8 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (1 Feb - Review)

Jon Moxley, Hangman Page, Samoa Joe and Darby Allin bring back the Wednesday Night WARS...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

Was it greedy or entitled to expect stronger hints of (and accompanying angles for) the big matches at Revolution on Dynamite this week?

Advertisement

AEW, on a red-hot streak of cracking TV episodes, is still several weeks away from its next pay-per-view, and the intervening TV has done a sublime job of telling mini-stories and promoting high-end matches fit for the medium. Tony Khan, by promoting an excellent series between Jon Moxley and Hangman Page, has also addressed a complaint levelled against his promotion for much of 2022: where he was once a bit stingy, almost fearful of giving away big, unpredictable matches on TV, he has struck an almost ideal balance over the last few months.

A lot of people almost demanded editions of Dynamite of this calibre in the autumn, and we're getting them.

Advertisement

Still, this is a company that has raised expectation levels, and the superb angles on WWE TV of late have brought into focus that Wednesday nights might be a little too action-heavy in comparison. Outside of MJF Vs. Bryan Danielson, a tremendous slow-burn story of contrasts, what else is on store on March 5?

Are the Gunns, a fun prelim comedy act, really going to work the Acclaimed? Who is Adam Cole going to wrestle? Was the teased Elite Vs. House of Black Trios title match abandoned?

Advertisement

Did AEW answer these questions last night...?

Downs...

2. Bad Storyline Takes Clichéd Turn

AEW

This Jericho Appreciation Society Vs. Ricky Starks and Action Andretti programme is a boring cliche. It is also actively bad.

Advertisement

Starks looks exponentially less cool stood alongside a blue chip up-and-comer type. Starks has already beaten Chris Jericho cleanly; there's no big bad for him to overcome. Their match on the January 4 Dynamite was white-hot. There's nothing left here beyond a quieter and longer sequel. The route to that sequel descended into numbing obligation last night.

Starks, per a backstage challenge issued by the JAS, must defeat three members of the stable to get to his rival (whom he has already beaten decisively). It's a booking cliche in 2023, and only an inspired tweak on the trope is working in MJF's favour elsewhere on the show.

Advertisement

This is total procrastination, regulation booking, which Jericho is trying to make exciting with alliteration.

This storyline is so flat that Starks might have been better off had he been shunted to Dark: Elevation for six weeks after all.

Advertisement

1. A Rare Lapse In Thought

AEW

The latest MJF bounty angle was great value in and of itself - more on that imminently - but the way in which it was sequenced revealed a rare, glaring continuity error. This was bad form from a promotion that usually operates with a keen sense of detail.

Advertisement

Before this segment, Konosuke Takeshita had roughed MJF up and torn his shirt. Then, not too long afterwards, MJF paid Rush a bounty to take out Bryan Danielson looking like a mega-star. His aviators look was so striking that he should wear this get-up all the time. With the exception, of course, of that segment.

It was a blatant pre-tape that took viewers out of it with a lack of thought.

Advertisement

Ups...

8. Cast-Iron Classic Opens The Show

AEW

Jon Moxley Vs. Hangman Page III was an absolutely incredible TV match. Tone, action, storytelling, drama, finish: it was perfect.

Advertisement

Themed on pure defiance, both men were so intent on maiming the other that they didn't care that the bell didn't ring; they brawled around the arena and by ringside to tell the story that they are each utterly consumed by the other at this point. No other aspirations matter.

Neither man can allow themselves to lose this war; losing it feels particularly definitive, damaging to the fictional characters, in a way few other stories do. That is how well it has been told. These men want to short-circuit each other's brains. That's how it started, and that's how they know it must end. The competition, figuratively and literally, is too stiff.

Advertisement

Except it didn't end that way; after both men worked one another's brain tissue over throughout, incorporating one horrific-looking avalanche Death Valley driver, Mox used his superior grappling victory to eke out the win. This thing is so well-told that it got a finish adjacent to "He stole one!" over. That finish wasn't the agreed-upon code, and Page was seething. Brilliantly, before being separated, Page and Mox performed warm-up exercises after the finish, as if they were remotely capable of going at that unreal pace all over again. They were not.

They went out there to f*ck each other up, sold being f*cked up, and pretended they weren't f*cked up in the post-match because they need to f*ck each other up again.

Advertisement

Because this is about pure defiance, pride, and desperate masculinity.

7. Middling Storyline Improves

AEW

Their feud with the Gunns had threatened to lower the Acclaimed's stock.

Advertisement

Last week's 'Family Therapy' session was strange, tonally. Nobody is taking this fun TV distraction feud seriously, but AEW asked the viewers to do that when the Gunns accused their father of not being around in their formative years. It was heavy material for what should be light entertainment.

After the Acclaimed's nothing squash win over Truth Magnum and Turbo Floyd, which only acted as pretext for the angle - a bit transparent - the Gunns and the Acclaimed were involved in a war of words. Billy Gunn couldn't be arsed. He just wanted them to fight and get it over with. Austin Gunn told him to walk out again, just like he did all those years ago when he was staring at the bottom of a bottle of pills. The ruse was complete.

Advertisement

Billy accepted the challenge for a World Tag Team title match - which Tony Schiavone was savvy enough to point out needs to be sanctioned by Tony Khan - after which Austin smirked. This was great heel work and equally impressive let-it-play-out booking; Like a true d*ckhead of a heel, Austin cares far more about the title than his relationship with his dad.

This story beat could have been sold better on commentary, but still: the threat of melodrama was extinguished.

Advertisement

6. Decent Progression In The Women's Division

AEW

The Homegrowns Vs. Imports storyline was advanced slowly on last night's Dynamite. This was solid, which is all too often a synonym for boring, but a gradual step in the right direction.

Advertisement

The Bunny challenged Jamie Hayter, but Renee Paquette learned that a brawl had broken out elsewhere in the building. Toni Storm and Saraya had attacked Dr. Britt Baker, whom Ruby Soho visited in medical later in the show. Soho was adamant that she had nothing to do with it, and only wanted to check on Baker's condition, but she has worked for WWE before.

Teasing alignments ahead of an expected faction war that provides the division with focus, depth, and a firm, overlapping direction, this was not not intriguing.

Advertisement

5. Konosuke Takeshita Scores His First Big Win

AEW

In a very fun if shallow match, Konosuke Takeshita completed his Kenta Kobashi-adjacent arc; after impressing in several narrow defeats, every last one of which was awesome, he finally won a big match on TV. It was a hoss spot-fest with little in the way of narrative tissue - Cage's signature match - but an at-times spectacular version of it. It elicited the gasps that this genre offers at its best; the big power bombs were ludicrous, in a good way, and a red-hot crowd popped for their ability to pull off a big dumb blockbuster.

Advertisement

Takeshita needed this win on this night because he's set to work MJF next week. The idea that he's finally hit form will enhance the drama of that more important match. It's still a formality, but this result better enables suspension of disbelief in the moment. Fans will want Takeshita to win, which will also work in its favour.

Was Cage a slightly underwhelming choice for the moment?

Advertisement

Possibly, but the timing was right, and after the MJF match, everything Takeshita does will take a far more interesting turn.

4. Grapplef*ck F*cks

AEW

In which the real importance of pro wrestling commentary announced itself.

Advertisement

Excalibur and in particular Taz were crucial to the viewing experience here; Bryan Danielson and Timothy Thatcher's subtle, super-intricate match was elevated by the announcers' ability to articulate the forensic technique that drove the drama. It would still have resonated as a very, very good match that wasn't especially difficult to follow, but sometimes a wrestler's perspective is needed. This exact genre of match needed a level of insight, honed by actual in-ring experience, to put the otherwise imperceptible strategy over the top.

Violent and nasty, Timothy Thatcher's approach divides opinion - are his faces intimidating, or silly? - but they worked here to provide a genre that isn't particularly TV-friendly a bit of much-needed theatre. Thatcher (logically) targeted Danielson's shoulder, which he bent in gruesome, unnatural positions throughout in addition to adapting his usual repertoire, with various arm-traps, to compound the agony.

Advertisement

Danielson escaped and emerged with the pyrrhic victory, one that lessens his chances of going over MJF at Revolution - but the Dragon still has the cardio advantage.

That dynamic is developing nicely.

Advertisement

3. MJF Shows Ass

AEW

In another contrived element of the angle, the audience was told to stand by for an interview with MJF. Rush was being interviewed. MJF interrupted. Unless the show is fake, the commentary team weren't to know this.

Advertisement

Still, MJF was on great form; describing his own Spanish as "Cómo se dice...mid", he asked Jose the Assistant to translate his offer of a bounty. Rush accepted with a monologue. In an amusing moment, the self-loathing that lurks within MJF surfaced. "Dipsh*t, translate" he said to Jose. After the mild controversy of the Takeshita promo, MJF showed ass.

He was the idiot, the dipsh*t, who can't begin to speak a second language. His comedic timing here was cracking. He resented doing it. It was written all over his embarrassed face.

Advertisement

2. TBS Title Match Over-Delivers

AEW

Apparently butchered by a commercial break, the Fite feed was watched to inform this review, so Jade Cargill's amazing walking press slam wasn't minimised in picture-in-picture. For the yanks, though, this wasn't on. It's often the women's match that seems to exist only as a sponsored payment vehicle.

Advertisement

That spot was nevertheless fantastic, and Red Velvet's performance from underneath was so spirted that she just about earned the visual pin. Jade and Velvet have always shared a strong chemistry, and it was apparent again here. Unfussy, with little of Jade's usual clunky hesitation, it was a more dramatic and hot match than much of Jade's back catalogue. Velvet's brief glimmers of hope got the crowd rolling, but Jade easily put her away by the finish.

That should be the end of this Baddies storyline. Hopefully, Kris Statlander isn't too far away from a return; much as what was shown of the match over-delivered, this TBS title reign peaked a while ago.

Advertisement

1. A Godly Main Event

AEW

Darby Allin Vs. Samoa Joe was a snuff film.

Advertisement

Darby entered the ring wearing a jacked studded with thumbtacks. In a tremendous spot, one brimming with that magic, only-in-AEW creativity, Joe neutralised it using the towel he always carries to the ring.

This excessively violent, terrifying match was an unreal, demented spectacle in and of itself and a promotional masterclass. This was Tony Khan operating in prime Paul Heyman "accentuate the positives, hide the negatives" form.

Advertisement

While Joe is far from some of the plodders that Heyman contrived to get over in the mid '90s, he's also far from the wrestler he used to be. Khan sensed this, and in programming him with the most demented bump machine in the game, he cast a resourceful magic spell. Contrast this ultra-dramatic insanity with Joe working Karrion Kross as if both men were wrestling underwater.

There is absolutely zero comparison. Khan at his best is a genius promoter and matchmaker.

Advertisement

The punishment Allin took here was gruesome even by his standards - without even taking into account those table bumps, Joe at various points threw Allin out of the ring like a fan had tossed in a beer can to his irritation - and it all worked to rehab Joe's monster aura to a level not witnessed since his mid-2000s heyday. At one point, Allin took a horrifying spill over the ring steps and somehow conspired to land on his feet after his momentum took him over the guardrail. It looked like a WWE2K glitch, like Joe was capable of inflicting physically impossible levels of punishment.

At the finish, after Allin spent too long exposing the wooden boards, Joe pulverised him with a muscle buster on the unyielding surface. In every definition of the word, that spot was f*cking sick.

Advertisement

An unpredictable, dramatic, barbaric, exhilarating slaughter, this was a video nasty. Ban this sick filth.

Or don't, because it was absolutely incredible.

Advertisement