8 Ups & 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Dec 18)

“Hey, f*ck me, right?” - Paige.

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

Did SmackDown require a "shake-up"?

Advertisement

Becky Lynch became The Man, and Daniel Bryan was made New, through two mea culpas: less politely, WWE f*cked up their heel turn and reintroduction respectively. But, in awesome collaboration with those acts, Becky and Bryan are the two hottest things in all of wrestling right now. WWE's much-maligned main roster is producing some of the the best content anywhere...

...and now we're being told the show isn't good even by WWE's standards. What?

Advertisement

More profligate than perfect, the blue brand creative regime has failed, miserably, to maximise Andrade Cien Almas, SAnitY, and even Tye Dillinger, whose jobber role provides, or should provide, reprieve from 50/50 booking. SmackDown, nonetheless, is both the Land of Opportunity and the Land boasting the best women’s scene in all of pro wrestling, the best World Champion in all of pro wrestling, and an invariably entertaining doubles division immune to stale repetition through an injection of massively creative talent.

Ultimately, to spare RAW from further embarrassment, WWE had to carry the storyline over to Tuesdays.

Advertisement

"RAW is particularly bad, because Vince McMahon pays most attention to it" is too honest a subtext even for this really strange exercise in atonement.

Yes, you’ll miss Andy Murray—I do too—but he returns in the New Year, and I’m his actual sensei.

Advertisement

Downs...

3. Shane McMahon: The Worst

WWE

It was difficult to give even one f*ck about this "New" SmackDown when WWE missed the entire point, and defied their own narrative, before the show had even started.

Advertisement

"The days of absentee management are over," said Triple H on Monday's RAW, who incidentally was absent from SmackDown. We want absentee management. We don't want Shane McMahon to "empower" his roster, and demand they grab the brass ring as, all the while, they read out somebody else's sh*t.

Imagine listening to this trust fund f*ckwit, if you were in that pack of maverick talents. This guy, who gets off on cosplaying as a badass wrestler as if he is literally five years old, is telling a roster that they are accountable, under the pretence of "reality", when in reality, they aren't. They all looked like supplicant drones just 48 hours removed from a pay per view they rocked the damn dome off.

Advertisement

Basically what we're saying here is absolutely f*ck Shane McMahon.

2. Paige Not Here

wwe.com

In that opening segment, it was revealed by Shane McMahon that Paige is no longer the General Manager of SmackDown, despite, in kayfabe, promoting an acclaimed television show and doing what Stephanie McMahon claims to have done without screeching unadulterated horsesh*t in our ears: Paige, in spearheading the SmackDown Women’s division, has in storylines managed a scene all the way to the WrestleMania 35 main event.

Advertisement

Maybe that’s what did her in.

Paige, who remains on the books in an as-yet-undetermined role, will be much-missed. If we must endure the authority figure trope—and we must—she was virtually the perfect choice for it. Benevolent and passionate, Paige existed on the periphery to make matches based on Superstar rank and fan sentiment. Proving a great, no-bullsh*t counterpart to the likes of The Miz, just one of several acts with whom she shared a winning chemistry, Paige enthusiastically oversaw the show without being overbearing about it—and without making the babyfaces look like dweebs under the broadest, most damaging means of squeezing out a sh*tty narrative.

Advertisement

And now she’s gone.

1. The Miz Is A Dork Now

WWE.com

The Miz, throughout 2016 and 2017, emerged as a key player, post-brand split.

Advertisement

Surviving the post-NXT landscape with the resilience and vile nature of a cockroach, the A-Lister soared in excellent, deeply personal high-stakes rivalries with Dolph Ziggler, and did WWE-style comedy far better than most with his wonderfully robotic impersonation of John Cena.

Now, the worst of WWE comedy has rendered him a punchline. The “gag” here is that Miz is unwittingly using the language of romance in his pitiful attempts to partner up with Shane McMahon. Here, in a segment with Vince, he told Vince that he and Shane are going through a “rough patch”. “Trust issues”. He also asked Vince, the father of the bride lol, to give him his “blessing” for their tag team. Vince refused.

Advertisement

This is probably for the best: knowing Shane’s in-ring activity, if they were to become romantically involved, Miz would be on the receiving end of a brutal rabbit punch.

Vince ended the segment by closing his office door in Miz’s face—closing the door also on his days as a serious proposition.

Advertisement

He was nonetheless afforded an opportunity to date Shane by partnering with Mandy Rose in a mixed tag team match opposite R-Truth and Carmella. This…wasn’t good: Rose and Carmella’s feeble exchanges looked deeply amateurish, significantly less coordinated than the seven second dance break, and your #30 entrants to the Royal Rumble matches and Mixed Match Challenges were defeated in about the same time as Corey Graves would last in Mandy Rose, the witless, unsettling pervert.

Ups...

8. A Mixed But Ultimately Decent Opening Segment

WWE.com

Becky Lynch cut a typically swaggering, badass promo at the expense of Ronda Rousey—to which Charlotte Flair interrupted to lay out her rematch credentials. An opening talk segment loaded with interruptions—just the three—hardly represents a “fresh start”, but then, two of WWE’s best talkers were promoted effectively, and even Asuka, in this context, reclaimed some of her old, invincible aura.

Advertisement

The problem, as it always is, was Vince McMahon.

He remonstrated with Becky and Charlotte—“Get over it!” were the words he used—and neither woman was permitted to banter him off. The idea of Becky telling Vince to “shut his mouth” was a Steve Austin comparison too far in 2018.

Advertisement

Ultimately, this was another very, very welcome removal from the nihilism-fostering automatic rematch clause trope—even if we were then presented with a match “right now”…

7. It Was A Good Match, Though

WWE.com

A segment featuring Asuka and Naomi that wasn’t a cringe comedy of racially dubious misunderstanding? It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas.

Advertisement

Naomi’s athleticism added not inconsiderable drama, as she avoided Asuka’s vicious, sudden striking game with crisp, fluid movement in the opening phase. The ring generalship of the Empress allowed her to maintain control; her creative reversals and terrifying native tongue trash talk unglued the crowd as the pace settled.

Asuka, casting the crowd seductive looks, seemed renewed out there. Naomi, more unheralded for her creativity, used the barricade to launch a kick in Asuka’s face—a sequence that ended with a rare, believable count-out tease.

Advertisement

For a TV match, this told a quietly good story: Naomi, buoyed by this unexpected opportunity, was too impetuous to mount a serious challenge, and fell at Asuka’s cerebral counter game. Laid out with a back-and-forth template, Asuka emerged looking like a real Champion by kicking out of Naomi’s finish.

Far from the best Asuka match, this nonetheless effectively heightened an already very good title picture.

Advertisement

6. God Bless Rusev

WWE

Rusev, like the star he is, cut the sort of characterful promo that serves to remind us that some acts are immune to wasteful booking.

Advertisement

He’s barely won a match of note in an age, but when he referred to himself as a “handsome” man—a “hunk”!—he put a smile on people’s faces, which, apparently, is what Vince wants from the millennials he so obviously despises. You can’t not smile when Rusev is in such rich comedic form. Immune also to awful pop culture references, Rusev referred to upcoming opponent Shinsuke Nakamura as “Sonic The Hedgehog”. A useless reference in the mouth of virtually anybody else, Rusev’s Bulgarian brogue put it over as something actually funny.

Later in the night, Shinsuke Nakamura ran a highlight reel of Rusev’s organic Total Divas comedic brilliance. This was actually fresh, as opposed to 2000-style A McMahon In Every Corner Of WWE Programming.

Advertisement

Usually, comedy drives too many Championship programmes; here, Nakamura portrayed Rusev as a clown in order to put forward the idea that he doesn’t belong anywhere near gold.

5. An Overdue Comeback

WWE.com

Nothing special but something necessary, the danger in modern WWE is that its heel performers are so much more entertaining than the babyfaces they’ve no bloody idea how to book—and this leads to endless heat segments that serve only to undermine the supposed protagonists.

Advertisement

Joe, as promised, apologised to Jeff Hardy with an expected bait and switch—so just a “bait”, then—but Joe is such a magnificent, imposing d*ckhead that the familiarity hardly mattered. You could book Joe in a programme with his own mother, and he’d convince us all that he can’t stand the sight of her.

Any analysis of this rivalry, most WWE rivalries, is always going to be centred on the heel—but Jeff was allowed a belated burn of a comeback, in which he challenged Joe’s lack of tangible main roster success.

Advertisement

Ending not in a fatalistic beatdown but a redemptive Twist of Fate, SmackDown continued its vastly underrated streak of presenting absorbing storylines outside of the various title pictures.

4. Let's See How Long This Lasts

WWE.com

After slightly above average TV fare between the Usos and the Bar, a big, near-division wide standoff ensued.

Advertisement

That diminishes the effort put forward, really: in one awesome spot, the drastically under-utilised Karl Anderson devised a killer cut-off spot; as Jey attempted a plancha, Anderson didn’t respond with the customary kick. In a sequence as seamless as it was gruesome, he stomped on his flying head. This was amazing. Karl Anderson is amazing. not that we’d know it.

Sunday’s TLC Triple Threat is as blurred in the memory as it was blurred by an endless exchange of moves, moves, and counters to moves, and more moves. This was the perfect time to put an end to the monotony, and end it SAnitY—SAnitY!—did by destroying the Usos in a believable beatdown worked with piss and vinegar. There was an air of thrown sh*t about this—in addition to the “boss is here, best get to work” desperation—but it wasn’t a rematch. It wasn’t a rematch!

Advertisement

We’ve been here before. WWE’s creative mechanisms are so fundamentally broken that this development hardly inspires hope—but a Fatal 4-Way is at least different to a Triple Threat.

3. A Call Up We Can Get Behind

WWE.com

It was revealed that Mustafa Ali is now officially a SmackDown Superstar.

Advertisement

This is a good decision: Ali’s act borders on the cornball, but he plays it very earnestly and credibly, and the gimmick is refreshingly inverse to how cynical and joyless this company is at its worst. We need a performer of his deep talent and ilk on main roster programming just as much as he needed to get out of that insulting 205 Live contract.

Once his mini-programme with Daniel Bryan runs its course, provided he gets booked—which on this show is no guarantee—Ali is going to make the likes of Shinsuke Nakamura and Andrade ‘Cien’ Almas look like deadly bastards when they kick the ever-loving sh*t out of him. A new breed of enhancement talent, in that he can put potential megastars over in electric contests, there’s scope for a future beyond that too: there are just enough dorky Bo Dallas vibes around Ali to act as a platform for a transition into an abrasively chirpy heel.

Advertisement

Let’s see if he gets booked!

2. An Excellent Main Event...

WWE.com

Daniel Bryan & Andrade ‘Cien’ Almas Vs. AJ Styles & Mustafa Ali fulfilled the fresh start remit accurately and brilliantly: by actually booking the incredible Almas, and injecting a new player into the mix, and not booking a bloody pay-per-view rematch, WWE delivered a main event that delivered pulsating excitement in the present and fascination for the future.

Advertisement

Following another incendiary, unique promo by the New Daniel Bryan, he was in no mood to wrestle a man he had only just defeated on Sunday. Almas was; maintaining the show-wide theme of a roster looking to impress, he almost made a literal impression on AJ’s temple with his just unreal spinning back elbow. AJ looked great here too—it’s as if he too feels renewed, away from his prolonged and too often inconsequential reign with the WWE Championship.

In lovely heel work, Bryan was all too eager to enter the ring with Ali in the opposite corner, slapping him flush in the face in one of several loathsome bully boy tactics. Ali sold them, and Andrade’s disgusting chops, with his inherent sympathy. Because he is a genius, AJ assisted Ali with a somersault plancha timed so brilliantly you’d think they were a tag team. Ali then sold Bryan’s dragon sleeper as if he was about to break his break, and Bryan, who like his alter-ego wastes nothing, applied the utmost pressure before the rope break.

Advertisement

Wrestled in a certain TV gear, and you can’t begrudge that, this headlining match accelerated into something bloody good in the final phase—and bloody unexpected…

1. ...With A Fascinating Result

WWE.com

[Very minor spoiler for the Christmas Day edition of SmackDown follows.]

Advertisement

Mustafa Ali pinned WWE Champion Daniel Bryan to lay claim to his title. Given that the heel champion cleanly pinned AJ Styles at TLC in a rare but very welcome conclusive finish, this hardly damaged the New version of the character. Rather, it produced a new and potentially very intriguing development.

Does this materialise on a January edition of SmackDown—or are we in for a return to a very astute 2000s Royal Rumble trope? In a bygone time, knowing the Rumble match sold the pay-per-view, WWE experimented by adding a fresh midcard face into a World Title match. Though not always successful, this tactic at least provided us with something different, and it helped launch the careers of Razor Ramon and Chris Benoit—and to a lesser extent Dolph Ziggler—as genuine main event propositions.

Advertisement

Bryan would obviously go over in such a scenario, while also providing ammunition to a WrestleMania opponent with a far more dangerous Road to WrestleMania 35. And, wrestled by an in-ring genius, Ali would be put over immaculately in defeat.

And so ended a good episode of SmackDown—not that it needed fixing. Maybe fix what is broke, eh?

Advertisement