8 Minor Changes That Would Make A Major Difference To WWE Survivor Series 2017
WWE is a few small changes away from a very special pay-per-view on Sunday.
The 31st edition of Survivor Series is just a few days away, and the penultimate pay-per-view of WWE’s year is shaping up to be one intriguing evening. When the matches were initially announced a few weeks ago, they were met with no small amount of derision. WWE wisely made changes in the weeks following, and many fans have done a complete 180 on the show.
The card is far from perfect, however. A number of the matches are somewhat bogged down by uninspired booking or unnecessary elements, or even the return of superstars who don’t seem to have any place in their match. Survivor Series 2017 is going to be fascinating, but it is far from perfect.
As usual, WWE would only need to make a small amount of changes in order for Survivor Series to tick all of the boxes in front of it. The wheel does not need to be reinvented, and no envelopes need to be pushed - but doing the simple things right often makes a world of difference.
8. A Kickoff Show Elimination Match
All WWE pay-per-views come with a one-hour Kickoff show to get the ball rolling. For the ‘Big Four’, this becomes a two-hour marathon as opposed to a 60 minute sprint, and it is fair to say that interest in the pre-shows is pretty minimal. Who really wants to see David Otunga giving insight into The Miz vs. Baron Corbin?
As of right now, the only match announced for the Survivor Series Kickoff show is Enzo Amore vs. Kalisto with the WWE Cruiserweight Championship on the line. The junior heavyweights won’t be putting on a 60-minute Broadway, unless the company wants to drive all viewers away from the show.
Survivor Series is traditionally an elimination match pay-per-view, and WWE should have booked such a bout on the Kickoff show. Not only would the match provide a lot more action for those who tune in, it would also provide a showcase for the many talents missing from the card.
A two-hour Kickoff show allows for more than just one match, so why not have two elimination bouts? One could have been a showcase for 205 Live, while the other would have contained the various spare parts of RAW and SmackDown. Karl Anderson, Luke Gallows, Chad Gable, Dolph Ziggler and the rest deserve better.
7. Something Other Than Corbin vs. Miz
Is anyone genuinely interested in Baron Corbin vs. The Miz?
Both men have their merits as performers, but it is difficult to think of a less appealing match-up than The Lone Wolf vs. The A-Lister. The Miz is a fantastic talker who needs a superior opponent to have a good match, while Corbin is still very much a work in progress. Unless something remarkable happens, this battle is going to be a drag.
Last year’s Survivor Series saw Miz defend the Intercontinental Championship against Sami Zayn, a battle between RAW and SmackDown with the blue show’s secondary title on the line. Why not do something similar this year? Having both titles on the line in such a fashion would lead to predictable outcomes, but Corbin is on such shaky ground that putting his belt in jeopardy isn’t so difficult or unbelievable.
The Miz is better served in the 5-on-5 elimination match. Survivor Series would be better off with Baron Corbin defending the WWE United States Championship against a RAW superstar. Who? There is plenty of red-show talent with the night off on Sunday. Bray Wyatt? Jason Jordan? Apollo Crews?
6. Alicia Out, Mickie In
The women’s 5-on-5 traditional elimination match is a peculiar one. Alicia Fox has somehow found herself as the captain of Team RAW, and is scheduled to lead Asuka, Sasha Banks, Bayley and Nia Jax into battle. Fox is actually the longest-tenured female performer in WWE, but she has been a non-entity for most of that time.
Is the former wedding planner on the verge of a push of a lifetime? Of course not. Her insertion into this match is jarring at best. The captain’s armband is largely superfluous, but there seems little point to having Fox in the match outside of a couple of wacky moments in the build up.
Mickie James has gone from challenging Alexa Bliss for the RAW Women’s Championship at WWE TLC to being off the Survivor Series card entirely. Mickie is one of the most underrated performers in the company, and her experience could have been vital in holding the moving parts together an inherently chaotic match such as this.
5. Tamina Out, Anyone In
On the subject of the women’s elimination match, it really does display how bare SmackDown Live’s female cupboard is. It was rumoured for weeks that Paige was on her way to the blue brand, only for it to be revealed that she is on her way to her previous home on Monday nights. The former two-time Divas Champion could well end up being the final member of Team SmackDown, and if that is the case, it is a big thumbs up from me.
If Paige does take that final spot, where does that leave Natalya? Nattie was SmackDown Women’s Champion up until this past Tuesday, yet now she is in danger of missing out on one of the four biggest shows of the year - on the 20th anniversary of the Montreal Screwjob, no less.
In an ideal world, Paige and Natalya would join Naomi, Carmella and Becky Lynch on the blue team. Tamina Snuka is simply not on the level of the other competitors in the match - Alicia Fox included.
4. AJ Vs. Brock - No Disqualification
AJ Styles vs. Brock Lesnar is a true dream match.
Styles is one of the best professional wrestlers on the planet, a man at the very top of his profession and arguably one of the most influential performers of the modern age. Brock Lesnar may well be the last great draw in American pro wrestling, a once-in-a-lifetime combat athlete that makes everything feel more important.
Styles vs. Lesnar will be a thrilling spectacle at the very least, but from a purely physical standpoint it may be difficult to buy AJ against the mass of ham that is Brock. It was a similar situation faced by WWE at SummerSlam 2013, ahead of CM Punk’s match with The Beast Incarnate.
That match subsequently became a No Disqualification affair, and the same should happen here. AJ vs. Brock doesn’t have the same emotional hook that the Punk bout did, but the stipulation would go a long way to improving The Phenomenal One’s chances of chopping down his physically superior opponent.
3. Rusev In For Shane McMahon
Shane McMahon shouldn’t be anywhere near a WWE ring at the moment. I say that with regards to a wrestling standpoint of course, as Shane-O Mac is fine as an authority figure. The SmackDown Live commissioner is a liability in the ring however, not to mention a serious health concern.
I understand the idea of wanting your authority figures to captain the two teams, but including Shane McMahon in the match is hugely detrimental to both the quality of the bout and the perception of SmackDown. Where is Rusev? Complaining about how the Bulgarian Brute is used is akin to screaming into space at this point, but that doesn’t make it any less frustrating. The man from Plovdiv absolutely should be in this match.
The continued use of Shane McMahon in an active capacity is a further kick in the teeth for fans of SmackDown General Manager, Daniel Bryan. If Shane and Kurt Angle can both get clearance for competition, what shape must Bryan be in? Either things are far worse than they seem, or WWE really is hell-bent on keeping the leader of the YES! Movement out of the ring.
2. Bring The Average Age Down
The men’s 5-on-5 traditional elimination match is expected to close the show on Sunday night. RAW and SmackDown will collide once again, as 10 of the top superstars in the company (well, seven top superstars, two authority figures and the COO) will do battle for brand supremacy. It could end up being an overbooked mess, but it should be a lot of fun nonetheless.
The problem is the average age of the combatants in the match. The SmackDown team has an average age of 40.2 years, only slightly better than that of RAW (40.5). 50% of the wrestlers involved are 40 years or older, with three closer to 50. This does not bode well for the future of WWE.
This is normal game once WrestleMania rolls around, but this is Survivor Series. The time to give younger stars the opportunity to headline pay-per-views is now. Kurt Angle, Triple H and Shane McMahon (the three men close to 50) have no place in this match. The last time all three appeared on the same Survivor Series was in 2003, when The Basham Brothers were tag champs, and Matt Morgan was a star of the future.
Kevin Owens (33) and Sami Zayn (33) will likely be involved illegally, as will Jason Jordan (29). Despite this, it is clear that WWE’s youth movement has ground to a serious halt.
1. Put Something On The Line
It isn’t entirely true that nothing is on the line this Sunday. Kurt Angle may well be out of a job if RAW comes up short, and whichever brand loses will have no small amount of egg on its face. But is that enough? Are bragging rights meaningful enough to add a bit of importance to Survivor Series 2017?
In order for these RAW vs. SmackDown events to matter, something needs to be on the line between the two brands. There needs to be something more than ‘brand loyalty’ to convince former partners to turn on each other. 12 months ago, eight of those competing on Sunday were on the opposite show and five weren’t even on the main roster. John Cena was on RAW just a cup of coffee ago.
It is a minor change, but WWE should have put something major on the line this Sunday. How about the first draft pick in a potential 2018 draft? The WrestleMania main event? Entry number 30 in the Royal Rumble? The truth is there are no consequences on Sunday. RAW and SmackDown will collide, but the WWE wheel will continue to spin as if nothing has happened.