Chris Jericho In AEW - What Went Wrong?
AEW fans want Le Champion to se retirer. How did this happen?
‘Le Champion’ was a wonderful time and, on all fronts, Chris Jericho was a superb AEW World champion.
Jericho, world-class in the ring on his best day and one of the most entertaining all-rounders in the history of US cable TV wrestling, cemented his legend six months into Dynamite’s run.
He excreted greatness every single week. His promos were hilarious, his matches felt special, and he lovingly restored, between concession stand brawls and breaking the arms of babyfaces, the much-missed hot territory angle. He became, for the first time in a legendary career that didn’t even need the distinction, a true Ace figure. That stunning run established AEW Dynamite as appointment viewing. The impossible brilliance of the original Stadium Stampede doesn’t happen if the Inner Circle had not been established as a riot of an act that people wanted to see get knocked off their perch.
Jericho was in effect a touring territory heel all along: the “carny succubus” was well cast as the interloper who tried to recreate AEW in his own hubristic image. His true purpose, you could argue, ended when he dropped the World title to Jon Moxley back at Revolution 2020 - but his apparent purpose was to elevate young or relatively unknown talent.
The inspired juxtaposition between PAC and Orange Cassidy enabled the latter to get over, but his very good programme with Jericho proved that the meme had staying power. It was divisive at the time and feels unfashionable now, and dragged on too long, but Chris Jericho Vs. MJF yielded many incredible moments. When it was over, Jericho had retained enough in the way of currency to create magic with Eddie Kingston at Revolution 2022. Eddie going over Jericho undeniably meant something at the time.
It all started to go wrong, and badly, after that. The WWEness of Jericho was always a concern, but it became a real issue in the post-match of his Barbed Wire Everywhere victory over Kingston, during which Eddie threw Jericho onto a bed of “barbed wire” and flimsy cardboard. That was framed as a measure of revenge. It was in reality a terrible cop-out, a carny political machination, not the first nor last instance of 50/50 booking, that insulted the intelligence of the fanbase.
By this point, mid-2022, Jericho led the Jericho Appreciation Society: a group that sought to parody sports entertainment. Rendered a small-fry TNA-grade concern within months, in the wake of WWE’s resurgence under Paul Levesque, it wasn’t a great idea to begin with. Jericho was playing to the gallery; AEW was always better when it showed its superiority over WWE, but there was Chris Jericho, insisting and telling you that it was better throughout a one-dimensional and overlong feud with the Blackpool Combat Club.
When that was mercifully ended, Jericho’s reputation as a transparent politician intensified.
CONT'D...
His list of rivals was already…convenient. Orange Cassidy was a sensation, and through his unique arc, few people had the chance to wrestle him. He was, quite literally, freshly squeezed; the hot new thing. MJF was a surefire AEW World champion, the first true heel since Prince Devitt and Sasha Banks. Eddie Kingston became a cult hero on his very first night. Jericho sure could pick ‘em.
When Ricky Starks got over, Jericho worked with him (at which point the “clout vampire” accusation became storyline canon). Then, Adam Cole made a miraculous comeback, and just as fans were overjoyed to see him again - and were prepared to receive the nicest guy in wrestling finally cast as a babyface - Jericho almost ruined that with a diabolical outing at Double Or Nothing 2023. In a move so transparently desperate that it was almost funny, of course Jericho wrestled hometown hero and consensus best wrestler in the world Will Ospreay, who wasn’t even under contract at the time, in Wembley stadium. The match was great, but then, Ospreay could work a great match with Kane.
Kingston was elevated and then demoted through his association with Jericho. MJF had to rescue Cole. Starks became a less compelling character after his flat, obligatory run through the Jericho stable gauntlet ahead of Revolution ‘23.
Jericho’s modus operandi - already a weird fictional thing, shouldn’t he as a wrestler be interested in advancing his own career? - didn’t even work. Often, Chris Jericho programmes simply happened, and when he invariably lost them, he was prioritised for the next pay-per-view cycle. His character did not fit into the wins and losses matter philosophy. Beating him meant nothing for his fictional opponents nor the real careers of those portraying them.
All the while, AEW signed yet more names to its extravagantly stacked talent roster, many of which vastly overshadowed Jericho - but never relegated him. He boasted too much clout to flounder in a meritocracy.
The brutal truth is that Jericho has annoyed, pissed off or bored people rigid for a long time, perhaps even longer than two years - but he was always capable of delivering a match so good that even the most ardent critics had to pay begrudging respect to him. You were sick of him, and then he delivered an awesome, out-of-nowhere war against Jon Moxley at Quake By The Lake. You were angry that Jericho throttled Daniel Garcia’s career without a hint of a blow-off match on pay-per-view, but then Jericho bladed his chest when working a sickeningly, beautifully physical match with Tomohiro Ishii. You were annoyed that you had to endure Jake Hager singles matches purely because of who he was mates with, and then Jericho wrestled a deliriously entertaining Falls Count Anywhere spectacle against Roderick Strong.
You could never truly, wholly, count him out.
You can now.
CONT'D...
Never fast, he’s really slow these days. He hasn’t wrestled a great, over match in a long while - since the Wembley aberration. Across January and February, his dire, ceaseless feud with the Don Callis family rumbled on. He wrestled Kyle Fletcher and Konosuke Takeashita and could barely keep up. There was a teetering, unnerving quality to those matches, in both of which he took really nasty bumps that he was physically incapable of executing properly.
Still clever, despite everything, his run with the FTW title will allow him to wrestle shortcut-laden plunder brawls in which he can hide. The fans in St. Louis however still hated his interpretation of that genre at Dynasty. They told him to retire.
Then, there was the incident over the holidays.
Chris Jericho, as Brawl Out continued to dominate the conversation, claimed he’d never signed a non-disclosure agreement; journalist Nick Hausman wondered aloud in response to that tweet if Jericho had made anybody else sign an NDA. Another X user then theorised that Hausman had insinuated that Jericho was responsible for Kylie Rae’s mysterious departure from AEW in 2019, posting a screenshot of an unsourced rumour speculating that Jericho had invited Rae to a hotel room under the false pretence that she wouldn’t be alone with him. Kylie in response to that posted a heart emoji. No allegation was made - but dots were connected by AEW fans. Those fans let him know at Worlds End.
It is impossible to invest in Jericho without knowing the extent to which, if any, he is a creep. On that "if any": Tony Khan was handed the opportunity, during the Worlds End (sic) press conference, to adamantly deny that Jericho had ever received a complaint related to his conduct in AEW. That opportunity was not taken; Khan instead blathered on, non-specifically, about AEW’s safety record.
Jericho, who hasn’t felt like the WWE interloper who could still hang with and beat his predecessors in years, has nothing left. He’ll never win a truly significant match again, or at least he absolutely shouldn’t, and fans can snuff that out like a bloodhound. Fans back winners. Jericho - a glorified jobber desperate to cling on - is a loser who can’t stop losing.
Jericho used to have the ability to pop fans just by saying a word or phrase in a daft, amusing way.
CONT'D...
The Le Champion character was launched with a little bit of the bubbly. It was also genuinely funny when Jericho would throw fireballs at people and suddenly declare himself to be a wizard, and you could believe that he believed it. That daft patter has deserted him, too. He doesn’t have that mojo anymore. He’s dead behind the eyes. He doesn’t even try his hand in 2024. He’s not even doing his drivel, like “GFY” or that time he called the Pinnacle the ‘Pineapple’ and MJF “My !*$% Friend”. It’s as if he’s lost the delusion even. It’s also notable that Jericho hasn’t bragged about his demo numbers in years.
More damningly still, Jericho used to be funny when he was defiant and pissed off. He botched a lionsault in a 2021 Dynamite tag. Fuelled by the criticism, he landed it perfectly the very next week and burned a hole through a ringside camera lens with an expression of pure fury and disdain. GFY for doubting him. He is Chris Jericho.
He made his career, in no small part, by lashing out at the critics and proving them wrong. That fire has been extinguished. It doesn’t seem like he’s remotely dialled-in. He used to know how good he was. He used to seethe at the idea that he was all too easily written off, knowing full well his next unexpectedly great match was imminent.
He should be reacting to this latest backlash with thunder in his voice, but he knows full well what is happening. He is resigned to it but doesn’t feel the need to go away. Why? Would doing so in late 2023 have scanned as an admission of guilt? Does he feel, at 53, that he can’t simply go away and come back better anymore? Wrestlers will tell you of the paradox that bumping - often compared to a low-impact car crash - gets easier and less painful the more frequently they do it.
Jericho is stuck. Nobody gets over when he loses, and nobody wants him to win.
All that’s left for him to do is lean in. He always prided himself on being the one guy in his era of WWE who knew what the bubble was, but never enclosed himself in it. He has now taken that mindset to a nonsensical extreme of a self-own.
He’ll never win a World title again, and his last blood feud (with Don Callis) was a sprawling, heatless mess, so now, he can only attempt to siphon the worst, meta, self-damning heat. Do you think he’s a clout vampire who gloms onto young, hip talent? Why, he’ll make a storyline out of it. His character should be principally concerned with pursuing titles, but even Tony Khan - who has been feckless throughout a saga that is ruining the vibe of his promotion - rightly won’t book Jericho in a programme for one of his many sanctioned titles. So Jericho’s new character is thus Chris Irvine: a fading force who is desperate to be relevant by association. This underscores that there is absolutely nothing left for the fictional character of Chris Jericho to do.
And, if it’s yet another dig at CM Punk - the veteran who imposes his advice on everybody through arrogance - it’s pathetic. AEW needs to move on.
What’s next?
CONT'D...
Perhaps the ‘Painmaker’ becomes the ‘Holidaymaker’: a meta heel who threatens to actually listen to the fans, and go away for a while, before doing a run-in before the show ends.
The less facetious answer to that question is for Jericho to go away for a minimum of nine months. Tony Khan could and at this point probably should save Jericho from himself. Jericho’s legacy is in tatters. AEW’s vibe is ghastly when Jericho is on TV, and he gets more TV time than most. Nobody cared about the All-Star Scramble at Revolution one way or the other, but between Worlds End and Dynasty, the message could not be louder: the people do not want to see Chris Jericho any longer. AEW can’t be the show that fans hijack. AEW was able to exist in the first place because its future fanbase hijacked WWE shows. Hyperbolic as it may read, this Chris Jericho run represents a spiritual death of sorts.
If it weren’t for the lack of clarity surrounding the rumoured 2019 incident involving Kylie Rae, this editorial would be tinged with guilt. Jericho has bumped more than most (the grim irony being that, the more a wrestler hurts themselves over time, the less fans will care). The Highlight Reel was aptly named; Jericho has produced reams of brilliance. Most everybody’s escapist hobby is better for his involvement in it.
Haunted by sexual misconduct allegations, lacking any value as an onscreen presence, a bleak distraction from a promotion in desperate need of selling tickets to a fun show, Chris Jericho is trapped underneath an avalanche - and all he’s doing is working out how to trademark his demise. A tragic grift.
It’s sad - but do you know what’s sadder?
The fact that wrestling moves on from everything much too quickly. If he allowed people to forget, and they always do, he could stem the bleeding. Who knows; after that, he could always reinvent himself as the ‘Cockroach’.
There’s always an angle to play; he’s just working his worst one yet.