CM Punk's WWE Matches In Chicago Ranked From Worst To Best

The story of a straight edge wrestler who became a city's favorite drug.

By Tomás Cunha /

After seven long years away from the sport, CM Punk recently made an emotional return to pro wrestling in his hometown of Chicago.

Advertisement

The incredible connection between Punk and his fellow compatriots present at the United Center, for All Elite Wrestling's second edition of Rampage, enhanced the moment even more and was felt by every fan watching around the globe just as much. It was a moment that captured everyone's imagination, love and attention - simply put, we witnessed a truly unforgettable history-making moment.

Needless to say, this wasn't the first time a CM Punk appearance/performance for a major company made a Chicago crowd go absolutely apesh*t and have what can best be described as, well, a collective religious experience. Before Punk's long sabbatical from wrestling, the 'Second City Saint' had his share of iconic moments in Chicago too, with his triumph over then-WWE Champion John Cena at Money in the Bank 2011 naturally being the one that comes to everyone's mind first.

But did you know that wasn't the only title that Punk captured in Chicago during his eight-year stint with WWE? Or that he wrestled another five pay-per-view matches with the home-field advantage other than the one with Cena?

All in all, CM Punk wrestled a total of eleven (televised) WWE matches "at home". Today, we rank them all from worst to best... in the world!

11. CM Punk Vs. Big Daddy V - ECW Championship (No Mercy 2007)

You already knew CM Punk had one of his best WWE matches competing over a title at a pay-per-view held in Chicago. But did you know the same could be said about one of his very worst?

Advertisement

Entering his second month as ECW Champion, Punk prepared to defend the strap in his hometown at No Mercy, against ECW original Tommy Dreamer. However, Dreamer was destroyed and eventually replaced by the former Mabel/King Mabel/Viscera at the event. Because he's a big boy and Dreamer's not, you see.

The "match" itself lasted a grand total of... wait for it... a whooping 94 seconds. Punk got absolutely squashed by the big challenger, did his first move of the match (a missile dropkick) and... Matt Striker entered the ring and got Big Daddy V disqualified.

The big man continued to destroy the 'Second City Saint' after the bell anyway, dropping big elbows on him that caused internal bleeding, leaving the hometown boy on his ass in front of all his loyal fans.

A nice way to accomplish three things: 1) make the champion look like a complete geek; 2) make the heel manager look dumb; 3) bury the title since the challenger couldn't give a lesser f-ck about winning it.

Still wonder why most people refuse to consider WWE's version of the ECW Championship a real 'World title'?

10. CM Punk Vs. The Big Show (Night Of Champions 2010)

Actually, make that two of CM Punk's worst WWE matches on pay-per-view.

Advertisement

A year after the 'Straight Edge Superstar' was the reigning World Heavyweight Champion, breaking the hearts of millions of kids and teenage girls all over the globe by ending their hero Jeff Hardy's WWE career, Punk was now working forgettable 4-minute matches on pay-per-view.

Calling Big Show's feud with the Punk-led Straight Edge Society in mid-2010 'one-sided' would be about as obvious as saying water is wet. Heading into this feud-ending match, not only had 'The World's Largest Athlete' unmasked a bald CM Punk in front of the whole world, he'd also defeated the entire group (Punk, Luke Gallows & Joey Mercury) in a three-on-one handicap bout at SummerSlam.

Surely they would let Punk have some kind of revenge at Night of Champions, at the very least a close back-and-forth match to give Punk back some much-needed momentum, no? No.

Four minutes after the bell sounded, CM Punk was already staring at the lights of the AllState Arena, while 'WEEEEEEELLLLL IT'S THE BIG SHOOOOW' played in the background. Well, at least it was some sort of a match, so that makes it automatically better than the previous Big Daddy V entry by default.

9. CM Punk Vs. Big Daddy V - Money In The Bank Qualifying Match (ECW 11 March 2008)

Guess who's back. Back again. V is back. Tell a friend.

Advertisement

Five months after the mauling that took place after the ECW Championship 'match' at No Mercy, WWE returned to the 'Windy City' for the tapings of that week's SmackDown and ECW. Coincidence or not, the extreme-brand hosted a No Mercy rematch between Punk and Big Daddy V, this time with a spot in the fourth-ever Money in the Bank Ladder Match at stake.

With fellow ECW wrestler and regular face of Money in the Bank ladder matches, Shelton Benjamin on commentary, Punk took the fight to Big Daddy V early on, though he was mostly unsuccessful at it due to BDV's clear size and weight advantage.

Punk tried to capitalize after the monster missed a King Kong Bundy-like Avalanche in the corner, but he (obviously) failed to lift him up for the Go To Sleep and the former Viscera landed with all his weight on top of the 'Second City Saint'.

Thankfully for Punk, Big Daddy V missed yet another big move, this time on the outside, and was just too big and too slow to answer the referee's count of ten in time.

So there's your curious fact of the day - CM Punk qualified for what would turn out to be his first Money in the Bank victory in his hometown of Chicago.

8. CM Punk Vs. Dolph Ziggler & Jack Swagger - Gauntlet Match (RAW 26 December 2011)

Fresh off a big win over both Alberto Del Rio and The Miz at TLC, in a who's who of 2011-WWE-Champions TLC Match, CM Punk needed new challengers for the new year. All Jack Swagger, Dolph Ziggler or Mark Henry had to do was accomplish what John Cena couldn't earlier that year - beat CM Punk in Chicago, as part of a gauntlet match on the final RAW of the year. If Punk managed to beat all three, he'd get a chance to beat the corporate yes-man-ship out of John Laurinaitis immediately afterward.

Advertisement

Jack Swagger went first and pulled off a good little mini-match with Punk, but ultimately (and predictably) succumbed to the reigning WWE Champion after a high kick to the face.

The Z-Man (not Tom Zenk) came in next, but not before the defeated Swagger assisted his then-partner by attacking Punk's knee, with Ziggler then targeting Punk's bad leg like a shark smelling blood.

Despite the odds, Punk was able to hit the GTS, only for Vickie Guerrero to sacrifice herself and break up the count, getting ejected from ringside as a result. That small window gave Ziggler enough time to Zig Zag the injured champion and pin him to become his next challenger.

Despite losing "at home", at least it gave Punk something new to do as the WWE Champion heading into 2012.

7. CM Punk Vs. Kenny Dykstra (RAW 26 March 2007)

For all the trivia lovers out there, here is CM Punk's very first WWE match in Chicago. One would perhaps think it would also be Punk's first-ever RAW match, considering he was still on ECW, but that was actually against Shelton Benjamin at the special 'Tribute to the Troops' edition of RAW on Christmas Day 2006.

Advertisement

WWE was clearly using their flagship programs to showcase the young wrestler in front of a larger viewing audience. After all, he defeated Johnny Nitro in a Money in the Bank qualifying match a few weeks earlier, and was about to compete in his very first WrestleMania.

Throughout the month of March, Punk appeared twice on SmackDown against fellow MITB participants King Booker and Mr. Kennedy, winning and losing respectively. But WWE's best opportunity to get over Punk as a true superstar came on the go-home episode of RAW, held in Punk's hometown. The company smartly capitalized on it.

Punk was booked against the criminally underrated and extremely talented former leader of the Spirit Squad, Kenny Dykstra. Six nights before the big show, Punk got to showcase all of his big signature moves in a short yet energetic enhancement match, which he won with the Go To Sleep.

The big pop Punk got was a clear indicator that he belonged on that year's WrestleMania card. But also, and more importantly, that people would be hearing Punk's name for years to come.

6. CM Punk Vs. Chris Jericho (RAW 18 August 2008)

Less than 24 hours after dispatching John Bradshaw Layfield to retain his World Heavyweight Championship at SummerSlam, Punk was put in a match against a fresh Chris Jericho, who didn't work a match at that year's SummerSlam. He was too busy punching Shawn Michaels' wife, Rebecca, in the mouth at the event instead.

Advertisement

Punk and Jericho worked their first (and less famous) of three matches in the 'Windy City', a 13-minute enjoyable back-and-forth match, as they usually did. Their chemistry was evident in some spots throughout the bout, particularly when Punk escaped a Walls of Jericho attempt by using a hurricanrana, which delighted those in attendance.

Lance Cade helped 'Y2J' score a win over the World Champion, getting up on the apron and distracting Punk long enough for Jericho to hit a quick Codebreaker for the victory. Sure, Punk's reign was far from perfect and he took some unnecessary losses on free television as champion, but at least he was somewhat protected here since Jericho didn't work SummerSlam.

Also on this episode of RAW, GM Mike Adamle (oh God, the memories...) announced Punk would defend the belt at Unforgiven the following month in the first ever 'Championship Scramble'. Little did anyone know he actually wouldn't, getting attacked by The Legacy backstage and replaced in the match by the man who would walk away with the gold, Chris Jericho.

5. CM Punk Vs. Umaga (Judgment Day 2009)

Punk's first run as World Champion didn't exactly set the world on fire, but a second consecutive Money in the Bank victory at WrestleMania showed there was some light at the end of the tunnel, and a move to SmackDown in the 2009 Draft gave Punk some new fresh faces to work with.

Advertisement

An example of that was the late Umaga, who prevented Punk from cashing-in on Edge for the Big Gold Belt yet again, thus becoming Punk's first rival on the 'blue brand'. The two got to open the Judgment Day pay-per-view in Chicago, exciting the crowd with a serviceable opening midcard match.

The focus was on Umaga's strength advantage early on, being able to cut off Punk's offense rather easily due to his huge size. Then, as the bout grew longer and the big man got tired, Punk's speed smartly came into play, putting the hometown hero back in the discussion. In the end, Punk blocked the Samoan Spike and went for the GTS, but he wasn't able to lift the 'Samoan Bulldozer', who connected with the Samoan Spike this time around for the win.

Some fans in the crowd were visibly disappointed with Punk's loss, having apparently forgotten the two most important WWE rules: a) "Mr. MITB" loses 95% of his matches; and b) wrestlers lose in their hometown 95% of the times. So what exactly was the shock there!?

4. CM Punk Vs. William Regal - No DQ Match, WWE Intercontinental Championship (RAW 19 January 2009)

After getting a brief first taste of a WWE World Championship the prior year, CM Punk found himself on the RAW roster's midcard as the calendar flipped from 2008 to 2009. Alongside his tag team championship partner Kofi Kingston (remember that?), the 'Second City Saint' entered a tournament in December to determine William Regal's next challenger for the Intercontinental Championship.

Advertisement

Punk bested Snitsky (in his final WWE match) and John Morrison on his way to the finale at Armageddon, where he secured the title shot by defeating the former World Champion, Rey Mysterio. The initial title match turned out to be a huge disappointment, though, as Regal conveniently got himself disqualified.

Thankfully, Stephanie McMahon was present to save the world as she always does, giving Punk a "last chance" rematch at the title in a No DQ match on the RAW before the Royal Rumble. An edition of RAW that just so happened to take place in Chi-town!

With the clear home-field advantage, Punk caught the champion by surprise early on with his series of kicks, strikes and submissions, before being the victim of a Layla distraction (Regal's valet at the time, wasn't 2009 a strange year...).

After surviving Regal's barrage of vicious knee strikes and headbutts, Punk valiantly came back and ended the physical tussle after hitting Regal with the GTS to win his first - and only - Intercontinental Championship.

3. CM Punk Vs. Chris Jericho - Chicago Street Fight, WWE Championship (Extreme Rules 2012)

Less than a year after the huge success that was Money in the Bank 2011 (which you know we'll get to in a second), WWE was bringing one of their pay-per-view extravaganzas back to Chicago with Extreme Rules.

Advertisement

Unlike last time, the hometown hero had gone from the hunter to the hunted, defending his WWE Championship against Chris Jericho in a rematch from that year's WrestleMania XXVIII, now with the added Chicago Street Fight stipulation to it. Also unlike last time, the focus was not on the 'Straight Edge Superstar'. That distinction went to John Cena's main event bloodbath with Brock Lesnar, who was returning to McMahon-land for the first time since his departure in 2004, fresh off an impressive run in UFC.

As expected, Punk and Jericho delivered a great championship bout with an exciting conclusion, one that would steal the show on most events. It certainly played a part in making Extreme Rules such an enjoyable pay-per-view, with their bout joining great company such as the aforementioned brutal Lesnar/Cena main event, but also an underrated two-out-of-three-falls match for the World Heavyweight Championship between Sheamus and Daniel Bryan.

However, as great as it was, it just wasn't the big story making the headlines coming out of this event, which prevents us from ranking it even higher. The same can't be said about this next entry...

2. CM Punk Vs. Chris Jericho (Payback 2013)

This match and Punk's previous pay-per-view meeting with Chris Jericho might've only been 14 months apart, but it certainly didn't feel like it, as a lot had changed during that time.

Advertisement

Punk's babyface run didn't even make it past RAW's 1000th episode in July 2012, when the 'Second City Saint' shocked the world by putting The Rock to sleep. 'The Great One' turned the tables by ending Punk's historic WWE Championship reign at the following year's Royal Rumble event, before the newest "Paul Heyman Guy" became the most recent (and ultimately the final) victim of The Undertaker's 'Streak' at WrestleMania.

Chris Jericho, meanwhile, lost to the debuting Fandango at 'Mania... Needless to say, both men entered the AllState Arena in search of a much-needed big win. It was Punk's first match and appearance since said Undertaker feud, back from a short hiatus, so naturally Chicago received the then-heel (but not for long) hometown boy as if he was the biggest hero in the history of wrestling.

Punk got the feel-good win on his return, but not before the two delivered a fantastic match worthy of Vince McMahon's 'see saw match up back and forth' line. The ultimate line of approval, dear younger readers who just saw the joke fly over your heads!

1. CM Punk Vs. John Cena - WWE Championship (Money In The Bank 2011)

What else!?

Advertisement

John Cena was in the midst of his 'superman' run on top, while Punk was fresh off once-promising-yet-ultimately-disappointing runs with stables. So to say that this match looked like a guaranteed easy win for the WWE Champion on his way to SummerSlam would be a massive understatement. Until Punk sat cross-legged on ?ℎ?? night.

Unlike the weird WWE Backstage shtick, the pipebomb promo indeed changed the culture, putting an end to the New Nexus crap (thankfully) and launching Punk into the main event scene. Punk, who was considering leaving WWE for real when his contract expired - which factored into the storyline, as you know - came out to a god-like reaction, with his fellow Chicagoans silencing Killswitch Engage's 'This Fire Burns'. That is nothing short of impressive!!

Impressive would also describe the savage reaction that 'The Champ' got, walking down the ramp with the knowledge that, at least for one night, it was not about him. What followed was an absolute classic, full of emotional storytelling, dramatic near-falls, exciting reversals and shocking twists and turns that left the AllState patrons more impatient with every second.

But then once they saw Punk pin Cena after a GTS, they knew right then and there, it was all worth it. And after the performance of his life, surrounded by his fans with the WWE Championship in his hands and a shattered Vince McMahon left behind, Punk too knew right then and there... Chicago Made Punk!

Advertisement