8 Puzzling Things About The Original WWE Draft
Looking back at the original draft with some perspective.
As the wrestling world reflects on Tuesday night's kick at the Brand Extension can, longtime fans have been harking back to the original go-around for the roster split. In particular, the night of March 25, 2002, when Vince McMahon and Ric Flair cherry-picked from a very deep WWE roster to set up the original Smackdown and Raw rosters.
There was some skepticism over the original draft, particularly because nothing like it had ever really been attempted. Without an easy-to-follow template, you'd expect there to be some unusualness from the untested concept, and there certainly was. Looking back at the 2002 WWE Draft today, some of the decisions are hard to rationalise.
WWE seemed to realise this too. Throughout the remainder of 2002, wrestlers crossed brands as though the shows were the most minimum of security prisons, reconfiguring things through an extended re-adjustment period. In other words, the months after draft felt like a prolonged do-over phase.
For some of the following entries, hindsight wasn't necessary. Watching the draft show live, hardcore WWF loyalists were watching their favourite program and thinking, "What the hell are they doing?". It's a phrase that has become oft-repeated by viewers in the ensuing fourteen years.
At the time, let's just say the Brand Extension didn't exactly start off on the right foot...
8. Steve Austin's "Clause"
People remember Stone Cold's infamous June 2002 walkout and the associated ugliness, but they forget that he also fled the company right after WrestleMania X8, and sat out for two weeks.
When the draft came around, Austin was in his self-imposed hiatus, and it was declared (in kayfabe) that Austin had a "clause" in his contract that gave him draft immunity. It said that if WWE should ever split into two brands, Austin could forego the draft and simply sign with whichever brand he wanted.
How convenient, right? Amazing that Austin would have the foresight in the late-nineties to figure that WWE might split into "brands" one day. Some theorised that Austin's absence had to do with WWE not wanting to pick Rock first and Austin second, or vice versa, and thus render one of the two "second place", but the walkout seems to override that idea.
Stone Cold's absence had to be explained, but what a peculiar solution they came up with.
7. Splitting The Dudley Boyz
If you watched the draft, then you witnessed Flair choose the New World Order collective (Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, and X-Pac) as a tandem entry. McMahon did the same for Tag Team Champions Billy and Chuck later, culling them to Smackdown as a duo. This seemed to be against the preordained rules, but whatever.
Then Flair singularly chose Bubba Ray Dudley. McMahon followed by selecting D-Von, thus splitting the long-running duo. It was one thing to test out each man's singles potential, but it was an odd time to do it. Fans quickly soured on the idea of a popular duo being halved, less than an hour after two other factions were herded onto shows in one piece.
Within eight months, the Dudleyz were put back together, owing to a dearth of legit teams on Raw.
6. Rikishi Picked 13th Overall
The expected names went early on, such as The Rock, The Undertaker, Kurt Angle, Hulk Hogan, Rob Van Dam, and others. There wasn't a true head-scratcher until the thirteenth pick, which was Smackdown's seventh choice. After the likes of mainstay upper-carders like Booker T, Edge, and Big Show went off the board, Rikishi was taken thirteenth.
With only ten selections per brand on the draft show, Rikishi was an odd choice. For the previous year or so, he'd only been a factor on sparing occasion, and his star wattage had diminished immensely from his near-main event run in 2000.
While others went undrafted altogether (we'll get to this later), Rikishi was treated like he was still a top guy. He still held novel appeal (depending on what hated villain's face he was sitting on), but he just wasn't a pick-guy at the time.
5. Mark Henry Picked 17th Overall
Before 2011, Henry was one of the most baffling cases on the WWE roster. He signed a ten year contract(?!) in 1996 on the sole merit of his Olympic power-lifting fame, and was mostly a wash with injuries for that decade, save for his amusing (yet disturbing) run as "Sexual Chocolate" in the Attitude Era.
When McMahon picked Henry for Smackdown, it was at a time when Henry may have been at his most irrelevant. He also missed a year of action from 2002 to late 2003 with further injury. Leave it to McMahon to be the one to choose two guys based on size and not much else.
Henry's 2011-12 run as the curator of the "Hall of Pain" was brilliant and it fit the mammoth Henry like a glove, but damn it took a staggering fifteen years to get there.
4. Maven Picked 19th Overall
This one's a bit more defensible, because at least Maven was still riding on the wave of his ultimately-limited celebrity.
Five months after winning hearts and minds as the male Tough Enough winner, Maven and his sky-high dropkick enjoyed some success as a gallant rookie trying to make good on his potential. With the Tough Enough win, and mini-feud with Undertaker, fresh in everyone's mind, Maven was a decent enough choice for a pick.
The only problem was that the air completely rushed out of the balloon quickly afterward. Maven quickly dropped the Hardcore title to Raven, who then absconded to Raw with a belt that had only five months of life left. Maven's stardom crashed roughly around the same time Tough Enough Season Two winner Jackie Gayda woefully underperformed on Raw.
In hindsight, saying Maven justified a pick sounds absurd, but to be fair, it really wasn't. It's just harder to defend today.
3. Not Drafting The Cruiserweight Champion
As you enjoy the Cruiserweight Classic and appreciate the steps Triple H and others have taken to bring international and independent flavours to the WWE world, remind yourself that there was a time where WWE seemed to rue the idea that they had a weight-exclusive belt for smaller wrestlers.
This was made clear when Cruiserweight Champion Tajiri went undrafted during the televised portion of the show.
Instead, Tajiri was taken in the 'random selection' portion, getting whisked to Smackdown along with the belt. While McMahon was lamenting (in story) not getting to draft Intercontinental Champion Rob Van Dam, and even booked Smackdown pick Kurt Angle to try and win the belt from him that night, the Cruiserweight title was an afterthought.
It was just, "Oh, I guess the belt's exclusive to my brand", and that was that.
2. The Wrestlers Who Weren't Picked
Considering that Henry, Rikishi, Maven, and other possibly-questionable talents were taken during the televised portion, and thus given a moment of shine to underscore their importance, you'd think the undrafted talents were a bunch of schmoes.
Maybe WWE thought so in their unique thinking process, but take a gander at what talents were subjected to the random selection phase on the company website.
Among them, The Hardy Boyz, Christian, The APA, Lance Storm, Trish Stratus, Diamond Dallas Page, Goldust, plus many others. While a talent's value is subjective, their beauty in the eye of the beholder, hindsight isn't exactly kind to how this all played out.
Tell somebody in 2016 that "Smackdown would rather have had Maven than Jeff Hardy or Trish Stratus", and you'll find a cross-eyed gaze staring back at you.
1. The Aftermath For The Unpicked
Lance Storm told an incredible tale recently to Bryan Alvarez of Figure Four Daily. For those that went undrafted, you may ask how they found out what show they would be working on. McMahon told those performers that they would have to check WWE.com after Raw to find out where they would be continuing their employment at. Seriously.
WWE wanted to drive web traffic, so they posted updates for the random selection phase in intervals on the website. In the days before smart phones with internet capability, Storm had to call a friend in Washington state and he, Jericho, and Christian sat for an hour while that friend (independent wrestler Dr. Luther) refreshed his browser every few minutes to let them know what show they would be on.
Instead of just telling Storm "You're on Smackdown", he had to find out his fate from a non-employee through a midnight phone call.