Did WWE Cross A Line On Raw Last Night?
Dean Ambrose's comments about Roman Reigns' leukaemia were not in the best taste.
At one point during last night's episode of Raw, the newly-minted 'evil' Dean Ambrose stuffed a hankie to his nose, dramatically hamming it up as he questioned the hideous stench coming from the Los Angeles crowd.
"What's that smell?!" Dean mugged, as the audience tepidly played along. It was the typical infantile stylings of WWE's crack team of TV writers - the very same who'd penned a man to literally p*ss himself the night prior - but besides being offensively bad, it was inoffensive in itself.
It was another line of Dean's earlier in the night which really got up people's nose - and not without reason.
After a feather-spitting Seth Rollins called his ex-Shield buddy out, Ambrose appeared on the big screen to finally extenuate his actions. Mean Dean intimated that for all The Shield were the vigilante do-gooders of the WWE Universe, once the cameras stopped rolling, they were a bunch of wrong 'uns. "We were rotten to the core from the very beginning," he admitted. "And now we're all going to pay for it in different ways. What goes around comes back around."
The promo was already drifting into sensitive territory, before Ambrose launched his ultimate broadside:
"I mean, look at Roman. For what [he] did in The Shield, he has to answer to the man upstairs."
Regardless of what Roman supposedly 'did' behind the scenes, there was an uncomfortable conclusion to be drawn from extrapolating Ambrose's comment: essentially, he was saying cancer is a punishment from God.
There was a brief, stunned silence as toes curled around the Staples Center.
It's worth noting that Ambrose's Glenn Hoddle moment was almost certainly approved by the man himself - or at the very least, Roman Reigns. It's also worth noting that his opinion is not endorsed by WWE, but is a belief held by his character - an on-screen baddie. Does that make it fair ground?
[CONT'D. P1/4]
Unlike traditional television shows, characters on WWE programming blur the line between fiction and reality. Ambrose's indelicate utterances might be exaggerated to serve a narrative purpose, but they regard a real life situation. It's this ambiguity which makes things icky.
Cancer touches everybody. It's likely that every person watching Raw on Monday night knows at least somebody who has been affected by the illness, if they're not a sufferer themselves. Whilst storylines shouldn't be sanitised to protect the sensitivities of everybody watching, WWE promotes itself as entertainment, not drama. Blaming a man's legitimate leukaemia on his own morality doesn't need to be part of that.
It's all the more tone deaf when one considers that the company spends one month out of each year devoted to the cause of the Susan G. Komen breast cancer charity. Gimmicks are frequently put to one side during programming as superstars gather to shake the pink ropes and vow to help beat the disease. It's not a good look to have one of these same superstars cutting a promo the next minute saying victims of the illness are paying the price for past misdemeanours.
Besides, the line wasn't just tasteless - it was unnecessary. Dean's later jibes of juvenilia were enough to let fans in on his alignment, most of whom can see through such reality-piercing invocations for the cheap heat-seeking shortcut they are. Why risk upsetting a huge portion of the fan base to achieve the sum total of nothing?
It's probably because WWE just can't help themselves. This isn't the first time good taste has been thrown out the window to push an angle. There's a massive pile of it in the alley below.
[CONT'D. P2/4]
Almost three years ago to the day, WWE caused considerable consternation when they had Paige come out and mock the death of Charlotte Flair's brother, Reid. During her promo, Paige pushed the perimeter into the personal, commenting that Reid - who died of an accidental overdose in 2013 - "didn't have much fight in him."
The comments sparked justifiable outrage, but the promotion insisted it was Charlotte's idea. A company spokesman noted that “Subject matter this personal is only approved as a result of the strong advocacy of the talent themselves" - setting the precedent for Dean's tacky cancer comments. He failed to explain why WWE hadn't bothered to contact Reid's father Ric about the segment, which was said to have left The Nature Boy in tears. The answer should be clear; it'd never have aired if they had.
During the Attitude Era, no subject matter was impeded by the barrier of common decency. WWE eased into their ribaldry in late 1997 when they subjected Brian Pillman's widow, Melanie, to an intense live interview just a day removed from her husband's sudden death. Vince McMahon, under only the thinnest veneer of sincerity, skewered Melanie with all the sympathy of Martin Bashir confronting Michael Jackson. He needed to make one thing abundantly clear: that WWE carried no responsibility whatsoever in Pillman's death. That the segment spiked the quarter-hour rating was a happy coincidence, of course.
[CONT'D. P3/4]
It's not just death WWE have been keen to exploit. The ongoing personal issues of their own employees have regularly been the source of on-screen stories, with few considerations for the better sensibilities of a fraught HR department. In 1998, Michael 'Road Warrior Hawk ' Hegstrand became the subject of ridicule for his very real struggles with alcohol abuse. At one point, Hegstrand threatened to commit suicide after scaling the Titantron, as tag partner Joe 'Animal' Laurinaitis attempted to talk him down. Unlike Charlotte's apparent consent, neither man had approved the angle.
Attitude's commitment to schlocky crash TV made a virtue of vulgarity. If a shocking segment might raise the rating, it was worth running - no matter how objectionable it was.
There was no justifiable reason for the tactic over a decade later, with WWE claiming to have cleaned their content.
On a June 2012 episode of Monday Night Raw, Vince McMahon contorted his face as he put on his best - or worst - Southern accent in outright mockery of Jim Ross' battle with Bell's Palsy. If anyone was tuning in just to see one of the company's most tenured employees being ridiculed, they were in the minority. The skit served just a single purpose: to amuse one man. Ethics didn't come into it.
And it's entirely possible that's the case today. The official bluster of a put upon spokesperson notwithstanding, there's an implicit and long-established understanding amongst talent that disapproval is a direct way to shorten career prospects. It's no coincidence the Road Warriors were out of the company just months after objecting to their offensive angle. The only wrong thing to say is "no".
The sad truth is, WWE couldn't cross the line with Ambrose's comments about cancer last night - they went beyond that line years ago. We had this same situation with the Reid Flair outrage: much furore in the immediate fallout, before everybody forgets about it until fresh crassness instigates a new round of hand-wringing. Heck, knowing the company, that'll be next week when they reintroduce God as an on-screen character.