Every AEW PPV Ranked From Worst To Best

AEW All Out 2020 isn't winning. So what is?

By Michael Sidgwick /

For a company that exploded on the scene as a result of the EVPs transcending match quality, AEW mastered the art of episodic television before perfecting its PPV formula.

Advertisement

Dynamite rules. It just does.

The slow-burn elegance of the booking preserves the major matches but rewards weekly viewers with wave upon wave of low-key brilliance. The penultimate quarter hour next week rundown is as awesome as anything that actually happens on the show, in what is a true measure of how great Dynamite is as a weekly fixture. The execution of the spotlight performances is often so great that fans fantasy book matches well before the announcements. Right now, Bryan Danielson Vs. Literally Anybody is a dream match - but how much more awesome is the prospect of Bryan Danielson Vs. Dante Martin following this week's episode, on which Martin proved himself as much a mat wizard as aerial sensation?

Even the best AEW pay-per-views have dragged at some point. It's not ideal. Are they weighed down by the sense of rapt anticipation, or self-indulgence?

One pay-per-view was flawless.

The rest are up for debate, which brings us to...

11. All Out 2020

The card was good to very good in isolated moments and in retrospect.

Advertisement

That doesn't make for a good show.

It was all over the place. The hot opener, a blistering effort in which the Young Bucks defeated the Jurassic Express, wasn't the opener. It followed a poor cinematic Tooth & Nail match between Dr. Britt Baker and Big Swole that paled in comparison to the actual fun comedy of the storyline build. Chris Jericho Vs. Orange Cassidy's Mimosa Mayhem match was genuinely, miraculously suspenseful, since they were only teetering over wacky vats of a cocktail, but it wasn't a pay-per-view semi-main. It was a TV match masquerading as one.

Jon Moxley Vs. MJF was awesomely creative and superbly worked - two different contests worked in two different environments at which both men were respective doyens - but it was undermined by the low mood generated by Matt Hardy's awful head injury and the negligence that in effect no-sold it.

Hangman Page and Kenny Omega Vs. FTR was a great match only in theory. The paid (!) spectators barely reacted to it. The Casino Battle Royale was a disaster; the Women's Title match good but not good enough to lift the vibe.

A scary time that unfolded against a sapping backdrop, All Out 2020 was the anti-Double Or Nothing 2020: a drab reminder of and not an escape from the pandemic.

10. Revolution 2021

Elements of the show were fantastic, but again: you don't watch a wrestling show in the thrill of the moment to think "Shame about that infamously sh*tty finish, the match alone will be great viewed in edited form a few months later!"

Advertisement

You watch a wrestling show to feel things. What AEW fans felt after that dud of an explosion was painful, vicarious embarrassment.

The notorious Kenny Omega Vs. Jon Moxley match was a phenomenal and true update on the legendary death matches of yore. Watching Mox subvert the suspense trope by immediately f*cking Omega up with a second consecutive explosion was exhilarating. It didn't matter. The finish was so dire that the realest men in wrestling, Mox and Eddie Kingston, looked like pitiful Terry Funk and Atsushi Onita cosplayers.

Elsewhere, the action ranged from excellent, to good if overlong, to solid, which by 2021 standards is just a bit boring.

The Young Bucks Vs. MJF & Chris Jericho was an awesomely fun hybrid of the old and new schools of storytelling. The Casino Ladder Match was committed and brutal, but baggy. Hangman Page Vs. Matt Hardy was a gentleman's three that was more admirable than electrifying.

The Sting & Darby Allin Vs. Team Taz Street Fight was really well done, and Allin took a wicked beating, but by that point, with the vaccine roll-out in full effect, the Cinematic match felt something a bit less like an acceptable compromise.

9. Double Or Nothing 2020

Not quite the best AEW pay-per-view, but certainly the most miraculous - even more so than the prior year's edition.

Advertisement

The first major show held amid the pandemic, AEW didn't no sell-it. They recognised that the situation was overwhelming depressing, and that the usual formula just wouldn't hit. Instead, knowing they could always resume normal service, AEW embraced levity and deranged creativity by using empty space as a canvas.

The vitality of Stadium Stampede's beaming fusion of wackiness and actually incredible wrestling sold and stole the show, but the rest of the card was worthy of the $50, despite Austin Gunn and Big Swole substituting for a five-figure crowd.

MJF Vs. Jungle Boy was a total banger worked with the furious competitive spirit of two young men at identical stages of their career. Jon Moxley and Brodie Lee subverted the clichéd kick-out face near-fall to electrifyingly brutal effect. Hikaru Shida and Nyla Rose battered f*ck out of each other in a cracking plunder brawl.

It wasn't perfect - the middle portion sagged, the Shawn Spears comedy bit failed, and the Casino Ladder match went much too long - but it wasn't even meant to be possible.

8. Double Or Nothing 2021

Serena Deeb is one million f*cking percent the most underrated and under-utilised performer in the world, and she showed it by convincingly dissecting Riho's knee with as much craft as dramatic effect.

Advertisement

The actual opener was even better: Hangman Page took vengeance on Brian Cage in a terrific physics-defying bomb blast that resembled video game wrestling in the best way: cool and improbable, as opposed to cooperative. The Young Bucks beat Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston in what was the only flaw of an incredible tag team classic. When was the last time you wanted a babyface tag team to win that badly?

The middle of the card sagged and underwhelmed. Dr. Britt Baker's long-awaited title win over Hikaru Shida only got going at the very end. Anthony Ogogo impressed in flashes - massively so, given his level of experience - but it wasn't enough to meet the AEW PPV standard. Miro Vs. Lance Archer was good, not great.

Sting brought the vibe right the f*ck back up with an awesome, ageless performance alongside Darby Allin against Men Of The Year heightened by how well he had sold those Team Taz beatdowns earlier in the year. Kenny Omega Vs. PAC Vs. Orange Cassidy was tremendous. Given the history of the former two and the strategic objective of the match, how awesome was the spot where Omega countered the Brutaliser by sending PAC out of the ring?

Stadium Stampede II couldn't replicate the one-off magic, but the ending, in which the cinematic bled into the live arena, was genuinely stirring symbolism.

Uneven, and long, but unforgettable at its peak, elevated by a wild atmosphere thought forever lost.

7. All Out 2019

All Out 2019 proved that Double Or Nothing was no aberration - at the perfect time, since Fight For The Fallen suggested it might have been.

Advertisement

More than what had already become expected - world-class in-ring action that peaked with a creative, frightening Escalera de la Muerte stunt show with no visible wires whatsoever - the upstart promotion used its resourcefulness and philosophies to connect the more unexpected names to its audience.

People remembered Darby Allin's spirited draw opposite Cody at Fyter Fest and got behind him. He didn't win the outrageous Cracker Barrel Clash. He didn't have to. The trust had already been earned. Luchasaurus connected big with crowds at Double Or Nothing. He was rewarded with a killer spotlight performance in the opening trios banger. Shawn Spears was an also-ran in WWE, which concerned the few fans who weren't into the high-quality, reality-tinged storyline stemming from Fyter Fest. He was presented as a snivelling cheap shot artist on the njght, and not a significant threat, to inform the add-on-heavy fun of Cody's vengeance.

AEW pitched itself as the non-WWE company in May. By All Out, they had already evolved into the listening company.

6. Full Gear 2020

A misjudged cinematic match aside, Full Gear was an inexplicable and premature return to a more normal atmosphere. It wasn't normal. 1,000 distanced spectators watched it. But it was so hot and thrilling that they felt like 10,000 strong at its phenomenal peak.

Advertisement

Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page I was a cracking, relentless tale of heartbreaking, acute strategic errors. John Silver Vs. Orange Cassidy was a charming banger that blended comedy and unexpected action brilliantly. Cody Vs. Darby Allin was a sumptuous technical affair that held up to the scrutiny of the most tedious limb work snobs without ever detracting from the urgency of the AEW standard. FTR Vs. the Young Bucks lived up to its lofty dream match billing with its incredible, intricate philosophical clash. They worked the stylistic battle with unreal narrative substance.

Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston's brutal I Quit match main event elevated the methodical into art with a pace that was far more emotionally absorbing than boring.

It wasn't perfect. Hikaru Shida Vs. Nyla Rose was a poor sequel. Elite Deletion brought down the sparse crowd. MJF Vs. Chris Jericho was a great TV story match that felt somewhat out of place in the semi-main slot.

But it felt like a real PPV where it had no right to.

5. Full Gear 2019

The very smallest removal from the energetic brightness of Dynamite's atmosphere just made it feel a bit off at times. The PPV was darkly-lit and the crowd wasn't mic'd as well as usual. This is a minor complaint made against a promotion that is held to the highest standard.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, the show f*cking ruled.

Young Bucks Vs. Santana and Ortiz while a bit long was an excellent hybrid of fun spots and substantive drama. Hangman Page Vs. PAC was an exceptional match with as much physical impact as nuanced craft. Riho and Emi Sakura disgraced the grim lack of storyline build with emotional turbo-charged drama. AEW has presented significantly better Tag Team Title matches than the spotty/exhilarating three way, and Joey Janela Vs. Shawn Spears while solid just wasn't premium at all. The last two matches however were phenomenal in completely different ways.

Cody Vs. Chris Jericho and its incredible, serendipitous finish restored the elegant prestige of a World Title fight, where Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley restored what wrestling violence used to feel like in a 40 minute death ride loaded with lush detail.

4. Double Or Nothing 2019

Surreal magic from the opening frame: big-time competition was back.

Advertisement

Double Or Nothing was the perfect advertisement and mission statement for what evolved into a near-perfect promotion.

Don't like the oppressive, homogenised WWE style?

Enjoy a stunning stylistic range spanning the brutal charm of joshi to lung-bursting international trios action.

Sick of synthetic, trope-heavy violence?

Watch, anxiously, as Cody and Dustin Rhodes shed pools of blood and tears over a brand new mat they made sacred in 20 minutes.

Bored of rubbish scripted promos that somehow think obnoxious, intentionally unfunny copy is effective heat?

The delightfully cruel MJF will pop you daft by pretending Bret Hart is about to get attacked...again.

Tired of WWE's patronising mandate that wrestling stars have to wait years to "develop" into wrestling stars, by which point they just feel normal?

Here's Jon Moxley to remind you what the game-changing impact of a shock jump looks like.

One very good if a slight let-down of a main event blemished the show as a 10/10 effort, but a 9 never felt so important.

3. Revolution 2020

Highlighted by the greatest tag team match of all-time - the Young Bucks Vs. Kenny Omega and Hangman Page was at once the most layered and the most exciting story ever told - Revolution 2020 was stronger in vibe than in match quality, not that much of it wasn't incredible.

Advertisement

That tag was better than incredible, creating as much conflict in the audience as inside the ring.

The show itself was the perfect, triumphant pay-off to the best stretch of pro wrestling TV this century - at least until AEW resumed live touring in July of this year. But was February 2021 better? It was magic.

Jon Moxley won the World Title from Chris Jericho in a crazed, shortcut-laden brawl; Darby Allin finally bagged his breakthrough win in an ultra-violent sprint; Orange Cassidy lost to PAC but enchanted the crowd after teasing out the joy of his act for several, patient months; MJF and Cody's very good if unfocused brawl was very much committed in making a new top heel.

Nyla Rose Vs. Kris Statlander was doomed and rubbish, though Statlander was battling through flu. Dustin Rhodes kissed a woman without consent, and it was disastrous.

Beyond that, Revolution was the arrival of the version of itself that AEW promised. And they promised the world.

2. Full Gear 2021

A sensational, near-flawless show that proved AEW isn't reliant on the wave of names that generated such buzz in the summer of 2021.

Advertisement

MJF's incredible win over Darby Allin, in a barnstormer of a pro wrestling match that threaded together modern flashes with the timeless core of selling, was equally as great in its own distinct way to CM Punk's witty war with Eddie Kingston. Bryan Danielson arrived from WWE and emerged as #1 contender to the AEW World Championship - which was won on the night by Hangman Page in an unbearably dramatic and ultimately euphoric main event against Kenny Omega. Dream signings held equal weight to internal projects years in the making, making a flexing nonsense of the worst take in all of wrestling discourse:

"aeW JUsT USeS EX-wwE gUYs!"

Southern tag doyens fed mind-bending lucha libre experts; submission-heavy intricacy slowly drew the Minneapolis crowd in; plunder made a man out of Jungle Boy and a pillock out of Dan Lambert.

The crucial range of AEW was in full effect on a hot night in a cold city. This time around, AEW didn't need any new signings.

Seriously: they didn't need any new signings...

1. All Out 2021

AEW took just over two years to perfect the PPV formula.

Advertisement

All Out 2021 was a masterpiece: the apex of what the company sought to achieve. It was a euphoric blast of fan service, yes, but that is a bad take almost, not that fan service isn't great. An entertainment entity should want to please its base. But All Out wasn't a hollow procession of pops because in the legendary post-main event angle, AEW set up at least the next PPV cycle. It was productive. It built.

The show rocked.

Trimming the undercard attractions by several minutes to stunning effect, the discipline and sequencing yielded the very best from the strong style opening double-header and Britt Baker's stripped-back banger against Kris Statlander. Lucha Bros. Vs. Young Bucks was the most emotionally intense stunt war ever. CM f*cking Punk returned! And in doing so reminded us how of Bret Hart's awesome stuff still totally works!

Even the very good but not as acclaimed stuff was great. MJF Vs. Chris Jericho was so much better and harder than expected, and the Kenny Omega Vs. Christian Cage main event was superbly crafted.

The wrestling world changed at All Out 2021 - into something incredibly special.

If you like this list, you'll LOVE the new book from @MSidgwick - Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW - available to pre-order RIGHT NOW at WhatCulture.BigCartel.com!

Advertisement