9 Ups & 4 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown
Daniel Bryan's bum reveal sullies Buddy Murphy's big night.
Last night's SmackDown, like the episode of Raw that preceded it 24 hours prior, promised much.
The revived King of the Ring tournament looked set to deliver an exciting high-workrate, feud-ending/continuing clash between Andrade and Apollo Crews as well as Kevin Owens vs. Elias which, at the very least, would keep the Shane McMahon storyline bubbling away. On top of this, Buddy Murphy challenged Daniel Bryan one week after his awesome clash with Roman Reigns, though the former WWE Champion had more than just the old Cruiserweight standout on his agenda: this, after all, was the night him and Rowan had promised to reveal Reigns' attacker.
Did SmackDown deliver?
Yes and no.
For the most part, it was another successful show to continue WWE TV's recent hot streak. This is in spite of its problems. Cracks are starting to emerge in some of the blue brand's biggest programmes. Recent trends have earned WWE the trust to turn it around, but SD's concerns shouldn't be swept under the rug either.
Let's break down every high and low from a show bringing a controversial reveal, Bayley's next Women's Title Challenger, and two in-ringer bangers...
Downs...
4. Chad Gable Is Short
This is literally his own weakness as a performer, so why do WWE keep drawing attention to it?
Slick, charismatic, fun to watch, and with a track record of elevating otherwise uninteresting material, the former American Alpha man is an underutilized undercard gem. He is absolutely somebody WWE could be making better use of and the kind of player the Intercontinental Championship division should be built around, yet reductive height jokes are all the writers can come up with him at the moment.
That wrestlers must be giants to be believable is a minority view in 2019. Perhaps he isn't built to headline pay-per-views, but Gable deserves better. This isn't how you get wrestlers over - it's the opposite.
... and it's coming from Shelton Benjamin, too! That might be the worst part. These guys used to tag together, so surely the former 'Gold Standard' has more on Chad than this?
3. Beating Buddy Down
It makes sense that Daniel Bryan and Rowan would batter Buddy Murphy after the Aussie had upset the former WWE Champion in the ring. These guys are as bitter and twisted as bitter and twisted gets. Of course they'd be upset, and of course they'd want to retaliate.
But that doesn't mean they should retaliate. Not in this context, at least.
WWE gave Murphy the biggest win of his career against Bryan, then decided to curb any momentum gained by immediately having him beaten down backstage. It happened after Buddy's victory over Roman Reigns too. The writers can't let this guy fly without clipping his wings straight after, and it's a shame.
Compounding this complaint is the probability that Murphy won't even get revenge on Bryan. In another storyline, WWE might use something like this as an opportunity to present Buddy as a sympathetic babyface in a big rematch. Here, Daniel's probably still moving on to a match with Roman Reigns, meaning he took his victim's heat away for nothing.
2. This Isn't Kofi Kingston
Last night's opening segment was mostly solid. Randy Orton cut a typically strong heel promo to kick things off, claiming Kofi Kingston ran away from him in front of his wife and kids at SummerSlam, prompting the WWE Champion to take a page from 'The Viper's' playbook and attack him out of nowhere. If it had ended with The Revival running him off immediately after this, it'd find itself on the Ups side of this column.
But it didn't. Instead, Kingston went a step further, shouting that they'd find out "who's stupid" before grabbing a chair, putting it around Orton's ankle, and trying to Pillmanize him. Dash and Dawson appeared before this could happen, getting battered with the chair for their troubles.
Like the Bryan/Murphy situation, it stands to reason that Kingston would be upset and want to take things to the next level after Orton accosted his family at SummerSlam. Again, that doesn't mean he should though.
The WWE Champion doesn't feel like himself when he does things like this. This isn't Kofi Kingston. This isn't the spirited, pure-of-heart underdog we fell in love with on the Road to WrestleMania, or the beloved warrior we screamed ourselves hoarse for in New York. Yes, all characters need to develop, but Ankle-Destroyer Kofi ain't it, chief.
1. It Was Rowan's Dad, Roman...
... it was Rowan's dad all along!
After dragging a hood-cloaked, black-clad man through the building and into a locker-room earlier in the evening, Daniel Bryan and Rowan finally pulled his veil back when Roman Reigns showed up at the end of the night. Turns it out was a Rowan doppelganger. Or a dollar store Kerry King. Or actual Steve Von Till. Take your pick; whichever you go for, it was super lame.
SmackDown closed with all four men sitting/standing around gawking at each other like idiots. Having partaken in one of the wettest reveals in recent WWE history, they had nothing, absolutely nothing, which almost feels grimly appropriate for the situation.
If there's a positive to be taken from this, it's that WWE didn't pull another bait-and-switch by not running with the reveal. Still, this was a flat way to end the show and a momentum hit for an otherwise interesting storyline. Perhaps it'll evolve into something stronger later down the line, but for now, this thing is almost funny-bad.
Ups...
9. This MIGHT Work
WWE's most underutilised wrestler, Sami Zayn, may have been relegated to a full-on managerial role last night. We'll address this potentially massive Down pending further clarification, though there's a chance his new union with Shinsuke Nakamura might work.
Zayn introduced his new ally while guesting on MizTV. After a typical promo railing against "the WWE trap of greed and ambition," he claimed that there were loads of people in the company who need his help. 'The King Of Strong Style' was apparently one of them, and out he came, prompting Miz to prod and pry. This ended predictably poorly for him. Downing 'The A-Lister' from behind, Nakamura laid into him with the Intercontinental Title, kicks, knees, and finally, the Kinshasa, seemingly setting up his next opponent.
It has been clear for the longest time that Nakamura needs a mouthpiece in this environment and Sami is one of the company's best talkers, making this a sensible union. Let's see where it goes before going deep on the underlying concerns.
8. Back In Your Box, Drake
Has the 24/7 Championship division become less fun since R-Truth stopped being the centrepiece? Yes.
Is your writer still thoroughly Sports Entertained? Yes.
This week's silly b*llocks saw Elias roaming around backstage, strumming his guitar. He came across a disguised referee who pointed to a shipping crate when asked "where is he?", and Drake Maverick popped out, mounting his latest ineffective title challenge. 'The Drifter' had bad news for him, though. He handed the 205 Live General Manager a note stipulating that the 24/7 rule had been frozen for the whole evening, so Maverick was stuffed back inside as Elias drifted away.
"I just want to consummate my marriage," Drake whimpered, head wedged under the lid.
This stuff is never going to change the mind of anyone who doesn't like it. It's a nice diversion, though. Maverick is endearingly pitiful.
7. Rowan Metal Shirt Appreciation
Perhaps the big man was blasting "Mother North" on his way to the arena last night.
Great choice this week, lad.
6. Shoved Off Her Perch
Charlotte Flair vs. Bayley is a potentially awesome feud that should help take the SmackDown Women's Championship division to the next level following the disappointment of Ember Moon's recent title challenge.
It came about during last night's Moment of Bliss, with 'The Queen' as boastful and braggadocious as ever. Her claim that she was the face of the division, more marketable than Bayley, and is SmackDown brought the champ from the back. Fired up, 'The Hugger' rubbished everything Charlotte said and accepted her challenge, then, in a surprising move, shoved her to the ground. At least she didn't try to destroy her ankle.
This has the potential to be an excellent feud with at least one excellent pay-per-view match, and with both divisions now built around the Horsewomen, it feels like the Raw and SmackDown Women's Championship scenes are on the rise. Bayley, Flair, Sasha Banks, and Becky Lynch could all be in singles action at Clash of Champions. That's an exciting prospect.
5. A Different Side Of Kevin Owens
With recent weeks painting Kevin Owens as a defiant, badass antihero, it was cool to see another side of his character last night.
Shane McMahon handed him a hefty $100,000 fan seven days ago. That's a shedload of money and after initially reacting by hurling a table at McMahon's office TV, KO had had time to contemplate. This led to him approaching the former Commissioner in earnest, effectively grovelling as he asked Shane to reconsider, noting the huge, detrimental impact it was having on his family. He appealed to McMahon's sensibilities as a father in doing so, though Shane was only willing to say he'd reconsider.
The duo reconvened later in the evening, with McMahon agreeing to pull the fine on the basis that Owens would be fired if he ever put his hands on a "WWE official" again. A relieved KO offered a handshake. Shane declined, saying "we're not quite there yet," so Owens bounced.
KO is a three-dimensional character, not just an antihero caricature. If the Shane storyline must continue, this was a good way to keep it fresh, despite what happened next...
4. Screwed
Sometimes, the obvious development is the right development. This was the case when Kevin Owens and Elias met in their King of the Ring bout.
Shane McMahon was at ringside, because of course he bloody was, and ended up cheating KO out of the tournament by pulling off his jacket to reveal a referee's shirt below. Owens couldn't lay a finger on him per their earlier agreement, so there was little he could do when Shane administered a fast-count following Elias' roll-up.
While nothing groundbreaking, the action preceding the finish was solid. The Shane development is what's important, though. It looked like he'd screw Owens from the moment the tournament bracket was announced and while this feud continuing through another pay-per-view cycle remains unideal, at least WWE are doing it the right way.
3. Top Guy Stuff
How great is this Revival/Randy Orton alliance? You can totally imagine these grumpy old f*cks sat at a bar after the show, drinking straight whisky (no ice), bemoaning flippydoos, pouring one out for Harley Race, and gushing over all the Mid-South they've been watching on the Network.
The Revival were battered by Kofi Kingston earlier in the night. That wasn't a good look for them, but they cut a solid promo laying into the "cowardly" New Day later on. Dash and Dawson then challenged the SmackDown Tag Team Title-holders for Clash of Champions. This led to Heavy Machinery coming out and we had a tasty little midcard scrap on our hands.
A fun bout concluded with Otis tagging the much-improved Tucker in following the Caterpillar, but Tucky was cut off and Dash cradled him for the 1-2-3. The right outcome to cap a solid night for the 'Top Guys.'
2. Andrade & Apollo Settle Their Beef
The cool thing about SmackDown's King of the Ring bracket is that every match feeds into a potential storyline.
Kevin Owens vs. Elias had the Shane McMahon hook, Ali vs. Buddy Murphy harks back to their awesome 205 Live rivalry, Chad Gable and Shelton Benjamin used to be tag partners, while Andrade and Apollo Crews are currently locking horns in an undercard programme and turned in a quality scrap last night.
This may have been Match of the Night on any other evening, but Murphy vs. Daniel Bryan happened. Nonetheless, Crews vs. Andrade III was comfortably their best bout to date. Yes, Apollo ate defeat, but got most of his coolest sh*t in throughout a comfortable 10-minute runtime that allowed both men plenty of shine, with 'El Idolo' eventually scoring the win with the Hammerlock DDT off a Zelina Vega distraction.
Andrade has considerably more upside, so him progressing was the right move. A potential banger with the Gable/Benjamin winner now awaits.
1. Buddy Shines Vs. Bryan
Another week, another first-class Buddy Murphy performance - this time against the consensus best technician in the company.
While Murphy's match with Roman Reigns relied primarily on big bombs, with the former Cruiserweight Champion's V-Trigger/Kamigoye/Brainbuster flurry a highlight, this bout was more measured. That doesn't mean it lacked explosiveness, though. Buddy's impactful bursts of offense are a big part of what makes him so exciting and he was excellent once more, blasting Bryan with a knee at the bell, hitting his awesome dive to the outside, and borrowing Will Ospreay's Cheeky Nandos kick and a Liger Bomb towards the end. The man loves his movez.
Bryan, that genius, dragged Murphy into his LeBell Lock to prevent further cloudbursts after the first act's sugar rush. He summoned Zack Sabre Jr. from there, pulling further limbs into the puzzle as he tried to stretch the will out of Murphy. The Aussie escape, however, and eventually shut the former WWE Champion down after Superkicking Rowan, finishing Bryan off with a V-Trigger and Murphy's Law.
A big, big victory for Murph, though it's a shame WWE chose to undermine it straight away. Nonetheless, here's hoping his push continues. He has earned this.