Never let it be said that WWE doesnt stick to their game plan even if that game plan is exactly the opposite of what is best for business. For the second Royal Rumble in a row, WWE told its fans collectively that it doesnt care who your favorite wrestlers are, the company will choose the next big thing and youll like it. What looked like it had the potential to be a really fun and enjoyable Royal Rumble match degenerated in its second half into an absolute mess and not just because the Philadelphia fans (rightfully) booed mercilessly. At one point toward the very end of the match, there were about 10 men in the ring with next to nothing going on. If the #28 entrant is coming in and there is nothing interesting happening in the ring, then something is dreadfully wrong. While the Rumble match itself was terrible, the Royal Rumble PPV itself did have a couple bright spots. The WWE World Heavyweight Championship match had the notoriously tough Philly fans chanting This is awesome! multiple times. (Perhaps this should have closed out the PPV rather than the Rumble match.) And there were some individual moments from the Rumble that were noteworthy. However, the Royal Rumble kicks off the Road to WrestleMania and thus is a barometer of how WrestleMania will shape up. And the biggest component of that is who wins the Rumble. Given how things unfolded, we could be looking at a repeat of last year, with the role of Batista being played by the 2015 Rumble winner, Roman Reigns. So lets get to the meager ups and booming downs from possibly the worst Royal Rumble ever.
Advertisement
DOWNS
7. A No-Win Situation
There was a very small window for the Ascension to emerge from their tag team match against the New Age Outlaws with an upward trajectory, and that was for them to demolish the Outlaws in less than two minutes, selling nothing along the way. But instead, we got a bout that had 45-year-old Road Dogg and 51-year-old Billy Gunn on offense for the majority of the time, with Konnor and Viktor only pulling out the win in the closing seconds. Fans had to know that the Ascensions dominance of NXT wouldnt automatically translate into running roughshod over WWEs tag team division. But its doubtful that anyone could have predicted the burial that has taken place, with the announcers and now legends getting their shots in on them. The Rumble tag match ended with the Ascension defeating what JBL called one of the greatest tag teams of all time, so thats something. But its going to be a difficult road for these two to navigate, and its doubtful WWE has the patience for them. (This is one instance where being proven wrong is welcome.)
6. Get The Hook
Of the four competitors in the Divas match, by far the most popular with the fans was Paige. So naturally, Paige was in the match the least and spent the majority of it on the apron reaching for a hot tag which never came. Its probably for the best for her, as she couldnt have saved the match. Its been said that these columns have been too hard on the Bella Twins, that Nikki has shown a lot of improvement in the ring. Sunday night, the Divas Champion was in there with two of the best female performers in WWE, and she still stunk up the joint. Nikki couldnt even throw convincing European uppercuts, and then she stole NXT Womens Champ Charlottes figure-four headlock. NXT is holding its next special event on February 11, with a four-way match for the Womens Championship. Who wants to place bets that its 10 times better than what was unleashed at the Rumble?
5. Where Were The Surprise Returns?
One of the biggest parts of the Royal Rumble each year is that superstars who have been on the shelf make their return during the Rumble match. Sure, there are legends and long-forgotten superstars who will make an appearance, but were talking about regular performers who are getting back to action. John Cena, Edge and Sheamus come to mind. But no major stars made their return to action Sunday night, even with the likes of Sheamus and Randy Orton on the sidelines. Whats worse, Ortons picture is on the poster for the Royal Rumble. In some ways, he was basically advertised to appear and didnt show. Maybe they needed his spot for the Boogeyman. Its somewhat understandable, as bringing Orton back and then having him get eliminated in short order wouldnt have made any sense. And thats an important point: It would be absolutely crazy to put a major star who has been on the shelf in a Rumble match that they werent going to win. It would be a waste and would run the risk of pissing off the fans. Oh wait
4. Cheap Heat With The Rock
Its almost unthinkable that an unannounced appearance from the Rock would be a negative in anyones eyes. His surprise promo back in October was a real highlight and made Raw feel like it was a must-see program if only for a night. But Rocks appearance at the end of the Royal Rumble felt like it was a desperate attempt by WWE to stem the boos that rained down on Roman Reigns at the end of the match. WWEs logic was clear: The Rock is still massively popular with fans (even tough fans like those in Philly), so his endorsement of Reigns would drive fans to openly cheer Roman, or at least cheer Rock as he stood next to Roman, so it looks like they like Roman Reigns too. Wrong. In a move that would only surprise WWE brass and those who didnt watch the end of WrestleMania XXIX, fans ignored Rocks endorsement and booed Reigns nonstop. Using a major star like Rocky like that just felt cheap.
3. Kicking Fans Where It Hurts
The theme of the 2015 Royal Rumble clearly seemed to be, We dont care who you cheer, well cram our babyface down your throat! This of course runs completely counter to Vince McMahons podcast interview with Steve Austin where he said that they listen to the fans. (If you believe that, theres a bridge for sale.) By the middle of the match, fans had completely turned on the match with Daniel Bryans elimination and were jeering everything that happened. Then the #25 entrant, Dean Ambrose, came out, and fans erupted. It bore a question: If WWE is going to book its biggest fan favorite to get eliminated around #15, and you know that the Philly fans are going to turn on the match (which also happened last year, so this wasnt unprecedented), then why would you hold off your next smart fans favorite for 10 entrants? It didnt matter though. WWE brilliantly booked two of its lumbers lummoxes, Big Show and Kane, to knock out and toss Ambrose, Bray Wyatt and Dolph Ziggler three extremely popular wrestlers in fairly rapid succession at the end. If WWEs goal was to royally piss off Rumble fans, mission accomplished.
2. Daniel Bryan Gets Shafted Again
At the 2014 Royal Rumble, Daniel Bryan stole the show in an opening match against Bray Wyatt, which Bryan lost. Then the Rumble match rolled around, and fans eagerly waited to see if Bryan the man most maligned by the Authority would enter and win the match to thwart the bosses and headline WrestleMania. He never entered the match, and it took an epic uprising from fans for weeks to propel him into the Mania main event. Sunday night, Bryan entered the Rumble at #10. About 10 minutes later, Wyatt knocked him off the apron and out of the match. This goes back to an earlier point about Randy Orton: If youre not going to book a major returning star to win the Rumble, dont bother putting him in the match. What makes this advice 10 times worse is that were talking about Daniel Bryan, the most popular wrestler in WWE, and the fact that we all saw what happened last year when Bryan didnt even enter the Rumble. This sort of booking just absolutely boggles the mind. God help the poor sap who gets the consolation feud with Bryan going forward. Hes going to get the wrong kind of crowd heat.
1. The Roman Empire Already Has Fallen
Lets state this upfront: If WWE felt like it had to bring in the Rock to offset anticipated negative backlash against Roman Reigns, thats a major sign that having him win the Rumble is the wrong move. Period. This isnt about the fact that Bryan should have won the Rumble, this is about sending Reigns out to get verbally crucified by the fans. You really have to feel for Roman, who is a talented star who should have a bright future in WWE. But instead of bringing him along smartly and letting him grow into a huge star, WWE is trying to strap a rocket to him and its failing miserably. Weve already seen his awful promos, and he hasnt had a really good one-on-one match yet. Sunday, the next major cracks in the armor came when Reigns won the Rumble despite fans overwhelmingly turning on the supposed babyface. And while this happened in front of the notoriously tough and smart Philly fans, this isnt going to be an isolated incident. No amount of damage control is going to offset the hatred Roman will likely receive because hes being pushed down fans throats. The only thing you can hope for as a fan is that the venom is really directed through Reigns at WWE brass and that Roman gets another chance to truly shine, because it wouldnt be fair for him to be written off due to the companys tone deafness.
UPS
7. Welcome To Dudleyville
When the Royal Rumble originally was announced, it was billed as a 40-man match. The thought was that WWE would try to get a bunch of ECW originals to appear since Philadelphia was the home of the former extreme promotion. Instead, it was kept as a traditional 30-man match, with just one surprise entrant from ECW: Bubba Ray Dudley. Given that Dudley hadnt been seen in a WWE ring in a decade and was a pretty popular wrestler in both ECW and WWE, this was an easy call. The Philly crowd ate it up, especially when Bubba appropriated R-Truth to stand in as D-Von, doing the Wassup Drop and Get the table! spots, and then hitting Miz with a 3D. Although Bubbas time in the Rumble was short and there was no appearance from D-Von, this was the one overture to the Philly crowd, and it was a welcome one.
6. Diamond Cutters For Everyone
When you look at WWEs Hall of Fame Class of 2014, you cant help but see one man, Diamond Dallas Page. DDP was instrumental in saving the lives of Jake The Snake Roberts and Scott Hall, both of whom have battled inner demons for years. He helped put them back on a path to wellness, and both men were inducted into the WWE HOF last year. It stands to reason that Page deserves and could well receive the same honor this year. A three-time WCW World Champion, his resume is just as good as anyone elses, and his work with Roberts and Hall also merits inclusion. DDPs appearance and performance in the Rumble Sunday night was more of a curtain call than anything else. Page is 58 years old, but his Diamond Cutters on Stardust, Fandango and Bray Wyatt looked as good as ever. It was a nice nostalgia return for DDP, and hopefully hell join his buddies in the Hall of Fame this year.
5. Wyatt Gives A Strong Performance
Buried amongst the pile of garbage in the Rumble match was a solid performance from Bray Wyatt, who entered the match at #5 and lasted nearly 50 minutes, eliminating six men. While his elimination at the hands of Big Show and Kane was unceremonious, he had a memorable run in the beginning of the Rumble. Wyatt managed to dump five straight men in the early stages of the Rumble, stopping at one point to grab a microphone to deliver a promo between entrants, ala CM Punk in 2010. While he didnt go on to win and his performance in the latter stages of the match was nondescript, Wyatt could milk his run a little going forward. Oh, and Wyatt was the one who eliminated Daniel Bryan, so if he needs a reason to get fans to boo him
4. Bringing The 700 Level To The Rumble
If youre familiar with Philly, the term 700 Level makes perfect sense. It refers to the top of the upper deck at Veterans Stadium, the former home to both the Eagles and Phillies. The 700 Level is where the boobirds used to sit the loudest, rowdiest fans you could find. That mentality was on full display Sunday night, as fans turned on the Royal Rumble the moment Daniel Bryans feet hit the floor. You knew it was going to be bad, but Philadelphia fans made Pittsburghs hijacking of last years Rumble look tame by comparison. Fans chanted for Bryan for an extended period, then CM Punk. When Dean Ambrose probably the last person in the match fans would accept winning was eliminated, the fans launched into a loud Bulls*** chant. Even the Rock bailing out Roman Reigns and raising his hand afterward couldnt fool the Philly faithful into cheering. If anything, it made them boo even louder. The Philly fans deserve credit for vocally expressing what a lot of fans watching at home on the WWE Network had to be thinking: This is a complete farce.
3. Dissension Among Miz And Mizdow
Thankfully, it looks like WWE is getting the breakup of Miz and Damien Mizdow right so far. Miz is obviously jealous of Mizdows popularity with the fans and its now hurting their ability to function as a team. Similarly, Mizdow is seeing that he is capable of receiving adulation and might want to branch out on his own. Mizs jealousy came out Sunday night as he refused to tag in Damien, pulling his leg and hand away twice. Then during the Rumble match itself, Miz tried to prevent Mizdow from entering the Rumble and wanted to take his spot. To Damiens credit, he stood up for himself and got into the match briefly. Miz of course was none too pleased. All of this sows the seeds of Miz physically assaulting his stunt double or Damien finally standing up to Miz and striking out on his own. While there might not be a lot of faith in WWE handling Mizdow afterward correctly, if they can at least do the breakup the right way, its a step in the right direction.
2. Rollins Can Hang
The WWE World Heavyweight Championship match was the sole saving grace of the Royal Rumble PPV. Granted, it wasnt enough to save it, but it was good enough to track down and watch. The match also marked an important step in the development of Seth Rollins as a main-event player. Sure, Rollins has main-evented Raw several times and also has been in the last match of Hell in a Cell and Survivor Series, but this was the first time Rollins really was put out there like this in a spotlight match on his own. J&J Security got involved a little, but for the most part, Rollins had to hang in there with a dominant Brock Lesnar and a resilient John Cena. Rollins looked like he fit in nicely with Cena and Lesnar, which is exactly what WWE needs from its next generation of stars. Lesnar is on a really short timeline with WWE, and Cena is approaching 40. New main-eventers are needed, and Rollins certainly looked comfortable in that role Sunday night. The ability to hit a flying elbow through the Spanish announce table and a corkscrew moonsault definitely didnt hurt either.
1. The Beast Slayed All
It bears repeating just how good the world title match really was. Had the Rumble match been at least passable, this would be a well-regarded title match. Instead, it will be overshadowed by the atrocious Rumble bout. But Brock Lesnar really gave the kind of dominant performance that made you wish he had been around more during the past four months. He threw John Cena and Seth Rollins around like they were ragdolls, suplexing them at will. Lesnar also cut off Cenas goofy You cant see me with a German suplex. Brock kicked out of an Attitude Adjustment at 1, then took three AAs and curbstomp and was walking around. He looked more like a machine than a man, getting up off a stretcher to return to the match and win. Lesnar most likely will be losing the title to Roman Reigns at WrestleMania XXXI, but he certainly looked like an unbeatable monster at the Rumble. While it wasnt as dominant a performance as SummerSlam, Brock looked like the kind of champ who can only be beat on the grandest stage of all. Its just a shame that despite the buildup looking great on this side, the buildup for the challenger on the Road to WrestleMania looks like it will be full of roadblocks. Reigns might be WWEs choice to slay the Beast, but the fans appear as ready to accept that as they were for a Batista-Orton Mania main event.