7 Ups And 4 Downs From WWE Extreme Rules 2022
WWE lets him in while wrestlers get extreme in Philly.
How do you rate a premium live event where the highs were pretty high, but the lows were lower than usual? That rollercoaster of an event certainly makes for a very tough grade for WWE Extreme Rules.
WWE delivered a massive return Saturday night, meeting and even exceeding expectations after a fantastic viral program that captivated fans online for weeks as they dissected clues to determine who was coming and when. Most matches were good or produced good results, even if the bouts themselves were lacking. The donnybrook match was a fantastic piece of business that let six men just batter the hell out of each other for 15 minutes.
But Extreme Rules also saw a match where pepper spray was used in the finish. A title match was embarrassingly bad, and no amount of smoke and mirrors could cover for it. And a match featuring a Hall-of-Famer was a long, drawn-out affair that went well beyond the tolerance limit for time and then turned into Run-In City – which actually is what partially saved it.
Overall, you’ve got to award Extreme Rules passing marks, but it wasn’t a home run of a show. It did deliver in several areas, and it will be remembered well for the final five minutes. But it won’t contend for PPV/PLE of the year.
Let’s get to it…
Downs...
4. Pepper Spray Finish Is… A Choice
It’s safe to say that Karrion Kross needed to win his strap match against Drew McIntyre at Extreme Rules. A loss in his first major feud would put this main roster run at just a half-step above his last one, where he lost to Jeff Hardy in his first match.
But winning the match because his valet saved him from a Claymore and used pepper spray to blind McIntyre? No buys.
Seriously, what a terrible booking decision. McIntyre came into the match with an injured shoulder, which Kross exploited. It would have been perfectly acceptable to lose fairly cleanly in that situation. Instead, Drew had the match all but won when Scarlett jumped in the way and sprayed him, allowing Karrion to hit the Kross-hairs for the win.
That’s not a helpful win, and it didn’t go over terribly well with the live audience either. It’s not necessarily a horribly damaging win for Kross, but it was still not the most productive either.
3. Weapons Can’t Mask Bad Match
You never want to be too critical of wrestlers who are going out there and putting their bodies on the line, especially when they’re wailing on each other with weapons.
But the SmackDown Women’s Championship match between Liv Morgan and Ronda Rousey was a disappointment, a messy affair that tried to build drama but was undone by several awkward moments and pauses that took you out of the match.
Rousey toyed with Morgan throughout, but Liv finally got the upper hand with the help of a baseball bat, fire extinguisher, chair and a senton through a table. Ronda used the bat herself, but consistently went back to submission attempts, including a clunky finish where she struggled to hook in a biceps crusher to make Morgan pass out.
Right outcome, but it took too long to get there and stumbled along the way.
2. It Keeps Going And Going And Going…
We’ll get to the last five minutes of the I Quit match in a bit, but holy hell, what a snoozefest the first 25 minutes were.
Edge and Finn Balor brawled all over the arena, into the stands and back to ringside, with the story clearly being that Edge would not submit no matter how much physical damage was inflicted upon him.
The problem is, that story took forever to tell. It moved so slowly and just dragged. The crowd was all but lost for much of this part of the bout. Asking whether Edge quit after a slingblade on the floor was a bit silly, and stuff like that only helped grind it to a halt.
So yeah, we’ll give kudos later, but if they had lopped about 10 minutes off the first part, this would have been much better. Instead, we’ve got to deduct some points here.
1. Padding Out Matches
One of the biggest complaints about Raw these days is that despite it being worlds better than it had been just two months ago, matches feel like they go on about 5-10 minutes longer than they should have, as if they miss their climax and keep going.
In reality, this is likely because Raw is three hours, so you need to fill that time somehow, and Triple H prefers to just pad out matches a few minutes to close that time gap. That’s what Extreme Rules felt like Saturday night, as six matches and Bray Wyatt’s return stretched over the length of three hours.
Looking at match times, it’s clear they could have shaved time of nearly every match and improved the overall feel of each one, as even the good ones felt like they could have been tightened up a bit. Hack about 10-12 minutes off the I Quit match and it’s much better. Trim 2-3 minutes off the ladder match and it sings. Lop 3-4 minutes off the SmackDown Women’s Championship match and save us all from that poor bout.
Looking at all of that, you could have booked a seventh match – maybe a tag team #1 contender’s match or a Women’s Tag Team Championship match – and that would have used that extra time to get a few more wrestlers some screentime.
Time management has been a consistent concern, and it’s starting to become more noticeable when you find yourself wondering when a match is going to end.
Ups...
7. Gritty Gets Revenge On Miz
The Miz/Dexter Lumis story is trending toward spoiled milk (past its expiration date), but they managed to salvage it for one night by getting gritty.
Sorry, getting Gritty. That would be Gritty, the Philadelphia Flyers’ mascot, who has become something of a cult icon in the region (where this writer resides).
Miz encountered Gritty backstage several times, trying to give him a T-shirt, only for Miz to throw it down and stomp it. Miz finally tired of Gritty’s antics and slugged him down, only for Dexter Lumis to appear behind him (completely blowing up the expectation that he would be in the costume) and choke him out. This allowed Gritty to recover and lay in the boots to Miz before walking off with Dexter.
It was just good fun backstage with a popular mascot and made Miz look like more of a jerk than usual. At least he was a clear heel here.
6. Rousey The Right Call
Disappointing match aside, WWE got it right Saturday night with Ronda Rousey defeating Liv Morgan to recapture the SmackDown Women’s Championship.
Rousey lost the title at Money in the Bank when Morgan cashed in her just-won MITB briefcase, then controversial lost a rematch at SummerSlam. A third loss would have been unfathomable for Ronda and her character and would have spelled trouble for her.
Winning the match and the title puts Rousey back on a path as the top woman heading into the fall and winter… and WrestleMania season. It might seem a bit silly to think like that, but you’re really just over three months away from the Royal Rumble, when a Becky Lynch Rumble win would put her on a collision course with Ronda.
That’s fantasy booking, but it’s really not that far-fetched. And it wouldn’t have been possible if Rousey had lost at Extreme Rules.
5. And Still… The EST
Conventional wisdom would have said that Bayley should have won the Raw Women’s Championship at Extreme Rules. She had the numbers and experience edge, and Damage CTRL would have benefited greatly from the increased momentum.
But Bianca Belair is just so freaking incredible of a champion that she made overcoming the odds and retaining her title make perfect sense and feel like the right call.
Belair and Bayley had a tremendous first-ever ladder match for the Raw women’s title, making what could have been a dull retread of countless other ladder matches feel more dramatic and impactful without resorting to too much gaga. Belair kept trying to climb to retain her title, while Bayley connived and plotted with the ladders. Bianca hitting a double KOD on Dakota Kai and Iyo Sky was a great moment.
And while it’s disappointing Bayley came up short, you can’t deny the quality of the match and just how strong Belair has been as champ. Her reign continuing can’t be anything but a positive.
4. Riddle Gets His Revenge
Had Matt Riddle lost the Fight Pit match at Extreme Rules, you’d have to believe that his push as a top-level guy would be over. You can’t call your shot in a match that heavily favors you after being beat down by the heel nonstop and then lose.
Thankfully for Riddle, he managed to submit Seth Rollins after a different kind of extreme match. There never had been a Fight Pit match on the main roster, and only two in NXT history. Turning this personal feud loose inside a steel structure where there was no escape and no pinfalls was a pretty good way to settle things, and they used the cage effectively without it becoming hackneyed or overdone.
In the end, Riddle managed to RKO Rollins on the raised platform, then hit a Broton to the ring below before tapping Seth out. It was a good, but not great, match that hopefully means both men will move on to different things now. This seemed pretty definitive.
3. Overbooked Crap, But Still Pretty Great
Typically, a match in which five wrestlers interfere in a match and the hijinks dominate the final five-plus minutes of the bout, it’s probably an overbooked mess.
But somehow, the end of the Finn Balor/Edge I Quit match was dramatic mayhem. Judgment Day ran down to gang up on Edge, leading to Rey Mysterio coming down to try to even the odds. But then Beth Phoenix made a surprise appearance to turn the tables, getting the handcuff keys to free Edge.
This then led to the climactic moment with Edge held by the rest of Judgment Day as Rhea Ripley threatened to blast Beth with a conchairto, prompting Edge to quit… only for Rhea to chair Phoenix anyway.
It was great drama and really sold Judgment Day as the biggest heels in the universe for doing that to Beth. But man, could we have gotten there 10-15 minutes sooner?
2. Are You Not Entertained?
When Gunther got the call-up to SmackDown, observant fans were counting down to when he and Sheamus would mix it up.
What you couldn’t immediately predict was that Imperium would fully reunite and tangle with the Brawling Brutes in a rivalry that has torn the house down repeatedly. And Saturday was no different.
The Brutes and Imperium demolished the entire ringside area – and each other – in a Donnybrook match that exceeded everyone’s expectations. Despite being a match with barrels and shillelaghs being available, most of the brutality involved fists, feet and full body attacks between the six men. It was an all-action brawl that had fans from the opening bell.
Better yet, Sheamus got a measure of retribution by putting Gunther through a table with a Celtic Cross, and then getting the pin on Giovanni Vinci with a Brogue Kick. Great opener where no one looked bad.
1. WWE Let Bray In
Weeks of breadcrumbs and clues from the viral sensation that was the White Rabbit QR codes and videos finally gave way Saturday to the return of Bray Wyatt to WWE.
It was basically an open secret to anyone who either followed the clues or read anything about it on social media that Wyatt was returning to the company at Extreme Rules (or at least it would be heavily implied at the PLE).
What we got was a really fun theatrical-style segment with WWE cycling through Bray’s different personae and sidekicks, as people portrayed the puppets from the Firefly Funhouse and The Fiend made an appearance in the crowd. The funhouse was shown as a dusty, cobweb-filled room before Wyatt burst through a door carrying his family lantern, looking closer to his original character than the mystic one we knew toward the end of his run.
The live crowd ate it up and erupted at his appearance, and it came off exceptionally well on TV too. Hopefully, they actually have a plan for him and aren’t going to drop the ball, because after all of this buildup, if they fumble the energy and enthusiasm he’s generated, then that’s on WWE.