8 Match Star Ratings For WWE Elimination Chamber 2020

God bless Daniel Bryan.

By Michael Sidgwick /

A lazy inconvenience of a pay-per-view WWE were under no obligation to promote, they simply, barely bothered!

Advertisement

Job done.

The last stop on the Road to WrestleMania...on Sundays, the build was weird, half-arsed, retconned: in many ways, the very existence of Elimination Chamber 2020 made WrestleMania 36 less special. The Street Profits and Seth Rollins and Murphy were scheduled to wrestle for the third time in 11 days, and yes the Street Profits are fun, Murphy deserves profile, and Seth Rollins is significantly better as a heel, but it's impossible to care because this numbing repetition is hardwired into the product for no reason beyond creative bankruptcy and the churn fulfilment requirement. Andrade Vs. Humberto Carrillo is always quite good, but it's impossible to care because this numbing repetition is hardwired into the product for no reason beyond creative bankruptcy and the churn fulfilment requirement.

WWE Creative Writers are paid $96,000. I should be able to repeat myself too.

Shayna Baszler announced herself as Becky Lynch's WrestleMania opponent via vampire bite, and then they put her in a match to formalise it. It's churlish to state that WWE is outright sh*t as a blanket statement, but this was literally awful storytelling because there was no drama to it whatsoever.

A three-on-one Handicap match? What?

8. KICKOFF: The Viking Raiders Vs. Curt Hawkins & Zack Ryder

A functional match - it very gently reheated the Viking Raiders ,as if they were a pair of poached eggs - there wasn't much to it because it was a five minute squash match on a Kickoff show.

Advertisement

Did it even need to go five minutes? Given that it repeated the bare minimum of story beats, no, it did not.

Curt Hawkins tried to whip Erik into the ropes and was met with a shoulder barge time and time again. It wasn't even effective; Hawkins rallied back to cut him off before launching into tandem offence, which wasn't ideal for Erik's aura. Hawkins and Ryder aren't even geeks. They are non-factors. They have done nothing on RAW of late beyond lose in two minutes to Drew McIntyre. They are walking corpses that exist to be further ground into dust by the stars, and yet they grabbed holds on Erik under the instruction of a goldfish masquerading as a road agent.

Ivar's hot tag looked as awesome as it always does, but Jesus Christ, he might as hell have obliterated Nicholas for how lowly Hawkins and Ryder are in 2020.

Bad news: this made the Viking Raiders look weak.

Good news: nobody gives a toss, and nobody will remember.

Star Rating: ★¾

7. Daniel Bryan Vs. Drew Gulak

This was fantastic both in itself and because it was so different to the in-house style.

Advertisement

Daniel Bryan is a layout genius. In this very technical grappling match, as he went hold for hold with Drew Gulak in front of an audience unfamiliar with the depths of the style, he seemed to throw or endure a stiff strike or accelerate the speed of his counters, knowing to the very second when that audience might disengage. He engineered a sustained reaction throughout almost unchartered narrative territory. An accessible version of a genre that doesn't tend to resonate in an arena, in which he put over an opponent perceived as comedic foil, if he's even perceived at all, this was both artistic triumph and bittersweet glimpse of a WWE that truly maximises the unique talents of its outrageously stacked and criminally under-utilised roster.

Through the medium of straight-up professional wrestling, Bryan told an anxious, dramatic story premised on a head injury that intensified the atmosphere, framed Gulak as a hard and very capable bastard, and put himself over as wily, spirited babyface.

Bryan was so selfless here - he over-committed with that terrifying shoulder bump - in what was a tremendous, gnarly, entirely believable professional wrestling match.

Star Rating: ★★★★

6. Andrade Vs. Humberto Carrillo - United States Championship Match

Loose in layout but snug and snappy in execution, this was the best version of a match over-exposed into crushingly normal territory.

Advertisement

This didn't do an awful lot for Carrillo. He lost, yet again, as Jerry Lawler spent the entire match questioning his talent in a way that wasn't in the entertaining, heels-always-hate-the-faces mode. His criticisms were reasonable and ultimately founded. In a strange moment that betrayed babyface psychology for the sake of getting a spot in, Carrillo twice ate the turnbuckle when attempting a kick. The babyface should be wise to the counter on the second run-through. A minor flub in an a match that built deftly, Carrillo was at least wise to the real thrust of the story. He avoided the danger of exposed "concrete" and had the guile and stunning athleticism to vault in plain sight over the referee and the top rope to flatten Andrade with an awesome dive.

It was some achievement to effectively call back to a repetitive story fans had lost all interest in, gauging by the initial, tepid reaction. WWE fans these days react to many matches like New Japan crowds, but it's different.

There is no respectful, withheld applause that erupts into an uninhibited crescendo; they go into a match with low expectations set by TV, and get worked into it on the strength of the talent.

Star Rating: ★★★½

5. Elimination Chamber Match For The SmackDown Tag Team Championship

Right.

Advertisement

We have now established that it is logistically impossible for WWE to promote a tag team Elimination Chamber match. The format invites confusion, contrivance and, as a result, several glaring botches. There's too much going on for fans and the talent involved to focus on, but the format wasn't solely to blame for what was a mess enjoyable in spite of itself.

The New Day and the Usos resumed their legacy rivalry but hardly honoured it with an uncharacteristic lack of chemistry, and the Lucha House Party impressed only after botching - in stereo - their first involvement. Gran Metalik provided the best high spot with his jaw-dropping hurricanrana, and Tucker ran him close with his own insane senton from the pod, but Lince Dorado's heavily telegraphed shooting star press from the damn roof, an unreal athletic feat, looked a bit silly, and again, this was a card that induced guilt for not engaging with it. This roster batters themselves for asinine creative too often.

As did John Morrison throughout; instead of anticipating the incoming pin attempts, he repeatedly piled on top of the Miz despite knowing better. He looked dumb, and this elongated heat spot failed to give itself a free pass of heart-in-mouth kick-out drama.

Heavy Machinery and Dolph Ziggler and Robert Roode provided the broad, heated story element, but this didn't inform the finish, and the fans lost interest after the peak - another psychological error in a match defined by them.

Still, all six men worked tremendously hard in an impossible situation, and, to use the WWE verbiage to which they are condemned, scratched and clawed their way to a worthy match.

Star Rating: ★★★

4. AJ Styles Vs. Aleister Black - No Disqualification Match

Dull, overlong, and psychologically inept, this was also very, very painful-looking and well-worked beyond the gaping plot hole. It was, in summary, a distilled example of the definitive and sad gulf between talent and creative.

Advertisement

This No Disqualification match, in which the babyface sought to exact retribution against the man who had incapacitated him, began with a collar-and-elbow tie-up, as if it was just another WWE match, echoing the strange Dean Ambrose Vs. Seth Rollins disaster of TLC '18. Whomever agented this needs a word.

It settled into a dull and plodding exchange of holds before Aleister Black ran wild with a kendo stick, after which the story emerged; Styles worked over Black's leg to minimise the effects of his Black Mass finisher, and it all made sense, and Black sold it very well, but the methodical rhythm and excessive, draining duration failed to ignite the crowd. At no point did the OC think to interfere in a No Disqualification bout until the finish, which broke the immersion; it asked a revealing question of the story, which failed to maximise all of its moving parts for maximum dramatic effect. They instead watched on innocently as Styles and Black beat the absolute sh*t out of each over, very slowly, to very little heat.

The Undertaker's interference gave Black the win, in the only moment fans truly cared about.

This was a waste of time so brutal that it made the fans feel nothing beyond mild guilt.

Star Rating: ★★½

3. The Street Profits Vs. Seth Rollins & Murphy - RAW Tag Team Championship Match

A popular result that built towards a deserved, feature singles showcase match for a man, Kevin Owens, who has been pummelled by the WWE system, this match was still very much just a match. Just a long, long match that played out to earned silence. It was two slightly above average RAW matches quite tediously spliced together.

Advertisement

The Street Profits' opening shine dulled, it went on that long, and much like the preceding match, it went long for the sake of it. The story didn't require the duration; this never resonated as the absolute fight of their lives, which is the purpose of a long title match. If anything, it exposed the limitations of the champions, who right now lack the ability to create a compelling and interesting near-20 minute affair.

It also compromised their real bond with the audience; because the hot tag took an eternity to build towards, fans lost interest, rendering the trope badly ironic. They didn't react at all to Angelo Dawkins' spree of offence because this intensified repetition - as main roster as the main roster gets - amounted to a long and arduous effort that did almost less than nothing for the defending babyface champions.

As with too much on the night, for the effort if not the craft, this earned the most Orange Cassidy of a thumbs up.

Star Rating: ★★¾

2. Braun Strowman Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura, Sami Zayn & Cesaro - Intercontinental Championship Match

A dumb, dumb, profligate dynamic, this was dragged through sheer force of will and commitment by Sami Zayn, on a quest to go viral, into acceptable and halfway entertaining territory.

Advertisement

He was excellent value, even in a miscast role. He pulled that role off, because he's such a polymath, which leads one to wonder why in the hell he is playing this role. He played the smug, slimy chickensh*t to perfection, using expert timing, punch-me-square-in-the-f*cking-face expressions and even brilliant sartorial choice to get himself over as an undeserving geek champion. Imagine the level of thought and what it went it to. This company does not deserve him.

He dispatched Shinsuke Nakamura to grind Braun Strowman down in what was an unremarkable heat segment made all the more uninteresting by how often we have seen it - it has been months - and even inspired sequences were undermined by that weird and damaging dynamic. Nakamura splatted Strowman's head into the ring post with his knee in a well-timed and vicious spot. This convincingly subdued Strowman in the context of this silly stipulation, but shouldn't three men taking it in turns to beat one man up subdue that one man without a scheme?

Zayn was funny when he over-celebrated because he's really good at this.

Star Rating: ★★½

1. Elimination Chamber Match For The RAW Women's Championship #1 Contendership

The decision to start the match with Natalya Vs. Ruby Riott was not a smart nor an effective one.

Advertisement

Three narrative threads that ranged from meh to compelling were plotted on television to build the match: the aftermath of the Riott Squad break-up, the marauding debut of Shayna Baszler, and the barely-explored, momentous match-within-a-match between the two most dominant NXT Women's Champions ever. WWE didn't go with even the least interesting story beat, opting instead for an exchange between Ruby Riott and Natalya that was met with total silence.

Fans, conditioned to respond only when Baszler entered the match, only responded when Baszler entered the match, and they only barely did. The layout was excellent, committed and necessary in theory. Baszler arrived, swung Liv Morgan head-first into a pod in a true 'Holy Sh*t' moment of brutality, after she had shredded everybody in her path with some proper squelching knee strikes and instant choke-outs. This was a very welcome rocket-strapper of a match removed entirely from the damaging 50/50 dullness of last week's RAW catastrophe with Kairi Sane. The issue is that, for unfathomable reasons, they didn't gimmick the countdowns. Perhaps this decision was made to register Shayna's dominance, but it compelled fans to switch off.

The big Asuka/Baszler showdown didn't quite level up to its fantasy-booked mythology, but it was just nasty, vicious and dramatic enough to put Baszler over as a killer.

A net success extracted from a position of real peril.

Star Rating: ★★★¼

Advertisement