9 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (5 Oct)

MJF ascends, Jungle Boy dips, Willow Nightingale rules.

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

Last week's flagship TV show approached disaster at points and was brutally flat at others.

Advertisement

Bandido was incredible, Chris Jericho was in masterful veteran form, but elsewhere...no. Two impromptu matches, a crowd that wasn't especially into the action, the sinister threat of an onscreen authority figure: WWE Dynamite was not great. At all.

The thing with AEW now is that, even when it's very good, it still feels bittersweet with the absence of the suspended four. CM Punk's run was incredible, and Kenny Omega had just rediscovered his full energy bar following a superb fitness-based storyline. Beyond that deflating vibe, AEW is drawing criticism for various misfires. Why did Tony Khan fork out for 'Jane' if Orange Cassidy is just going to sort of exist? What happened to the clean, decisive finishes?

Advertisement

How was it even possible for the women's division to get worse?

AEW Dynamite premiered on October 2, 2019, in front of 11,500 paid at the Capitol One Arena in Washington, DC. The three year anniversary celebration, at the far smaller Entertainment & Sports Arena, drew a damning 2,819. That first number was always going to be an aberration, but still. That is some comedown; stark evidence that the halcyon days may well be over.

Advertisement

Did this week's show mark a return to form...?

Downs...

2. A Flat, Basic Segment

AEW

Fuego del Sol has been annihilated in far more interesting ways than he was last night. The Miro and HOOK squashes were significantly better. Even as obligatory pretext to an angle, this was under-baked. It wasn't even basic and violent. Luchasaurus was far better as a babyface.

Advertisement

It was obligatory pretext to an angle, and not a particularly exciting one.

Christian Cage's cheap, localised heat is always very funny, but Jungle Boy came perilously close to drawing "What?" chants from an otherwise engaged audience. His promo was more corny than vengeful, and the combination of his histrionic delivery and the character he's cutting this material against - an evil dinosaur - just feels too fake to convince.

Advertisement

1. Heat On The Booker, Not The Talent

AEW

The main event was excellent - more on that shortly - but allowing Sammy Guevara to take the fall was a bad choice that detracted from what was a vital and reassuring episode of Dynamite.

Advertisement

The details behind the alleged "brawl" are not conclusive. TMZ reported that "Sammy allegedly pushed Andrade" and that "punches were thrown". Bryan Alvarez of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter however tweeted that "many in AEW have disputed the TMZ version and noted that if it was true, it's very hard to believe Sammy would have worked the main event while Andrade was sent home".

Regardless, every fan in the building and online had made their mind up about Sammy. Was this fair? Potentially not. Dave Meltzer strongly suggested on Observer Radio that Guevara was attacked and offered no resistance.

Advertisement

He might well be completely innocent. At the very least, both men, provided they aren't working - and what a terrible work it would be - have acted as a distraction from the fiction that AEW badly needs to get over all over again. Booking a finish almost designed to instigate yet another tedious and damning conversation was a terrible choice. Putting Guevara over was a bad move, irrespective of what happened on Wednesday, because of what happened earlier in the week.

How did this even happen?

Advertisement

Everybody with a brain expected to wake up to the headline 'Sammy Guevara and Andrade el Idolo in Backstage Brawl!' - so how were they even allowed in proximity to one another?!

Ups...

9. A Genius Returns

AEW

MJF Vs. Wheeler YUTA was a tremendous television match, and MJF is phenomenal at making every bump count.

Advertisement

He never just lands on his back and clutches at it because he knows there's a story to tell across every available second. He knows, that as a heel - for now - people want to see him endure pain. Every bump he takes has a certain personality. Sometimes he clasps his hand in prayer the second before impact. Sometimes he falls flat on his arse, like a clown, because watching the jackass get hurt should be funny. Sometimes - later in the match when he needs to get more serous - he looks like he dies upon impact when getting smashed against the barricade. All are incredibly cathartic. MJF's bumps have more personality than several pro wrestlers.

He's also so good that he needn't even bump to command a standing ovation. His warp speed pin trade signature is that of which a pro wrestler dreams: a booming reaction for what is ostensibly a cardio work-out. Getting paid to go the gym, basically. His grasp of crowd psychology was also fantastic here.

Advertisement

YUTA was sensational here too - his fire and wit were such that he was never in danger of losing the support of the crowd, which felt all too possible a fortnight ago - but the trademark MJF match layout worked so well here.

He was an ar*ehole.

Advertisement

He ate sh*t.

This two-chord rhythm was so beautifully simple that he drew a super-dramatic "boo!/yeah!" reaction for the entirety of the match.

Advertisement

AEW is exponentially better off with MJF back.

8. Chris Jericho Is A Wizard, Again

AEW

This was such a small detail, but it indicated the level of thought that goes into even the most mildly amusing throwaway lines.

Advertisement

The Jericho Appreciation Society were interviewed backstage, in a brief segment that built the main event and wasn't interrupted - an 'Up' in itself these days - in which Jericho talked around his being a cheating heel d*ckhead. In a superb deadpan one-liner, Tony Schiavone said "You mean systematic cheating?"

"You say tomato, I say tomato" Jericho said in response. This was such a great bit of interplay between a respected broadcast professional undercutting and not standing for a heel's bullsh*t. The stern, impartial broadcaster is such a useful tool in framing a wrestling promotion as legitimate, and this was an amusing exploration of it.

Advertisement

In another tremendous detail, Jericho explained away what was thought to be a dumnb plot hole last week, maintaining that he actually respects Daniel Garcia's rebellious behaviour, hinting that there's still a way back for him - which is why he didn't lead a gang beat-down last week.

The real Let It Play Out promotion rewards the faith yet again.

Advertisement

7. The Core Purpose Of AEW Returns

AEW

Without being blow-away great - the crowd was somewhat spent, having watched a returning top star blow them away - Darby Allin Vs. Jay Lethal was a solid and quietly, beautifully-worked wrestling match.

Advertisement

The framing of it was just as much of a minor joy. Darby Allin in a pre-tape spoke of this as a simple sporting fixture promoted to determine who is closest to orbiting the title picture. Too little of that is dry, but too much clumsily welding storylines to matches and the whole thing feels contrived. This was refreshing given how convoluted AEW has felt of late.

In a creative and superbly-timed spot, Darby only just avoided crashing into the referee when evading a Lethal grapple. In a nanosecond, putting over the believability of the contest and his own strategic acumen, Lethal chop-blocked Allin's leg. This was great; a small, crucial movement in putting over the cost of a fraction of a mistake.

Advertisement

Lethal's heat sequence was vicious and compelling, and Darby's bumping was as acute and terrifying as ever. He sold throughout the comeback, and while there were shades of numbing distraction to the finish, it at least suggested that the heel triumvirate is on the way out.

Just as well: it's a drab, distinctly midcard act that has never felt close to essential.

Advertisement

6. Big, Dumb (And Smart) Fun

AEW

Brian Cage has always maintained, despite much damning evidence to the contrary, that he actually can cut a promo and that he can operate on the televised stage.

Advertisement

He was right - tonight, at least. His pre-tape, elevated by Prince Nana's wonderful "We in the money!" sing-song - was threatening and assured. His match with Wardlow was such tremendous fun, too. You know what one of the best noises in all of wrestling is?

The earnest, awestruck gasp of a '90s AJPW crowd watching on as one of their Four Pillars heroes takes something ghastly to their head. The Washington crowd sounded something like this when Wardlow rocked Brian Cage with a tijeras. The sound of wonder flooded the Entertainment & Sports Arena.

Advertisement

The rest of the match was a fun, incredulous spectacle - a great contrast to the intricate technical fare of the first two matches, and reminder of the awesome range with which AEW has established itself as a hub world for the entire form. Wardlow busted out his most spectacular aerial yet, and what a worker. He carefully distributes his most eye-catching moves so that his act never feels stale.

The third successive AEW "original" won on an Anniversary special that also played host to a celebration of the ultimate homegrown tag team. This, you suspect, was no accident - and the timing of it was crucial, given recent, creeping narratives. And, on a night on which Tony Khan was determined to bat back the backlash, FTR made the save when Gates of Agony interfered in the post-match. The pop was electrifying.

Advertisement

Really, the whole night was.

5. Hope Springboards Eternal

AEW

On a night defined by recovery, the women's division segment - still not plural sadly, but when is that going to change? - was brilliant across the board.

Advertisement

The trios match pitting Willow Nightingale, Athena and Toni Storm against Jamie Hayter, Penelope Ford and Serena Deeb was a lean, all-action affair that astutely showcased the depth of the division (even if the set-up last week was a criminal, baddies-are-automatically-friends contrivance).

Every performer received a chance to shine, but Willow and Penelope stood out. That's another singles match that needs to happen, after - or hell, on the same show! - as Toni Storm Vs. Athena. The basement dropkick counter from Ford's handspring elbow attempt was so brutal and emphatic. The structure of the match was clever; the audience has been conditioned to not react to women's matches, and they simply weren't allowed the time to turn off. The division needs saving, no hyperbole, and assembling hot, breathless contests that also allow a glimpse into potentially great match-ups puts over the present and builds the future.

Advertisement

Moreover, Dr. Britt Baker simply declaring that Saraya can't wrestle was funny - as if it's up to her, in a great, arrogant bit of character work - and the idea that this means she can is vital reprieve from the dreadful threat of an onscreen authority figure.

Paige got physical, but took no bumps - a far better way of preserving the mystery than hinting at the worst WWE device of the century.

Advertisement

4. This Is What AEW Is

AEW

Fundamentally, National Scissoring Day was silly. Some of the content was, too.

Advertisement

Swerve Strickland carrying a rock bordered on dismal prop comedy - "Ken...do stick" - but the difference here is the acknowledged absurdity of the joke and the willingness and belief to force it over the line with a gag that was simply too dumb and yet too inspired not to smile at.

The rock/paper/scissors thing was the sort of joke that you couldn't not admire. When Smart Mark Sterling walked down to the ring, legal papers in hand en route to his doom, it was impossible not to grin wryly at the composition of the joke, even if the joke itself was naff. The sheer graft that went into it was too impressive. Comedy can be nice like that sometimes.

Advertisement

The visual of a literal flying leg scissors was a joy. A stupid, only-in-wrestling joy. The segment advanced the Acclaimed Vs. Swerve In Our Glory programme, but it was more than a mere angle.

Within the most daft package, this was an entertaining and goddammit, perhaps even profound segment of wrestling television. Watching a room full of strangers become a collective, adjoined by the irresistible slice of wrestling b*llocks that is the scissor hand gesture, was as much why we all watch wrestling and why it is worthwhile as a five star match or a PPV-selling promo. It's a fun and vital escape from the drudgery of life.

Advertisement

Max Caster for president.

3. A Small, Logical Booking Step

AEW

Hangman Page defeated Rush in a match that probably didn't reach its ceiling, but was nonetheless very good.

Advertisement

It was an inspired pairing, of two of the hardest-hitters in the game, and the crowd transformed into the sickos meme for the duration. The chops were disgusting, the action was full-on - a massive "f*ck yeah" is extended to that straitjacket piledriver - although it wasn't quite the brand of exhilarating that compels you to absolutely lose it front of the TV set. It was still a worthy and logical match that further established Page ahead of his big show-down in just under a fortnight.

That prospective match felt massive by the time Jon Moxley exited the ring...

Advertisement

2. Jon Moxley Cuts A Great Promo Even By His Standards

Jon Moxley

Jon Moxley stormed the ring to confront Hangman Page, and magic was cast. This was great - so great that Mox sold buys for a pay-per-view match that isn't even happening.

Advertisement

"Between the two of us, we've beaten just about everybody there is to beat here in AEW - except each other."

That line was exceptional. In just 20 words - where some wrestlers feel the need to drag a point over 20 minutes - Moxley put over himself, his opponent, and the match. His words were credible; there is no top star in the promotion that hasn't eaten a defeat to Page and or Mox.

Advertisement

Kenny Omega. CM Punk. Bryan Danielson. MJF. Chris Jericho. Adam Cole. Eddie Kingston. (Cody Rhodes, having left doesn't really count).

What a great observation, and what a tremendous way of dressing up a TV match as a major, unpredictable contest between the two winningest babyfaces in the history of the promotion. Mox was respectful, threatening and possibly even apprehensive, all at once. This was a money promo.

Advertisement

It's not enough for a promotion to just put on great matches. At its best, AEW Dynamite is an unbeatable blend of in-ring, promos and angles, and this show nailed the trifecta and elevated itself into ep of the year contention.

1. Still, Damn Fine Main Event

AEW

Curious result aside, the main event was damn fine and deserves praise for its storytelling and in-ring performances.

Advertisement

Sammy Guevara, ironically, was on bravura form. He knew when to perform at his dazzling best and, even better, when to show ass when he was undone in his attempts to be a pr*ck. Bryan Danielson chopping him to death was deeply cathartic. Daniel Garcia flexing his pure wrestling ability over Chris Jericho was a choice narrative thread, and the finish - indicating that it was all for nought - was a gripping twist in the ongoing story.

In totality, this was a blistering, multi-layered match that most people have forgotten about.

Advertisement

The wrestling is the most important part of the wrestling show, incredibly enough.

It's time AEW gets back to it on a full-time basis; if every show was as good as 95% of this one was, the battle for perception will be won.

Advertisement