7 Wrestlers Who Were Blatant Knock-Offs
Sadly, we'll never get to see Hulk Hogan and The Warrior take on Randy Hogan and The Renegade...
Wrestlers "borrow" from each other all the time. For example, nearly everybody who does a frog splash stole it from Eddie Guerrero, and he took it from Art Barr. The Big Show started his career as a less French version of Andre the Giant. TNA even stole WCW's gimmick of letting Vince Russo ruin their company.
But for every Ric Flair - who took the "Nature Boy" persona from Buddy Rogers but unquestionably made it his own - there are a hundred unabashed rip-offs who exist only to be a worse version of a good thing. They're the Transmorphers of the wrestling world, subsisting entirely off of fans who weren't paying enough attention when they bought a ticket to a show.
So if you've ever been tricked by a Samoa Moe, a Thundertaker or a CM Funk, you can at least take solace in the fact that you aren't the only one - this nonsense has been going on for years.
7. WCW Had A Hulk Hogan-Like Jobber Named Randy Hogan
In the late '80s, WCW decided to fight back against the WWF's iconic megastar Hulk Hogan in the pettiest, most impotent way possible: with a knock-off version that looked like your weird uncle cosplaying as the WWF Champion. And, also like your weird uncle, he was named Randy.
If you tried to make Hulk Hogan in create-a-wrestler mode but kept a bunch of default settings, you'd end up with Randy Hogan. He had the bald head, the bleached hair on the sides, and the blond Fu Manchu, but everything else about him was... off. He was shorter than Hulk and lacked his signature tan, with a complexion that could best be described as Silly Putty.
None of this was important, of course - Randy Hogan was seemingly only on the roster so WCW management could watch "Hogan" job out to their top stars like Vader and Sting.
Randymania would continue to run mild over WCW until 1994, shortly before The Hulkster himself finally signed with the promotion. Sadly, this meant that we never got to see Hogan vs. Hogan headline Starrcade in a match that would've surely drawn hundreds of dollars for WCW.
6. The Powers Of Pain Were Knock-offs Of Knock-offs
The Powers of Pain (Warlord and Barbarian) debuted in 1987, and with their face paint, burly physiques, and overall "dystopian desert wasteland" look, it was immediately clear they'd lifted their entire gimmick wholesale from fellow NWA tag team The Road Warriors. But as tempting as it would be to criticize the duo for unoriginality, we should probably keep in mind that The Road Warriors themselves actually stole their gimmick from the film Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior, right down their team name.
In other words, The Powers of Pain were knock-offs of knock-offs.
Warlord and Barbarian actually worked a program with the Road Warriors, but failed to gain the same level of success as the team they were emulating. The Powers eventually left the NWA for the WWF, where they lost a feud with fellow Road Warrior copies Demolition and cemented their status as the third-best post-apocalyptic face-painted tag team of the 1980s.
As an interesting post-script, WWE's The Ascension have been compared to The Powers of Pain since they began floundering on the main roster, effectively making them knock-offs of knock-offs of knock-offs and placing them further from the original source material than Brad Pitt's World War Z film.
5. John Cena Was Ripped Off By... John Cena
Very few people think of John Cena as a second-generation wrestler, but that's because they don't know that his father, John Cena, Sr., was actually a small-time promoter and personality in the Massachusetts area under the ring name Johnny Fabulous. He didn't gain any notoriety to speak of, which is why his kid wrestles under his own name and not "Johnny Fabulous, Jr." or "El Hijo de Johnny Fabulous" or whatever.
After his son started collecting WWE championships, John Cena, Sr. began making appearances on the New England independent circuit as... John Cena. And while it's hard to argue that the man shouldn't be able to use his own legal name, come on. If you're a local wrestling promoter and you advertise that "John Cena" is appearing on your show, you know that fans are expecting the "You Can't See Me" guy, not his sexagenarian father who's old enough that he maybe literally can't see you.
John Cena himself (the famous one) eventually told his old man to knock it off, and Cena, Sr. went back to his old Johnny Fabulous moniker. Remember this fiasco the next time you roll your eyes at your dad's bad jokes - it could be worse.
4. Asya Was A Transparent WCW Clone Of Chyna
Christi Wolf was a female bodybuilder who debuted as Ric Flair's burly nurse named "Double D," a play on Arn Anderson's "Double A" nickname, because WCW was kind of stupid in 1999.
Later in the year, she joined Shane Douglas, Dean Malenko, Perry Saturn, and Chris Benoit in The Revolution, becoming the member we'd second-most like to forget. It was around this time that somebody remembered what a massive, industry-changing success Randy Hogan had been and decided that Wolf's character should be based on the WWF's Chyna. Chyna and Wolf had tons of similarities: they were both female bodybuilders, and that was literally it, but whatever. It was close enough for WCW.
Wolf was renamed Asya because - and this is absolutely true - Asia is bigger than China, so WCW hoped that fans would consider Asya superior to Chyna. They didn't, and Asya's placement with four of wrestling's best talents only accentuated her lack of experience. Her most notable WCW moment came in 2000, when she helped Madusa pour barbecue sauce on Oklahoma after he won the Cruiserweight Championship, because as stupid as WCW was in 1999, it was insanely, unbelievably stupid in 2000.
3. Jack Pfefer Killed Chicago Wrestling With Disappointing Knock-Offs
Jack Pfefer was a highly successful promoter in the early days of wrestling, but he made himself into a pariah in the 1930s by giving journalists details about how matches were "fixed." He did this because he felt other promoters were trying to limit his influence, but as anybody but Pfefer himself could've predicted, it only made his life harder.
By the 1960s, Pfefer was still promoting wrestling events in Chicago but was finding it impossible to get major stars to appear. Pfefer figured if he couldn't book the big names, he'd book names that were like the big names. I mean that literally - he started promoting wrestlers with names just one or two letters different from those of major stars.
If you were a fan of Bobo Brazil or Buddy Rogers, for example, Pfefer hoped you'd pay to see Hobo Brazil or Bummy Rogers. He even promoted a guy named Bruno Sanmartino, a name so similar to the real thing that you probably had to read it twice just now to make sure. Unsurprisingly, Chicago fans grew tired of Pfefer's antics, and it was years before wrestling became profitable in the Second City again.
2. Dick Foley Incurred The Wrath Of Mick Foley
In the early 2010s, fans in the Carolinas region were excited to see that beloved WWE Hall of Famer Mick Foley would be making appearances for some local promotions. This excitement turned to confusion and eventually outrage when they arrived at these shows and realized it wasn't Mick Foley, but Dick Foley - some unknown indie wrestler copying Mick's gimmick and appearance, including the Cactus Jack T-shirt, flannel overshirt, and unruly hair and beard.
And the tiny, no-name promotions this Cactus Hack appeared for weren't above taking advantage of their fans, either, advertising their shows with YouTube videos titled "FOLEY IS COMING!" when it turned out to be this Dick instead.
Enough fans were disappointed by this seventh-rate knock-off that Mick Foley himself (the real one) actually commented about it on his official Facebook page, lamenting that it was hurting his reputation in that area. Several of his followers replied that Dick had been telling people he'd been given permission to use the gimmick. Because that makes sense - what famous, highly successful performer wouldn't want somebody stealing their likeness and using a name that's only one letter different from theirs?
1. WCW Really Hoped You'd Think The Renegade Was The Ultimate Warrior
As part of the build-up to WCW Uncensored 1995, where Hulk Hogan was scheduled to face Vader in a strap match, Hogan teased fans with "the Ultimate Surprise," showing a silhouette of a muscle-bound man with long hair and tassels. It was clearly The Ultimate Warrior, and fans salivated at the thought of his arrival in WCW.
Some of these fans were disappointed with what they got instead at Uncensored: the debut of The Renegade, a face-painted wrestler with hair, wrestling tights, and entrance music almost identical to Warrior's. I say "some of these fans" because despite being smaller than Warrior and having a different build, some WCW viewers actually believed Renegade was Warrior, just using a new name.
WCW and The Renegade did nothing to dispel this notion, and Renegade gained a bit of popularity that was only stopped by the real Warrior appearing in magazine interviews to crush the myth. Renegade dropped the copycat elements from his gimmick and was quickly relegated to the lower depths of the card.
Warrior did eventually debut for WCW in 1998, but, uhh... let's just say this was one instance where the knock-off was actually less disappointing than the real thing.