7 Ups & 8 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (May 7)

In which SmackDown Live becomes Raw Lite. Thanks, Wild Card Rule...

By Andy H Murray /

WWE.com

Only a complete and utter catastrophe could have prevented SmackDown from claiming brand superiority this week, such was the absolute mess WWE made of Raw's Wild Card episode. Regardless, the blue brand's writers didn't exactly ace it last night. This was a messy show plagued by Wild Card-created problems, and while most of the in-ring action delivered, it's hard to see it as anything other than a net negative in terms of content quality.

Advertisement

Raw invaders were guaranteed after the previous night, and the first two came at the top of the show. AJ Styles and Sami Zayn arrived to challenge for Kofi Kingston's WWE Championship, leading to a crowd-pleasing main event that came together in a similar manner to Raw's Kingston vs. Daniel Bryan clash and hit similar notes in the end.

Elsewhere, Shane McMahon delivered on his promise to name new SmackDown Tag Team Champions following The Hardy Boyz' decision to vacate, and while the belts did find new owners, they were made to work for it. There was no sign of Becky Lynch or Charlotte Flair, but Mandy Rose, Sonya Deville, Carmella, and Ember Moon maintained the women's division's representation with a tag, while Ali and Andrade had what looked like a banger match sabotaged by one of SD's most devious heels.

Advertisement

A sloppy start to life under the Wild Card Rule. Let's hope shows like this don't become the norm...

Downs...

8. No More Repeats

Advertisement

Does repeating the Firefly Fun House segment (again) technically make Bray Wyatt the sixth Raw wrestler to appear on this week's SmackDown, despite the Wild Card Rule?

The reruns need to stop. They hark back to the bad old days when SD was no more than a glorified Raw recap show, as entertaining as these Wyatt bits are.

Advertisement

7. Oh Hey Buddy

Advertisement

Former 205 Live standout Buddy Murphy finally debuted on SmackDown last night... sort of.

Rather than appearing on the broadcast, Buddy challenged Ali, his former Cruiserweight rival, in an untelevised YouTube clip. This presumably went down during a commercial break.

Advertisement

Murphy and Ali always make magic when booked against each other. This means their match will almost certainly rule, but debuting a wrestler via dark segment is a great way to tell the audience that they don't need to care about them. They've done big Buddy dirty here, and while there's every chance he'll get over, not debuting him in the coldest manner imaginable would've been nice.

6. Oh, How We've Missed You?

WWE.com

AJ Styles was the first Raw Superstar to hit this week's SmackDown as part of the Wild Card Rule, with the former WWE Champion's music hitting at the top of the show. Cue: Corey Graves putting over just how much they'd missed having 'The Phenomenal One' on Tuesday nights.

Advertisement

Three weeks. That's how long Styles has been gone for, yet the announcers were putting him over as if he'd been absent for years.

This is a minor complaint, but things like this remove you from the fictional universe WWE are supposed to be maintaining. This is a fantasy world, but it needs to be grounded in reality, and we've barely been given enough time to "miss" AJ for him to be welcomed back in such a manner.

Advertisement

5. Breaking The Rules

WWE.com

WWE broke Vince McMahon's goofy Wild Card Rule on its very first night, with Roman Reigns, Daniel Bryan, Kofi Kingston, Lars Sullivan, Elias, and Shane McMahon all appearing on Raw. The limit is supposed to be four. Even if you discount Shane as an authority figure, five men crossed over. McMahon's "Elias doesn't count lol" explanation doesn't fly, either.

Advertisement

One would assume that WWE would make good on this blunder by actually adhering to the Wild Card last night, but no: the dipsh*ts did it again.

AJ Styles, Sami Zayn, The Miz, and The Usos all appeared on SmackDown. That's five individuals. As the rules and regulations outlined on WWE.com stipulated four individuals, not acts, Jimmy and Jey cannot be considered a singular entity.

Advertisement

What was the point in instigating this dopy rule if they can't stick to it? It was a compromise between Vince McMahon and USA/Fox network officials, yet the Chairman still doesn't know what he's doing with it.

4. Excuses, Excuses...

WWE.com

Make no mistake: Kevin Owens was kept off most of this week's SmackDown because WWE and Vince McMahon don't see him as a star on the same level as Raw's AJ Styles, not because "it's his birthday." This transparency dripped from the first-hour segment in which KO explained his absence.

Advertisement

'The Prizefighter' appeared later in the show, attacking Xavier Woods to distract Kofi Kingston during the main event. Scant contributions from the man who'll challenge for the WWE Championship at Money In The Bank.

Owens was de-prioritised so that WWE could book a filler title defence in a desperate attempt at salvaging this week's TV ratings. That's it. Let's not pretend that this was some kind of compelling one-night story: it was a cynical substitution designed to stop viewers from changing the channel in the second hour, and another example of McMahon's growing anxiety as WWE's viewership circles the drain.

Advertisement

3. Promote Your Matches

Advertisement

Here's a novel idea: perhaps Vince McMahon, the world's most successful wrestling promoter, should try promoting again.

Announcing matches like AJ Styles vs. Sami Zayn vs. Kofi Kingston on the night is fine for a quick crowd pop, but it won't save ratings. It might help the second-hour drop-off, but people who aren't already watching won't hear about the match, meaning it can't be used as a promotional tool.

Advertisement

The same goes for Kofi Kingston vs. Seth Rollins on the Raw after WrestleMania, and this week's main event between Kingston and Daniel Bryan. These were hot-shotted, on-the-night decisions born of desperation, with no planning or foresight. They weren't promoted, but manifested out of nowhere, making it seem like Vince, in his hunger for more, has lost sight of what professional wrestling actually is.

2. A Dull Opener

WWE.com

The participants' four compelling personalities may have carried SmackDown's opening segment on another night, but this week's was p*ss boring.

Advertisement

Nothing makes it seem like WWE programming is going through the motions like a dull revolving door opener. Here, AJ Styles showed up, spat his catchphrases out, and got interrupted by Sami Zayn. The former 'Underdog From The Underground' sh*t on the crowd and Styles' "toxic ego," with AJ resorting to ribbing Sami for "smelling like garbage." It's almost like having Braun Strowman throw the guy in a big wasn't a good idea.

The New Day's arrival came soon after, the chit-chat continued, another bad smell joke came along, and the main event was effectively put together. It ticked that box, but the content itself was unengaging. Nobody stood out on the microphone, nobody said anything interesting, and nobody got their stuff over, making this one of the most skippable curtain-raisers WWE has put together in some time, even if it wasn't as soul-destroying as Raw.

Advertisement

1. Wild Card Problems

WWE.com

Here's the thing about WWE's Wild Card Rule: it stinks.

Advertisement

Vince McMahon clearly threw it together on a whim with no thought for how he'd execute the bloody thing. We saw it with six, not four, wrestlers crossing over from SmackDown to Raw, and five going the opposite way last night, and we haven't even been told who's actually calling the shots on these moves. Is it up to the authority figures to decide? Can the wrestlers just show up on Raw or SD on a whim, with nobody's permission? These things are important and need to be clarified.

What's also clear is that the Wild Card Rule is only going to apply to perceived "stars." Guys like AJ Styles and Roman Reigns are going to appear on both shows most weeks, while midcarders and young hopefuls will be left in the dust. It's a ratings grab, after all.

Advertisement

On top of this, Wild Cards will destroy SmackDown's identity. WWE's red and blue brands felt like different shows not only because they are written by different people, but also because they starred different casts. Now, it's all the same. SD will likely tread circles in a holding pattern until the October TV deal kicks in, with Raw retreads and recaps in abundance, and it's hard not to succumb to cynicism at this point.

Ups...

7. Absolution Overcome

WWE.com

This is a charitable Up. Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville vs. Ember Moon and Carmella finished on this side of the column because it didn't suck. The faintest of praise, but it's enough on a show as mediocre as last night's.

Advertisement

Carmella took the heat early. Sonya nailed her with a Spear for the two, and the heels controlled briefly. This led to Ember Moon's hot tag. 'The Shenom' went nuts, hitting Rose with a cross body for the near-fall, before Sonya ate a dive for her partner, allowing 'God's Greatest Creation' to hit her Bed Of Roses finisher for the win.

The whole thing lasted little over two minutes. Paige arrived with Asuka and Kairi Sane afterwards, announcing that her new charges would face her old allies next week, continuing their ongoing storyline. The Japanese stars could cut through Rose and Deville en route to a Women's Tag Team Title shot, so let's hope it's a decent bout.

Advertisement

6. The Brawl Before The Fall

WWE.com

Shane McMahon stuck around after announcing the Daniel Bryan and Rowan vs. The Usos SmackDown Tag Team Title match. The Money In The Bank briefcases were sat on tables in the ring, and it looked like the former Commissioner had something to get off his chest before The Miz jumped him from behind, brawled him up at the ramp, and ate sh*t moments later.

Advertisement

Bo Dallas and Curtis Axel emerged from the back, laying into their former leader. The number's advantage put Miz down quickly, and with McMahon battering 'The A-Lister' with a steel chair, the babyface was left lying.

While nothing groundbreaking, this segment was a solid continuing of Miz vs. McMahon. Their feud has over-delivered to an almost shocking degree, and having The B-Team as henchmen gives Shane another way to generate heat - one that doesn't involve slapping an old man around. Let's hope their MITB cage match is as much of a fun trainwreck as their WrestleMania 35 encounter was.

Advertisement

5. Outta Nowhere

WWE.com

Andrade and Ali could have had an awesome show-stealing SmackDown match if given the chance last night, but Randy Orton ruining it isn't a problem. This is 'The Viper' in 2019. He's the cold, uncaring WWE lifer the company use to draw heat from workrate-minded fans, and having him sabotage a clash between two internet favourites fits his presentation to a tee.

Advertisement

The action preceding Orton's intervention was strong. Ali and Andrade worked well in their five minutes together, and kept things fast, fresh, and exciting with a classic back-and-forth layout highlighted by pop-worthy spot. The closing seconds saw Andrade hit the top rope, get crotched, and eat a Spanish Fly, before Randy came in, cutting the duo off before they could really move through the gearbox.

Both wrestlers were laid out with RKOs afterwards, with Andrade's coming as he flew threw the air. There's an argument to be made that Orton made them look like goobers here. Regardless, the man's a 13-time World Champion. He should be doing things like this from time to time.

Advertisement

4. Earn It

WWE.com

Your writer was ready to hate whatever Shane McMahon did with the SmackDown Tag Team Championships on last night's show, and already had a Down mapped out in his head. Fortunately, Shane gifting the belts to a pair of heels turned out to be a swerve. Daniel Bryan and Rowan were made to wrestle for the belts instead, and they wound up facing the most dominant tandem in modern SmackDown history.

Advertisement

This was the right move. While handing the straps to a villainous team may have generated cheap heat, it would have further devalued a set of championships that has been stuck in the sh*tter for months. Going all in on said heat may have been the only way of pulling it off, with Shane naming himself and somebody like Elias as champs, but Bryan and Rowan earning their straps was the better choice.

3. World-Class Presentation

Advertisement

Though new SmackDown star Roman Reigns didn't directly appear on last night's show, a well-crafted video package recapping his career up to this point ensured he had a presence - and a strong one at that.

It began with 'The Big Dog' telling the world he hoped his story could inspire others to tread a similar path. We saw shots of him from 2010 to 2014, bleeding into Shield highlights, then Roman winning the 2015 Royal Rumble. From there, Reigns faced Triple H to become WWE Champion in 2016, then beat John Cena the following year, before besting The Undertaker in that WrestleMania 33 bout. The good times ended with his leukaemia diagnosis and ensuing absence, before the package closed with him punching Vince McMahon in the face and announcing SD as his new home.

Advertisement

WWE's video packages always look and feel like gold. This was no different. It was a top-level production for a top-level star, and a break from the kind of presentation that drove fans away from Reigns in the first place, with the crowd's positive reaction highlighting its effectiveness.

2. Save Us, Bryan & Rowan

WWE.com

The bout to claim SmackDown's vacant Tag Team Championships hit all the right notes, with new champions Daniel Bryan and Rowan besting The Usos in a contest typical of their Samoan opponents, who never seem to disappoint between the ropes.

Advertisement

It was an exciting bout throughout, and it peaked at the right moment. Double Superkicks led to an awesome near-fall as Jey's dive took Bryan out and allowed Jimmy to cover Rowan following a splash. This was The Uso's best chance to win. Later, Rowan swatted their double dive, and while the tide turned soon after, the former Bludgeon Brother eventually nailed Jey with the Iron Claw for the victory, with Shane McMahon handing the dark blue straps over.

While some will complain about Bryan being "relegated" to the tag scene so soon after returning, him and Rowan show great promise as a team. They work well together. Rowan, though limited, has always been an effective enforcer, and his bruising style provides a nice contrast to his master's sharp technicality and cunning villainy. They could yet be the duo that saves this paper-thin division from complete destruction.

Advertisement

1. Ticking Every Box

WWE.com

AJ Styles vs. Kofi Kingston vs. Sami Zayn worked on a number of different levels:-

Advertisement

1. From a workrate perspective, this was strong. Three of the best wrestlers in the company were given the freedom to craft something memorable without having to break their backs. A smart layout gave everyone ample opportunities to shine, and all three men got over, including Zayn, the eventual pin-eater.

2. Kofi's ongoing storyline with Kevin Owens was continued when KO attacked Xavier Woods are ringside, distracting the WWE Champion long enough for Zayn to almost steal the win.

Advertisement

3. The right guy won. Kingston shouldn't be losing the belt at this stage. He was never in any real danger here, but successful near-falls made it seem like he was on the brink.

4. WWE have successfully presented Kofi as a credible challenger without sacrificing bouts that could be used to hype pay-per-views later down the line. This is a big one. The promotion was big matches far too often, and while they could have built a B-level show around the Bryan rematch, getting it out of the way on Raw frees the New Day man up for fresher opportunities.

Advertisement

A successful match across the board, then. Let's see if it has any impact on ratings.