7 Ups And 5 Downs From WWE NXT TakeOver: Respect

The women steal the show all over the card while Dusty Rhodes is memorialized.

By Scott Carlson /

Less than two months after NXT€™s insanely popular and nearly perfect special event TakeOver: Brooklyn, the Little Promotion That Could held its latest event Wednesday night. While it had a lot going for it €“ finals in a tournament honoring the late Dusty Rhodes, the debut of a top Japanese star and a groundbreaking Iron Woman main event €“ it really wasn€™t fair to expect this Full Sail University show to top the Brooklyn affair. Several hundred fans rarely can compete with 13,000. Still, TakeOver: Respect was a pretty good effort, as NXT broke new ground by having two women hold down the main event for a half-hour €“ a bold move by doing both of these unique decisions at the same time €“ and debuted a female wrestler who could have an immediate impact on the women€™s division. Three of the six matches on the card were eaten up by the semi-finals and finals of the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, an inaugural tournament announced in Brooklyn that had its share of good moments and teachable moments. Although this wasn€™t the Earth-shattering event that Brooklyn was, this was an enjoyable way to spend a Wednesday night, and the energy from the Full Sail faithful added to the night, with one exception: Chanting €œWomen€™s wrestling,€ €œMain event€ and €œThis is Awesome€ multiple times during the Bayley/Sasha Banks match isn€™t cool or smart the third time you do it. Otherwise, thanks for the energy, and of course for the respect. So what deserves to get called up to the main roster and what should be sent packing? Let€™s get to it€

Downs...

5. Isn't Cody Dead?

This moment is a hard one to judge, so it€™s going to get a very mild €œdown€ here. With the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic complete, NXT brought out the Rhodes family to present the inaugural trophy. They even went the extra step of having Eden Stiles (Brandy Runnels, Cody€™s wife) do the ring announcing. Also out there were the American Dream€™s sons, Cody and Dustin. Neither man was in his paint, which can be construed as a couple different tactics. It seemed like WWE was moving away from the ink for this match to get real emotions out of TV. But you have to remember that this is still technically within storylines. So when Cody took the mic and started talking about Dusty, it€™s tough to reconcile that Stardust has said that Cody is no more and doesn€™t exist.It also doesn€™t help that when the time came initially after Dusty€™s death, neither son appeared on TV to soak in the cheers from the crowd. Cody finally resurfaced, but solely as Stardust, and he never acknowledged Dream€™s passing. That€™s fine €“ disappointing, but fine €“ but then to reverse course, you should have a good explanation.

4. Send Saxton Packing

Sometimes you have to give WWE announcers a pass when they spew inane chatter and downright dumb comments. They get their marching orders from others, with Vince McMahon yelling in their ears for three hours on Raw and at PPVs. But Byron Saxton, who also does commentary at NXT is awful. Sorry, but the man is just a cliché machine (he spit out at least three in rapid-fire succession in one sentence during the Dusty Rhodes Classic finals match). He also has an annoying habit of pretending to step inside a wrestler€™s head and telling the audience what they€™re saying at that moment. It€™s really annoying because he€™s always wrong, and because of his faux voice. Sorry Saxton fans, but he is bad enough to make some long for Jerry Lawler to make his return to Raw.

3. Hideo Itami, Remember Him?

When the legendary KENTA signed with WWE a little more than a year ago, it was hailed as a major moment. Hulk Hogan (remember him?) was sent over to Japan to take part in the signing. He debuted to much fanfare in late 2014 and seemed like he was on his way, participating in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania XXXI. Then May 2015 rolled around, and Itami suffered a serious shoulder injury that might keep him out of action for the rest of the year. During TakeOver: Respect, the camera panned into the crowd to find Itami and Funaki sitting there. Sadly, there was no loud cheers or chants from the crowd (maybe he wasn€™t shown on the big screen?), so he just looked at the camera and waved. It was a sad reminder of how big he was when he came in and has now faded to being all-but invisible. When he returns, it hopefully will be with a flurry and we€™ll see him restart his upward trajectory.

2. Enhancement Model

Maybe there€™s more to this ongoing storyline, and if so, then all can be forgiven. But watching Tyler Breeze lose big matches regularly (Bull Dempsey is not a big match, just a big man) is frustrating. Breeze was at the top of the card a year ago, fighting with Adrian Neville, Sami Zayn and Tyson Kidd. Now he€™s losing to Jushin €œThunder€ Liger and Apollo Crews. That€™s not to say that he€™s better than Liger or Crews, or that it€™s necessarily the wrong call, but Breeze has been toiling away for a while now, and instead of being promoted, he€™s floundering, losing special event matches after badgering NXT general manager William Regal to put him in these matches.Perhaps this is all leading to Tyler confronting Regal, or maybe it will lead to a Zayn-like quest to get on-track. But for right now, Breeze continues to entertain and perform€ and job.

1. Non-Tag Team Wins Tag Team Tournament

The Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic was (and still is) a great idea. Generally, tournaments are great ways to have a long-term program and series of matches to fill your shows, and they can elevate a performer or team in the process. However, there was one major flaw with the inaugural tournament: A duo that had never teamed before (at least in NXT) won the whole tourney. In fact, the two teams in the finals were comprised of first-time partners who defeated regular tag teams in the semis earlier in the evening to advance. Of the 16 teams in the whole tournament, nine were regular tag teams. Four of them lost in the first round.Granted, there€™s a fair amount of star power in the top teams in the tourney, but it could have been a great opportunity to elevate a regular tag team, say Jason Jordan & Chad Gable, rather than giving NXT Champion Finn Balor and Samoa Joe another piece of hardware for their shelves. Just a thought going forward for next year€™s tournament.

Ups€

7. R-E-S-P-E-C-T

The TakeOver series has had several simple, yet effective names: Arrival (the first event), Rival, (R)Evolution, and now Respect. It€™s reassuring to hear WWE€™s developmental system talk about how the €œultimate prize€ is respect, especially considering that the parent company has had wrestlers feuding over a shampoo commercial, spilled coffee, tweets, retaining the €œMiz brand€ and of course, Total Divas conflicts. NXT opened its latest special event reliving Bayley€™s crowning achievement, then showing a host of other legendary champions winning their titles: Daniel Bryan, Eddie Guerrero, Edge, Booker T (in WCW, no less), Ron Simmons and Ultimate Warrior. The narrator made sure to note that the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic was all about paying respect to the late American Dream, while Bayley/Sasha Banks is now more of a respect feud over the NXT Women€™s Championship. Fans would probably respect WWE more if some of this mentality spilled over to the main roster.

6. Graves Has Got €˜It€™

Kudos to NXT announcer Corey Graves, who continues to impress as he makes the transition from wrestler to commentator. Graves clearly studied how Jesse €œThe Body€ Ventura conducted himself €“ how he interacted with the play-by-play announcer, how he related to the wrestlers, and how he rationalized every decision the heel made but still had limits. Graves was solid Wednesday, relating a situation to his own wrestling career (Scott Dawson using a chop block to take Cena out), praising Apollo Crews for his technique during a pinfall attempt, and many other really good moments. He continues to impress and could easily transition over to the main roster if they wanted to. That€™s not to say that he wouldn€™t wither with a worked-up Vince McMahon in his ear on Raw and PPVs, but it€™s good to see a former wrestler doing the color analyst stuff pretty well.

5. Replenishing The Ranks

Forget the WWE€™s version of the Divas Revolution. It€™s been sanitized and bastardized into a cautionary tale of what happens when WWE is handed a golden opportunity: the company snatches defeat from the jaws of victory. Instead, it€™s worth it to focus on the place where the revolution started: NXT. However, NXT€™s women€™s division has been depleted due to the recent round of promotions, leaving at one point five regular female wrestlers on television (with others dropping in sporadically). Recently, we€™ve seen Bille Kay and Peyton Royce join the ranks, and Wednesday, Asuka made her much-anticipated debut. (We€™ll largely discount the return of Eva Marie.) We also learned Wednesday that Nia Jax, whose vignettes have been airing for nearly two months, will debut next week on NXT. Once that happens, you€™ll have 10 women featured on television regularly, plus the occasional appearance from ol€™ Blue Pants. Hopefully this new round of women can live up to bar set by NXT€™s Four Horsewomen.

4. World€™s Greatest Tag Team 2.0

NXT struggled for a while to find a gimmick that fit Jason Jordan, a talented guy with a good build and a lot of potential. The organization found it by partnering him with another performer with a strong amateur wrestling background, Chad Gable. The unlikely duo has rapidly become one of the better teams in NXT and probably will taste tag team gold sooner rather than later. Jordan and Gable might have ended up on the wrong side of the match Wednesday night, but their bout was a coming out party of sorts. The fans were solidly behind them as they battled Rhyno and Baron Corbin, hitting some impressive moves, most notably Gable€™s roll-through bridging German suplex on a 275-pound Corbin.The duo is smooth and crisp in the ring and has a fair amount of chemistry outside it too. It might seem odd to compare them to Kurt Angle€™s former running buddies, but their amateur background, attitude in the ring and even their tights are reminiscent of the World€™s Greatest Tag Team. We€™ll see what the future holds for them€

3. Japanese Fury

Had it not been for Tajiri€™s tenure in WWE more than a decade ago, Asuka very well might have been bestowed the nickname €œThe Japanese Buzzsaw€ during her debut Wednesday night at TakeOver: Respect. The former Kana kept her match against Dana Brooke moving at a breakneck pace that left you breathless after a while. She transitioned almost effortlessly between submission moves before throwing in a devastating suplex. At one point, she turned a Brooke body vice in to a kneebar, then an anklelock and then a German suplex. She applied a cross-armbreaker and fluidly turned it into two more holds before releasing.Overall, it was a very impressive debut that seemed to indicate that her time in NXT is going to be short€ because she likely will be promoted to the main roster in the near future.

2. The Boss Resurfaces

At NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn, we saw Sasha Banks essentially break character as she re-entered the ring after losing her NXT Women€™s Championship to congratulate and hug Bayley, and to join her fellow Four Horsewomen to celebrate. When she showed up on NXT to challenge Bayley to a rematch, Banks had softened her stance to saying she respected the new champ and seemed to be playing more of a face. The 30-minute Iron Woman match certainly looked like it was going the same direction, with mutual respect and simply trading pin attempts. But Sasha turned it around when she took Bayley€™s pity and assaulted her. She scored her first pinfall with the help of a thumb to the eye to help solidify her standing. But the thing that put Sasha over the top as a full-fledged villain Wednesday night was when she got in the face of Bayley€™s biggest fan, Izzy, a little girl who attends many NXT events. Stealing Izzy€™s bow and mocking the young girl was something you really don€™t see anymore, nor the taunting that she did to Izzy and Bayley€™s parents.It was an awesome display that reminds fans of old school heat, yelling at fans. It€™s such a shame we don€™t see that these days.

1. Bayley Gets Vicious

Hats off to both women for their awesome main event Wednesday night, but Bayley was the story of the night, adapting her personality as she ramped up her intensity. It€™s been a slow climb for the goofy, lovable wrestler, as she€™s gone from being a fangirl to NXT Women€™s Champion. During the course of their match, Bayley and Sasha Banks include a couple callbacks to their epic struggle at TakeOver: Brooklyn, most notably Bayley repaying Sasha for assaulting her broken hand (Bayley tried to break Sasha€™s hand during the match) and Banks blocking Bayley€™s attempted top roe reverse hurricanrana and landing on her feet and hitting a Bayley-to-Belly for a near fall. Bayley also got downright mean with her submission move, bending Sasha€™s finger back as far as possible while kicking her in the head.All of this made perfect sense in the normal progression of Bayley€™s character development, and she definitely earned even more respect from fans who were waiting to see her break out, and from wrestlers who underestimated her.