8 Controversial WWE Finishes That Actually Worked

Because not everything is as slapdash as Undertaker/Lesnar from this year's SummerSlam.

By Lewis Howse /

The controversial finish to The Undertaker and Brock Lesnar's epic clash at this year's SummerSlam left spectators confused, the referee and timekeeper looking like a fool and WWE looking like they had no bottle. Done to protect both Lesnar and 'Taker, it actually did nobody any favours, as the camera crucially missed the Dead Man tapping out the first time 'round. What had been an awesome spectacle up to that point was ruined in the eyes of many because WWE had booked the finish that they did. Although I felt the negative reaction to the outcome was a little OTT, I could still see where the complainers were coming from. A clean or even different controversial finish would have been so much better. There were many ways they could have accompished the same goal without resorting to the whole 'timekeeper inexplicably rings the bell even though he doesn't have the authority to end the match' bit. In fact, had WWE looked back through the history books, they could have cribbed a decent controversial finish. There have, believe it or not, been controversial finishes that actually worked in the past. Here are eight of the best examples.

8. Montreal Screwjob Take 2

Survivor Series 1998 is one of those Marmite shows that wrestling fans either love or hate. The actual bell-to-bell wrestling was poor and Russoriffic booking was front and centre. As an isolated show, it really doesn't stand up, but it does work within the context of the storylines at the time. You know what else sucks, besides crappy wrestling? WWE's rehashing of the 'Montreal Screwjob' finish, which they did ad nauseam for years and years (until they finally made up with Bret that is). At Survivor Series 98, however, it hadn't been done to death and actually made total sense, given that it was the one year anniversary of the incident and Vince McMahon wanted to crown a new WWF Champion, even if he had to it by force. Vince rang the bell on Mankind as The Rock had him in the Sharpshooter, despite the fact that Foley hadn't tapped and was edging towards the ropes. Vince had screwed him and The Rock was now the corporate champion. There's a wonderful moment where the penny drops for the live crowd, as they realise that the McMahons were orchestrating things over the last few months just to get this moment.

7. Night Of Champions 2012

CM Punk versus John Cena, while not exactly this generation's Austin versus Rock, was a damn fine feud, easily one of the best of the past five years. The two men had incredible chemistry in the ring and produced several awesome matches on TV and PPV, including a genuine classic at Money in the Bank 2011. Another belter between the pair occurred at Night of Champions 2012. The two had their customary great match filled with breathless nearfalls (including an awesome Cena kickout of a Rock Bottom) before a rabid crowd. After twenty five minutes of action, Cena realised he had to do something special to beat Punk and busted out a rarely seen second rope german suplex. The move put Punk down for three but, unfortunately for Cena, he didn't have the energy to bridge properly and his shoulders were counted along with Punk's. The match was a rare draw, but a sporting one, which set up a rematch at Survivor Series (also featuring Ryback).

6. That's Not Sting!

Okay, the guy in the picture is Sting, but the guy that Sid Vicious pinned for the World Title at the end of the same match definitely wasn't. Sting and Sid brawled backstage at around the ten minute mark of their match, with 'Sting' chasing him back to the ring a short time later. Only it was a slightly flabbier, slightly taller Sting. It was actually Barry Windham, trying to pull a fast one for the Four Horseman. 'Sting' went for a weak scoop slam, Sid fell on top and was crowned the new World Champion. The fans were left with hands on their heads and mouths open. Moments later, after the fireworks had went off and the balloons had dropped, the real Sting re-entered the arena, with a rope tied around his wrist. Justifiably p***ed off, Sting decked Sid with the belt, gave him the stinger splash and cradled him to reclaim his title. The initial confusion, with Sting seemingly losing his title in such a weak, rushed manner was great and one of the few Dusty finishes that really worked.

5. The Original Twin Magic

We've been seeing the old 'twin magic' routine for years now, first with the Basham Brothers and now with the Bellas. It's a good gimmick and usually provokes a reaction, but it's hard to deny that it's getting a little tired. When it's used sparingly, it's very effective, but seeing it week in, week out on WWE TV completely dilutes it. Probably the most effective use of the old 'twin switch' trick occurred at Survivor Series 2000 at the finish of Kurt Angle and The Undertaker's WWF Championship match. It wasn't a great match, since Undertaker wasn't at 100% health-wise and Angle was still in his rookie year in the business, but at least the finish got people talking. After receiving a right pasting, our desperate Olympic hero sought the sanctuary of under the ring. Undertaker dragged him back out, naturally, and delivered a spine-jarring Last Ride. It was now a formality, and Earl Hebner counted the one, two, thre - oh wait, no he didn't. Realising that the man the Undertaker just powerbombed wasn't Kurt Angle, Hebner stopped in his tracks to inform the Dead Man, giving Kurt enough time to sneak in and roll him up for the duke. The man 'Taker was pinning was, in fact, Kurt's look-alike brother Eric. It didn't make Angle look like a badass or anything, but it was a damn fine finish.

4. Perfectly-Timed Double Winners

WWE actually had the temerity to bookend the November 29th 2004 Raw with two controversial finishes. In the first match, a battle royal to determine the number one contender to Triple H's World Heavyweight Title, final two Edge and Benoit's feet both hit the ringside area at exactly the same time, causing the main event to become a triple threat match. Then in the (pretty damn good) Benoit/Edge/Triple H main event, WWE booked another controversial finish: with Triple H taken out by a Randy Orton chair shot, it was down to Edge and the Rabid Wolverine. The finish saw Edge, who was locked in the Crippler Crossface, roll-up Benoit for the 1-2-3 at exactly the same time that he tapped out. Of course, the two refs in the ring (one had been bumped earlier in the match) disagreed over who the winner was and Raw ended on a cliffhanger. It was a great end to the show and really made you want to tune in next week to see how it all played out. Unfortunately, the whole thing just led to the Elimination Chamber at New Year's Revolution 2005, where Triple H reclaimed his title. So he never really lost the title and then won it back anyway? Great. Still, the finish to the November 29th Raw main event was top stuff.

3 Lying, Cheating And Stealing

If you're not cheating, you're not trying! That was Eddie Guerrero's inspirational mantra during his wonderful run between early 2003 and his death in November 2005. Although it wasn't exactly the best message to be conveying to the young and impressionable wrestling audience, but it did result in some fantastic match finishes. Indeed, one of the highlights of Smackdown during this period was Eddie's wonderfully inventive ways of getting the better of his opponents and winning matches. Eddie, who was a heel but rapidly being turned babyface by the fans, began trying to frame his opponents, throwing a chair or other inanimate object into their hands before feigning being struck himself. Invariably, the referee would see this and either disqualify the non-offender or provide a distraction long enough so that Eddie himself could level his foe with his own chair or title belt. It was magic stuff, but did lead to controversy, with rematches becoming regular occurrences once the refs and authority figures had clocked onto what was happening. Played for laughs instead of being truly controversial? Maybe, but the finishes were so entertaining and often ingenious.

2. The Incredible Title Change That Never Was

What a wonderful piece of business this was. Jericho and Triple H opened the April 17th 2000 Raw with a great little WWF Title match before a white-hot crowd. It was originally non-title but Y2J had goaded the game into putting the belt on the line. Triple H, being that damn good and a cerebral assassin etc. took the bait. Big mistake. Towards the end of the match the ref got bumped and Earl Hebner came down to take over officiating duties. Triple H was not happy with this and shoved Hebner down, providing enough of a distraction to allow Jericho to nail him with a spinning heel kick and a Lionsault. Coming to, Hebner counted a very quick 1-2-3 as Jericho become the new WWF Champion... ...for about ten minutes. After the commercial break Triple H ordered that Earl reverse the decision, which he did. Thus Jericho's first WWF Title win was voided. Still, the finish was great and resulted in one the loudest pops in Raw history.

1. I'm Seeing Double - Four Hebners!

Hulk Hogan never lost a World Title cleanly, did he? It usually took the 82nd Airborne to get Hogan's shoulders on the mat and the title off his waist. Yes, the Hulkster was always 'protected', usually to an annoying degree. The way he lost the WWF Title at The Main Event in 1988, however, was rather brilliant. Hogan was defending against Andre the Giant in a rematch from WrestleMania III. There would be no repeat of the bodyslam and the big leg, as evil referee Earl Hebner counted the pin for Andre, despite the fact that Hogan's shoulders were blatantly off the mat. It transpired that Andre's manager, Ted Dibiase, had bribed Hebner to screw Hogan out of the title. Earl's identical twin Dave was supposed to be the referee, but he had locked in a closet backstage. It was a great finish and helped excuse Hogan's upcoming absence (he was filming cinematic classic No Holds Barred) while also setting up a tournament for the vacant championship at WrestleMania IV.