Over the years, professional wrestling has been heavily influenced by the world of horror. Dating back to the days of Bruiser Brody and Ox Baker, there has always been an element of madness and terror in the business, helping to create characters that have kept fans on their toes. Some of the most iconic and enduring gimmicks of all-time were created with the intention to strike fear in the hearts of the audience. The Undertaker, Andre the Giant, Psycho Sid, Mankind, Jake Roberts, Kane...the list goes on and on. However, this propensity for trying to craft innovative, fearsome gimmicks has also resulted in some of the most laughable characters and ridiculed moments the business has ever seen. But, hey, coming up with new ways to scare people is tough (just ask Stephen King.) Sometimes you just have to take a trip to the local Halloween shop, blindfold yourself, and start ransacking the place in hopes that when you reach the checkout counter you'll have enough stray pieces to make a genuinely horrifying creation. As one might expect, this doesn't always go over so well...
Advertisement
9. Vampiro
Ian Hodgkinson was better known in WCW by the name Vampiro. Why Vampiro? Because Ian Hodgkinson is a terrible ring name. The problem with being called Vampiro, though, is that it set up certain expectations for the audience. Namely, that he was a vampire. Which he was not. What Vampiro amounted to was little more than a gothic punk rock enthusiast with a penchant for painting his face to look like a skeleton. He wore a leather vest, sported dreadlocks, and spoke in the type of vague metaphors that would confuse even the Ultimate Warrior. Rather than go full-on with the "brooding Vampire" gimmick a la Gangrel, Vampiro cobbled together bits from every ill-defined monster he could think of, turning the character into a bland (often laughable) character. "Oh...now he likes to set people on fire? So he's a vam-pyromaniac? Sure...that makes sense". Classic Vince Russo, or something. It didn't help that spent a good amount of time as a lackey for Raven and teamed up with The Insane Clown Posse. Hell, WCW thought so much of the character (which had been a major draw in Mexico in the mid-90s) that they let him feud with The KISS Demon.
8. Zeus
Tiny Lister is an imposing dude. He had a look that was custom built for wrestling, what with the six tons of neck muscles and that menacing lazy eye. Unfortunately, he was completely wasted as the meta-wrestler Zeus. Here's how the concept of Zeus came to be involved with the WWE; Hulk Hogan starred in the box-office flop No Holds Barred as wrestler Rip Thomas, who decides to wrestle Zeus in a - you guessed it - no holds barred match (!) to get revenge for his brother, whom Zeus had earlier put in the hospital. In order to capitalize on the non-success of the movie, and presumably because Vince McMahon refuses to admit defeat, ever, he brought the Zeus character into "the real world" to challenge Hulk Hogan in WWE. How did they get the feud going? Simple. Zeus was upset about being billed under Hogan in the promotional materials and having to lose to him on camera. So...yeah, the character of Zeus wanted to wrestle the "real" Hulk Hogan because he fake lost to his fake character in a movie. Look at all the sense that makes. The set-up was quite possibly the dumbest, least effective way to break kayfabe in the 80s. Luckily for the company, no one seemed to notice all the confusing stumbles through the fourth wall.
7. Isaac Yankem, DDS
WWE had apparently reached their quota for generic bodyguard types in 1995, so they decided to give Jerry Lawler's henchmen an absurd backstory to go make him stand out from the Diesels of the company. So naturally they went with "evil dentist" as the de facto gimmick. Because what's more frightening than a guy with ironically bad teeth who wears scrub pants and a white smock? Even children, who are notoriously terrified of dentists, looked noticeably unfazed by the introduction of the drill-wielding dentist (complete with those stupid magnifying glasses and a horrible Jheri curl). Thankfully, this gimmick lasted about as long as Fake Diesel, and Glenn Jacobs eventually went on to play the genuinely fearsome Kane.
6. Giant Gonzalez
Awww, look at that big ol' fluffy giant. He's...he's kind of cute, really. Honestly, it's tough to look at a character like Giant Gonzalez and truly believe that WWE creative thought this was a character worthy of striking fear into the heart of anyone. (Unless those people were terrified of poorly airbrushed onesies.) Putting him in a feud with The Undertaker was the quickest way to discredit any sort of menace Gonzalez was supposed to have, as the mere sight of the legitimately ominous Dead Man alongside this weirdly "nude" dude with removable forearm hair made audiences cringe with awkwardness instead of fear. Ultimately, the former NBA star Jorge González was too sweet of a guy to portray anything other than a lovable giant with a peculiar case of hirsutism.
5. The Boogeyman
Oh, Boogeyman. You had so damn much potential. Remember how creepy those teaser vignettes were? A strange, painted dude with one f**ked up eye crawling out of a child's bedroom closet and whisper-asking, "Do you...know me?". They were pants-sh**tingly chilling. But due to an injury, the character was introduced much later than they intended, and during that time they decided to turn him into the weird kid in elementary school who ate worms to gross people out. Oh! And remember the time he ate that giant mole right off of Jillian Hall's face? That was so stupid and disgusting that it went right full circle into being hilarious, although that's probably not what they had in mind when they scripted it.
4. Kizarny
Kizarny was favorably described as the lovechild of Jake "The Snake" Roberts and Doink the Clown. So right up front, there's a big question as to what level of creepiness this character is supposed to bring into the ring. Is he going to be the dark, sadistic snake-charmer? Or is he going to be the latter stages of the mischievous (but harmless) jester? But when he debuted in the ring against an unenthusiastic MVP (who knew going into the match how ridiculous this gimmick was going to appear), Kizarny showed himself to be little more than a watered-down Even in his initial promos (set against the backdrop of a carnival so saturated with color that even mid-00's Tim Burton would be turned off), the scariest characteristic of Kizarny is that he spoke in a made-up variation of Pig Latin. Watching him in the ring was like watching your drunk, coked-out uncle trying to perform gymnastics in a cluttered foyer. It was a great deal of fun to watch...but for all the wrong reasons.
3. Snitzky
Look, there were some moments of genuine creepiness during Snitzky's second run with the WWE, as the hairless, mentally-unstable sadist. But his initial run with the company will forever be summarized in one moment. This one: When the creative team attempted to play up Snitsky's role in Lita's kayfabe miscarriage (because...goddammit...ratings?), with the big goateed neanderthal taunting Lita about the death of her unborn child (ugh), it became clear in one breathtakingly loony segment during an episode of Raw that they'd run clean out of ways to make this angle seem even more heinous. So...baby punt. That happened. That's a thing that happened and will always be a thing that happened no matter how much WWE tries to downplay it in the future. And it was hilarious. Go back up and look at the gif again. It's still hilarious, even considering the terrible context of it all. It didn't help that he had the acting abilities of a fish sandwich and always talked like a character from a Scooby Doo blooper reel.
2. Mantaur
With a taste for human flesh and a fondness for wearing a giant bull's head to the ring, Mantaur would have been an insanely awesome character if the creative team in charge of creating this gimmick had left the details at that. He's a cannibal who wears a f--king cow head to the ring? That's easily creepier than Kane, even during his best years. But the mask was supremely silly (remember, this was pre-Attitude days, so they couldn't go too far with it) and his entire move set consisted of charging attacks and stomps. Oh, and he routinely "moo-ed" after performing a big maneuver. And rather than get as slyly creepy with the whole "taste for human flesh" thing, they showed Mantaur pigging out at a buffet of foods that were definitely not made from humans.
1. The Yeti
What to say about The Yeti that hasn't already been said about a balled up roll of dirty toilet paper... Hey, when you have a guy who's over 7 feet tall, there are only so many gimmicks you can give him. So why not give him an entirely ridiculous Halloween-themed character to debut at Halloween Havoc? There were many, many problems with this, of course. Not the least of which is that WCW doesn't understand what a yeti is. There are a few interpretations, depending on the region we're talking about, but by and large, a yeti is an ape-like or bear-like man in the mold of Big Foot. A yeti is not a mummy. But semantics aside, the proper way to introduce a creature who's supposed to be even more powerful than The Giant doesn't involve him tag team dry-humping Hulk Hogan in the middle of the ring for 20 seconds too long.