9 Great Wrestlers Who Were TERRIBLE At One Specific Thing
Even the greatest performers to ever lace up their boots have one specific thing that they suck at.
No matter how great any of your favourite entertainers are, perfection is nothing more than a concept. Your favourite bands have bad songs, your favourite actors and directors have made bad movies, and your favourite wrestlers have holes in their game. Even the biggest legends to ever grace the squared circle have things that they suck at. It's a fact of life.
This list features nothing but in-ring legends (and Vince McMahon's son). They have provided a litany of classic matches over the years, so many that they appear to be damn near flawless, but all of these wrestlers have one specific thing that shows that they are human after all. It may not be enough to harm their legacies, but we are here for nitpicking at even the greatest of in-ring performers.
So, from People's Champs to Best Bout Machines and two separate workers to have called themselves The Best In The World (one with a far more credible claim to this than the other), these are some of the greatest wrestlers to ever grace a wrestling ring, who have one specific thing that they are terrible at.
9. The Rock
The Rock is all about personality in whatever he does, but this applies to his in-ring work more than anything else. Whatever 'The People's Champ' lacked in wrestling prowess, he more than made up for with his ability to pop a crowd. Not so great at technical wrestling? Who cares when your kip-up makes thousands of people lose their minds, and the Spit Punch works like a charm.
Even armed with the knowledge that The Rock is more dedicated to showmanship than technical endeavors, watching him do The Sharpshooter was a painful thing to behold. 'The Great One' knew how to apply all of the drama to slapping the move on an opponent, but it always looked aesthetically terrible. Loose and cumbersome, it was perhaps not a great idea to steal a move from one of the greatest in-ring technicians of all time.
It's a bizarre addition to his regularly used array of moves, because so much of what The Rock does is all about popping a crowd. The 'Spine On The Pine', 'The People's Elbow', and the 'Rock Bottom' are all basic moves, but are incredibly pleasing on the eye. Best to leave 'The Sharpshooter' to the professionals.
8. Shane McMahon
OK, so calling Shane McMahon a great wrestler might be a stretch that's stretchier than Stretch Armstrong doing an Abdominal Stretch on Stretch Street, but it doesn't mean we can't point out how ludicrous some of Shane O'Mac's in-ring work was. Despite being an integral part of the Attitude Era with some great feuds under his belt against the likes of Big Show and Kurt Angle, his rudimentary wrestling has aged over time like mouldy fruit.
Shane has had a long-standing and well-documented love of all things MMA, and that was to his detriment when it came to throwing punches in the squared circle. It's unclear as to whether or not Shane thought he was adding a dose of realism to his punches in his later years, but he was much more convincing when prancing around, swinging his arms around like a broken clock and throwing jabs than he was at making his heymakers look like something to be feared.
Fans will always be able to look back fondly at Shane's daredevil stunts and being thrown off of really high structures, but his punches remain the stuff of nightmares.
7. Kenny Omega
They don't call him 'The Best Bout Machine' for nothing. Kenny Omega is one of the most justifiably revered wrestlers of his generation, and by the time he hangs up his boots, he will go down as one of the most legendary in-ring performers of all time. That said, even the best of the best have parts of their game that seem to annoy the hell out of people.
Detractors of 'The Cleaner' have often been irritated by the facial expressions that Kenny pulls during matches. As the Canadian made his name for himself in NJPW, he is one of the Western superstars who fully embraced Japanese culture in a way that some fans from the US, Canada, and Europe found hard to accept.
Omega is on record as having a big love of Anime and fighting games in which characters are known to pull extreme facial expressions. Kenny has always employed these aesthetics in his matches, and that seems to be an acquired taste for some fans. Wrestling is a bombastic art form. Even still, Omega's application of extreme snarls and wide-eyed facial contortions has always been a source of annoyance for a very vocal set of fans.
6. John Cena
It feels very 2013 to be criticizing John Cena for anything he does inside the ring. Cena has always been an easy target for those who have a preference for in-ring technicality, and there's a list as long as The Great Khali's arm of gripes that have been aired ad nauseam over the years. Most of them are valid, but almost all of them miss the point that John had a gift for putting the "entertainment" in Sports Entertainment.
Even with that caveat, it is genuinely hilarious how loudly Cena calls his spots inside the ring. The likes of WWE: Unreal and a 24/7 news cycle that constantly updates fans on what's going on behind the curtain have long killed any sense of reality to any aspect of pro wrestling. Nevertheless, hearing John shouting "hit me in the back" and "duck the clothesline" as loudly as the in-house commentary team is distracting in the extreme.
The choreography of pro wrestling is an art form in itself, and Cena's success and litany of classic matches speak for themselves, but Cena bellowing "kick me" is objectively ridiculous.
5. Edge
Across his WWE career, Edge had audiences spellbound during his matches. A great in-ring storyteller who was able to draw extreme emotion from the audience across the singles and tag divisions, few performers of his generation could generate heat or gasps of wonder from crowds of all sizes quite like the 'Rated R Superstar'.
This only makes it more surprising that his finisher lacked finesse. Edge's Spear always looked flat, especially after he sold the upcoming move so brilliantly, usually crouched in the corner of the ring with maniacal expressions. Sure, he's been slightly bailed out on this by the calamitous Spears employed by Jey Uso over the last year or so, but when you existed on the same roster as Rhyno, it was impossible to ignore the lacklustre detonation of Edge's Spear.
If we're looking for kindness towards the 'Ultimate Opportunist', we will always have Edge's expert selling of his mid-air Spear from a ladder onto Jeff Hardy at WrestleMania 17. That's a rarity, though, as the majority of Edge's Spears look less like being hit by a train and more like being soft tackled by an out-of-breath linebacker.
4. Seth Rollins
Seth Rollins blew WWE fans' minds when he joined the main roster as part of The Shield. After a stellar run in NXT, where he was rightfully made the brand's first World Champion, and his work in Ring Of Honor that made him one of the most respected performers in the world, his reputation was catapulted into the stratosphere as he continued this form in multi-man tag matches and, eventually, a glittering solo career.
Seth's Curb Stomp finisher was one of the most beloved finishers in a generation, but it was outlawed for a few years by Vince McMahon, with McMahon justifiably worried that WWE's younger fans would try the move at home and cause harm, and, let's be honest here, potential lawsuits. As such, Rollins adopted his mentor Triple H's Pedigree as his finisher with far less fanfare.
Triple H's Pedigree worked because of his sheer size and intensity. Seth Rollins is a far more nimble and agile performer, and his Pedigree always felt flaccid and loose in comparison. The Stomp was eventually reinstated, and all was well in the world once more, but the stench of Rollins's Pedigree still lingers.
3. CM Punk
It is often taken for granted how much CM Punk has influenced the style of wrestling that so many people know and love today. Being signed from the indies at a time when working outside of WWE saw talent treated as if their craft was nothing more than a paid hobby, Punk opened the floodgates for performers from Ring Of Honor and the early NXT classes that thrilled a new generation of sports-savvy wrestling fans.
Punk would have to leave moves like the Pepsi Plunge behind when wrestling for a publicly traded company like WWE, and has largely expertly transitioned his style to fit WWE without having to compromise on his personal style. One of the few moves that he worked into his repertoire that doesn't quite land, though, is his top rope elbow drop.
Pointing to the heavens with two fingers raised to the sky, CM Punk's top rope elbow drop is obviously done in homage to 'Macho Man' Randy Savage. Given how integral Savage was to the boom period of the '80s which enabled WWE to become the juggernaut it is today, Randy has been woefully underappreciated by the company. Even if Punk's elbow drops aren't to the standard of the originator (or the stunning one employed by Kairi Sane), the tribute is admirable in its intention.
2. Lance Storm
Oh, sure, let's criticize one of the greatest wrestlers of the 1990s and early 2000s while we're here. Lance Storm is one of the most respected workers to ever grace professional wrestling. What he lacked in mic skills and charisma, he made up for tenfold with an eye-watering array of moves and a technical proficiency that any wrestler lacing up a pair of boots should aspire to.
It's nice of Lance to remind us that he is in some way human by being completely unable to use a steel chair. This wasn't so bad when he worked for WCW and WWE in the latter part of his career, but it was undoubtedly a hindrance while he plied his trade in ECW. Known for extremity so much that it was literally in the name of the company, being unable to wield the most popular illegal foreign object of all time was far from ideal.
If you doubt us, just look up "world's safest chair shot" and watch Lance hitting Rob Van Dam with a chair like he's trying to break the top of an egg to dip his toast into.
1. Bret Hart
Bret Hart is arguably the most respected in-ring performer of the televised era. The man is so talented that he could put on a five-star classic with a mop. In fact, 'The Excellence of Execution' is so revered that people continue to pay tribute to him by stealing his spots and moves to this day. Nobody really complains about it either, because if you're going to steal, you may as well steal from the best there is, was, and will be.
It's a peculiar gripe for some of his detractors to have, but pay attention to 'The Hitman's matches, and Bret often walks around with his mouth completely ajar. It doesn't affect the quality of his work whatsoever, but it has proven to be a jarring visual element to his vast array of classic matches for some.
Bret's mouth gaping like a fish out of water has proven to be aesthetically distracting for some of wrestling's more pinickity fans. It's present in almost all of his matches, so it's not an unfounded criticism, but it does feel a tad harsh, given that Bret is a contender for the greatest wrestler of all time.