9 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2021
Becky and Brock return, Bianca derailed. Good matches, some questionable booking.
No matter what WWE threw at the wall Saturday night at SummerSlam, they had been fighting an uphill battle since 10pm Friday night, ET.
But damned if the company didn’t actually try and put on a pretty good PPV overall. They boasted two huge returns that popped the crowd, delivered a couple excellent matches, a couple more good ones, and crammed in four title changes along the way.
SummerSlam will have several interesting angles coming out of it, with Becky Lynch’s return and capturing the SmackDown Women’s Championship by dispatching Bianca Belair in less than 30 seconds being the most divisive by far. Having Lynch back is tremendous and a huge shot in the arm, but derailing a homegrown success story like she was the Honky Tonk Man was just uncalled for. It all depends how WWE proceeds from here, but that was “no buys” from this writer.
The Goldberg/Bobby Lashley angle disguised as a match that really just set up a rematch was also awful. And the Raw women’s division continues to be an embarrassment, sometimes in the ring and almost always in the storytelling.
But Edge/Seth Rollins delivered everything you could have wanted, while Roman Reigns/John Cena was an outstanding match that proved that Cena really is one of the greatest of all time. Damian Priest and RK-Bro got some really nice moments as well.
With that said, let’s get to it…
Downs...
7. WWE Homogeny On Display
Before the Big E/Baron Corbin kickoff show match, it was announced that a fan had won a TikTok contest to be a guest ring announcer at SummerSlam.
While this isn’t a knock against the winner herself – she did a really nice job – it’s worth noting that she clearly was given a crash course by WWE on how to do the announcing. And thus, she sounded like every other ring announcer in WWE. A one-shot guest announcer should be distinguishable, but if you closed your eyes and someone told you it was Kayla Braxton (who used to do ring announcing in NXT) or Alicia Taylor (NXT’s current ring announcer), you’d believe them.
That’s more of an indictment of WWE’s system, which values homogeny among its performers over bringing uniqueness and authenticity to the product. It really is a miracle they haven’t toned Pat McAfee down yet and turned him into a nonsense-spouting WWE factory.
6. Xavier: From Beating Champ To Water Guns
Remember several weeks ago when Xavier Woods pinned WWE Champion Bobby Lashley clean in the middle of the ring on Raw? Neither does WWE.
Woods pinned Lashley last month in the lead-up to Kofi Kingston’s challenge at Money in the Bank. Since then, they’ve done nothing with that. And Saturday, Xavier was involved in a comedy segment involving the “Drip Stick 2000” with Miz & John Morrison, spraying them with water.
Lashley has lost exactly three televised singles matches this year, to Riddle, Kofi and Xavier. He’s avenged the first two, but not Woods. Why isn’t WWE doing something with this? Even a two-week program would have been fun, and it could have given Woods something interesting to do and showcase his immense talent, rather than getting in a water fight with Miz & Morrison.
At least Xavier’s Scott Hall gear was spot-on, and his survey was on-point.
5. Not Ready For Primetime
You could possibly make this an “up” because this feud hopefully ended Saturday night and was brief, but holy hell it was bad.
Drew McIntyre and Jinder Mahal clashed at SummerSlam, and instead of it just being Drew hitting a Claymore in 30 seconds, we had to watch Mahal on offense for a couple minutes before McIntyre threw him around the ring a bunch and kicked his head off.
Worse, the entire feud centered on McIntyre’s sword, and the weapon didn’t play into the match at all, with it only coming out afterward to chase off Shanky & Veer, two guys Drew beat single-handedly on Raw. That was it. So the entire “Drew’s gonna behead people with a sword” deal was meaningless, and we had to endure Jinder on offense on the second-biggest PPV of the year.
Meanwhile, Bianca Belair got squashed. Sounds just wonderful.
4. Good Match, But Doesn’t Matter
With a better storyline and likeable characters, the Raw Women’s Championship match could have been an easy “up” here.
The match itself was really good – particularly the second half – but it was impossible to get into this match when you’ve got Charlotte Flair, Nikki A.S.H. and Rhea Ripley, and you don’t know who to root for. Flair was obviously the heel, but Ripley is only now slowly rehabbing her massively botched run as champion, and Nikki has been a bad comedy character who lucked into the women’s title.
And really, all of this bad storyline just led back to where we were a month ago: with Charlotte as the Raw Women’s Champion once again. It’s as if they needed to do something with the women’s Money in the Bank briefcase and fill a month of stories, so they just booked this mess, ending right back where we started. Joy.
It really is a shame, because all three women delivered in the ring Saturday night, and it’s difficult to give them a pass and ignore the crappy storytelling and poor character development. Oh, and we now have to hear about Charlotte’s 12th title reign. Yippee.
3. A Bathroom Break Match In Every Sense
It’s one thing to call the Eva Marie/Alexa Bliss match a “bathroom break” match, but it would be best if we could just flush everything about this mini-feud and just move on with our lives.
The ring action itself was nothing special, with Eva being pretty limited. Instead, they focused on the doll, Lilly. Eva Marie grabbed the doll paint-brushed it and then slapped Bliss with it. This set Alexa off, who went on to topple Eva with a DDT. Hopefully, THE END.
But to add a bit more of storyline that no one gets or understands, Doudrop mocked Eva Marie on the mic, put on her robe, and strutted off, seemingly breaking off her alliance with the model. Of course, there’s always the chance the two could be back together Monday on Raw given this company’s mindset. But why were they even together in the first place? Don’t forget they started breaking up just a couple weeks after debuting.
If this leads to Doudrop reclaiming the fire that Piper Niven had in NXT UK and we de-emphasize Lilly, then this was great. But it’s doubtful.
2. Disappointing Match To Set Up Rematch(?)
The WWE Championship match between Goldberg and Bobby Lashley seemed to promise a short, simple match. Punch, spear, spear, spear, spear, pin. Champ retains, Hall-of-Famer rides off into the sunset after a hard-hitting match that puts over champion.
But instead, we got a bit of back-and-forth, followed up by an injury angle, with MVP blasting Goldberg with a cane and then Lashley targeting the legend’s knee with chop blocks and ramming it into the post. After a handful of these moves, Goldberg was unable to stand, which prompted the referee to throw the match out.
Yep, a world title match between two brutes who boast the spear as a finisher ended on ref stoppage because Goldberg’s knee buckled. Seriously. And then to really make it worse, Lashley attacked with a chair, then put Goldberg’s 15-year-old son Gage in the Hurt Lock after he attacked the champ.
All of this is seemingly setting up a rematch at Crown Jewel later this fall, which was announced Saturday for October. Great, so now we’re using the second biggest PPV of the year to set up rematches for a Saudi Arabia PPV that historically has been little more than a glorified super house show.
1. WTF Was That?
The return of Becky Lynch was probably the one big legit main event-level surprise WWE could pull at SummerSlam, and they did. And then they botched it and derailed their biggest homegrown star in 2021 in less than 30 seconds.
Lynch challenged Bianca Belair after Sasha Banks was ruled out of the SmackDown Women’s Championship match. She then cheap-shotted Belair, hit a Manhandle Slam and pinned Bianca for the title.
Keep in mind that Belair was dominant on SmackDown since winning the title at WrestleMania 37, even beating two women in separate matches Friday night. And she was discarded in seconds in what should have been a dream match that was given a proper build.
Sure, you can argue that Becky is by far the bigger superstar – and that’s very true – but sacrificing one of only a handful of homegrown stars to break through recently was just moronic and short-sighted.
WWE will try to retcon this and reverse-engineer this feud, but they very clearly took all the mystique away from Belair to pop a crowd. Unless this was a heel turn for Lynch or gives Belair a serious edge, this was just wrong.
Ups...
9. Unique Stage/Ramp Adds To Product
After taking a swipe at WWE for its guest ring announcer sounding like every other announcer, we have to tip our caps briefly to the entrance area and aisle that they employed for SummerSlam.
So many stadium PPVs still utilize the same giant entrance stage and ramp that we see on Raw and SmackDown, sometimes on a larger scale. So seeing Saturday’s more muted entryway – an LED board at the door and a bar of lights across the bottom of the bowl – looked really cool. Of course, it’s more likely that they used that setup so they could jam more fans into the stadium, but still, let’s give them credit for not falling back on the same old, same old.
If only WWE would do this more often with its PPVs and give them more of a unique feel.
8. Simple But Effective
There really isn’t much to the setup behind the kickoff show match between Big E and Baron Corbin: Corbin stole E’s Money in the Bank Briefcase, and he wants it back.
But in this situation, there are actual reasons behind the thief’s motivation. For weeks now, Corbin has descended into poverty, becoming more and more pathetic since losing his crown to King Nakamura He’s lost matches, his self-respect, his home, his family… everything. So Baron being a desperate man stole E’s MITB briefcase in the hopes that he could cash it in to become champion – and thus make some money.
We’ve seen wrestlers steal the briefcase before and have griped about how nonsensical that is, that possession isn’t 9/10ths of the law here. But in Corbin’s case, his desperate situation justifies that irrational action.
And just to close the thread, WWE actually put a proper coda on this mini-storyline, with Big E controlling much of the match, winning cleanly, and reclaiming his briefcase. And Corbin’s downward spiral continues.
7. RK-Bro Give Perfect Opening Moment
One of the biggest mistakes WWE makes at times is that they feel like every PPV match needs to be a lengthy bout following the same template. But they stepped out of that a bit Saturday night to open the show.
Riddle (in his hometown) and Randy Orton solved the mystery of Omos the simplest way possible and knocked off AJ Styles & Omos for the Raw Tag Team Championships. They managed to isolate Styles by keeping Omos mostly out of the match, with Riddle posting him near the climax.
The match itself was full, but not drawn-out, with Orton dodging the Phenomenal Forearm, AJ blocking the RKO, and then Orton nailing the RKO for the win and the titles. The contest was just long enough but didn’t overstay its welcome, and the celebration afterward was fun to watch.
6. Father/Son Can’t Overcome Brothers
Maybe we’re setting up a father/son betrayal down the line, but for right now, the story of the Usos being just a bit better than Rey Mysterio and his inexperienced son Dominik worked fine.
Jimmy and Jey battled the Mysterios to retain their tag titles Saturday night, beating Dominik down for a good portion of the match. But when Rey got the hot tag, he took it to both Usos while his son remained down and out.
Unfortunately, Dominik wasn’t able to help his father out, and Rey fell to the Usos, as the numbers were too much to overcome. This meant that the Bloodline remained intact for another PPV, and the Mysterios will be forced to evaluate their path forward.
5. Making A Champion
This writer called the United States Championship match a potential sleeper for match of the night, and it delivered exactly what it needed at SummerSlam.
Damian Priest overcame Sheamus’ onslaught to topple the Celtic Warrior and capture his first title in WWE. The match itself was aided by an unfortunate misstep, when Priest did a step-up dive to the floor and splatted back-first on the floor. That apparent injury became the story of the match, as Sheamus targeted it over and over.
Sheamus delivered some serious, hard-hitting offense (as expected), which led to near-falls that sucked the fans in and had them rallying behind Damian. The climax came when Priest ripped Sheamus’ mask off and pounded him, leading to a comeback topped off with the Reckoning, bringing him the victory.
It was a perfect little bit of storytelling, and the fans’ reaction made it mean even more. Great job all around.
4. Welcome Back To The Man
Now, we have rightfully trashed the decision to have Becky Lynch squash Bianca Belair in seconds for the SmackDown Women’s Championship, but let’s just reflect on what having The Man back in WWE means for the company.
Lynch easily was one of the – if not the – biggest star(s) in WWE at the time she left due to pregnancy. Her departure left the Raw women’s division with a pretty big hole it never really filled Her presence can carry a show, and her ability can carry matches to respectability when they have no right to be any good.
Having Lynch back in WWE is exactly what WWE needed right now, a shot in the arm they desperately needed. Her return wasn’t on par with CM Punk showing up at AEW Friday night, but her shock appearance was one of the biggest surprises WWE could pull off, short of The Rock turning up.
Of course, we’re going to have to see how they play things after her sucker-punch and sudden win for the women’s title, but let’s give some kudos here for having her back in WWE.
3. Edge, Rollins Deliver Incredible Match
You can quibble about who picked up the win Saturday night, but no one can deny that Edge and Seth Rollins delivered an absolutely incredible match at SummerSlam.
Starting with Edge’s Brood throwback entrance, the two had the crowd firmly in the palms of their hands. They battled back and forth, each scoring a series of near-falls. The story of the match was that Edge’s fused neck wouldn’t stand up to a Rolling curbstomp, so Seth clearly targeted it throughout the match. But Edge showed that age really is just a number, keeping pace with Rollins.
The crowd bought several of the near-falls, most notably Rollins’ missed Phoenix Splash that was countered with a spear. Edge even dusted off his wife Beth Phoenix’s Glam Slam for a near-fall. But in the end, despite bringing the Edgecution and Edgeucator out of mothballs, it was a sleeper/crossface that brought Edge the win.
Great match. You might disagree with the winner, but you can’t deny the quality of their work.
2. Beast Mode: On
We last saw Brock Lesnar in WWE, he was losing the WWE Championship to Drew McIntyre at WrestleMania 36 in 2020.
Saturday, the beast returned to WWE to confront Roman Reigns and blow the roof off the stadium in Las Vegas. It was legit probably the biggest, most attainable surprise WWE could pull off. While it wasn’t on par with CM Punk’s big return, it was an incredible moment and sets up a legit huge match down the line.
There also is the interesting dynamic of Paul Heyman, who managed Brock during his last run and is now seconding Roman to the ring. Almost immediately, you start wondering if Heyman could backstab Roman and realign himself with Brock, similar to how he sold Lesnar out back in 2003 and siding with the Big Show.
Regardless, this was a hell of a way to close out SummerSlam and leave fans thirsting for more.
1. Cena Steps Up In Defeat
John Cena is a bona fide box office star. He had no obligation to get back in a WWE ring and wrestle. And even if he did, no one would have really blamed him if he played it a bit safe and didn’t take too many big bumps.
But instead, Cena had a barn-burner of a main event with Roman Reigns over the Universal Championship. The match started slowly and methodically, making you wonder if they really were going to play it safe and steer clear of anything too heavy.
After a few minutes though, they started tearing into each other, with Cena pulling out all the stops. The story of the match was John being half a step too slow and having to fight from underneath, relying early on on rollups, trying to surprise Reigns. But once he found his footing, Cena started bringing the fight to Roman.
But it was all for naught, as Reigns kicked out of everything, including a Super Attitude Adjustment, and put Cena down with two Superman Punches and a spear to retain. Really solid match that solidified Reigns’ superiority and showed that Cena still has the goods.