7 Ups And 3 Downs For NXT TakeOver XXV

Another solid show from the black & gold brand with a barn-burner main event.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE

NXT’s track record when it comes to its TakeOver specials has been fairly consistent – they almost always deliver a hellacious, simply entertaining wrestling show. It’s everything WWE’s over-produced spectacles aren’t.

Advertisement

Saturday’s TakeOver XXV was billed as a landmark show, five years into the WWE Network era, the 25th NXT special, a phenomenon that has grown from small shows at Full Sail into these arena shows that often upstage the main roster’s PPVs several times a year. The matches become instant classics, and the shows generate so many of them that it’s hard to keep track of them all.

TakeOver XXV was a solid show, featuring the traditional five matches, three of which delivered as promised and two that fell a little short, but still were better than what you’d see on any typical B-show PPV these days. We saw new champions crowned, a returning NXT star, and just some generally really good wrestling. And all of it clocked in at less than three hours. What else could you want?

Advertisement

As with most TakeOvers, this is a pretty easy one to watch and enjoy, but NXT did manage to botch a couple things, most notably the Women’s Championship match. Someone is going to need to explain the logic there.

With that said, let’s get to it…

Advertisement

Downs…

3. Shots Fired

WWE Network

Ooooh, look at WWE! They’re being edgy!

Advertisement

First Sami Zayn name-dropped “AEW” and there are conflicting reports about whether it was scripted, or whether Vince McMahon was pissed. Then on Saturday, Nigel McGuinness opened TakeOver by declaring that the black & gold brand is the “true alternative in sports entertainment.”

That’s an indirect reference to AEW, which has billed itself oftentimes not as competition to WWE, but an alternative to the wrestling juggernaut. There really wasn’t much doubt that Nigel’s comment was meant to be a jab at AEW thinking it could position itself as a change of pace for WWE fans, when the company has its own change-of-pace brand in NXT.

Advertisement

Regardless, it’s just dumb. If you’re going to go to war and call out the competition, do it. But at the same time, it’s a little hollow when it comes in the midst of a creatively bankrupt period for WWE and just after a devastating podcast interview with Jon Moxley eviscerated the company’s creative process.

Maybe just focus on improving your own main roster product before taking jabs at opponents?

Advertisement

2. Ryker Detracts From Ladder Match

WWE

Let’s put aside questioning what WWE/NXT sees in Jaxson Ryker for a second and discuss his role in the NXT Tag Team Championship ladder match.

Advertisement

It was a safe bet that Ryker was going to play some role in the bout, but when he came out and ran over everyone in the match – six men! – without selling a single thing, it was ridiculous. It took all six to recover and beat him down to knock him out of the match, and even then, he barely sold the beating. This lasted way too long and ultimately did nothing other than slow down the entire match.

Besides that, Ryker has had eight televised matches since last summer, despite two years in NXT. He’s big, muscular and intense, but that’s about it. Maybe someone out there can shed some light on why he’s out there no-selling beatings from people and acting like he’s nearly invincible.

Advertisement

Regardless, his involvement in the ladder match did not help it at all.

Advertisement

1. Pull The Trigger Already

WWE

What is the NXT braintrust waiting for with the NXT Women’s Championship?

Advertisement

Shayna Baszler is in the midst of her second run with the title, and multiple times now, it’s looked like time for her reign to end, only for it to continue. Although broken up by a 10-week reign by Kairi Sane, Baszler has held the title for nearly a full year, dating back to WrestleMania weekend last year.

At TakeOver XXV, it looked like Io Shirai was poised to live up to the hype that followed her into NXT from Japan, but as has happened numerous times at recent TakeOvers, she tapped out to the Kirifuda Clutch after Shayna’s talentless Horsewomen came down for a distraction. (Though this time, Shirai was foolishly more distracted by Candice LeRae taking out Marina Shafir and Jessamyn Duke than anything else.)

Advertisement

At this point, the question has to be what their plans are with Baszler and the women’s division. When Asuka held the title for 500+ days, the division was low on star power and she was the biggest star on the roster. Today, LeRae, Deonna Purrazzo and Mia Yim are all capable contenders.

Advertisement

Baszler is 38. Either WWE is gonna call her up to the main roster or they aren’t. She’s a solid wrestler and can contribute wherever she is, but this just doesn’t make sense at this point.

Ups…

7. Welcome Back, Prince Pretty

WWE

It’s safe to say that Tyler Breeze wasn’t going anywhere on the main roster, especially when you consider his last singles match on Raw came in December. Before that, October, and before that, August.

Advertisement

So while it might seem like a demotion to send Breeze back to NXT after nearly four years on the main roster, anything where he got to actually wrestle had to be an upgrade.

And Prince Pretty showed that he’s still more than capable of having a good match, battling Velveteen Dream in a solid bout for the NXT North American Championship. Dream would retain his title, but Breeze hopefully reminded WWE brass that he’s not just a warm body on the roster.

Advertisement

Of course, it’s probably best he spend some time in Florida until there’s evidence he’ll be treated better on the main shows.

6. Video Packages Continue To Shine

Advertisement

No matter how bad the writing is across the main roster, one thing you can almost always count on is that the video packages will be strong. The same applies to NXT's video production unit.

Three videos really stood out at TakeOver XXV: the opening recap of all the previous TakeOvers, Velveteen Dream’s send-up of Tyler Breeze’s failed run on the main roster, and the NXT Championship match between Johnny Gargano and Adam Cole.

Advertisement

The rundown of the previous 24 TakeOvers made you realize how far the brand has come in just five years. From hosting “special events” at Full Sail to selling out arenas, now they’ve got the formula down pat where you can almost guarantee TakeOver will be at worst enjoyable, at best an instant classic.

These videos do a great job of tying rivalries up with a bow for fans who don’t catch NXT TV each week, and when done well, they can make even a basic feud look heated. It’s good to know this hasn’t fallen off.

Advertisement

5. Sultans Of Swag Triumph

WWE

You can’t help but want to celebrate a little with the Street Profits after they captured the NXT Tag Team Championships Saturday night.

Advertisement

The duo has toiled away as a popular but under-utilized team for two years, never rising to the level of tag title threat. In fact, this was their first TakeOver match as a team. For Angelo Dawkins, the wait had to be even more unbearable, as he’s been competing on NXT TV in 2012, one of the original black & gold superstars. He’s seen dozens of wrestlers come in with and after him and go on to become champions in WWE while he’s remained in Florida.

But that all changed at TakeOver, with Dawkins and the hyper-athletic Montez Ford (who springboarded to the ladder to retrieve the titles) getting the fans behind them, capturing the belts and then celebrating in the crowd.

Advertisement

Just a good moment that deserved its own item.

Advertisement

4. Strong, Riddle Throw Down

WWE

It was kind of a foregone conclusion that Roderick Strong and Matt Riddle would have a hard-hitting, rapid-striking matchup at TakeOver.

Advertisement

But the two opened the show with a match that left you wondering how either man had all their teeth intact afterward. Strong repeatedly unloaded on Riddle, whose “injured” back was the story of the match. The Original Bro kept coming back, at one point hitting a Go to Sleep/German suplex combo that would have been fine as the finisher.

Strong would counter later by getting his knees up on a Floating Bro and quickly hitting a gutbuster and Tiger Bomb for two, then immediately turning it into a Strong Hold. But in the end, Riddle gutted it out, which makes a ton of sense since he’s likely being positioned as a future NXT Championship threat.

Advertisement

But man, what a fantastic opener.

Advertisement

3. Ladder Match Chaos

WWE

Just when you think you’ve seen every spot you possibly can see in a ladder match, NXT goes and puts on a match with scores of new ones.

Advertisement

The Undisputed Era, Street Profits, Forgotten Sons and Oney Lorcan & Danny Burch had a full-speed, brutal ladder match for the vacant NXT Tag Team Championships that WWE’s main roster wishes it could pull off regularly.

There were a ton of moments that were praiseworthy, so here's just a few: Kyle O’Reilly and Bobby Fish hit an elevated spike DDT on Montez Ford, then transitioned into a German suplex onto a ladder; Wesley Blake powerbombed O’Reilly into an upright ladder to knock it and Fish over; Ford hurdled a ladder to hit a dive to the floor onto Jaxson Ryker; Forgotten Sons got lifted off a ladder and taken out from electric chair positions.

Advertisement

Everyone had moments to shine in this match. While the Forgotten Sons are often disregarded (and sometimes rightfully so), even they didn’t look out of place in this match.

2. Johnny TakeOver Delivers Again

WWE

What else can you say about Johnny Gargano beyond how incredible he is in the ring?

Advertisement

Gargano and Adam Cole put together a second straight TakeOver main event title match that stole the show, proving that Johnny has earned every nickname he has. It was Gargano’s 14th TakeOver, which is really crazy to think about.

And it gets even crazier when you realize the matches he’s had at those 14 TakeOvers: tag title battles against The Revival and Authors of Pain; wars with Tommaso Ciampa, fights with Andrade Almas; and now NXT Championship classics against Adam Cole.

Advertisement

It’s unclear whether this marks the end of Gargano’s run in NXT – he was originally going to be called up to the main roster, as he and Ciampa showed up at the same time as Ricochet and Aleister Black – but if this is his swansong, it’s as good as it gets.

1. Adam Cole Finally Draped In Gold

WWE

For a while now, we’ve heard Adam Cole talk about how the Undisputed Era was going to be “draped in gold” in 2019. Five months in, and nothing.

Advertisement

That changed Saturday night at TakeOver XXV, when Cole made good on his promise, capturing the NXT Championship (fairly) cleanly by defeating Johnny Gargano. This kind of needed to happen, as Cole had been promising for months and months that Undisputed Era was going to run roughshod over NXT, but spent more time teasing a breakup than actually doing anything else. If they were going to be a serious stable, they needed to win at least one of the major matches Saturday.

Advertisement

As NXT champ, Cole can now back up his promos by holding up the title. It’ll be interesting to see if Roderick Strong targets the North American Championship, or if Kyle O’Reilly and Bobby Fish go for the tag titles in the coming weeks.