8 Wrestling Exceptions That Prove The 'Top Guy' Rule
The rule exists because world champions like these were so rare.
If JBL had to build a WWE superstar from the ground up it would look like Randy Orton. If Vince McMahon had to build a WWE superstar from the ground up hed probably lock himself in the factory like Willy Wonka, play Q Lazzarus Goodbye Horses on a loop and serenely walk into the lake of baby oil and muscled torsos.
The big man likes his men big. He likes them big, tumescent and rock hard. He likes them that way so much hes willing to give any guy with the look a golden ticket and near infinite chances to get over and become a top guy. This has led not surprisingly to the misconception that these bumpy, vascular fancy boys are predisposed to make it as top guys in the wrestling biz.
The criteria for top guys also demands obedience, malleability and marketability. The only game in town wont pull the trigger on a top talent unless they display a winning combination of these traits but some wrestlers who made it to the tippy top didnt really come out of that sycophantic, oily cookie cutter.
Heres a list of eight mold breakers that by their very existence highlight how ingrained this top guy convention isand make you question its validity.
8. Chris Benoit
The Canadian wrestler had credentials. He wrestled all over the world, affiliated with two wrestling dynasties in the Hart family and the Guerreros and when that bell rang he would work a frenetic strong style that would make the cheap seats wince for his opponents. Dont let Hugh Jackman fool you though, Wolverines are notoriously small.
Billed at around 5 ft. 11in, with perma-scowl and missing teeth, it would be fair to assume that the 'Rabid Wolverine' would need more than a cursory glance to ascertain his main event value. Another downside to prospective promoters was his mic skills. Benoit could cut your basic fired up promo and thats about it.
His unsurpassed work ethic combined with a deep respect for the traditional values of the wrestling business eventually led him to gold, crying in the ring with best friend and also champion at the time, Eddie Guerrero.
From reports about Benoits demeanor backstage, an argument could be made that his old school mentality and unwillingness to politic may have delayed him as much as his size. One thing is for certain though, Chris Benoit was a believable champion and if anybody challenged the conventions on the aesthetic of physicality, it was him.
7. Daniel Bryan
Theres no way we can go on without talking about the ultimate Cinderella story. Bryan represents a dying breed of territory wrestlers and was a veteran long before he graced the squared circle in WWE. Similar to Benoit, Bryan is shorter than your standard American football player and this was for some reason still a problem in 2014.
Transitioning from other sports is great for your career. All your accolades are exhaustively listed every time you pop up, but for career pro-wrestlers like Bryan, achievements and experience are largely redacted. Bryan was put into the first ever NXT and allocated to his pro, The Miz. A mismatch certainly but we saw something interesting from the violent vegan. He was a wolverines whisker less aggressive than Benoit but on the mic he was a good deal less uncomfortable and more versatile.
He jumped into many a silly angle throughout his time and despite not factoring into Vinnies plans much he played ball and got over in the most unexpected ways. Eventually he earned his moment and with a completely unified universe behind him, he reached the summit.
Known for exciting matches, tireless charity work and insane crowd reactions, Bryan could have redefined the industry if he just had more time.
6. Shawn Michaels
Being Shawns height in the 90s was a much bigger deal than it is now for prospective top guys. He was part of the new generation that were the first to weaken the misconception about the land of the giants. The main reason he makes the list is actually not his size. A unique entry on this list, HBK is an exception to the rule based on his extremely unruly nature and backstage actions. He and his clique have been rumored to starve wrestlers who offended them by using Shawns pull with the boss to impede their progress.
Known for his tantrums as much as his ability, the showstopper was at the head of confrontations with the public and with the boys in the back. He was largely hated by his contemporaries and despite causing a lot of problems for many; he was insulated from fallout by Vince.
When rumors abound that The Undertaker watches your title match with taped up hands in case you decide to lose your smile before doing the job, you probably arent the blueprint for top guys after you. Shawn surprised everyone with how many opportunities he was given and unlike most it had nothing to do with his biceps.
5. Rey Mysterio
Tiny. Tiny, tiny, tiny. And ethnic. Not to say these things get you squashed but Rey Rey had to get out from behind two of the boss blind spots when it comes to talent. Vince apparently loved Rey and saw a lot of potential for exciting matches and exhaustive branding. Sounds too good to be true, right?
The smallest man on this list, Rey Mysterio the second of his name actually found success because of his differences from other main eventers. He represents a harmonious relationship between the giants and the smaller guys. And for a while, the crowd was a sea of Mysterio masks.
He does prove the top guy rule perhaps more than anyone in his matches. Despite his white hot luchador skills, the party line was that Rey was the underdog in every fight he was in. His selling ability, skill and connection to the fans made these potential squash matches David vs. Goliath every time. Bringing high stakes and must see feel to all of his feuds.
Beating Luchadores and Heavyweights alike and even holding the big gold belt, Mysterio perhaps perpetuated the reductive stereotype about size in the WWE, but he proved that you can get out from under it.
4. Bret Hart
The Excellence of Execution led the new generation in 90s WWE. He successfully carved out his own substantial niche of fandom in a time where Hulk Hogan, the top guy that started this rule, dominated the landscape.
Bret set precedent for non- ginormous beefcakes making it to the top of the mountain but like his contemporary Shawn Michaels, he was also known for his at times less agreeable attitude. He was making record guaranteed money at a time when few were and was less than satisfied with passing the torch to his bitter enemy HBK.
This set the stage for the most controversial event in wrestling, but beforehand Brett was a megastar. He was one of the first megastars to have been raised in the business. Kids loved him for his values, women loved him for his looks and men loved him for his incredible and believable in ring style.
He was weak on the microphone and was more argumentative than malleable but he was not such a huge departure from your standard main eventer. The time in which he came up was pivotal. He may be the largest man to set the table for the little guy.
3. CM Punk
Much like Daniel Bryan, CM Punk is one of two wrestlers that made a huge and iconic impact on the world of wrestling despite managements best efforts. Punks achievement in this regard is yet more impressive given how disagreeable he is.
Size was much less of a problem during the Punk years than it was in the 90s and early 2000s but he did have that mark against his name going in. Another indie veteran, he came up in his first match with Justin Credible and made himself and his opponent look very, well, credible.
His attitude is well documented, though hes also famous for objecting to erratic behavior that Vinnie endured at the hands of Michaels. The straight edge internet darling was perhaps judged by the kind of fandom he attracted. It was not long however before he won the respect of colleagues, whether they liked him or not.
Punks main departure from his glistening, high-protein contemporaries was his willingness to air dirty laundry in public. Punks mic has been cut off several times and he has visibly infuriated the likes of Triple H and Vince for a definite shoot. Given that Roman Reigns is being pushed in a post Punk world really exposes the backwards logic behind building a star.
2. Eddie Guerrero
No other man could have taken a gimmick like Latino Heat and made it work so well. This singular performer received criticism in WCW from the seven foot tall Kevin Nash who famously called Guerrero a Vanilla midget. This is the kind of climate that Eddie operated in and this is the kind of climate that he made every cocky beefcake look very foolish.
Billed at a pedestrian five feet, eight inches, Uncle Eddie had a defined upper body and very thin legs. He was Mexican, from a famous wrestling family who arent the McMahons and he had inherited the famous Guerrero temper. He battled addiction for years and entered WWE as a 33 year old employee of the enemy promotion.
Swimming against that tide anybody else would have floundered. His absolutely genius cheating and cocky attitude resonated with fans and he eventually made it to the title picture. Normally It is not well received by us internet marks when a fan favourite must cheat to win but he got it over.
They would never make Roman wriggle out of his boot to steal a win and while caveats like this protect the top guy rule, this man could make a packed arena cheer for it.
1. Mick Foley
Mrs. Foleys baby boy! This manthese men are the polar opposite to Vince McMahons blueprint. Remember that horrific Wonka world of fake tan and eroticism I mentioned? Well Mick Foley is the guy who broke in, trashed the thong room and got rolled into the boiler room by the Oompa Loompas.
Mick once dreamed of being the handsome wrestling Lothario that Vince always dreamed of. Hed have the looks, the charm and the prowess. This would not work out. Not right away anyway. He entered WWE earless and toothless. So Vince covered his face with some old belt and let him do his thing.
His brutal self-destructive style was grueling, but he quickly won the love and even respect of the attitude era fans. All four faces of Foley were far removed from the Top Gun volleyball scene template, but self- sacrifice, a genius ear for promos and the ability to reinvent himself kept him relevant, marketable and truly loved.
After his rough retirement, Vince gave the lovable psychopath his WrestleMania moment. He shared the main event many times, but Foleys success was earned many times over. What he had to do to be the man proves the rule, but my God, what an exception.