7 Worst One-Off Pay-Per-Views In WWE History

Ranked for your displeasure.

By Graham Matthews /

Last year's WWE Battleground pay-per-view is widely regarded among fans as one of if not the worst event of 2013. From a mediocre match from CM Punk and Ryback to a WWE Championship main event ending in a no contest, it was a pretty atrocious event that it is better off unremembered. The only memorable match from Battleground was Cody Rhodes and Goldust vs. Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns with the Rhodes brothers' jobs on the line, the single saving grace of that show. By some miracle, Battleground managed to get renewed for a second installment this year, airing on the WWE Network this Sunday, July 20. This time around, the card appears to be much better on paper and has potential to be excellent. Dean Ambrose vs. Seth Rollins, the WWE Tag Team Championship match and even AJ Lee vs. Paige are all matches highly anticipated by fans and should be stellar. It will also serve as an exciting lead-in to SummerSlam which is also shaping up to be an event for the ages. There have been many PPVs, however, that weren't as lucky as Battleground and didn't receive a follow-up. Whether it be due to a lackluster card or simply a poor buyrate, the events never made it past their inaugural installments. Some have been long forgotten by fans, while others are forever etched in the minds of the WWE Universe, and not for the better. Fans now have the ability to relive all these one hit wonders on the WWE Network. You can decide for yourself whether that's a good thing or a bad thing.

7. This Tuesday In Texas (December 3, 1991)

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x22su3_tuesday-in-texas-1-7_sport WWE's pay-per-view business was still in its infancy at this point, so it's hard to blame this event for being a bummer. Even still, it was a prime example of WWE trying something new by moving its PPVs from the signature Sunday slot to Tuesdays and failing miserably in the process. It didn't help that the card wasn't as strong as it possibly could've been, either. After a slew of dark matches, the show kicked off with Bret Hart defending his Intercontinental Championship. So far so good, right? Not when you learn that his opponent was Skinner. The event was also supposed to see Jake "The Snake" Roberts clash with The Ultimate Warrior, but their feud was cut short when Warrior departed the company. Randy Savage replaced him in the feud. They had a good match at the show, but not nearly as good as they were capable of having together. Hulk Hogan and The Undertaker have never had the best chemistry, and their main event match at This Tuesday in Texas was no exception. Undertaker had just won his first WWE Championship at the 1991 Survivor Series, so for him to lose the title only a short while later back to Hogan felt premature. It'd prove to be meaningless anyway since the title was declared vacant the next day by then-WWE Commissioner Jack Tunney. This event wasn't as bad as some remember it as, but it was definitely a flop and it's not difficult to see why.

6. Breaking Point (September 13, 2009)

In late 2009, WWE completely revamped their pay-per-view schedule, replacing all of the classic events with gimmicky shows. Among these new gimmicky shows was Breaking Point which had the theme of the main event matches being held under submission rules. It seemed to have potential on paper, especially since submission matches are far and few between these days. The concept of the event, however, was better in theory than it was in execution. Among the three headlining matches was D-Generation X vs. The Legacy in a Submissions Count Anywhere bout. In this rematch from SummerSlam, the two teams went to war with each other with The Legacy dividing and conquering to pick up the big victory. Aside from that, there wasn't much to get excited about on this show. John Cena and Randy Orton met for what felt like the millionth time for the WWE Championship while the main event between CM Punk and Undertaker ended in a fluky finish, a take-off the Montreal Screwjob. The undercard left a lot to be desired. Christian and William Regal shine in their match for the ECW Championship, but Kofi Kingston vs. The Miz for the United States Championship had no story behind it and Kane vs. The Great Khali simply did not need to happen. The verbal exchange between Dolph Ziggler and Montreal's own Pat Patterson also came off awkwardly. Many of these same matches were repeated the next month at Hell in a Cell anyway. The transition from Unforgiven to Breaking Point was expected to increase PPV buys, but in fact it did the exact opposite. There was a whopping 42,000 decrease in PPV buys from 2008 to 2009, so it came as no surprise the following year when Breaking Point wasn't included in the PPV lineup. It'd be replaced in the September slot by Night of Champions. It's also interesting to note that WWE hasn't held a PPV in Canada since.

5. The Bash (June 28, 2009)

The year 2009 played host to not one but two pay-per-views that weren't brought back for a second installment. Yes, The Bash is a takeoff of The Great American Bash, but it is considered its own event and does not carry the lineage of the classic WCW and WWE annual extravaganza. It was never explained why the event was dropped the "Great American" adjective, but either way, the change in name did not garner it any more success. The Bash was one of those shows that had the tough task of following an extremely entertaining Extreme Rules event from only weeks prior. Granted, the card wasn't entirely terrible, but most of it was forgettable and merely set up the much better Night of Champions. Randy Orton and Triple H had yet another encounter over the WWE Championship on this show and despite the Three Stages of Hell stipulation, it was still the same old, same old from the two seasoned veterans. The event marked the first ever one-on-one matchup between Jeff Hardy and CM Punk and while it was well-wrestled, the fluky finish left fans disappointed. Even still, it set the stage for the remainder of their rivalry as well as Punk's heel turn several weeks later. John Cena vs. The Miz, a feud that had been built up for a number of months, only received five minutes of in-ring time. The sole saving grace of the show was the Mask vs. Intercontinental Championship match between Chris Jericho vs. Rey Mysterio, a contest considered to this day as one of the best bouts in years. The Bash did 178,000 PPV buys, down 18,000 from the year prior. WWE's version of The Great American Bash has never been stellar, but The Bash completely ruined any chances of the annual event ever making a return to PPV.

4. Invasion (July 22, 2001)

In a shocking turn of events, WWE Chairman Vince McMahon purchased World Championship Wrestling in March 2001. The newly aqquired stars of WCW would proceed to invade the then-WWF and run rampant over the entire roster. It was an angle made in wrestling heaven, leading to fans speculating what dream matches they were to bound to see finally come to fruition. Extreme Championship Wrestling, which was also brought out by WWE earlier in the year, joined in on the fray before long, siding with WCW to form The Alliance. The ongoing war between WWE and The Alliance set the stage for Invasion, a one-off event in July that would pit wrestlers from both factions against each other. On paper, it seemed like a dream come true for wrestling fans, but the actual execution of the show was flawed. The biggest issue with the event (and the invasion as a whole) was that none of the top-tier guys from WCW made the jump to WWE. Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Goldberg, Rey Mysterio and several others didn't debut until the following year, leaving The Alliance to consist of mostly midcard talent. The only two memorable matches from the show were the Hardcore Championship match between Rob Van Dam and Jeff Hardy and the Inaugural Brawl in the main event. RVD and Hardy would produce an even better match the following year and the Inaugural Brawl didn't feature much star power. The event failed to live up to the lofty expectations from fans and would basically sum up the WCW/ECW invasion in a nutshell: a disappointment. This was never meant to be more than a one night only PPV anyway and no other installments were ever planned, but it was still seen as a failure.

3. Capitol Punishment (June 19, 2011)

From 2008 to 2013, a different WWE pay-per-view was held every June. There were a lot of failed experiments, and Capitol Punishment was among them. It was not a gimmicky show like Breaking Point or Hell in a Cell, but it was themed in the sense that the show emanated from Washington, D.C. and the set resembled the Capitol building. A Barack Obama impersonator was also featured throughout the night, making for many groan-worthy segments. Silliness aside, the card wasn't all that strong, either. R-Truth was arguably the hottest heel in the company at the time, but was rushed into the WWE Championship picture and felt out of place in the main event of a PPV. Very few people believed Truth had a chance of winning, so the match wasn't at all unpredictable or compelling. Randy Orton and Christian had another excellent encounter, but the shady finish with the heel Christian's foot underneath the rope as the three count was made. It also paled in comparison to other matches they had at Over the Limit, Money in the Bank and SummerSlam. As for the undercard, CM Punk and Rey Mysterio had a barn-burner of a bout, but the rest of the card was lackluster. Alberto Del Rio vs. Big Show was beyond boring, Wade Barrett vs. Ezekiel Jackson was forgettable and Evan Bourne vs. Jack Swagger died a death in the filler spot before the main event. The show was newsworthy since two titles changed hands, but it was quickly forgotten about the following month when it was surpassed by the epic Money in the Bank PPV. Similar to Invasion, Capitol Punishment was never meant to be more than a one-off event, but it continued the streak of mediocre June PPVs despite the buyrate being better than the year prior.

2. Fatal 4-Way (June 20, 2010)

If you haven't already noticed, June isn't the strongest month for WWE pay-per-views. It caused WWE to switch up their PPV scheduled several times from 2008 to 2013 before finally settling on Payback. The aforementioned Capitol Punishment and The Bash events were failed experiments, but were no worse than 2010's Fatal 4-Way. The theme of the show saw the two world championships defended in Fatal 4-Way matches. Yes, that was the big selling point of the show. Fatal 4-Way matches can be fun at times, but when overdone, they grow tiresome. To hold three of them in the same night was a bit excessive, especially none of them were all that memorable. The night saw three titles change hands, but even then the event was forgotten by fans within weeks. Alicia Fox won the Divas Championship from Eve in a match no one cared about, Rey Mysterio won the World Heavyweight Championship from a poorly booked Jack Swagger, and Sheamus captured the WWE Championship from John Cena... before running away from The Nexus to close the show. Whoever thought a PPV built around Fatal 4-Way matches in 2010 was poorly misguided. It ended up doing a disappointing 148,000 buys. The fact the event ended 25 minutes before the top of the hour was also mind boggling and left viewers wanting more. Needless to say, Fatal 4-Way was (thankfully) not brought back the following year.

1. December To Dismember (December 3, 2006)

After two very successful One Night Stand pay-per-view events, Extreme Championship Wrestling was resurrected as a new brand of WWE (along with Raw and SmackDown) in June 2006. It started off extremely (no pun intended) well with Rob Van Dam holding the ECW and WWE Championships simultaneously and many old ECW stars being brought back. At the time, Raw and SmackDown still had their own PPVs (disregarding the super shows such as WrestleMania and SummerSlam), so December to Dismember was created in December as an ECW-exclusive event. The show was shaping up to be a major milestone for the rechristened ECW brand, but it was ultimately nothing more than a major disappointment. The main event of the show saw six Superstars battle it out in an Extreme Elimination Chamber match for the ECW Championship. Among the participants was Bobby Lashley, Big Show, Rob Van Dam, Hardcore Holly, CM Punk and Test with only one being an ECW original. Lashley, only days removed from debuting in the Land of Extreme, captured the title, a decision not well received by fans. In fact, ECW founder Paul Heyman lobbied for Punk to eliminate Show via submission, but Vince McMahon denied the request. Due to this, all the issues Heyman had with WWE and its Creative Team came to a head, resulting in his abrupt departure from the company. The rest of the lackluster card included Balls Mahoney vs. Matt Striker, Daivari vs. Tommy Dreamer, and an intergender tag team match pitting Kevin Thorn and Ariel against Kelly Kelly and Mike Knox. With that being the advertised lineup for the show, it's no shocker it ended up doing a terrible 90,000 buyrate with only 55,000 of them being domestic, the worst buyrate a WWE PPV has ever done. Many fans saw the show as nothing short of a failure for WWE. Even Tommy Dreamer and Stevie Richards were upset enough with the turnout of the show that they asked for their respective releases from the company afterward, but were turned down. December to Dismember was actually slated for a second installment in December 2007 but was cancelled after all WWE PPVs became tri-branded that spring. In a way, 2006's December to Dismember event foreshadowed the floundering future of the ECW brand and its inevitable demise.