8 Burning Questions For WWE Backlash 2016

Can the blue brand's first PPV rise to the occasion with AJ Styles as a major draw?

By Scott Carlson /

WWE has entered a new phase of the brand split period, as we now have our first brand-specific PPV on the horizon in more than nine years, SmackDown’s Backlash, on Sunday night. On paper, it looks a lot weaker than last month’s SummerSlam, for obvious reasons; more than half the WWE roster is on Raw.

Advertisement

Sure, we’re guaranteed two new champions, with the SmackDown version of the Women’s and Tag Team Championships being decided, and AJ Styles stands a very good shot at winning his first WWE world title Sunday. So whilst it could be an eventful night, some of the matches feel a little lacklustre.

Fans have had this feeling before, and WWE has turned around and delivered an outstanding show, so there is always room for that to happen again. But you can’t deny that this PPV feels rushed, taking place just three weeks after SummerSlam and without a match involving the brand’s biggest star, John Cena.

As WWE dips its toe into the waters of brand-specific PPVs once again, we’ll see how this era of fans respond. With that said, there are several questions that will need to be answered over the course of Sunday night, so let’s take a look at them…

8. Are There Any Late Additions?

As of right now, there are only six matches scheduled for the PPV, two of which are related to the SmackDown Tag Team Championships. Even with backstage segments, intros, and possible interviews, it is going to be awfully tough to fill three hours.

Advertisement

Now, it’s possible that WWE could be looking at these brand-specific PPVs as being more like the old In Your House specials, which were two-hour affairs (or like the NXT TakeOver specials were last year). Perhaps Backlash will only last about two or two-and-a-half hours. Or maybe there will be one or two matches announced on the pre-show to pad out the PPV.

Wrestlers such as Baron Corbin, Kalisto, Apollo Crews, Kane, the Ascension, Vaudevillains, Tyler Breeze, and Fandango currently don’t have anything to do Sunday night. Perhaps we’ll see a tag match added on the undercard, or maybe we’ll finally get that Corbin/Kalisto match that was supposed to take place at SummerSlam.

Oh, and there’s that John Cena guy. He’s still on the roster, right?

7. Will Slater Land A Job?

For better or worse, one of the big stories from the SmackDown Tag Team Championships tournament is that “free agent” Heath Slater could finally land a job with one of the two brands if he and partner Rhyno win the tournament.

Advertisement

Slater has proven over time that he is confident on the mic and comfortable doing whatever WWE asks him to do, even though most of the time it involves making a total a** of himself and getting beat down. In July, he was the only active wrestler who wasn’t drafted by either brand. Then neither GM wanted to sign him. Yet despite being undrafted, he’s gotten more mic and ring time than most of the undercard on either roster.

And now, he and Rhyno are in the tournament finals, likely against the Usos, assuming they beat the Hype Bros. in a second chance semi-final. Assuming that happens, will we see Slater live the dream? Or will the Usos heel their way to a third tag title reign and solidify their turn?

6. Is Ziggler Irrelevant?

It might feel strange to write this as Dolph Ziggler prepares to battle for the Intercontinental Championship, one month after competing for the WWE World Championship. But that is exactly the point.

Advertisement

Ziggler looked like he was on the ascent back in November 2014 when he eliminated three members of Team Authority at Survivor Series, sending the bad guys packing (for all of five weeks). One might think he’d get a big push out of that, but since the beginning of 2015, Ziggler has won 64 of 127 televised matches, or almost 50%. He floundered for months this year until the feud with WWE World Champion Dean Ambrose lit a fire that burned through his promos.

So the question here is simple: Is Ziggler irrelevant? If he loses to Miz for the IC title and moves on to something else, then the answer is easy. If he wins and carries the title with pride, then maybe not. Or could this match be a catalyst for something new with his character? It will be interesting to see if we see something – anything – moving Dolph forward.

5. Will Women’s Match Shine Or Embarrass?

WWE has made a concerted effort to put more focus and more of a spotlight on the women’s division on both programs. That has meant more camera time for the women, which also means there has been more of an opportunity for things to go awry.

Advertisement

Splitting a small women’s division means that there are fewer places to hide wrestlers who either aren’t up to par or are still green. Case in point, the women’s six-pack elimination match for the new SmackDown Women’s Championship. Natalya and Nikki Bella are the only women who have held gold before, and Becky Lynch is the probably the odds-on favorite to win Sunday’s bout.

But you also have Alexa Bliss and Carmella still adjusting to the main roster and an athletic but not-quite-clicking Naomi in the match. That’s not to say that all of these women can’t and won’t deliver at Backlash; this match could yet be pretty good.

But it could just as easily be a trainwreck, with six wrestlers tripping over each other and the match having no real flow. Obviously, everyone wants this match to succeed and draw in fans, but a bad match could have the opposite effect.

4. Can Wyatt Win A Big Match?

This has to be one of the biggest “must-win” matches for a major character – with one caveat.

Advertisement

Bray Wyatt has consistently been one of WWE’s most reliable promo men in the company. He manages to captivate the crowd with his Bayou-tinged diatribes every time, before backing it up in the ring. However, the end result almost always is Bray losing yet another feud, and then simply moving on to the next one.

At some point, Wyatt either needs to win a big match or undergo a major transformation as a character. Given the dearth of major heels on the SmackDown roster, Bray needs this victory over Randy Orton – and not some convoluted win due to Erick Rowan or a returning Luke Harper or some other smoke-and-mirrors tactic. To be a convincing bad guy, he has to win the occasional big match.

So, will Bray win on Sunday? Or will we get more of the same?

3. Are Tag Titles Already Worthless?

Let’s do a comparison simply by listing names and then come back to the discussion:

Advertisement

Edge & Rey Mysterio, D-Von & Ron Simmons, Eddie & Chavo Guerrero, and Kurt Angle & Chris Benoit.

Jimmy & Jey Uso, Jason Jordan & Chad Gable, Zack Ryder & Mojo Rawley, and Rhyno & Heath Slater.

Those are the final four team members from the SmackDown Tag Team Championship tournaments in 2002 and 2016 respectively. To say that these two don’t balance out is an understatement of epic proportions. The 2002 tourney also included Brock Lesnar, Tajiri, Mark Henry, Rikishi, and a very young John Cena. The 2016 version? The Vaudevillains, the Ascension, Fandango, Tyler Breeze, and the Headbangers.

A lot of the wrestlers in the 2002 tournament were still on the ascent as performers and had yet to peak. Edge, Rey, Eddie, and Benoit hadn’t won their first world titles yet – but they were already highly regarded performers in the upper echelon of the roster.

Not to denigrate the wrestlers vying for the SmackDown tag titles now, but the gravitas that was there in 2002 is completely missing. And that can devalue the tag titles right out of the gate. Say the Usos win, but beat the makeshift team of Rhyno & Slater. Compare that to Benoit & Angle defeating Edge & Mysterio. How is beating a guy from the Attitude Era and a free agent adding value to an Usos title win?

At least we can say that there’s nowhere to go but up.

2. Is AJ’s Time Now?

It’s not often that John Cena puts over a wrestler clean as a sheet. He’ll have outstanding matches with just about anyone (the John Cena United States Championship open challenge proved that) and he’ll give opponents a ton of offense, but Cena almost always 'Rises Above Adversity' to win.

Advertisement

That’s why AJ Styles’ super-clean, hard-fought victory over Cena at SummerSlam was such a big deal. Styles’ star has never been brighter in WWE – save for the moment he walked out at #3 in the Royal Rumble in January. Conversely, Dean Ambrose has seemed to falter with the WWE World Championship, poking Dolph Ziggler like a heel would and then acting goofy the next. Ambrose has been a favorite of many fans, but his act could be waning.

Does all of that mean that Sunday is AJ’s night? Could he break through and leave Backlash as the world champion? Imagine that: Kevin Owens and AJ Styles as WWE’s top two champions. Craziness. Either way, Styles isn’t getting any younger (he’s 39), so if WWE is going to cash in on him, now’s the time.

1. Will First Brand Split PPV Excel Or Disappoint?

One of the criticisms that plagued the original brand split was the proliferation of weak brand-specific PPVs diluting the market. The dynamic has changed a lot, with WWE focused less on PPV revenue and more on WWE Network subscriptions, but there still has to be some execs watching this event closely.

Advertisement

If these September brand-specific PPVs falter and October’s two events are also off, then we could be looking at a rethinking of this strategy. Raw and SmackDown PPVs ran from 2003-07, so the company could be a lot more patient than just a couple months. But there’s no denying that this first effort (and Clash of Champions in two weeks) will be scrutinized.

From a fan’s perspective, brand-specific PPVs mean that only half the WWE roster is being utilized, so if I’m a casual fan who wants to see all the top stars, I’m going to be at least halfway disappointed – unless the product is so good it blows me away. Sure, we’ll still get both rosters for the “Big Four” PPVs, but we’re entering a new era (well, re-entering an old one) on Sunday.

Will SmackDown’s Backlash deliver the goods, or will it fall short? Tune in Sunday night to find out.

-

What do you think? Will Backlash sink or swim? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!

Advertisement