7 Ups And 10 Downs From WWE Royal Rumble 2017
A show-stealing title bout, but a Rumble leaving much to be desired.
Show of hands: Who thinks WWE knows right now what all the major matches at WrestleMania are going to be?
After watching the Royal Rumble Sunday night, you might easily be convinced to keep your hand down. WWE had a somewhat open field of top contenders to win the 30th annual Royal Rumble match and delivered what had to be termed an unexpected winner in Randy Orton, a guy who has been in a tag team for the past few months.
Couple that with the decisions to have John Cena win the WWE World Championship, keep the WWE Universal Championship on Kevin Owens (for now), and have Roman Reigns pull double duty – presumably to fans could boo more – and you’ve got some open spots on your booking sheet. Or in the case of Cena/Orton XL, you’ve got a match that is the very opposite of fresh and exciting for Mania.
Despite that, the Royal Rumble PPV delivered a bunch of really good matches, with the Cena/AJ Styles title match giving fans heart palpitations. Charlotte Flair/Bayley also delivered the goods, and Neville’s coronation was a nice moment. The Rumble itself had some good moments, but overall it once again was a disappointment.
With that said, what tossed a bunch of unsuspecting jabronis and what got Santino Marella’d? Let’s get to it…
Downs...
10. Forgetting Recent History
The tagline for this year’s event might be “Remember the Rumble,” but Michael Cole’s memory apparently doesn’t even go back 365 days.
During the Raw Women’s Championship match, Corey Graves made reference to Ric Flair’s 1992 Rumble victory, winning the vacant WWF Championship. Cole immediately piped up, “The only time in Royal Rumble match history that the WWE Championship was up for grabs in the Royal Rumble match.”
There’s only one small problem with that statement: It’s not true. In fact, the WWE Championship was up for grabs at the Rumble last year. Roman Reigns was forced to defend his title at the Rumble and lost when Triple H entered at #30. Little mistakes with misspeaking are easy to forgive, but this one can’t be brushed aside as easily.
9. Why No DQ?
Two weeks ago, Sheamus inadvertently hit a referee, which ultimately cost Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson the Raw Tag Team Championships when their pinfall was waved off in favor of a DQ.
Sunday night, with two refs assigned to the tag title match, Sheamus wound up for a Brogue Kick on Anderson, only for Karl to move and let the ref take the boot. The second ref outside the ring climbed in and let the match continue as if nothing happened. A few moments later, we had new tag champs.
Why didn’t this warrant a DQ again? Wiping out a ref is a DQ, isn’t it? Or does this fall under the inadvertent contact “rule,” so the match continues? (If that’s the case, shouldn’t the previous title bout been the same?)
8. Pinning The Champ
WWE loves to make contenders look strong by having them pin a champion in nontitle matches. It’s their favorite tactic, and it’s aggravating how often they resort to it.
Sunday night, Naomi pinned SmackDown Women’s Champion Alexa Bliss with a split-legged moonsault, winning the six-woman tag match for her team. While it was good to see the returning Naomi get a pinfall – conventional wisdom said that the returning Mickie James would likely get the win – why did it have to be at the champ’s expense?
Bliss already is an undersized, somewhat unlikely champion, and she not only got pinned in a nothing match, she had to be carried out over Natalya’s shoulder. If they wanted to give Naomi a pin, Nattie could have taken it, maybe after a cheap shot from Nikki Bella to further that rivalry. Naomi could have said that that PPV victory justified a title shot.
7. Where Were The Surprises?
Putting Tye Dillinger aside, who were the unknowns in the Rumble? Who wasn’t already on the main roster?
The answer would be “no one.” All 29 other men entering the Rumble were on the main rosters of Raw, SmackDown or 205 Live. No one had been on the shelf with an injury for a long period and made a surprise return. No one had been absent from TV for a long period and was a total shock.
It was just a huge disappointment, especially with the rumors flowing about Samoa Joe debuting or Finn Balor coming back from injury. No one else from NXT arrived. No legends showed up. No one on the sidelines got back in the game.
That can be all well and fine if the Rumble itself is well-planned and well-paced. When it’s not…
6. Jericho Dismissed Unceremoniously
So Chris Jericho enters the Rumble at #2, hangs around until #30 comes out, and he gets knocked out by Roman Reigns fourth to last.
What. The. Actual. Hell.
The moment Kevin Owens retained his WWE Universal Championship, it felt like WWE was planning on Jericho winning the Rumble (finally) to give us best friends colliding at WrestleMania. At worst, Jericho would be in the very end fighting to a dramatic finish.
Instead, Y2J was knocked off the turnbuckle to the floor to end his hourlong run in the Rumble. No drama, no confrontation. Just a Superman Punch and his night was over. Yes, fans can’t always get what they want, but this is this writer’s list, and Jericho being eliminated like that was a dumb move.
5. Reigns As Superman
A frogsplash through a table. Brass knuckles. Chairshots. A Stone Cold Stunner.
None of that could put Roman Reigns down for the count. He kept kicking out and coming back, when any of those individual moves would have won a normal match. Finally, it took Braun Strowman to come down and demolish Reigns as payback for two previous spears to end Roman’s night.
Look, heroes have to put in a superhuman effort every now and again. And kicking out of almost any one of those moves is understandable in a big match. But when Reigns kicked out of a Stunner in Texas, then it just got silly. Maybe if the fans were buying it, but the reaction was more of a, “Is he seriously kicking out?” as opposed to excitement.
That’s to say nothing about what happened later.
4. Part-Timers Rule Temporarily
We all knew going into the Rumble that Goldberg, Brock Lesnar and Undertaker were participating in the Royal Rumble this year. And while it was welcomed by many as adding star power to the match, there was always one concern: that they would all pile up at the end of the match.
And that’s exactly what happened. Lesnar came out at #26, Goldberg at #28 and Taker at #29. They spent about a total of 10 minutes combined in the Rumble match and eliminated 10 men combined. And none of them were there at the end of the match.
It was a very strange use of all three men. Lesnar was barely in there long enough for the smoke from his pyro to dissipate. And of course, everyone else not named Roman Reigns in the match was just a geek for the three to maul. Even Randy Orton got F5’d like he was a nobody.
It’s tough to call these three men being in the Rumble a negative, but given the poor pacing throughout the match, it just made their appearances rougher than if things had flowed better.
3. Lengthy Logjam
Whoever booked the Royal Rumble this year clearly forgot about one important feature: avoiding dead space.
From the moment Braun Strowman was eliminated, more than 16 minutes passed before the next elimination. By that time, the ring was full with 13 wrestlers: New Day, Sheamus & Cesaro, Sami Zayn, Rusev, Dean Ambrose, Baron Corbin, Miz, Chris Jericho, Bray Wyatt and Apollo Crews. It was a ridiculously boring period of the match, with very little (if anything) happening and no one standing out.
This is something a smartly booked Rumble avoids like the plague. You let the ring fill up with five or six wrestlers and send someone out who tosses half the field (like Braun Strowman did at #7). What you can’t do is have 10 or 12 guys lying in the corner or on the ropes waiting for the next wrestler to enter the match.
Just an almost unforgivable error after 30 years of Rumbles.
2. Roman’s Unwelcome Return
Wow, WWE will not rest until Roman Reigns is officially The Man in the company, right?
After receiving an overall negative reaction during his WWE Universal Championship match (which he lost) Reigns made a splash as the #30 entrant into the Rumble – and the fans booed it pretty well. He immediately squared off against the Undertaker, with the Deadman clearly the favorite. So when Roman tossed Taker from the Rumble, let’s just say he wasn’t given a tickertape parade.
If WWE is planning on turning Reigns heel and having his attitude reflect that, then this booking could be forgivable. But as it stands we were treated to Roman showing up twice on PPV and very nearly winning the Rumble for the second time in three years. (Not-so-fun fact: Reigns has now been in four straight final fours.)
It’s a mind-boggling decision that simply doesn’t reflect the fans’ reaction. And wanna bet that he’s still in the conversation to get a title match at WrestleMania, if he doesn’t face Undertaker after eliminating him?
1. Orton? Seriously?
Are we seriously going to do John Cena versus Randy Orton for the WWE World Championship at WrestleMania?
For the record, Cena and Orton have faced each other for a world title on PPV 20 times in the past 10 years. And the last couple times, the fans mercilessly turned on the bouts and booed nonstop because they’ve seen this match far too often.
But Orton won his second Royal Rumble Sunday night, while Cena won his 16th world title, so it looks like both men are on a collision course for WrestleMania. What makes this Orton victory even worse is that there were so many interesting angles they could have explored: Chris Jericho facing best friend Kevin Owens; Undertaker finally facing Cena; Goldberg getting a title match; Samoa Joe debuting and facing AJ Styles or Owens.
Orton versus Cena (if it holds) will die a horrible death in front of 70,000+ fans in April simply because it’s been done so many times before.
Ups...
7. International Tag Stars Wins Tag Gold
For all the praise that the announcers have been bestowing on Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson, if they hadn’t won the Raw Tag Team Championships Sunday night, it might have been time for them to pack their bags and head back to New Japan.
Gallows & Anderson managed to capture the tag titles, their first WWE gold, by defeating the guys who ended the New Day’s record-setting title reign, Sheamus & Cesaro. The makeshift duo had begun gelling well in recent months, but you couldn’t really view them as much more than placeholders. They were a pretty decent team, but both are established singles stars, and it was time for one of the more established tag teams to win the straps.
Here’s hoping that Gallows & Anderson can live up to the billing they’ve been given and infuse some life into the tag division. If nothing else, we’ll give them finally winning tag gold a thumbs up.
6. A Logical Loss
After being beaten up and having her knee wrenched in recent weeks, there’s no way Sasha Banks was at 100% heading into her match against Nia Jax at the Royal Rumble.
So it should have been no surprise that Jax toppled The Boss without much trouble Sunday night. Sasha was fighting on one leg and wasn’t able to get things going. Couple that with the fact that Jax hasn’t been pinned in WWE and has been dominant since being called up to the main roster and you have a recipe for a Nia victory.
How WWE handles it from here is important. If Sasha (in storyline) works to get herself healthy and comes up with a gameplan stop the unstoppable Jax, then it could make for a good Mania match. That’s where this assumption is coming from, and we’ll stick with it until proven otherwise.
5. A Perfect 10
There wasn’t a ton to cheer in this year’s Royal Rumble, but thankfully WWE got one thing right.
Fans started chanting it as the countdown wound down, and when Tye Dillinger’s music hit at #10, the Alamo Dome erupted. As many had hoped, the Perfect 10 entered the Rumble at #10. Tye squared off against Braun Strowman, but fortunately wasn’t eliminated right away. He lasted about six minutes before Braun tossed him.
This appearance wasn’t about how many people could Dillinger eliminate or whether he’d make a flashy show in the ring. This simply was about Tye making it and WWE not blowing a fun moment for fans. It was an easy win-win, and the company made it happen.
4. Strowman Gets The Diesel Push
As predicted, Braun Strowman was a force to be reckoned with in the Royal Rumble. And he did not disappoint.
During his run, Strowman eliminated seven men: Mojo Rawley, Big Cass, Kalisto, Mark Henry, Big Show, James Ellsworth and Tye Dillinger. He was completely dominant during his 12-minute run, and it took everyone – Sami Zayn, Dean Ambrose and Baron Corbin – ganging up on him to soften him up and toss him.
Sure, Strowman was long gone before the heavy hitters arrived in the late 20s, but he had a nice run early in the match to establish himself even more as a force.
3. Neville Is Crowned Champ
The journey of the four-month-old cruiserweight division has been a checkered one, with no one really catching on as champ, and the division flailing at times. Short matches that don’t reflect what the wrestlers can do in the ring haven’t helped matters.
But Sunday, Neville and Rich Swann got a little time to put together a pretty decent match, with the two starting slowly but building to them trading wicked kicks and some highspots. It all was capped off with Neville, the most recognizable superstar in the division, capturing the WWE Cruiserweight Championship. It helped that the match itself was more involved and complete than the typical bout we’ve gotten on Raw.
Neville’s new heel persona had instantly made him 100 times more interesting and instantly unlikable, and as a result, he deserves a run with the title to see if that can spark something with the division.
2. Charlotte Shows Her Superiority
The running storyline for the past month has been that Charlotte Flair is wrestling royalty, while Bayley is merely a fan living out her dream and has no right challenging the Queen for her Raw Women’s Championship.
While we all know that’s pretty far-fetched (Charlotte’s lost her title three times), it still works with an underdog fan favorite like Bayley. And so, when Charlotte won a hard-fought title bout Sunday night cleanly, it followed the storyline perfectly. Sure, she could have relied on Dana Brooke, or her feet on the ropes or some chicanery like that and things would have still worked.
But having Charlotte win clean allows her to repeat the mantra that Bayley isn’t in her league, and it lets the Huggable One doubt herself, maybe have to earn another title match at WrestleMania, where she would get one last shot to shut Charlotte up and prove her wrong.
It writes itself quite nicely, doesn’t it?
1. Cena And Styles Steal The Show
If you were wondering whether John Cena and AJ Styles could follow up their instant classic from SummerSlam last year, the answer is a resounding “YES!”
Cena and Styles went toe to toe in a battle that featured both men breaking out home run maneuvers, at one point trading submission holds back and forth: Calf Crusher to STF to STF to Figure Four to cross armbreaker. Both men hit their finishers multiple times but were unable to hold their opponent down for three.
In the end, it took Cena hitting two AAs in rapid succession to get the pin after an Avalanche AA failed to do the job. There are going to be plenty of people who say that Cena shouldn’t have gotten his 16th world title reign, that it cuts AJ’s legs out from under him. But Styles clearly showed he’s got the goods, and as long as he isn’t booked like a goof for the next few months, then it’ll all be moot.
Also, kudos for Charles Robinson, aka Little Naitch, being the referee to present Cena with his title, tying him with Ric Flair for the record number of reigns.