orton’s nature to be cheerful and grateful to the fans, so that was a nice touch. He said he wanted to be part of history and compete in WarGames, so joining Cody Rhodes’ team helped check an item off his bucket list.

But the most interesting part of his promo came when Orton said he had unfinished business with the Bloodline – “every single member” of the group. That was a strong hint that Jey Uso might be in the crosshairs, even despite him telling Jey they were cool later on. Never trust a Viper, after all.

Advertisement

Orton sparring with Rhea Ripley was a nice little change of pace, as Mami has made herself the unofficial leader and spokesperson for the Judgment Day, issuing dire warnings and setting the table for the group. Randy of course wasn’t backing down, and that made for a good little standoff.

As far as returns go, this worked in picking up Orton’s loose threads of the Bloodline feud, as well as integrating him into the ongoing Judgment Day saga on Raw.

3. Creeds’ Coming Out Party

WWE.com

WWE might have figured out that the formula for rallying fans behind the Creed Brothers: Let Julius and Brutus display their freakish feats of athleticism and strength repeatedly until the crowds lose their collective minds.

During the tag team turmoil match, the Creeds were the de facto heels against #DIY and the New Day, with fans booing their offense and cheering their opponents. But every time Julius did a deadlift slam or he and Brutus flew around the ring in a way men their size shouldn’t be able to, the crowd slowly came around.

By the time they got to the Creeds versus Imperium, fans seemed to be on the fence… until Julius went off with a series of belly-to-belly suplexes and kip-ups. From then on, the Nashville audience was fully behind the brothers on their way to victory and becoming number one contenders for the tag titles.

Advertisement

There obviously is still work to be done in developing their characters a bit more and getting fans to invest in them beyond their insane ring work, but it’s visible and audible that this is working.

2. McIntyre’s Descent Continues

WWE.com

Drew McIntyre continues to do some of the best character work of his career week after week. His slow descent into darkness has been handled almost perfectly, and Monday’s roller coaster ride was tremendous.

McIntyre came out to congratulate Seth Rollins for winning at WarGames, and then issued a challenge for a World Heavyweight Championship rematch, saying he learned his lesson during their big match at Crown Jewel. The Scottish Warrior said he was putting Jey Uso in the past and was ditching all sympathy in coming after Rollins.

But the moment Rollins told McIntyre that he already was slated to face Uso next week on Raw, Drew lost it and attacked Seth, showing that the madness is continuing and he can’t shake it, and in fact he’s losing control.

Advertisement

Sami Zayn’s attempt to rein McIntyre in was well-intentioned, but Drew instead turned his focus onto Sami for next week. At this stage, McIntyre is just lashing out at anyone in his path, anything perceived as an obstacle, with Jey being a trigger for his rage. While he’s still able to pull it down a notch, there’s coming a point where he’ll cross the Rubicon and go full-fledged heel, and that’s going to be terrifying.

1. ‘I’m Home’

WWE.com

CM Punk’s first promo back in WWE after nearly 10 years is going to be dissected by every analyst, armchair critic and social media influencer out there, but perhaps the most notable thing isn’t just the words he uttered, but the vibe he created.

Punk went pure babyface in his return, talking about how he’s “home” in WWE and how everyone backstage was happy to see him. It was the exact opposite of what fans likely expected from him – and that very well might have been the point.

He told the crowd that the truth was that he was home in WWE, that it’s “where I belong.” He thanked the fans who continued to chant his name and never forgot him. He steered clear of any references to why he actually left and took some gentle swipes at those who might not be happy to see him back because he threatens their spot as the “best.”

The promo delivered the pure babyface vibe it needed to while leaving a lot of leeway for him to go in any number of directions. He can continue as the virtuous, returning hero for a while… until he pulls the rug out from under fans and veers off into a hypocritical heel. Happy-go-lucky Punk is not a real thing.

Advertisement

It’s an intriguing start to this second act in WWE for Punk, especially given how the first chapter ended. Fans wanting a pipebomb were probably confused, while modern WWE fans likely loved him praising the company. But with Punk, things are rarely as simple as the words on the page. People are going to have to read deeper.