9 Worst Abuses Of Creative Control In Wrestling

What if we did it this way instead?

By David Cambridge /

The biggest wrestlers generally command the biggest contracts, and that doesn't just mean generous financial incentives. In some cases, it also means being permitted the ability to exert control over the creative direction of their character.

Advertisement

Having so dramatically burnt his bridges with WWE in the late '90s, Bret Hart famously asked for creative privileges when he sat across the negotiating table from Eric Bischoff - a request the WCW head honcho could hardly refuse having let Hulk Hogan pull the strings for much of the last three years.

Creative control is, ostensibly, less prevalent in today's wrestling world - although there are murmurs every now and then that one or two of the biggest WWE stars (John Cena, for instance) are able to have a quiet word in the booker's ear if they are pitched something they aren't so keen on.

And, honestly, it's not always bad, since wrestlers often have their finger more firmly on the pulse than those behind the scenes. Sometimes they use their swing to lobby for things that are worthwhile.

But, truthfully: a lot of the time they don't.

9. Shawn Michaels At One Night Only 1997

Shawn Michaels was - allegedly - guilty of flexing his creative muscles twice in the run up to his European Title match with The British Bulldog at Birmingham's One Night Only in September 1997.

Advertisement

First, it was reportedly the 'Heartbreak Kid's lobbying that saw his match - a secondary title bout, albeit one featuring the home-country hero - get the main event billing, ahead of Bret Hart's WWF Championship defence against The Undertaker (which, no Brits or not, was perhaps still the bigger pay-per-view draw).

Despite, according to reports, being assured he would win, Bulldog then suffered the indignity of a loss on his home turf after Michaels apparently refused to do the job. A little childish, true, but try and find a better heel performance anywhere this side of 2000.

8. Hulk Hogan Refusing To Put Over Mr Perfect

Granted, WrestleMania VI, the scene of Hulk Hogan's mega showdown with Ultimate Warrior, wasn't exactly the opportune time for Mr. Perfect to at last become a main event player.

Advertisement

It was understandable that the Hulkster would sooner work with Warrior - and so too was it understandable that the company, looking for the biggest possible draw for its flagship event, decided to put Hennig on the undercard.

The problem was Hogan's (apparent) steadfast refusal to put over Mr. Perfect at all, fearing that he wasn't big enough to be a legitimate contender to his WWE Title throne.

This was despite the fact that Hennig made it to the last two of the Royal Rumble in 1990, where he was eliminated by the Hulkster - seemingly to set up a blow-off encounter down the line.

7. Triple H At Royal Rumble 2016

Triple H's WWE power grab is, for the most part, to be welcomed, since without the input of 'The Game' it is unlikely NXT - or the company's burgeoning women's division - would have reached the same heights.

Advertisement

But his record in the hot seat is not entirely unblemished. Despite a slew of injuries, the decision to put him in the main event of WrestleMania 32 - at close to 50-years-old - was still a little questionable, especially as it meant winning the 2016 Royal Rumble over one or two more deserving stars.

Neither can it be said that the decision served some nebulous "greater good", with the 'Mania main event ultimately falling short of expectations and Roman, having failed to win the support of the crowd, back to square one.

6. Stone Cold Refusing To Put Over Lesnar

Stone Cold's reservations about putting over Brock Lesnar in 2002 were not entirely without merit, to be fair.

Advertisement

The 'Texas Rattlesnake', as he has stated in the time since, essentially objected to the idea of such an earth-shattering result coming off the heels of just a few weeks build, arguing that any encounter between the two should follow a meticulous, well-arced storyline which gave Lesnar the time to grow into his new main event shoes.

But by throwing his toys out the pram altogether, Austin killed any hope there was of seeing these two behemoths slug it out, and although it barely hurt the 'Next Big Thing's career, for the fans, at least, it will always go down as one of WWE's biggest missed opportunities.

5. John Cena At SummerSlam 2010

According to Wade Barrett, he and the rest of Nexus were so miffed about the planned finish of their SummerSlam 2010 main event that they marched straight to Vince McMahon's office for an explanation.

Advertisement

If they had got an audience with the chairman, what they probably would have heard is that John Cena himself had personally lobbied for the ending, which saw the WWE veteran come back from a DDT onto the exposed concrete to beat the final two rookies from the opposing side.

While there is no indication that Cena was responsible for them losing the match altogether (or the subsequent derailing of their push), the closing sequence he came up with was poorly conceived, and did no favours for anyone involved - least of all Barrett.

4. Hulk Hogan At SummerSlam 2005

Neither Hulk Hogan nor his opponent, Shawn Michaels, exactly covered themselves in glory at SummerSlam 2005.

Advertisement

Hogan has generally taken the brunt of the criticism though - partly because he is the internet's favourite wrestling boogeyman, and partly because Shawn Michaels, by comically over-selling is every move after throwing a tantrum, at least made us laugh.

But even the most ardent Hulkamaniac would surely have to concede that their hero stepped out of line when he reneged on his agreement to work a multi-match feud, giving Michaels no opportunity for a riposte after losing clean at SummerSlam.

And, in the interest of balance, it must also be said that the 'Heartbreak Kid' - in a return to his sulky mid-90s form - responded in kind by stamping his feet in front of the whole world.

3. Hulk Hogan Refusing To Put Over Bret Hart

Legend has it that Vince McMahon and his franchise player agreed to a quid pro quo at the beginning of 1993.

Advertisement

Hogan, approaching the end of his WWE career, would be given one last moment in the sun at WrestleMania IX - where he defeated Yokozuna for the title in the go-home match - on the condition that he did his boss a favour by putting over his successor Bret Hart down the line at SummerSlam.

But Hogan had other ideas, having apparently grown resentful of the 'Hitman' for his alleged willingness to work for a smaller cut of the pay-per-view pie (which, you know, could have had big implications for some of his contemporaries, the 'Hulkster' included).

Having failed to reach a compromise, Hogan dropped the belt back to Yoko at King of the Ring instead, and Bret - fittingly - faced Doink the Clown at the 'Biggest Party of the Summer'.

2. Bret Hart At Survivor Series 1997

Bret Hart had good reasons to take issue with Shawn Michaels - the 'Heartbreak Kid' stealing his spot in One Night Only's main event being one of them - but there are better ways to get even.

Advertisement

He could have fulfilled his contractual obligations at Survivor Series and then headed off for the greener pastures of WCW, helping his new employers dethrone Vince McMahon and his leading diva from wrestling's top spot.

Instead, he refused to put his beef to one side, and went into his final match determined to walk out of WWE with their biggest prize around his waist.

Whether Vince could have picked a different opponent is up for debate, but the fact remains: Bret let personal pride get in the way of his duty to the profession.

1. Hulk Hogan Vs. The Butcher

If you believe some reports, the only reason The Butcher - aka Brutus Beefcake - got a gig in WCW at all was because his good friend Hulk Hogan, who made the same move himself, put in a word for him.

Advertisement

Given that Beefcake had spent close to a decade building up his wrestling profile under the employ of Vince McMahon in the 1980s, that was perhaps an exaggeration - yet the chasm between his fortunes towards the end of his time in WWE and the early part of that in WCW can't be ignored.

At Starrcade '94, the two friends ended up headlining the show in a bout for the WCW World Heavyweight Championship, while the likes of Sting and, in particular, Vader (who apparently didn't see eye to eye with the Hulkster) were left on the under-card.

Advertisement