8 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Nov 9)

Saraya proves her worth, Bryan Danielson is a master, and you just don't know about that MJF...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

Full Gear needed to be sold on Dynamite last night.

Advertisement

MJF Vs. Jon Moxley needed something more than a mystery angle, or at least it seemed that way last week. It's not AEW's fault that TNA existed, and that its unforgettable awfulness has seeped into the brains of fans anxious over the threat of an Aces & Eights-adjacent plot development, but still: cliffhangers drive TV, high-stakes conflict drives big PPV matches.

The JAS Vs. BCC storyline has peaked, and while it isn't bad, it's hardly unmissable fare. Was booking a match in which one upcoming PPV World title contender had to lose...twice...a good idea? Chris Jericho's motive for the four-way match was actually quite sound, by the standards of this sort of thing, but should it be up to him?

Advertisement

Beneath the World title scenes, the build has been uneven. Toni Storm Vs. Jamie Hayter was strong stuff in both backstory and their teased physical interactions, and the prospect of Powerhouse Hobbs Vs. Wardlow instantly possessed that timeless, almost hypnotic quality of a heavyweight fight - but the Acclaimed's act while fun hasn't resonated with the credibility of the best title reigns.

Did this week's show intensify the hype?

Advertisement

By subverting what usually sells a big event and deepening an already intriguing mystery, yes it did...

Downs...

2. Full Gear Party Match Doesn't Feel Worth Going To Yet

AEW

Jay Lethal Vs. Trent was a fine-to-good match highlighted by some committed and pleasingly brutal bumping, but it was inessential pretext to a strange miss of an angle.

Advertisement

The Jeff Jarrett stuff feels better in the ironic sphere of social media than it does on TV at present.

AEW capitalising on Jeff's carny rep and delivering the catharsis within weeks that TNA wouldn't do for years is great, opportunistic booking, and the visual of Sting eating a chair shot as an unaware Jarrett struts away will make for a neat comedy spot at Full Gear, but his appearance on Dynamite this week wasn't up to much. He's meant to be the preeminent master of the carny dark arts. They're in his blood.

Advertisement

This is made difficult to buy when he can't time out a TV segment properly. Or was that the joke? If so, it didn't land, and neither did a guitar shot. Shouldn't he have raged at the production staffer who was winding him down? Wasn't a weapon shot there the while point of the bit? He didn't actually go long on a promo again, did he?!

A very confusing segment of television, during which it wasn't a good idea to take the piss out of WWE. Get your own house in order first, etc.

Advertisement

1. A Bad Tease Of A Match Nobody Wants

AEW

Christ, the latest chapter in the story of 10 was an atrocious advancement of a monumentally bizarre, contrived and weightless story.

Advertisement

The original idea, in what is now a drastically altered timeline, was for Andrade to attempt to recruit 10 into the AFO. It was bad and redundant enough to begin with; a routine AEW means of, one would expect, building to Andrade Vs. Hangman Page at Full Gear. Page defeated Rush to further what was a cliched means of booking an upper midcard "banger". Then, Andrade was put on ice after trying to get himself fired by assaulting Sammy Guevara, and after that, Page suffered a concussion in his match against Jon Moxley. The whole thing collapsed, it was a parody of an AEW storyline to begin with, and now it's...back on, for f*ck's sake, with Rush playing the role of Andrade.

Rush still wants 10 in what AEW can't bring themselves to call the RFO because they know full well this b*llocks - their longest-running storyline outside of the Elite's saga! - is just that.

Advertisement

John Silver called Rush a Rushbag, and if this thing needed to get any worse, he used a pun-based "more like" insult that a WWE creative writer would think is lame.

Ups...

8. A Fun (If Unfocused) Opener

AEW

FTR and the Acclaimed Vs. Swerve In Our Glory and the Gunn Club was a pleasing start to the show in and of itself, although it did a better job of showcasing the tag team division than the World title match at Full Gear.

Advertisement

Dax Harwood was on sublime form again, between his early suplex barrage and one of the better "if you know you know" spots of the year - and even if you don't know that Road Dogg was dumb enough to put himself over Bret Hart on his worthless podcast, it was still funny watching Austin Gunn cosplay as a culture-appropriating, mid-air-humping, deluded f*ckwit before Dax tried to shred his ligaments via Sharpshooter. This Bret > Road Dogg spot was the highlight of a match that while very fun didn't approach the exhilarating mind-melt of the best AEW multi-man matches. It wasn't paced nor plotted with that signature brilliance.

Also: Tony Khan has a near-infuriating habit of telegraphing certain narrative developments, and it is blindingly obvious that Swerve In Our Glory won't make it past November. The very, very subtle tease of an FTR Vs. Acclaimed match felt bigger than the one we're getting in just over a week, too. That isn't ideal.

Advertisement

Still: f*ck Road Dogg.

Star Rating: *******

Advertisement

7. Very Compelling Full Gear Main Event Build

AEW

Is this the hardest to call main event in the history of AEW on PPV?

Advertisement

There's a lot going on here, and as you'd expect, it was all delivered brilliantly.

Let's unpack:

Advertisement

In a pre-taped promo, MJF discussed his story of being overshadowed by fate. Matt Hardy's near-death experience; a neck tattoo; a press conference: he resented it all and vowed that it wasn't going to happen again. The rhythm, poise, and conviction in his delivery was incredible, even by his standards. He will be an unreal babyface one day, even if that day isn't Full Gear. He straddled that ambiguity masterfully here.

Immediately following that, Stokely Hathaway cut a pre-taped promo of his own, promising to see MJF "in hell" - but isn't that where MJF, the self-professed "Devil", knows he needs to be to get to the top?

Advertisement

Later in the night, the mystery deepened. Jon Moxley cut a promo that touched on MJF's internal moral crisis but zoned in on how much of a devil his challenger really is. His delivery was also fantastic, and his line of questioning maintained a long gestating thread: how authentic is MJF, really? William Regal smiled devilishly throughout - was he cheekily suggesting that MJF was only good at playing the villain, or does he have something up his sleeve? We were once again reminded that Mox all but ended Regal's in-ring career.

This eyeballs emoji storyline beat might well hint towards the Full Gear finish, but who knows at this point?

Advertisement

Nobody, and that's the hook: while an intense personal conflict sells a big fight better than any other device, this compelling mystery is so layered at this point that you will pay a premium fee to finally get the answer.

6. The Full Gear Eliminator Tournament Starts Strongly

AEW

Eddie Kingston Vs. Ethan Page was a good match with a bold result.

Advertisement

It won't please many, because it was thought bad enough that Chris Jericho defeated Kingston. Ethan Page, who would star in a promotion that hadn't signed main event-level talents in the double digits over the last 18 months, is not on Jericho's level. Nor is he on Kingston's.

The action was strong, particularly after the commercial break. Page is a willing and animated bumper, and because he's such a large man, Kingston looked spirited and tenacious for lifting him off his feet. The slug-fest was snug and well-paced, as you'd expect from a Kingston exchange, and Kingston was "protected" when Stokely Hathaway distracted Bryce Remsburg, who missed Page tapping out. It was cheap, and once again contradicted the "Paul Turner must tighten up the officiating" storyline, but they arrived at a far better and cleaner means of protecting Kingston at the finish: that avalanche Ego's Edge was a terrifying kill-shot.

Advertisement

Flawed, but good, and there's little to worry about as it pertains to Kingston: this was a continuation of an interesting new phase of his arc. His head isn't right. He's better than this, he just doesn't believe that presently.

The redemption is happening, and this has enabled the Page push in the meantime.

Advertisement

5. Subverting The Pattern To Great Effect

AEW

Tony Khan has a tendency to really let his storylines burn slowly. To tremendous effect and with the most suitable character, he subverted one of his favoured patterns last night.

Advertisement

After thrashing Ari Daivari in an open challenge, Wardlow took the microphone and summoned Powerhouse Hobbs. He told his rival that he might want the TNT title, but it's going nowhere. He's never going to lose it. In fact, he wants to win every title in the company. This is when ROH TV champion Samoa Joe struck. Booking this angle so close to Full Gear was a great choice. It makes the presumed Wardlow/Hobbs a 50/50 prospect, since Wardlow can pursue a different title in the event that he loses. It also changes that assumption, which drops a hook for next week's show. It was also great from a character perspective.

Joe isn't the type to stew or agonise over such a dilemma. He doesn't care about the friendship because he felt patronised. The very second he wasn't perceived as a threat, he became one. Really good, atypical stuff, and a one-off, double gold, triple beefburger of a hoss fight is as cool a prospect as an informal monster division.

Advertisement

Any direction this takes will rule.

4. The Women FINALLY Get Some Weighty Material

AEW

The segment building to Saraya Vs. Britt Baker was exceptional - or very close to it. The woman received the spotlight and used it sell a match that feels like it could not possibly mean a thing more to them. It is everything to them. Baker was on great form.

Advertisement

She dislodged the tongue from her cheek and put over her opponent and the gravity of the occasion without losing the crucial thread of disrespect that informed Saraya's response.

That response was uneven, as frankly a lot of her work in AEW has been thus far. She felt like the heel at first, and should have grasped in the wake of the All Out press conference that fans have a near reverent respect for the talent credited with making AEW what it is today. But then her voice cracked and a flood of emotion broke through it, and her promo evolved from shaky and ill-advised into something special and thoroughly believable.

Advertisement

You'd have to be something close to a sociopath not to respect Saraya's journey to get here. With a slight tweak, this could have been perfect. Saraya should have said something to put over the fact that Britt did eventually earn the forced push. It's not as if it would have detracted from her own journey.

As it happens, it was, as the very least, more than worthy of the go-home standard.

Advertisement

3. Jamie Hayter: Championship Material

AEW

Jamie Hayter Vs. Skye Blue was a surprisingly good and competitive match that was possibly best saved for a different episode.

Advertisement

The action was limp at some points and impactful at others, but rather than being uneven, it was paced nicely and the crowd started to get into it. Blue's code red variation was impressive and drew a big pop before Hayter obliterated her face with that awesome ripcord lariat. While Hayer probably shouldn't have been tested this much by a performer nowhere near her level in storylines - particularly ahead of the biggest match of her career - this was nonetheless a promising glimpse her of her potential as champion.

This is what champions do: they make lesser opponents look strong without denting their own credibility.

Advertisement

A strong night for Hayter, even if wasn't the sort of strong you'd expect at this point in her story arc.

2. Bryan Danielson: Pro Wrestling Genius

AEW

Bryan Danielson is a genius.

Advertisement

He used his shoot medical history to intensify the anxiety that Guevara generated through his heat spot, which itself was such a great meta touch. Sammy opened up a gaping hole in Matt Hardy's head with that exact flying chair shot stunt in the summer of 2020.

A welcome departure from a worked brain injury - if only because he's told that story already this year - Danielson was savvy enough to draw from his gruesome history with Takeshi Morishima and sold, to startling effect, the possibility of a second detached retina. In a happy byproduct of this narrative choice, a double-down cross body spot looked all the better for being slightly awkward. Danielson couldn't see. The match was better in general as a result for not looking the cleanest.

Advertisement

In a further brilliant wrinkle, the story told was mutually beneficial. Guevara was an intentionally reckless, excellent heel here, and the fans were more than willing to buy that story beat. Danielson, barely able to see, played the role of a wrestler so instinctively great that he worked out where his opponent was intuitively to enable several, super-dramatic cut-offs. His Busaiku knee counter out of the corner was fantastic, as was his headbutt rampage moments earlier. Once he knew where Sammy was, naturally, he chose not to let go of his head, bludgeoning it into a pulp with his own.

While it wasn't quite the cleanest match, execution-wise, when it hit, it literally hit: Sammy's fall-winning GTH was as full-on as it gets. A great, emotive contest evolved into something exhilarating by the final three minutes: a spectacular exchange of moves fuelled by Guevara's desperation in the face of the dragon rising again. At times, booking Danielson to put over and mentor young technical prodigies can feel like a waste.

Advertisement

At others, like this, it makes sense: if there is a way to bottle his magic and attempt to impart it to others, you grab the nearest lid.

1. Less Bullsh*t To Which We've Been Subjected Recently

AEW

Without being blow-away great throughout, this week's Dynamite was much improved in the quietly important department of "How much tired trope-y b*llocks was on this show?"

Advertisement

While the usual interference reared its head, five of the six matches ended cleanly, even if they weren't entirely pristine throughout. Just one backstage promo was interrupted, and that angle was actually consistent with Lance Archer's character. He has spent his entire AEW tenure running amok and destroying people backstage. Nothing felt rushed, like they'd ran out of time; the main event was allowed to register as both a Bryan Danielson masterclass and Sammy Guevara rehabilitation.

Full Gear took shape, and feels, in part, like the most unpredictable pay-per-view AEW has presented thus far.

Advertisement

The refs are still stupid, the rules still inconsistent, but this was a more bold night than many cynics have come to expect from the promotion of late - and the Women's division might actually be on its way to relevance at long last.