7 Ups And 3 Downs From NXT TakeOver: New York

Black-and-gold brand continues raising the bar.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE

Holy hell.

Advertisement

Dear WrestleMania 35, good luck following TakeOver. Try not to screw it up with 150 angles and video packages. NXT’s latest offering gave fans plenty to stand up and cheer about, and many certainly did.

Friday’s card featured five title bouts, as every regular NXT title, as well as the WWE United Kingdom Championship, was up for grabs. We ended up with a memorable show that set the bar extremely high, with the NXT Championship match once again leaving everyone shocked.

Advertisement

We also saw the modern-day Vikings, the War Raiders, square off against the hottest tag team in WWE, Ricochet and Aleister Black. Velveteen Dream defended his North American Championship against the up-and-coming Matt Riddle. Shayna Baszler faced three challengers for her women’s title. And Pete Dunne put his UK strap on the line against WALTER.

If that doesn’t fire you up as a fan, then you better check your pulse.

Advertisement

So with that said, let’s find out what charged ahead into battle, ready to conquer, and what came back, fallen on its shield. Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

3. Barefoot Warrior

WWE

This might seem like a strange “down,” but this really is the first chance this writer has had to lodge this complaint.

Advertisement

Watching Matt Riddle compete barefoot just makes you cringe a little. He doesn’t even tape his ankles, as Rusev did.

Oh, did you forget that Rusev used to compete barefoot too? He fractured his foot after a year on the main roster and missed more than a month of action. It’s hard not to think that at some point, Riddle is going to jam his foot or do some damage that would have been avoided if he were wearing boots.

Advertisement

Even from a wrestling world perspective, it doesn’t make sense. We saw Velveteen Dream simply stomp Riddle’s bare foot to injure him, and Mauro Ranallo noted that competing barefoot makes it easier for your opponent to lock in an ankle lock.

Cool look, but it just doesn’t seem to make much sense from either perspective.

Advertisement

2. Women Underperform

WWE

It’s a tough call when you consider what qualified as a passable women’s match just a few years ago, but Friday’s NXT Women’s Championship match was a disappointment.

Advertisement

The fatal four-way bout between champ Shayna Baszler, Kairi Sane, Io Shirai and Bianca Belair had a good amount of action, but it was very disjointed and felt more like just a series of moves. Yes, there was the undercurrent of Io and Kairi teaming up and then squaring off, and everyone hit their finishers on Shayna, but other than that, it fell flat.

It’s a shame, because we’ve seen Baszler have a few really good title defenses, but this certainly was not one of them. If you’re going to skip one match from TakeOver, this is it. It’s perfectly watchable, but it doesn’t match up to the other four, or even past NXT Women’s Championship bouts.

Advertisement

1. Baszler Again?

WWE

Umm, what?

Advertisement

Fans know that on the Raw and SmackDown after WrestleMania, we typically see several superstars get called up to the main roster. One of those NXT wrestlers many expect to move up is the current Women’s Champion Shayna Baszler. The Queen of Spades has been part of NXT for nearly two years now, and she’s improved significantly since her debut.

While she might still be new to the game and have a bit to learn, Baszler is also 38 and could fill a gap if Ronda Rousey does indeed leave after WM 35. It seems counter-intuitive to have Shayna retain the title and keep her in NXT longer at this stage.

Advertisement

Besides that, Baszler has beaten nearly everyone, so unless someone is coming along to dethrone her, this was the easiest way to get the title off her without having someone beat her directly.

Just a confusing decision all-around.

Advertisement

UPS…

7. Dunne’s Record-Setting Reign

WWE

Let this number sink in: 685 days.

Advertisement

That’s how long Pete Dunne held the WWE UK Championship. And while you could make excuses for how in the beginning, there were no challengers and no NXT UK brand, the simple fact is that Dunne was out there wrestling and defending that title for nearly two years.

His reign was the longest in WWE in 30 years. There are only five title reigns that have been longer (all WWE Championship). Dunne has long since surpassed Brock Lesnar and Asuka. That is not insignificant by any means.

Advertisement

You’ve got to wonder what’s next for Dunne. Does he remain in NXT UK, where only a small fraction of WWE’s global audience will see him? Or could he possibly move to the main rosters stateside?

Advertisement

Time will tell…

6. R-E-S-P-E-C-T

WWE Network

Let’s give some kudos to the wrestlers giving kudos to each other.

Advertisement

Not every match was a blood feud between mortal enemies, so it was quite alright for competitors to acknowledge each other’s performance afterward. In this case, we saw the first two matches end with that mutual respect.

War Raiders and Ricochet & Aleister Black shared a series of hugs and bows to each other, which was both an acknowledgement of how hard both teams fought, but also that Black & Ricochet had fought their last battle in NXT. The duo then drank in the cheers from 15,000+ afterward.

Advertisement

Surprisingly, Matt Riddle and Velveteen Dream shared a fist bump after their North American Championship match, but only after Dream teased rejection.

It doesn’t always happen – and it shouldn’t – but when it does and is appropriate, a sign of respect is often a nice little touch.

Advertisement

5. Dream, Riddle Ramp Up The Aggression

WWE

About five minutes into the North American Championship match, it was looking like Matt Riddle and Velveteen Dream just weren’t clicking. They were somewhat slowly going through the paces, trading some moves, but something felt off.

Advertisement

Then, they suddenly took off and delivered a fantastic bout, another in a long stretch for the Dream. Riddle heeled it up a decent bit, kicking Velveteen while he was in the ropes and dominating for much of the match with vicious strikes and submission holds.

But Dream kept coming back, even Hulking up at one point to put the Original Bro on the defensive. Still, Riddle seemed to have his number, until Velveteen escaped the Bro-mission and rolled him up to hand Riddle his first loss in NXT.

Advertisement

Solid match, and the Dream lives on.

4. Dunne, WALTER Deliver STRONG Match

WWE

Given all the hype that has surrounded WALTER, he had a lot to live up to since his NXT UK debut three months ago.

Advertisement

And he and WWE UK Champion Pete Dunne put together a hard-hitting match that played to both men’s strengths. Dunne, nicknamed the Bruiserweight, was just that, bull-rushing ahead against the bigger WALTER, but using a lot of small joint manipulation to gain the upper hand and stay in the match.

Meanwhile, WALTER just painted Dunne’s chest with chops. He also threw some impressive suplexes and slams, and he matched Dunne’s viciousness. But it was fun to watch the undersized champion constantly go back to the well of grabbing a finger or two and bending it like crazy, trying to compensate for his lack of size by bringing WALTER down to his level.

Advertisement

In the end, Dunne couldn’t overcome his bigger opponent and his 685-day UK Championship reign finally ended.

3. Tag Title War Breaks Out

WWE

What’s not to like about the NXT Tag Team Championship match between War Raiders and Ricochet & Aleister Black?

Advertisement

The bout featured a game of “Can you top this?” between the two teams, with Hanson and Ricochet trading high-flying moves – at one point, Ricochet’s handspring back elbow missed, only for Hanson’s to connect – and everyone going 100kph with knee strikes, dives and slams.

Despite it being their NXT swansong, Ricochet & Black came close enough that no one would have been surprised if the 2019 Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic winners pulled it off. But it wasn’t to be, and there was no shame in the challengers losing, as they had clearly been in a war.

Advertisement

Watch this match and try to find a point where they downshifted into second gear.

2. Johnny Champion Arrives

WWE

Oh NXT, you love to play with our emotions and get our heart rates racing.

Advertisement

Fans have been waiting for what feels like forever to see Johnny Gargano hoist the NXT Championship above his head, and everyone thought that Friday night had to be the night. So after getting the first two falls of the 2/3 falls match out of the way, it was just a matter of time before Johnny Wrestling did the inevitable.

Only… it didn’t quite go like that. Adam Cole kept abusing Gargano with superkicks and Last Shots, only for Johnny to kick out time and time again. When Gargano kicked out of a Canadian Destroyer, fans lost it. But when Undisputed Era got involved and Cole then hit a Last Shot, fans became unglued.

Advertisement

But somehow, Gargano recovered enough to take out the Undisputed Era and lock in the GargaNO Escape for the win and the title.

It was a surreal moment that summarized everything that’s great about NXT and everything that’s wrong with WWE. Just a phenomenal ending.

Advertisement

1. Best PPV Ever?

WWE

It’s going to be really, really hard to top NXT TakeOver: New York, not just this weekend, but in the history of wrestling PPVs.

Advertisement

Consider that the worst match of the show, the NXT Women’s Championship fatal four-way match, wasn’t even a bad match. It just didn’t click really well or wow the crowd. This wasn’t Alicia Fox versus Melina.

Also, consider that each of the other four matches were fantastic title bouts that saw two new champs crowned and over-delivered on match quality. The opening tag title bout was an all-out war, while the North American Championship got a signature bout, and the UK Championship match represented a changing of the guard.

Advertisement

And of course, the NXT Championship match was a fantastic display of crowd manipulation, as fans repeatedly lost their collective minds at all the false finishes.

Just a fantastic show that will be remembered fondly going forward.

Advertisement