8 Ups And 4 Downs From NXT TakeOver: Toronto

NXT delivers superb show once again, daring WWE roster to top them.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

If it’s the Saturday before a major PPV, then it must be time for an NXT TakeOver. And if that’s the case, then it must be time to set the bar at an impossibly high level for the WWE main roster to flail at the following night.

Advertisement

NXT delivered yet another home run of a PPV Saturday in Toronto, putting on multiple matches that just wowed the crowd and sent fans into a frenzy. It was all action from bell-to-bell in nearly every bout, with the main event being a display of brutality you just don’t see in today’s WWE.

Despite high-quality wrestling, it wasn’t all gold stars for NXT, as there were some questionable decisions with the PPV itself and booking decisions during the event. Still, this is easily a highly recommended show in which even a confrontation between matches was a must-see affair. That’s the sort of thing that just doesn’t happen often. It’s a testament to good writing, good booking and great match-planning.

Advertisement

We’ll have to see how SummerSlam fares on Sunday, but TakeOver got things started off on the right foot and laid the gauntlet down. So let’s see exactly how that happened Saturday night. Let’s get to it…

Downs...

4. Pointless Hype Video

WWE.com

As TakeOver began, Mauro Renallo welcomed us, and the lights in the arena went out. Something big was in store… or so we thought.

Advertisement

The lights slowly came up as music built to a crescendo. Was this leading to another over-the-top Velveteen Dream entrance? Was a new NXT superstar debuting in a surprise moment? Then the answer came:

It was a PPV hype video playing on the big screen.

Advertisement

The video itself was fine, but the build-up led to the complete opposite of what you’d expect. A hype video could show on the full screen for the viewer, not from a bunch of camera angles inside the arena. (And besides that, who videos a hype video?)

It’s a minor point, but it was a misfire to start the show with an odd dodge like that.

Advertisement

3. Wrestling At Half-Speed

WWE.com

After watching the first three matches of TakeOver: Toronto, the NXT Women’s Championship match felt like it was being wrestled in molasses… or maple syrup, since it was in Canada.

Advertisement

The bout between Mia Yim and Shayna Baszler was wrestled at half-speed, and it was also noticeably sloppy, with miscommunications, slow-motion transitions, and lulls that played to silence. The idea that both women had injured arms factored partly into that, but it just didn’t work at all.

It’s understandable that not every match can be full speed ahead, but if you’re going to do something like this, you need to have a better game plan than Yim and Baszler did. It was far too pedestrian and just didn’t work from an entertainment perspective, nor did it from a wrestling clinic perspective.

Advertisement

It’s disappointing, because Shayna has been solid in the ring for the most part, and Yim seemed to be gaining momentum on NXT TV. This was somewhat baffling.

Advertisement

2. Questionable Booking Decisions

WWE.com

We’ll get to the matches themselves in the ups, and match quality was off the charts (as usual), but we have to call attention to the decision to have all four champions retain their titles Saturday.

Advertisement

Many fans speculated that things were setting up for Adam Cole’s prophecy for the Undisputed Era to be draped in gold to finally come true… only that didn’t happen. Bobby Fish & Kyle O’Reilly lost their tag title match to the Street Profits, while Roderick Strong didn’t win his North American Championship bout. That left Cole to defend his NXT Championship, which he successfully did.

In the other title match, Shayna Baszler inexplicably held onto her NXT Women’s Championship, which we’ll get into more in the next item.

Advertisement

But with a PPV where it was very easy to envision three titles changing hands and it being extremely logical and beneficial to storylines, the fact that none changed hands makes it baffling. The Profits, for example, have been on Raw for several weeks now, so why do they still need the NXT tag titles? Velveteen Dream is long overdue to bring his experience to the main roster too.

This was just confusing.

Advertisement

1. What Was The Point?

WWE.com

Perhaps the biggest ongoing storylines in the NXT women’s division has been Shayna Baszler’s reliance on her running buddies Marina Shafir and Jessamyn Duke to save her NXT Women’s Championship time and time again.

Advertisement

So logically, when a babyface wises up and takes out the two lackeys, you would think that would mean that the heel champ who has needed those underlings would be susceptible to losing her title, right? Right?

Wrong.

Advertisement

Mia Yim took out Shafir and Duke in the weeks prior to TakeOver and resorted to some underhanded tactics of her own during Saturday’s title bout – pulling hair, gouging the eyes, etc. – and incapacitated Baszler’s right arm, and she still couldn’t win the title. Shayna pulled out the win with a submission via leg triangle.

What was the freakin’ point of all the build-up? Months upon months of Baszler holding onto the title because of her friends would lead you to believe that this would be the time she loses, when she’s all alone and against someone willing to bend the rules herself.

Advertisement

Instead, she just pulls out the win again. Storyline logic be damned. It’s a baffling thing from NXT, which usually is pretty good about this sort of thing.

Advertisement

Ups...

8. Dawkins Shows Some Fire

WWE.com

Throughout their existence as a tag team, the Street Profits have been a feel-good, have-fun duo, and that’s perfectly fine. But sometimes, you have to show you’ve got that competitive edge, and we got that right out of the gate.

Advertisement

The NXT Tag Team Championship match opened with Angelo Dawkins and Kyle O’Reilly squaring off. O’Reilly made the mistake of calling the Profits a joke, and Dawkins snapped. The Curse of Greatness grabbed Kyle and shoved him into the corner, screaming, “Who’s a joke?!?” at him before patting the top of a frightened O’Reilly’s head. (Montez Ford’s facial expression of shock in the background was gold.)

O’Reilly then naturally did what any good heel would do: slap Dawkins and immediately retreat into the ropes.

Advertisement

It was a nice little moment that told you something about the characters, something WWE often falls short with.

7. Canada’s Hero

WWE.com

Whenever you’re watching an NXT TakeOver, you typically can count on the Velveteen Dream to deliver a memorable entrance, and Saturday was no exception.

Advertisement

With TakeOver emanating from Toronto, Dream’s entrance began with an old, familiar theme blaring, “I’m the Mountie!” as several mounties came out on the stage. The music then switched and the mounties shed their coats and hats to reveal the NBA Championship Toronto Raptors dance squad, who performed for a couple minutes before the Dream came out. It was a nice break in the action and a wonderful intro that played off its surroundings perfectly.

Give it up for Velveteen, who continues to deliver the goods both before and during the match.

Advertisement

6. Shirai Remade

WWE.com

One of the legit criticisms that can be levied against WWE is when they turn a wrestler from face to heel or vice-versa, very little actually changes. Sure, they might change their outfit and even their entrance music, but when the bell rings, it’s still the same person.

Advertisement

Io Shirai, however, has undergone a complete transformation of character. A technicolor superstar sporting a mask to the ring while bubbly music played, Shirai shed all of those to become a black-clad villainess with strobe lights and booming house music.

But inside the ring Saturday night, Io showed an aggressive side we’d rarely seen in NXT. She taunted Candice LaRae throughout the match, showed her up and preened about it, and attacked with more vicious moves (suplex on the table, Camel Clutch, Air Raid Crash, Koji Clutch to finish).

Advertisement

The result was a different Shirai than we’ve seen for the past year, which is what you really want when you have a heel turn, not like we get when Natalya or Big Show turn and the only difference is whether they smile for the fans or tell them to shut up.

5. Riddle, Dain Whet Everyone’s Appetite

WWE.com

Only having about five TakeOvers a year featuring five bouts each makes it difficult to squeeze in a lot of different stuff, but NXT managed to add a nice teaser Saturday night.

Advertisement

As the announcers prepared to move to the NXT North American Championship match, Matt Riddle came out to the ring to call out Killian Dain, who had attacked him previously. Dain obliged, and the two had a pull-apart brawl that saw them both fight off security as they continued to tear into each other.

Dain ultimately got the upper hand by jumping off the stage with Riddle on his back through a table stack, leaving the Original Bro laid out.

Advertisement

The match is for a future episode of NXT, but this was the kind of thing that would send a casual fan to check it out when it comes up. Nicely done.

Advertisement

4. Tag Team Bout Builds To Frenzy

WWE.com

As the NXT Tag Team Championship match between the Street Profits and the Undisputed Era began, it felt like the two teams were on slightly different pages to start.

Advertisement

But as the contest progressed, it quickly became clear that they were in sync and putting on a hell of a match. Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins each spent time on the receiving end of a heel beatdown, but there was plenty of back-and-forth action, with Ford’s crazy athleticism on display. Kyle O’Reilly’s striking offense also got a nice showcase as always.

A really fun highlight came when Ford appeared to go for a People’s Elbow – to a huge reaction from the Toronto crowd – only to be cut off. So Montez fought off both men and proceeded to nail a Rock Bottom on Bobby Fish – for a close 2 count.

Advertisement

The Profits would retain in a solid opener, with only one drawback: Ford spent a lot of time in an O’Reilly heel hook, but he ignored the damaged ankle later in the match, which was a little disappointing. Still, it was a really good match to kick off the show.

Advertisement

3. Squash Becomes All-Out War

WWE.com

When Io Shirai suplexed Candice LaRae onto the announce table about a minute into the match, you couldn’t help but think we were headed to Squash City.

Advertisement

The early part of the match was all Io, and you kept waiting for her to put LaRae away. But then the match swung the other way, with Candice getting some nice offense in herself, including a tope DDT, brainbuster and an Octopus. She delivered a vicious reverse spike rana on Shirai that brought fans out of their seats for a close 2 count.

However, Io was not losing her first PPV match as a heel. A top-rope Spanish Fly, moonsault and Koji Clutch finished LaRae in what turned into a really good, hard-hitting women’s match.

Advertisement

The main roster women should watch this match and take notes.

Advertisement

2. And Still…

WWE.com

Good luck trying to describe all the action in the triple threat NXT North American Championship match. It just ain’t happening.

Advertisement

Pete Dunne, Velveteen Dream and Roderick Strong went at 100 kph at TakeOver: Toronto, tearing into each other with series after series of high-impact, hard-hitting moves. They had some unique combos, like Roderick using a Strong Hold on both men at the same time, Dream breaking up a Dunne triangle by hitting a Coast-to-Coast elbow drop on him,

And even though Dunne returned to take the pinfall loss, it took a Dream Valley Driver, End of Heartache and then a Purple Rainmaker to put him down.

Advertisement

Basically, when you looked at this match on paper, it looked phenomenal. And then the three wrestlers went out and delivered.

Advertisement

1. Gargano, Cole ‘Fight Forever’

WWE.com

What can you say about the Adam Cole/Johnny Gargano main event?

Advertisement

Some will likely hate the match (or at least the caged third fall) because of how they kept kicking out of increasingly vicious and violent moves. But this writer was all-in on the rising aggression and never-ending action. It was cringe-worthy (in a good way), non-stop action from beginning to end, with classic wrestling to open, a street fight in the middle, and an ECW-style caged brawl to close it out.

Both men showed their familiarity with each other by their counters, and then with how they attacked each other. If you enjoyed their earlier bouts, then this was a great conclusion to the trilogy. Cole managed to get the win, but it was a lucky break for him, rolling over after he and Gargano plummeted from the top of the cage through a table.

Advertisement

If you didn’t enjoy the match, that’s your loss, but no hard feelings.

Advertisement