8 WWE Tag Team Stars Who Couldn't Cut It As Singles

Sometimes you just can’t make it on your own.

By Lewis Howse /

There's absolutely nothing wrong with being a career tag team wrestler. Hell, some guys have gotten their place in various professional wrestling Hall of Fames based on their work in doubles competition. Wrestling needs tag teams and some guys were just made to work in pairs.

Advertisement

Few get into the business hoping to become a tag team lifer, however. While some may want to emulate the success of their heroes (how many guys getting into the business name the likes of the Road Warriors and the British Bulldogs as inspiration?), they must also harbour a desire to go it alone and make a name for themselves, by themselves.

Regrettably for those performers, a great tag team wrestler does not a great singles wrestler make. Oftentimes, a tag teamer will split from his partner only to fail to cut it in the singles ranks, bombing badly. Sometimes, this will happen over and over again to the same wrestler, cementing their status as a tag team guy for life.

Whether it was because of politics, bad timing or the fact that the audience just wouldn't accept them on their own, these eight guys were all pretty damn good tag team wrestlers who couldn't move past that and attain singles glory. 

8. Billy Gunn

Ah, Billy Gunn. No matter how many times WWE tried to position him as a major singles star, it just never quite seemed to work. He was destined to remain in the tag team scene, were he enjoyed considerable success with numerous partners.

Advertisement

Billy boy's first tag team stint was with 'brother' Bart, as a member of the mid-90s friendly Smokin' Gunns. The Gunns were a solid midcard act and captured the WWE Tag Team Titles three times in their three-and-a-half years together. The inevitable split occurred and Billy moved on to a doomed 'Rockabilly' gimmick, with Honky Tonk Man as his manager.

'The Real Double J' Jesse James realised that both of their careers were going nowhere and so the two formed an alliance. Really, this was WWE management just throwing two guys together because they had nothing else for them to do, but they made the best of it and completely turned their careers around.

The New Age Outlaws, as they became to be known, were one of the most over acts of the Attitude Era, so over that they found themselves becoming members of the ultra-popular D-Generation X group. Billy had some great times as a member of DX, but WWE brass always viewed him as a future singles star.

He was taken away from the group, dubbed 'Mr. A**', won the 1999 King of the Ring and entered into a feud with The Rock. Regrettably, Gunn was outclassed in that feud and it did nothing for his reputation. It was, in fact, a setback and he soon found himself teaming up with The Road Dogg again.

By the time Gunn returned from a shoulder injury in the fall of 2000, WWE had decided to try their luck with him once more. Now known as 'The One', Gunn was given an Intercontinental Title reign and placed in main event scenarios and, while he was over, it didn't last (which he later claimed was due to the backstage politics of Triple H).

It was a familiar story from them on, with Gunn finding himself teaming with Big Show, Chuck Palumbo and then Hardcore Holly in between half-hearted singles pushes, before he was released in November 2004. A brief singles run in TNA as The Outlaw didn't set the world on fire, either.

7. Albert

Oh Albert/A-Train/Baldo/Prince Albert/Jason Albert/Tensai/Sweet T/Hip-Hop Hippo/Matt Bloom/Giant Bernard, you just never seemed to find your true self, did you?

Advertisement

The hairy-backed one debuted in WWE in 1999, teaming with Droz. Unfortunately, Droz was paralysed during a tragic in-ring accident later in the year, and the team were split. Albert then briefly teamed with Big Boss Man, before Bull Buchanan came along and took his place.

The multi-pierced one landed on his feet, however, being recruited by newcomer Trish Stratus to form a team with Test, known as T&A (geddit?). The team were an ever-present in the tag title division and were rather successful, contesting well-received feuds with The Dudleys, APA and Hardy Boys among others.

The team split in early 2001 (WWE had big plans for Test) and Albert spun his wheels a little before hooking up with X-Pac and Justin Credible to form the unbelievably lame X-Factor stable. Once that sh*t show had run its course, Albert began teaming with Scotty 2 Hotty. They were strictly opening match material, but had a goofy sort of chemistry.

And then came the serious attempts to repackage Albert, now known as A-Train as a singles star. John Laurinaitis was so high on him that he overlooked the popular and talented Matt Hardy and placed him in a feud with Edge. Then the Train was given high-profile feuds against The Undertaker and Chris Benoit.

Regrettably, he failed to get over like management had hoped and was quietly released a short time later. Following some great years working for New Japan (where he formed another tag team with Karl Anderson), Albert returned to WWE in 2012 as main event heel Tensai.

The gimmick was a dud and Albert bombed in the role. So guess what happened next? They put him in a tag team, first with Santino Marella and then Brodus Clay. Both were fine for what they were.

It was obvious that the current head coach at the WWE Performance Center couldn't make it on his own and only really flourished when he had another person by his side.

6. D-Von Dudley

Unlike many of the names on this here list, D-Von Dudley didn't really hop from one team to another with any sort of regularity. He has spent most of his career tagging with Bubba as the Dudley Boys. You might say that they've had a pretty decent run, all things considered.

Advertisement

But there was a period of time where D-Von was forced to fly solo. Well, almost. The 2002 WWE Draft separated the former WWE, ECW and WCW Tag Team Champions as Bubba went to Raw and D-Von moved to Smackdown. Bubba continued to do his usual thing, often teaming with Spike Dudley, whilst D-Von was given a totally new gimmick.

He was now 'Reverend' D-Von, a crooked preacher who enlisted the help of his muscle and sometime partner 'Deacon' Batista to help him win matches. The pair split pretty quickly, though, and D-Von hooked up with Ron Simmons in a short-lived team that screamed 'we have nothing for these two well-respected veterans but still want them on the show'.

It didn't take WWE long to realise that their experiment had failed and they reunited the Dudley Boys at Survivor Series 2002, six months after they were forced to go their separate ways. While Bubba did manage to have a successful singles run as Bully Ray in TNA, D-Von has yet to prove that he can get it done on his own.

5. Charlie Haas

Charlie Haas debuted as a pro way back in 1996, teaming with his brother Russ. The two were signed to a WWE developmental deal in 2000 but, sadly, Russ died of a heart attack in December 2001. The Haas brothers had been working house shows and dark matches before the tragedy and it had looked like the plan was to bring the duo up to television shortly.

Advertisement

The graduate of Seaton Hall University would be brought up a little over a year later, as a member of Team Angle. He was paired up with another amateur standout, Shelton Benjamin, and wrestled in place of leader Kurt while the Olympic gold medalist recovered from injuries.

Once Angle turned babyface, Shelton and Charlie split and went out on their own, re-christening themselves The World's Greatest Tag Team. The team were getting better every week and put on some great matches in 2003/04, but were split up when Shelton was drafted to Raw in March 2004.

Charlie floundered for a while before he was put into a tag team with first Rico and then Hardcore Holly. Both were perfectly fine midcard acts but WWE released Haas in July 2005, due to budget cuts. They brought him back in April 2006, tag teaming with Viscera of all people, before easing back into his old team with Benjamin.

They broke up once more in November 2007 when Shelton was drafted to ECW and Charlie floundered, eventually doing a gimmick where he parodied other wrestlers (Haas Hogan, anyone?). That went nowhere and, after months of not doing anything, Haas was released in February 2010.

Haas was a good, solid worker but completely unremarkable in many respects. He was a great tag wrestler and enjoyed his best years (early 2003 - mid 2004) when teaming with Benjamin, but when he was left to his own devices, he failed to get over and make an impression.

4. Road Dogg

Oh, you didn't know?

Advertisement

Road Dogg, like his New Age Outlaws partner Billy Gunn, was definitely built to be a tag team wrestler. Completely unremarkable when left on his own, he was able to highlight his positives and hide his weaknesses when paired up with someone that complimented his style.

A member of the legendary Armstrong wrestling family, Road Dogg began his WWE career as 'The Roadie', assistant to would-be country singer Jeff Jarrett. The two rarely teamed, however, with Roadie reduced to accompanying his man and interfering in his matches.

When Jarrett left for WCW, Roadie was left with nothing to do and formed a last-gasp tandem with Billy Gunn. This really was WWE just throwing them together and seeing if they could sink or swim. Thankfully, for them, they were enormously successful and this period is undoubtedly the high point of their careers.

The cornerstones of the Attitude Era went their separate ways, though, and Dogg began teaming with DX stablemate X-Pac. Theirs was a short-lived union, and Road Dogg soon formed another team with newcomer K-Kwick (R-Truth) in late 2000.

Personal problems resulted in RD getting released from his contract and he later resurfaced in TNA. He was no singles star there, either, usually teaming with either Konnan or former partners Truth and Gunn. He never really got a bite of the singles cherry but when he did (such as the spring and summer of 1999 when he went after the IC and Hardcore Titles), it never really went anywhere and management soon lost interest.

3. Jim Neidhart

The Anvil was brought into the WWF from Stu Hart's Stampede promotion as a singles wrestler managed by Mr. Fuji and, incredibly, actually faced his future tag team partner 'Cowboy' Bret Hart in a series of matches early on in his run there.

Advertisement

The Hitman, upset with his go-nowhere and ill-fitting gimmick, suggested to Vince McMahon that he team him up with Neidhart, and thus the Hart Foundation were born. They were one hell of an act, too, with Bret's technical prowess gelling nicely Neidhart's explosive power.

The two had a good six-year run, capturing the Tag Team Titles twice. It was obvious that Bret had the qualities and potential to be a singles star, but what to do with big Jim? He commentated wrestling challenge for a while post-split, before forming the New Foundation with Owen Hart.

That run was brief, with Neidhart being fired for unprofessional conduct in February 1992 before it could really get off the ground. He came back a little over four years later, and reformed his team with Owen, before being let go once again due to unprofessionalism.

His next return was as the masked WHO, which was basically an excuse for Jerry Lawler and Vince McMahon to make bad jokes on commentary ('Who's on first' etc.). Needless to say, it didn't lead to any championships and he was gone soon after, brought back again to act as a member of the Hart Foundation stable in 1997 before moving to WCW in January 1998.

Neidhart never amounted to much as a singles wrestler. His matches weren't particularly exciting or anything and he usually needed someone else in there to mask his shortcomings.

2. Rick Steiner

It might seem strange to call a three-time World Television Champion and United States Champion as being a guy that couldn't cut it, but the fact is that Rick Steiner's title reigns are long forgotten, didn't make any impact at the time and that he will always - ALWAYS - be remembered for his awesome partnership with brother Scott.

Advertisement

The real-life badasses and amateur standouts are one of the most decorated in professional wresting history and were great workers to boot. Indeed, the Steiners were one of the best, most exciting tag teams on the planet in from the late 1980s to the early 90s, as their plethora of classics from NWA/WCW, New Japan and the WWF attest.

The two split in 1998 (it was due), with Scott going on to adapt the effective Big Poppa Pump character. Rick, on the other hand, just kind of bounced around from storyline in between spells on the sidelines with injury. His most notable contribution during the final couple of years of WCW was his bizarre interaction with psycho doll Chucky and his run of unnecessarily roughing up opponents like Konnan, Lash LeRoux and Kwee Wee.

Truth is, nobody wanted to see the slow, plodding and broken down Steiner out there by himself. They were only really interested when he was tagging with brother Scott. It's no surprise that The Dog-Faced Gremlin's star faded as the Big Bad Booty Daddy's started to shine bright.

1. Marty Jannetty

Poor Marty Jannetty. His lack of solo success, coupled with the amazing, Hall of Fame career of his former partner Shawn Michaels, has led to him being the defacto measuring stick when it comes to gauging the success of a tag team once they split from one another.

Advertisement

How many times have you heard someone referred to as 'the Marty Jannetty' of a team? It's a shame, really, because the former Rocker was a talented worker in his own right and didn't exactly have a dud of a career in WWE. It has to be said, however, that whenever he was without a tag partner, he struggled.

Jannetty's best period was undoubtedly teaming with HBK, although he only won WWE tag gold when he began tagging with 1-2-3 Kid in 1993. His biggest shot at singles stardom was in a feud with Michaels, but that was brought to an abrupt end when he was fired following the 1993 Royal Rumble, apparently because Vince McMahon and WWE management felt he was under the influence of drugs or alcohol, leading to the low quality of the match.

Curt Hennig apparently convinced Vince to rehire Jannetty a few months later, telling the boss that the match was actually a stinker because of the Showstopper. Jannetty captured the Intercontinental Title but dropped it back to Michaels a few weeks later and it was back to the tag ranks for him.

A low point came in 1996 when he and Leif 'Al Snow' Cassidy formed the New Rockers (putting the word 'New' in front of something is never a good idea in wrestling). Jannetty was so unimpressed with his lot that he asked for and was given his release.

In his mind, the team should have been broken up so that they could feud with one another and forge singles careers. WWE, however, felt that Jannetty had received a crack at singles stardom in the past and had failed to take advantage of it.

In their eyes, he was a serviceable midcard tag team wrestler and little else.

Advertisement