9 Times Wrestling Made You Believe

When the art of wrestling meets the suspension of disbelief, and we forgot it's supposed to be fake.

By Ben Counter /

wwe.com

Wrestling is pre-determined entertainment, something its fans have come to accept ever since the demise of 'kayfabe' during the 1980s. Its scripted nature can help make it entertaining in a way 'real' sports rarely match.

Advertisement

At its best, professional wrestling is high drama as well as an athletic showcase, and like any good play, movie, or novel it has the power to make us forget we're watching a story at all. The very best wrestlers know this, and are as much actors in a stage play taking part in the ring as they are athletes. The WWE is in the business of stories - if it wasn't, everything it produces would be the XFL.

When wrestling makes us suspend our disbelief it can bring out our emotions, confound us with an unexpected turn, or get us thrumming with tension. It's not easy to achieve, and plenty of the WWE's wrestling storylines fail to engage the part of our brain that doesn't care about whether it's 'fake' or not. But sometimes, for a few glorious moments, we forget about the scripted promos and backstage politics.

Sometimes, wrestling makes us believe.

9. Mark Henry’s Retirement Promo

Big Mark’s sorrowful retirement promo came at a time when Edge’s retirement was still very clear in fans’ minds. The memories of that emotional in-ring heart to heart must have been particularly raw when the living menhir, Mark Henry, walked to the ring in wrestling’s most memorable pink jacket, carrying a pair of wrestling boots he was surely about to hang up.

Advertisement

Mark began in the halting, uncertain tones of someone who is speaking from the heart. He mentioned his beloved family as he seemed close to tears. He even acknowledged the ‘Sexual Chocolate’ chants as he addressed the crowd as if they were close friends and colleagues.

We believed absolutely that Mark Henry’s long career was at an end. We believed it so completely we forgot for the moment that John Cena was in the ring with him.

And then we remembered it as Mark Henry slammed Cena through centre of the Earth and inducted him into the Hall of Pain. Not only did we believe Mark Henry was about to retire, we believed that John Cena believed it, too, and that Mark Henry was a nuclear-strength badass by swerving him along with an arena full of people.

8. John Cena Manipulates Us Into A Frenzy At Brock Lesnar’s Return

Cena again, because for all it might be cool to dislike him, he’s really, really good at this. No better illustration can be found than at the climax of the Raw the night after WrestleMania XXVIII. Cena had lost his match with The Rock, who had already emerged for a traditional later era Rock evangelical hype promo. The morose John walked out before a smart and vocal crowd who were hopped up on sugary drinks and the internet rumour that Brock Lesnar was about to re-debut with the WWE.

Advertisement

Instantly, Cena lost control of the crowd. He was supposed to be introducing The Rock for another segment, but the crowd weren't having any of it. "We Want Brock!" they chanted..

"I understand the excitement in the air," said Cena, desperation crossing his meaty face. As he dolefully introduced The Rock amid the catcalls of the audience, it seemed the biggest Raw of the year had completely lost control of its climactic segment.

Then Brock Lesnar’s music hit. The Minnesotan Death Bear stomped to the ring to one of the greatest collective fangasms the WWE has ever seen. He F-5’d Cena, walked away again, and left the crowd so completely in the palm of the WWE’s hand they might as well have been wearing Cena sweatbands.

The crowd believed Cena had lost control. They believed he had finally shed all respect the audience had for him and what he stood for. And he let them believe it, because again, he’s really good at this.

7. Triple H Makes Us Forget To Hate The Rumble

The 2016 Royal Rumble posed a tricky booking conundrum for the WWE. The year before had seen Roman Reigns win to a brutally negative reaction. The year before, similar crowd grumpiness ensued when Daniel Bryan failed to win, or even compete in the main match. Fans were primed to hock a running throat dumpling at whatever displeased them, especially anything Reigns-shaped. That was a problem since Reigns was actually defending his world title in the match.

Advertisement

So what to do? Simple, in hindsight - make everyone forget Roman Reigns. Firstly, Reigns didn't win, which was stage one of the solution to this exam-level booking question. Secondly, fireworks had already erupted when smart mark favourite AJ Styles made a rumoured but still groundbreaking appearance in the Rumble to create a story about someone other than Roman. Thirdly, and perhaps most crucially, Triple H glowered his way to the ring at number 30, an event unexpected enough to take the focus off Reigns. Finally it wasn't Roman contesting the win at the end, but Trips and Dean Ambrose, whose greasily lovable babyface act was a fine counterpart to the boss’ regal douchitude.

Thus, Triple H’s win achieved a rare booking triumph. In the drama of a pretty well-booked Rumble, and especially of a big storyline turn in Triple H’s imperious victory, it made everyone forget they were supposed to hate it.

6. Shawn Michaels Makes Us Care About Him

Shawn Michaels was a difficult man to care about in 1995. His antics as a backstage uber-tool were starting to bleed into audience perceptions. This was, after all, about the time he was mauled in Syracuse, New York by an 'undetermined number' (one) of US Marines who objected to whatever he was getting up to that night.

Advertisement

But his performance in a match on Raw versus Owen Hart got audiences to do the unthinkable - care about Shawn Michaels. After dumping Hart out of the ring, skinning the cat back in and throwing his lunge-n-guns pose, Michaels grabbed his head, stumbled around and flopped unconscious onto the canvas. Hart and managers Jim Cornette and Mr Fuji sold confusion, as after a believably long time trainers got to the ring with bottled oxygen. Even Vince McMahon, not yet fully acknowledged as the WWE's owner, broke his commentator character to get in the ring and look worried. In an era before WCW milked the 'worked shoot' until the concept was dry, the audience had no reason to believe Michaels wasn't really in trouble. It might seem cheap now, but it certainly got its audience feeling concern for Michaels where there was no little hatred before.

5. Nakamura Vs. Zayn Makes Us Forget Zayn Literally Has To Lose

NXT Takeover Dallas stands as one of the several NXT shows seemingly made for a breed of jaded, grizzled wrestling fans who wants indyesque quality as an alternative to the razzle-dazzle of the main roster. Perhaps its most striking offering was the debut of Japanese Michael Jackson/Boa Constrictor hybrid Shinsuke Nakamura, taking on beloved babyface Sami Zayn.

Advertisement

There’s a rule here we need to be made aware of to understand why this match was so remarkable. Before a wrestler is bumped up to the main WWE roster from NXT, they always lose, to put over the guy taking the slot they leave behind. Pretty much everyone in the building knew Sami Zayn was heading to the crimson pastures of Raw, and that he was going to succumb to the man from Kyoto.

And yet, for the length of that match, the audience somehow forgot that Zayn had to lose. The alchemy is hard to pin down, but it surely has a lot to do with Zayn’s top-tier battered babyface performance, with a hint of retaliatory aggression against Nakamura. The two battled back and forth, drawing in the audience with every move. The NXT faithful believed this wasn't a traditional farewell loss by the ginger dynamo. They believed either man could win, that either could emerge from the maelstrom victorious. "Fight forever," chanted the crowd - and that was before it became a cliché.

4. Rusev Makes Us Believe He Can Beat Cena

Cena once again, but this time we’re focusing on the man he faced at WrestleMania 31. Rusev was challenging Cena for the United States Championship, but prior to the event no one could fathom how John Cena, a man as American as cheese in a can, could possibly fail to win the star-spangled title from a grizzly foreign heel. Of course Cena would win. This was WrestleMania, and he was Cena.

Advertisement

And then came the entrances. It started with a volley of salutary gunfire from artillery pieces on the stage as the Russian anthem kicked in and soldiers bore the flag of Rusev's adopted country down the aisle. Lana, in full Rocky IV mode, paraded the title like an ermine-clad Tzarina. And then, Rusev entered.

In a tank.

The WWE must feel a note of regret when they look back on this masterpiece, because they can't do it again, at least not for the first time. Everything was choreographed, not just to make viewers hate the unapologetic Ivan Drago analogue, but to make the audience believe he was a big deal. For the length of the entrances and much of the match, the East was comfortingly evil again. Everyone believed that Rusev was a supervillain, and that he could beat John Cena.

And then Cena won. But for a moment, they believed.

3. Bret Hart Makes Us Believe In Family

Bret Hart isn't remembered for dynamic promo skills, but he didn't need them when he reformed the Hart Foundation in 1997. A heel Hart broke up a match between his brother Owen and brother-in-law British Bulldog, then grabbed a mic and explained to them he didn't care what the audience thought, he cared about family.

Advertisement

Bret's words didn't have to be growled or yelled to be powerful. Owen's eyes teared up when Bret described dressing him for school and helping him with bullies. He called on his brothers to join him as a family again. It was believable because it had a strong vein of reality to it - Owen's tears may easily have been real, and the angle leveraged the genuine family connections of the Hart clan to give Bret's new faction a reason to be.

Hart couched his arguments on heelish terms, as he cursed out an America founded on 'brother versus brother' and rejected the love of the fans for the love of his family. But the birth of the new Hart Foundation was completely believable, because cheap heat aside, Bret Hart was right.

2. Samoa Joe Looks Even More Like A Monster

Blood! Hardwired into the human brain is a reaction to the shedding of claret, rooted deep in the lizard cortex concerned with the basics of survival. A glimpse of the red stuff tickles some obscure ganglion that sparks basic emotions in everyone.

Advertisement

Wrestling fans are jaded to a spot of blood. They no longer live in an era where wrestlers cut open an eyebrow in reaction to a stiff insult, but they still know it’s part of the show, a shortcut to adding drama to a match so overused it barely does anything any more. But blood still has power, as witnessed in Samoa Joe’s NXT Takeover match against Finn Bálor, in June 2016.

Early on in the match, a clash of heads opened a cut beside Joe’s eye, and it bled. A lot. And the match changed. In the minds of the audience, Joe changed. For a moment they saw not a man in a predetermined wrestling exhibition, but a looming monstrosity from the depths of their minds. Joe pushed aside the referees who tried to towel him down. The crowd booed at the interruptions as Joe’s streaming head wound refused to be stemmed. And for a few glorious moments, Samoa Joe was not a man, but an honest to goodness monster.

1. Love Conquers The Macho Man

Randy Savage's match against The Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VII saw the betassled roidebeest defeat the Macho Man in a retirement match. Miss Elizabeth, who had been replaced as Macho Man's lady friend by Queen Sherri during Macho's heel run, was picked out by the cameras in the crowd. As Macho reeled from a supposedly career-ending defeat, Sherri threw a classic hissyfit and chewed out Savage in the ring with a few unladylike boots to the gut thrown in. Cue Miss Elizabeth, who jumped the rail, threw Sherri out of the ring, and faced the man who had rejected her.

Advertisement

Savage acted confused for several minutes, until finally, to the biggest pop of the night, he threw his arms around his former manager in a combination reunion and face turn. The audience's reaction was ecstatic, as if they chose for the moment to believe the love between the two characters had overcome the ancient caste system of face and heel. It was a perfect moment of suspension of disbelief, with the crowd willingly buying into a performance that went beyond wrestling and had everything to do with giving the people what they really wanted.

Advertisement