8 Teams That Were Stupidly Split Up In WWE Drafts

Why fix what isn't broken?

By Graham Matthews /

The WWE Draft is known for being among the company's most unpredictable nights of the year, for better or worse.

Advertisement

Several Superstars over the years have found success on their new show after being moved in the annual Draft, while others have gotten lost in the shuffle. That's especially true for tag teams, who are notoriously never safe when it comes time for WWE to shake up its Raw and SmackDown rosters every year.

Since the Brand Extension was originally introduced in 2002, multiple tag teams have been shockingly split up. Some were for the better, such as The Miz and John Morrison in 2009 or The New Day in 2020, whereas others were broken up for no good reason.

The aftermath in most of these cases proved their parting of ways to be the wrong call, leading to WWE either reuniting the duo or stable soon after or firing one or both members of the now-defunct team. It's bound to happen to a tandem or two in this year's installment of the WWE Draft, but if the company was wise, they would ensure that history doesn't repeat itself by making those same mistakes again.

These are eight instances of WWE separating a tag team simply for the sake of doing so.

8. Andrade And Zelina Vega

It's likely Andrade would have left WWE a lot earlier than he did had he not been paired off with Zelina Vega on NXT TV in the spring of 2017.

Advertisement

The former IWGP Intercontinental champion floundered on the black-and-gold brand until Vega came along to serve as his mouthpiece. Together, the two were a money combo, and thus it was no surprise that Vega led him to NXT Championship glory within a matter of months.

WWE was wise to keep the unit intact upon their move to the main roster (which isn't always a guarantee if SAnitY, Enzo, Cass and Carmella, and Kross Kross with Scarlett are any indication) in May 2018. He eventually captured the United States Championship in 2019, but by late 2020, it was clear WWE was starting to sour on the duo based on their lousy win-loss record.

Angel Garza was also involved in their act for a time that year, but instead of Garza being sent to SmackDown to be by himself, Vega was drafted to the blue brand while Garza stayed put on Raw and Andrade went undrafted.

Needless to say, no one benefited. Garza became a mainstay on Main Event before his latest "push", Andrade requested and was granted his WWE release, and Vega was reduced to enhancement status on SmackDown (only after being fired and brought back, of course).

7. The Basham Brothers

As talented of a team as Doug and Danny Basham were together, it was evident they had no future as singles stars in WWE. It was booking malpractice for them to ever be separated, but that's exactly what happened in the 2005 WWE Draft.

Advertisement

The duo had success on SmackDown early on in their run when they unseated Eddie and Chavo Guerrero as WWE Tag Team champions in late 2003. They later regained the gold while members of JBL's Cabinet faction, during which period they were prominently featured on the blue brand and scored plenty of television time.

Following the dissolution of the stable that summer, Danny was drafted to Raw in WWE's 2005 Draft Lottery for seemingly no reason when they could have easily instead being brought over to Monday nights as a unit.

That marked the beginning of the end of The Basham Brothers in the company. Danny's Raw run amounted to nothing while Doug was relegated to Velocity for the remainder of the year. They had a brief run on ECW in 2006 under masks as Paul Heyman's enforcers before being released at the onset of 2007.

6. The Riott Squad

For a faction that was never meant to last long, The Riott Squad reached a level of popularity the company likely never expected them to. Their entire run together consisted of them serving as stepping stones for Superstars such as Charlotte Flair, Ronda Rousey, Sasha Banks and Bayley, and yet, they made the most of every situation they were in.

Advertisement

Despite losing more than they won, Ruby Riott, Liv Morgan and Sarah Logan were fixtures on SmackDown and Raw from 2017 through 2019. The WWE Women's Tag Team Championship was created for a team exactly like them, but they were broken up before they had a chance to hold them.

Their split occurred in April 2019 when Morgan was sent to SmackDown in the Superstar Shake-Up. With Riott undergoing surgery for an injured shoulder, Logan was forced to fly solo on Raw. That left all of them in limbo without much to do on their respective shows. Even Riott failed to get going again once she eventually returned to the ring in early 2020.

By the time WWE decided to put The Riott Squad back together in the summer of 2020, Logan had already been released. Riott and Morgan resurrected the group by themselves until Riott was also released the subsequent summer.

5. Deuce And Domino

In retrospect, it's quite amazing that Deuce and Domino lasted as long as they did and were as successful as they were given their goofy gimmick.

Advertisement

Still, their talent in the ring was undeniable (at least in the case of Domino), and the potential was always there for them to be more than what they were. That could have happened had they stuck together for longer than two years and not been split up in the 2008 WWE Draft.

They had already formally broken up on SmackDown at that point having already won the WWE Tag Team Championship on SmackDown, but it couldn't have been more apparent that WWE had no plans for any of them on their own. That includes their manager Cherry, who also floundered once they all went their separate ways.

Not only were Domino and Cherry released from their contracts in late 2008, Deuce was also let go the subsequent summer. To the company's credit, they tried with Deuce a.k.a. Sim Snuka in late 2008 by testing the waters with him as a singles star and linking up with Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton, but he stuck out like a sore thumb and was booted soon after.

At a time when WWE was splitting up tag teams left and right, Deuce and Domino could have helped out the Raw tag team division instead of being broken up and released.

4. SAnitY

SAnitY was doomed to fail from the moment WWE called them up to SmackDown in unspectacular fashion, so their unceremonious split in the 2019 WWE Draft shouldn't have come as much of a surprise to fans.

Advertisement

Although Eric Young, Killian Dain, Alexander Wolfe and Nikki Cross were positioned more as the gatekeepers of NXT than anything else, they played their roles well and helped elevate a ton of talent. When it came time for them to be called up following WrestleMania in 2018, they deserved an opportunity to show what they could do.

They never got it.

Instead, they floundered for the year they were on SmackDown and went their separate ways in the 2019 Superstar Shake-Up. Young went to Raw, Dain returned to NXT, and Wolfe migrated over to NXT UK.

Dain and Wolfe had much more success than Young, but even still, all three of them were eventually released, leaving Cross (now Nikki A.S.H.) as the lone surviving member of SAnitY. Who knows what would have happened had WWE actually given the stable a shot and not given up on them so quickly.

3. The Club

AJ Styles had everything going for him in the first six months of 2016.

Advertisement

He had the perfect debut at the Royal Rumble followed by a fun feud with Chris Jericho on the road to WrestleMania and then back-to-back pay-per-view main events with Roman Reigns over the top title. He then immediately transitioned into a rivalry with John Cena.

Above all else, he had his own stable consisting of himself, Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows.

Collectively known as The Club (a blatantly lazy name for a group), they played off their history in Bullet Club and had incredible chemistry together. Anderson and Gallows were being pushed around the same time, so all three of them were firing on all cylinders.

Just as their "Beat up John Cena!" tagline was starting to get over with the audience, they were shockingly split up in the 2016 WWE Draft, with Styles going to SmackDown and Anderson and Gallows reporting to Raw.

Styles had no problem fending for himself on the blue brand, but Anderson and Gallows were not as fortunate. They were largely booked like losers from that point forward, and although they attempted to recreate that magic by reforming The Club in 2019, it didn't prevent The Good Brothers from being released in April 2020.

2. Heavy Machinery

Heavy Machinery had all the tools necessary to be a super successful team on WWE's main roster, and shortly before the pandemic hit, it appeared they were well on their way to accomplishing that.

Advertisement

Otis and Tucker were gradually getting more and more over with the audience thanks to the storyline with Mandy Rose heading into WrestleMania 36. They were also genuinely likable dudes, so when the time was right, they were bound to receive a raucous reaction when they won the SmackDown Tag Team Championship.

Unfortunately, the pandemic really hurt their momentum because they didn't have the fans to play off anymore. Otis' angle with Mandy fizzled out, leaving Vince McMahon to believe he no longer had a use for his tag team partner.

In a shocking turn of events, Tucker was sent packing to Raw in the 2020 WWE Draft. It was mere weeks later that Tucker solidified the split by betraying Otis and costing him the Money in the Bank briefcase, though there was never a blow-off bout between the two and Tucker was later released from the company.

Heavy Machinery should have ascended to higher heights and held gold at least once together.

1. The Dudley Boyz

Unlike most pairings on this list, The Dudley Boyz were an incredibly decorated duo and held tag team gold on countless occasions before being split up in the inaugural WWE Draft in 2002. Despite that, there was no zero reason for them to be used as single stars at that stage of their respective careers and breaking them up was a shortsighted decision.

Advertisement

The move only seemed designed to send the message that "anything can happen" in the WWE Draft and that not even a tag team of The Dudley Boyz' stature was safe. Needless to say, it was the wrong call and, unsurprisingly, neither of them amounted to much singles success on SmackDown or Raw.

It took longer than expected, but WWE inevitably bit the bullet and admitted defeat by reuniting The Dudley Boyz in grand fashion at Survivor Series 2002. They teamed together in WWE for another three years after that and eventually took their talents over to TNA Wrestling.

Bubb and D-Von did ultimately branch off on their own for a few years starting in 2010, but for WWE to force their split as prematurely as they did set a poor precedent for tag teams inexplicably being broken up in the Draft in the years that followed and still to this day.

Advertisement